What do you think?
Rate this book
Добрите крадци
Когато замъкът на дядо й е отнет с измама, Вита решава, че трябва да оправи нещата. С помощта на новите си приятели – джебчийката Силк, въздушния акробат Самюъл и дресьора на животни Аркадий, тя съставя дързък план. Ще проникнат тайно в замъка. Ще откраднат това, което принадлежи по право на дядо й. Ще разобличат измамника. Ще бъдат добрите крадци!
Планът им крие много подводни камъни, защото Ню Йорк от двайсетте години на XX век е пълен с тайни и опасности. Дали смелата Вита и верните й приятели ще успеят да надхитрят града, който никога не спи?
Изпълнена с приключения и хумор, „Добрите крадци“ е история за рисковете, които сме готови да поемем заради хората, които обичаме. Завладяващ разказ за надежда, решителност и състрадание, който ни показва, че нищо не е невъзможно, когато вложиш сърцето и душата си в него.
Планът им крие много подводни камъни, защото Ню Йорк от двайсетте години на XX век е пълен с тайни и опасности. Дали смелата Вита и верните й приятели ще успеят да надхитрят града, който никога не спи?
Изпълнена с приключения и хумор, „Добрите крадци“ е история за рисковете, които сме готови да поемем заради хората, които обичаме. Завладяващ разказ за надежда, решителност и състрадание, който ни показва, че нищо не е невъзможно, когато вложиш сърцето и душата си в него.
304 pages, меки корици
First published August 27, 2019
304 people are currently reading
4004 people want to read
About the author
Katherine Rundell
34 books2,068 followersKatherine Rundell was born in 1987 and grew up in Africa and Europe. In 2008 she was elected a Fellow of All Souls College, Oxford. Her first book, The Girl Savage, was born of her love of Zimbabwe and her own childhood there; her second, Rooftoppers, was inspired by summers working in Paris and by night-time trespassing on the rooftops of All Souls. She is currently working on her doctorate alongside an adult novel.
Source: Katherine Rundell
Source: Katherine Rundell
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 530 reviews
April 17, 2021
fulfilling my 2021 goal to read one book each month by an author i love that i haven’t gotten around to reading yet
another PERFECT story by katherine rundell. i love her so much that i (almost) want to have a bunch of kids just so i can fill their tiny sticky hands with her books.
like the best of her work, this one is tightly plotted, with wholesome-but-authentic characters and a few surprises.
it's a historical heist/adventure story about a group of kids from different backgrounds who are corralled and led by the inimitable vita into pooling their specialized skill sets and abilities into a plot to recover an emerald necklace with sentimental/familial—as well as monetary—value from its hiding spot in vita's grandfather's crumbling family manse—the straight up castle whose ownership he's just been hoodwinked out of by a wicked, heartless man.
vita's plan is to sneak into the castle, recover the emerald for her grandfather, and hopefully get his home back as well.
it's age appropriate without being kiddy, she presents diversity without it feeling checklisty and she addresses racism and immigration and economic imbalance in the melting pot of 1920s manhattan in a thoughtful appropriate way that feels natural, while phrasing it perfectly and succinctly:
Racism can't be cured by black excellence when it's caused by white ignorance.
vita is a very likable character, stubborn and passionate, shining with determination; a courageous girl adhering to her own moral code. a brush with polio has left her with a twisted leg and in chronic pain, but she refuses to let it slow her down. she's realistic about what she can and cannot do, but having to endure pain has become something of an asset—it has toughened her up and made her less likely to back down from a fight.
People do not expect a small girl to be willing to take or inflict pain.
it's a charming and entertaining book with a positive message about family and friendship and teamwork. vita's got maybe a little more empathetic generosity of spirit than seems realistic when it comes to a wounded enemy, but—hey, it's a middle grade book, and i suppose "carrying a full-grown man-villain to safety" is a good lesson in politeness and grace.
because i love heist narratives a LOT, this is right up there with my former favorite, Rooftoppers. i love this ragtag team of circus performers and pickpockets, and the way they distribute the labor each according to their strengths, even vita, whose contribution, apart from planning, is not immediately apparent:
love. it.
although i am less keen on the whole "normalizing bird-aggression" parts:
THAT IS JUST HOW THEY TASTE YOU BEFORE RETURNING TO DEVOUR YOUR FLESH!!
other than that, a wonderful book for kids or old ladies like me.
come to my blog!
another PERFECT story by katherine rundell. i love her so much that i (almost) want to have a bunch of kids just so i can fill their tiny sticky hands with her books.
like the best of her work, this one is tightly plotted, with wholesome-but-authentic characters and a few surprises.
it's a historical heist/adventure story about a group of kids from different backgrounds who are corralled and led by the inimitable vita into pooling their specialized skill sets and abilities into a plot to recover an emerald necklace with sentimental/familial—as well as monetary—value from its hiding spot in vita's grandfather's crumbling family manse—the straight up castle whose ownership he's just been hoodwinked out of by a wicked, heartless man.
vita's plan is to sneak into the castle, recover the emerald for her grandfather, and hopefully get his home back as well.
it's age appropriate without being kiddy, she presents diversity without it feeling checklisty and she addresses racism and immigration and economic imbalance in the melting pot of 1920s manhattan in a thoughtful appropriate way that feels natural, while phrasing it perfectly and succinctly:
Racism can't be cured by black excellence when it's caused by white ignorance.
vita is a very likable character, stubborn and passionate, shining with determination; a courageous girl adhering to her own moral code. a brush with polio has left her with a twisted leg and in chronic pain, but she refuses to let it slow her down. she's realistic about what she can and cannot do, but having to endure pain has become something of an asset—it has toughened her up and made her less likely to back down from a fight.
People do not expect a small girl to be willing to take or inflict pain.
it's a charming and entertaining book with a positive message about family and friendship and teamwork. vita's got maybe a little more empathetic generosity of spirit than seems realistic when it comes to a wounded enemy, but—hey, it's a middle grade book, and i suppose "carrying a full-grown man-villain to safety" is a good lesson in politeness and grace.
because i love heist narratives a LOT, this is right up there with my former favorite, Rooftoppers. i love this ragtag team of circus performers and pickpockets, and the way they distribute the labor each according to their strengths, even vita, whose contribution, apart from planning, is not immediately apparent:
"Right," said Silk. She turned and looked at Vita, at her thin hands, at her bloodied elbow. "So if he's climbing the wall, and he's taming the dogs, and I'm picking the lock to the walled garden—what are you doing?"
Samuel and Arkady turned to Vita, as if the question had not occurred to them.
"Well...it's my family's emerald," she said reasonably enough.
"But what can you do?" asked Silk.
Vita's brain drew a total blank. She thrust her hands in her pockets, and her fingers met her penknife. She thought of Lady Lavinia, and her sharp-eyed watchfulness.
"Wait a second." The mostly-devoured loaf of bread still lay on the beer barrel next to the bread knife. She took it, an apple, and an orange, and set them side by side on the mantlepiece.
"My grandpa taught me to do this," she said.
She crossed to the far end of the room, took the bread knife, the steak knife, and her own penknife in one hand, and without pausing to make sure the others were watching her, threw the knives over their heads at the mantlepiece.
They yelped and ducked and twisted to stare.
The bread knife had sliced a chunk off the apple. The steak knife had stuck in the bread. And her own Swiss Army knife had cut straight to the center of the orange, filling the room with the scent of the faraway sun. In fact, she had been aiming to slice the apple exactly in two, like Lady Lavinia in Carnegie Hall, but she did not admit it.
"I can do that," she said. "I'm the just-in-case."
love. it.
although i am less keen on the whole "normalizing bird-aggression" parts:
"Rimsky!" He made a whistling, hissing sound through his teeth. The crow took off, sweeping in three lazy flaps to land on Arkady's outstretched hand. She hopped up Arkady's arm to his elbow, leaned over to the boy's breast pocket, fished a crust from it, gave him a peck on the thumb, and took off again.
Arkady sucked a small amount of blood from his thumb. "Bird affection takes a bit of getting used to."
THAT IS JUST HOW THEY TASTE YOU BEFORE RETURNING TO DEVOUR YOUR FLESH!!
other than that, a wonderful book for kids or old ladies like me.
come to my blog!
September 28, 2023
✰ 3.75 stars ✰
“She had to do something to make it right. She did not yet know what, nor how, but love has a way of leaving people no choice.”
Brimming with youthful spirit, heartfelt friendships, and family triumph, The Good Thieves is an amazing adventure story set in the days of the dazzle of surreptitious casinos, allure of dangerous heists and glitter of magical circuses that transfixed the streets of New York City. ✨ In a time when 'justice seems to be only for those who can afford it', fiercely spirited and determined young Vita takes it upon herself to reclaim the inheritance of her Grandfather's property of Hudson Castle and his precious heart that was so unjustly stolen from him by the conniving entrepreneur Sorrotore.
A compelling Middle Grade that reminded me of my early years of devouring Enid Blyton's mysteries on a weekly basis, I had a good time with this one. Fresh and appealing, the writing style and lovely illustrations that adorned each chapter's headers pulled me into the story, because much like Vita - I wanted to see justice served and I wanted to know how it would come to be. I loved how it also became a mystery, as well - for what she was seeking may be more than what meets the eye. I liked that Katherine Rundell placed our young intrepid into situations that while dark and dangerous, still felt very plausible and believable for their attempts in facing off the villains that targeted them. 🙏🏻🙏🏻
“There’s prestige in a troupe, if you can make it fly.”
Vita and her band of henchmen troupe made for a fascinating and unique troupe that shined in the most dire of situation. ‘We’re a troupe now. We fought together; we ate together,' and they truly stood by each other, through thick and thin, especially when one of them would yell 'Run!' to save themselves, but they never abandoned them. 🤍🤍 Each character had a unique specialty to them - each bringing something different and diverse to the table that when banded together, they each played a critical part in the heist Vita had requested their assistance with. Vita was so head-strong and determined - 'planning, watching, thinking' is what she excelled at. She didn't let her own disability hinder their plan or motives; in fact, it spurned her further into action - not to be outdone by the others, and believed wholeheartedly that even the little plan she had concocted in her little red notebook seemed impossible, 'whispered, a small voice inside her, impossible doesn't mean it's not worth trying.' 🥹🥹
Their heist definitely took some interesting and action-packed twists and turns through New York City! 🗽 From leaping into pot holes and wading their way through damp and murky tunnels, from facing off guns and jewels of fearless gangsters, from being trapped in the foreboding dungeons of mysterious castles, and then transporting you to the wild and thriving lights of the glamorous circus life of trapeze artists and beautiful animals, it was a whirlwind of a journey through New York City of yesteryear. It leapt to life through her pages - the inclusion of each moment fit well into the scene - never once feeling out of place or contrived. 👍🏻👍🏻
“It is so rarely we are given the opportunity to prove ourselves by laying treasure at the feet of those we love.”
And amidst all their daring adventures, there was one thing that I also took note of, which I appreciated. The subtle tones of showing how divided the different social status of class existed at this time. While Vita was of an upper class and stoutly believed that 'it was what you did: you fought for the people you love' was enough of a reason for her to face off a truly awful villain, her other three young friends didn't have it so easy. 🥺🥺 That as a young Black boy, Samuel may not be able to fulfill his dream of being a ballet star, because 'the world isn’t generous with its imagination to people of my skin' or Silk, with her stretch of poverty and fearfulness of working with others, doesn't want 'to trick and twist and lie and run', but just be a normal kid. I liked how these little facets actually played a bigger part towards the end - even when all was said and done. 🤌🏻
I'll definitely consider checking out more books by this author. Her fluid writing style certainly gives me hope that she has the potential to bring magic to historical middle grade books with a little sparkle and a lot of warmth of courage and spirit. Something I'm always in the hopes for. 🌟🌟
“She had to do something to make it right. She did not yet know what, nor how, but love has a way of leaving people no choice.”
Brimming with youthful spirit, heartfelt friendships, and family triumph, The Good Thieves is an amazing adventure story set in the days of the dazzle of surreptitious casinos, allure of dangerous heists and glitter of magical circuses that transfixed the streets of New York City. ✨ In a time when 'justice seems to be only for those who can afford it', fiercely spirited and determined young Vita takes it upon herself to reclaim the inheritance of her Grandfather's property of Hudson Castle and his precious heart that was so unjustly stolen from him by the conniving entrepreneur Sorrotore.
A compelling Middle Grade that reminded me of my early years of devouring Enid Blyton's mysteries on a weekly basis, I had a good time with this one. Fresh and appealing, the writing style and lovely illustrations that adorned each chapter's headers pulled me into the story, because much like Vita - I wanted to see justice served and I wanted to know how it would come to be. I loved how it also became a mystery, as well - for what she was seeking may be more than what meets the eye. I liked that Katherine Rundell placed our young intrepid into situations that while dark and dangerous, still felt very plausible and believable for their attempts in facing off the villains that targeted them. 🙏🏻🙏🏻
“There’s prestige in a troupe, if you can make it fly.”
Vita and her band of henchmen troupe made for a fascinating and unique troupe that shined in the most dire of situation. ‘We’re a troupe now. We fought together; we ate together,' and they truly stood by each other, through thick and thin, especially when one of them would yell 'Run!' to save themselves, but they never abandoned them. 🤍🤍 Each character had a unique specialty to them - each bringing something different and diverse to the table that when banded together, they each played a critical part in the heist Vita had requested their assistance with. Vita was so head-strong and determined - 'planning, watching, thinking' is what she excelled at. She didn't let her own disability hinder their plan or motives; in fact, it spurned her further into action - not to be outdone by the others, and believed wholeheartedly that even the little plan she had concocted in her little red notebook seemed impossible, 'whispered, a small voice inside her, impossible doesn't mean it's not worth trying.' 🥹🥹
Their heist definitely took some interesting and action-packed twists and turns through New York City! 🗽 From leaping into pot holes and wading their way through damp and murky tunnels, from facing off guns and jewels of fearless gangsters, from being trapped in the foreboding dungeons of mysterious castles, and then transporting you to the wild and thriving lights of the glamorous circus life of trapeze artists and beautiful animals, it was a whirlwind of a journey through New York City of yesteryear. It leapt to life through her pages - the inclusion of each moment fit well into the scene - never once feeling out of place or contrived. 👍🏻👍🏻
“It is so rarely we are given the opportunity to prove ourselves by laying treasure at the feet of those we love.”
And amidst all their daring adventures, there was one thing that I also took note of, which I appreciated. The subtle tones of showing how divided the different social status of class existed at this time. While Vita was of an upper class and stoutly believed that 'it was what you did: you fought for the people you love' was enough of a reason for her to face off a truly awful villain, her other three young friends didn't have it so easy. 🥺🥺 That as a young Black boy, Samuel may not be able to fulfill his dream of being a ballet star, because 'the world isn’t generous with its imagination to people of my skin' or Silk, with her stretch of poverty and fearfulness of working with others, doesn't want 'to trick and twist and lie and run', but just be a normal kid. I liked how these little facets actually played a bigger part towards the end - even when all was said and done. 🤌🏻
I'll definitely consider checking out more books by this author. Her fluid writing style certainly gives me hope that she has the potential to bring magic to historical middle grade books with a little sparkle and a lot of warmth of courage and spirit. Something I'm always in the hopes for. 🌟🌟
August 30, 2021
To Listen to this review instead, visit the peachybooks.ca post
here.
“But it’s not always sensible to be sensible.”
KATHERINE RUNDELL, THE GOOD THIEVES
Historical fiction is one of my top genres, so I was eager to read this book set in depression-era New York City with my Li’l Peach. Just like mum, the budding bookworm is a lover of history. We had only ever read non-fiction books about the past, so this was an exciting read that introduced him to a beloved genre.
At the commencement of this fast-paced story, Vita and her mother had just traversed the ocean from England to assist her ailing grandfather. Her mother was hopeful that with the clearing up of his financial affairs, he would return to the UK with them in the coming weeks. The loose ends would take a little more work to clear up than anyone had imagined, least of all Vita.
The frail man defeatedly admitted that for a mere two hundred dollars, the equivalent of three thousand today, he had been scammed out of ownership of the historic family castle by a bulldozing, real-estate mogul. Although her grandfather seemed resigned to this fact and his inability to do anything about it, Vita had other plans.
If she could get into the castle and dig out some abandoned treasure, they would use the proceeds from the sale of the gem to get a fancy lawyer and set things straight. This lofty goal would seem all the more difficult to achieve given her apparent limitations: the painful and maldeveloped foot she acquired from her battle with Polio years earlier and her ignorance about the big city that she now must expertly navigate.
Possible impediments aside, our fearless heroine ventures out on her own to do a recognisance mission when she ends up crossing paths with my favourite character of the book. Silk, a homeless young teen, rough around the edges and tough-as-nails, is a hustling pick-pocket, the perfect match for the courageous Vita. As fate would have it, she also befriends Samuel and Arkady – performers in a travelling circus running temporarily at Carnegie Hall, just across the way from where her grandfather lives. Together they form a tattered yet tenacious crew of ‘good thieves,’ and the story jets off from there.
Bravery, ability, and determination are the guiding forces for this talented gang of kids as they seek to defeat the scoundrel Sorratore as he stealthily attempts to snatch up historic properties across New York City. Thanks to their diverse skillset: Samuel the acrobat, Arkady the animal whisperer, Silk the street hustler, and Vita with the expert aim – a skill she picked up when she was a small child, under the tutelage of her now infirm grandfather – a tightly-woven plan was all they would need to succeed.
The all-important red notebook held the path to victory as Vita prepared every step needed for things to come together. Unfortunately for them, they met much friction along the way. Vita is an admirable role model for young readers, as her organisational skills and strong leadership are matched only by her grit to fight through the discomfort and pain of her mission.
There were teachable moments throughout the story, as themes of family, friendship, loyalty, racism, crime, and dishonesty are in abundance. Visually evocative scenes play out as Rundell transports us through the bustle of Manhattan, the landscapes of suburban New York, and the majesty of the decaying castle.
Endearing characters, an exciting plot, appropriate pacing, and sheer enjoyment have me rating this middle-grade fiction gem 4.5 peaches and adding Rundell’s other popular offering, Rooftoppers, to my list without delay.
To see Rimsky, the crow bookmark I made in honour of Arkady's helpful feathered friend, visit my blog post here:
“But it’s not always sensible to be sensible.”
KATHERINE RUNDELL, THE GOOD THIEVES
Historical fiction is one of my top genres, so I was eager to read this book set in depression-era New York City with my Li’l Peach. Just like mum, the budding bookworm is a lover of history. We had only ever read non-fiction books about the past, so this was an exciting read that introduced him to a beloved genre.
At the commencement of this fast-paced story, Vita and her mother had just traversed the ocean from England to assist her ailing grandfather. Her mother was hopeful that with the clearing up of his financial affairs, he would return to the UK with them in the coming weeks. The loose ends would take a little more work to clear up than anyone had imagined, least of all Vita.
The frail man defeatedly admitted that for a mere two hundred dollars, the equivalent of three thousand today, he had been scammed out of ownership of the historic family castle by a bulldozing, real-estate mogul. Although her grandfather seemed resigned to this fact and his inability to do anything about it, Vita had other plans.
If she could get into the castle and dig out some abandoned treasure, they would use the proceeds from the sale of the gem to get a fancy lawyer and set things straight. This lofty goal would seem all the more difficult to achieve given her apparent limitations: the painful and maldeveloped foot she acquired from her battle with Polio years earlier and her ignorance about the big city that she now must expertly navigate.
Possible impediments aside, our fearless heroine ventures out on her own to do a recognisance mission when she ends up crossing paths with my favourite character of the book. Silk, a homeless young teen, rough around the edges and tough-as-nails, is a hustling pick-pocket, the perfect match for the courageous Vita. As fate would have it, she also befriends Samuel and Arkady – performers in a travelling circus running temporarily at Carnegie Hall, just across the way from where her grandfather lives. Together they form a tattered yet tenacious crew of ‘good thieves,’ and the story jets off from there.
Bravery, ability, and determination are the guiding forces for this talented gang of kids as they seek to defeat the scoundrel Sorratore as he stealthily attempts to snatch up historic properties across New York City. Thanks to their diverse skillset: Samuel the acrobat, Arkady the animal whisperer, Silk the street hustler, and Vita with the expert aim – a skill she picked up when she was a small child, under the tutelage of her now infirm grandfather – a tightly-woven plan was all they would need to succeed.
The all-important red notebook held the path to victory as Vita prepared every step needed for things to come together. Unfortunately for them, they met much friction along the way. Vita is an admirable role model for young readers, as her organisational skills and strong leadership are matched only by her grit to fight through the discomfort and pain of her mission.
There were teachable moments throughout the story, as themes of family, friendship, loyalty, racism, crime, and dishonesty are in abundance. Visually evocative scenes play out as Rundell transports us through the bustle of Manhattan, the landscapes of suburban New York, and the majesty of the decaying castle.
Endearing characters, an exciting plot, appropriate pacing, and sheer enjoyment have me rating this middle-grade fiction gem 4.5 peaches and adding Rundell’s other popular offering, Rooftoppers, to my list without delay.
To see Rimsky, the crow bookmark I made in honour of Arkady's helpful feathered friend, visit my blog post here:
March 17, 2022
I read this to my kid. There's a surprisingly high vocabulary level here, and I found we took a lot of breaks to discuss this word or that word. Some of it was the British English, used a bit hilariously to describe New York City ("rubbish bins" in NYC? ha ha).
For the first third or so, I thought we'd put it down. Then as the heist slowly built up, my kid was hooked.
For the first third or so, I thought we'd put it down. Then as the heist slowly built up, my kid was hooked.
July 21, 2019
Also Posted on For The Love of Fictional Worlds
Disclaimer: An ARC was provided via Bloomsbury Indiain exchange for an honest review. The Thoughts, opinions & feelings expressed in the review are therefore, my own.
The Good Thieves is a wonderful and adventurous middle grade fiction set as part of the historical genre – so basically it had all the makings of what could end up being one of the most enjoyable books in recent times. (Spoiler Alert: It did!)
Told in the POV of Vita – the tone of the book is set right from the start – for the indominable spirit of Vita absolutely dominates the plotline – it is her grandfather who looses everything to a crooked businessman. It is she who comes up with a plan to hoodwink the villain and it is her, who brings together a team of quirky and peculiar group of children to makes sure her plan bear fruit.
And that’s all you will hear about the plot itself.
What you should remember when YOU ARE picking up this book is that, not only does the author writes in a way that it becomes easy to get lost in the book, but also does so in a way that all the sub – genres working in the background blend together seamlessly and the fact that all the characters in this story have their individuality preserved throughout the book; shows how talented Ms. Rundell is in weaving her magic – and yes this plot contains magic as well as some of the most brilliantly quirky characters I have had the pleasure of meeting.
The Good Thieves is for you, if you love an action packed David vs Goliath fight as well love rooting for the characters who revel in their individuality rather than conforming to the norms.
For more reviews visit For The Love of Fictional Worlds :)
Do come join us at For The Fictional Worlds Facebook Page | Twitter | Instagram | Goodreads | Amazon |
June 8, 2019
From time to time, I read a middle grade book and my book choice this time has been "The good thieves". This is my first book by Katherine Rundell and her writing is absolutely beautiful.
Vita's grandfather, Jack has been cheated by a gang and they have taken his home. Vita seeing his granddad sad and broken, wants to do something to make him happy again. With the help of 3 people, she plans to get his home back.
Vita is fierce, brave and strong. Her planning and aiming skills are amazing. She's determined too. She's one of the strongest female characters. The gang of friends are unique in their own way. There are 2 guys, Arkady (being kind to birds & animals) & Samuel(gymnastic) and a girl named Silk (lockpicker). I love the way their friendship started and traveled.
How can there be no bad guy? There comes Sorrotore. He is a suitable evil-villain candidate. Being the opportunistic sick person, he makes the life of people difficult and also doesn't give a damn about other people.
The author even described about the circus, castle and places in the setting which has added more charm to the story. I love the relationship between the grandfather and the grandkid.
The book setting is brilliant and the story is perfectly paced. It holds the suspense element till the end. It's been a wonderful adventure ride for me. Highly recommended.
P.S. One of the prettiest ARCs I've seen. It's so shiny.
Vita's grandfather, Jack has been cheated by a gang and they have taken his home. Vita seeing his granddad sad and broken, wants to do something to make him happy again. With the help of 3 people, she plans to get his home back.
Vita is fierce, brave and strong. Her planning and aiming skills are amazing. She's determined too. She's one of the strongest female characters. The gang of friends are unique in their own way. There are 2 guys, Arkady (being kind to birds & animals) & Samuel(gymnastic) and a girl named Silk (lockpicker). I love the way their friendship started and traveled.
How can there be no bad guy? There comes Sorrotore. He is a suitable evil-villain candidate. Being the opportunistic sick person, he makes the life of people difficult and also doesn't give a damn about other people.
The author even described about the circus, castle and places in the setting which has added more charm to the story. I love the relationship between the grandfather and the grandkid.
The book setting is brilliant and the story is perfectly paced. It holds the suspense element till the end. It's been a wonderful adventure ride for me. Highly recommended.
P.S. One of the prettiest ARCs I've seen. It's so shiny.
December 7, 2020
Lovely chapter heading illustrations but unfortunately I wasn't as charmed by the story. I found it quite dull and unrealistic.
Believathon III: The Mystery of the Missing Maleficarum. The Footprints: A book with a prominent villain.
Believathon III: The Mystery of the Missing Maleficarum. The Footprints: A book with a prominent villain.
May 29, 2024
"rara vez tenemos la oportunidad de demostrar lo que valemos poniendo un tesoro a los pies de aquellos a los que amamos"
El libro es bastante interesante, con un objetivo claro desde el principio y sin muchas tramas secundarias, tiene buenos personajes con los cuales puedes llegar a empatizar.
Es una buena lecturas que en dos días o en una tarde te puedes terminar, para pasar el rato está bien. Con un plot twist inesperado y el tema de la amistad bastante presente, junto a la perfección de lo moral y lo inmoral.
La descripción es bastante buena, desde los personajes a los escenarios y paisajes hasta los sentimientos que casi puedes sentir a través del papel.
Aunque hay veces que te confundes en la lectura porque cambia el punto de vista sin aviso y me ha tocado releer un párrafo varias veces para entenderlo.
Por otro lado, lo de la protagonista con el ketchup no es ni medio normal, jajaja.
Aunque el final se me ha quedado un poquito soso.
El libro es bastante interesante, con un objetivo claro desde el principio y sin muchas tramas secundarias, tiene buenos personajes con los cuales puedes llegar a empatizar.
Es una buena lecturas que en dos días o en una tarde te puedes terminar, para pasar el rato está bien. Con un plot twist inesperado y el tema de la amistad bastante presente, junto a la perfección de lo moral y lo inmoral.
La descripción es bastante buena, desde los personajes a los escenarios y paisajes hasta los sentimientos que casi puedes sentir a través del papel.
Aunque hay veces que te confundes en la lectura porque cambia el punto de vista sin aviso y me ha tocado releer un párrafo varias veces para entenderlo.
Por otro lado, lo de la protagonista con el ketchup no es ni medio normal, jajaja.
Aunque el final se me ha quedado un poquito soso.
August 22, 2019
“The night city was swept by a premature winter. An ice snap froze the water in the pipes. Sleet washed down the city, swept the detritus of the mud and the old newspaper and the furious cats out from the murky alleyways into the main roads.”
First of all, I thought the writing style for both ‘The Wolf Wilder’ and ‘The Good Thieves’ were beautifully crafted. It seemed effortless for the author to string sentences together as the whole novel is filled with seamless prose and if you are looking for an example, try reading the quote that I had placed above of this sentence. I have loved the style of her writing and the technique she used to string sentences and words together ever since I read ‘The Wolf Wilder’. The author does not concoct extra information just to prolong the novel or string more sentences together to hit a goal or something, she gives the information so impeccably that everything seems necessary. In addition, I thought the descriptions that she had given in the novel were perfectly measured as it felt so real in my brain that I could touch it, virtually. Speaking of descriptions and feeling it virtually, this brings us to the next point: The Atmosphere.
The atmosphere of this novel is a mixture of comedic relief, hatred and anger. It is facetious because of the constant banter between the characters and the arguments seem to never end which I, at times, found myself laughing at the exchange of words between them. Hatred and anger come into play due to certain characters doing nasty businesses and I thought the author did a good job at extracting our emotions out from our body and let it diffuse into the atmosphere. Thus, I admired the crafting of the atmosphere made by the author.
The pacing of the novel is uprightly one of the most astounding items that is being placed in the book as it moves in a rapid manner and this is due to how addictive the plot is in which I will talk more about later on. The plot has an addictive quality to it and this gives the book an advantage as readers will carry on with the novel without ceasing as they would like to find out more about what is going to happen to the characters. To compare it with ‘The Wolf Wilder’, I thought ‘The Good Thieves’ was traversed better than it because I can sense vacillation at certain localities in ‘The Wolf Wilder’ that took me out of the context of the story and the ending for it was hastened like it was elbowing me laboriously out of the house or in this case, the book. Therefore, ‘The Good Thieves’ granted me a better impression than ‘The Wolf Wilder’ will ever remit.
In order to properly review the characters, I am going to split the protagonist and the side characters into sections to enunciate my feelings on each one of them. Please take note that I will not analyse the antagonists of the novel as I do not want to pillage the plot of the book to you. Thus, we shall begin:-
1) Vita: I do not actually know how to review our protagonist without sounding like a broken record. Well, here goes nothing. She is smart and skilled in throwing weaponry with perfect precision. I enjoyed reading about her scheme to take her grandfather’s castle back from the antagonist and her marvellous plots and plans.
2) Arkady & Samuel: Their characters are not well-developed but I enjoyed the constant banter that Arkady gives to his other teammates and friends. Both Arkady & Samuel have a beautiful friendship and both of them aspire to be something else and they chase after their dream and that is a very heart-warming thing to read about.
3) Silk: I enjoyed the glimpse-through backstory that the author has bestowed upon her but her character is, again, not well-developed and therefore, I cannot really comment on her characterisation. If I were to rectify a part of this book, I will definitely give a thorough background story for Arkady, Samuel and Silk characterisation because I thought it was extremely important to give backbones to your characters.
However, there were plot holes and specific precincts in the novel that I found highly unbelievable. For example, on page 17, chapter 3, I do not know how Vita manages to find the antagonist of the novel because New York is freaking huge, how can she just randomly find him through a ‘car ride?’ and trust me there are more unbelievable instances such as the ending. [Spoiler] How can all of them make it out in one piece, unscratched?
Lastly, topics like racism are touched on in this novel but not really explored which disappointed me because this could be the very first children novel that includes important topics such as racism in but it will, unfortunately, be marked as a missed opportunity as the outcome of the novel did not explore it much.
In conclusion, I am proffering this novel 75% (A-) as I enjoyed it immensely although it has certain flaws and thus, the rating.
⇛ This book is currently available at all good bookstores. Do give it a try!
August 14, 2019
Makes me want to run away from home and join the circus. Vita is truly a heroine with grit and reminds me of Ada in "The War That Saved My Life." In order to help her grandfather get back his castle on the Hudson she puts together an amazing team of kids with unique skills. The task before them is daunting, but they become a troupe in the effort to overcome all obstacles. Love the setting of this historical novel in Prohibition-era New York City featuring John Dillinger and a famous circus performing at Carnegie Hall. Loved it!
Thank you to Simon & Schuster and Edelweiss for providing a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster and Edelweiss for providing a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
May 6, 2019
I've always found Katherine Rundell's writing beautiful, but her upcoming MG book The Good Thieves hits a whole new level - it's just dazzlingly good! I love fierce, vibrant Vita (even when I cringed at some of her very believable decisions) and the band of friends she gathers for a perilous heist in 1930s New York, and I found their peril genuinely terrifying. The setting is rich and fun, and the plot is incredibly compulsive - it just rockets breathlessly along. I loved it all the way!
June 27, 2022
Un roman jeunesse très addictif et bien pensé qui m’a beaucoup plu !
Want to read
October 10, 2020I’m getting some real Carmen Sandiego vibes from this and that cover is beautiful😍 hoping to read this in November!
December 30, 2024
While not my favorite book by this author, still another solid YA/middle grade story.
The story follows Vita and a small troupe of children with interesting skills. She’s recruited them to help in her Plan which will help her grandfather get his house back.
Full of all the twists, turns, bad guys and better children, another solid read from Katherine Rundell.
The story follows Vita and a small troupe of children with interesting skills. She’s recruited them to help in her Plan which will help her grandfather get his house back.
Full of all the twists, turns, bad guys and better children, another solid read from Katherine Rundell.
October 31, 2019
Now THIS was a Katherine Rundell book. A fully real place, brilliantly shining characters and a desperate and twisting adventure of a plot make The Good Thieves another reason for Katherine Rundell being one of my favourite authors.
Rundell always has a clear picture of the place her story is set in–Africa, Paris, Russia, the Amazon, and now New York. As always, I could taste, smell, feel where the characters are and what they are doing. The coffee and the ketchup, the subway and the taxis, the rushing streets and Carnegie Hall all contributed to a vibrant setting that is as much a character as any of the people.
And the people that walk these pages are exceptional. I actually didn't love the characters in Rundell's previous book. In fact, I only really liked one person in The Explorer and I felt that she wasn't given a chance to shine, so I was pleased when I felt that she came back in this book as a slightly different character that is in her element.
She is one of four exceptional children on which the narrative is focused, and while they are all fantastic in their own right, they share three qualities: all four have distinct talents, personalities and difficulties, all four are people I wish I could know in real life and all four have courage and resilience that take my breath away.
In addition, Rundell's adults are realistic characters with understandable fears and problems along with admirable forbearance and love for the children in their care. And the animals are, as always, funny and smart and a perfect complement to the story.
Finally, the plot. Rundell's books don't often have me on the edge of my seat, but there was a time while reading The Good Thieves where I was extremely concerned (a.k.a. freaking out) because of this one worrying incident . . . but it is expertly made right in a completely unforeseen twist. Katherine Rundell never leaves the reader disappointed at the end of a book (thank goodness), but there was certainly the grim possibility of a broken heart towards the end. Thankfully this did not come to pass, so I can easily give The Good Thieves five stars!
Rundell always has a clear picture of the place her story is set in–Africa, Paris, Russia, the Amazon, and now New York. As always, I could taste, smell, feel where the characters are and what they are doing. The coffee and the ketchup, the subway and the taxis, the rushing streets and Carnegie Hall all contributed to a vibrant setting that is as much a character as any of the people.
And the people that walk these pages are exceptional. I actually didn't love the characters in Rundell's previous book. In fact, I only really liked one person in The Explorer and I felt that she wasn't given a chance to shine, so I was pleased when I felt that she came back in this book as a slightly different character that is in her element.
She is one of four exceptional children on which the narrative is focused, and while they are all fantastic in their own right, they share three qualities: all four have distinct talents, personalities and difficulties, all four are people I wish I could know in real life and all four have courage and resilience that take my breath away.
In addition, Rundell's adults are realistic characters with understandable fears and problems along with admirable forbearance and love for the children in their care. And the animals are, as always, funny and smart and a perfect complement to the story.
Finally, the plot. Rundell's books don't often have me on the edge of my seat, but there was a time while reading The Good Thieves where I was extremely concerned (a.k.a. freaking out) because of this one worrying incident . . . but it is expertly made right in a completely unforeseen twist. Katherine Rundell never leaves the reader disappointed at the end of a book (thank goodness), but there was certainly the grim possibility of a broken heart towards the end. Thankfully this did not come to pass, so I can easily give The Good Thieves five stars!
September 23, 2019
Title: The Good Thieves
Author: Katherine Rundell
Publisher: Bloomsbury
Genre: Middle grade
The Good Thieves by Katherine Rundell is a middle-grade novel filled with action, adventure, fun, hope, friendship and all. The story takes off with our protagonist Vita Marlowe who was on her way from Liverpool to Newyork with her mother Julia to meet her grandfather Jack who had been cheated out of his ancestral home by a greedy Newyork millionaire Victor Sorrotore. On seeing the injustice done to her grandfather, Vita was determined to set things right. So she devises a plan to outwit her enemy (Sorrotore) along with her newly found friends Arkady (an animal tamer), Samuel (a trapeze artist) and Silk (a lockpicker). Together the four set on an adventure to reclaim Hudson Castle from the evil hands of Sorrotore.
Rundell had so vividly presented the 1930’s New york. I liked the setting and the narration. What I loved most about this book were the characters. Vita Marlowe was one of the strongest female protagonists I have ever read in fiction. Rundell had very strongly registered a message through Vita’s character that with determination anything is possible despite the physical disabilities. Samuel’s character had set an example that with dedication and hard work one would be able to achieve his/her dream despite the limitations. More than the plot, I liked the moral this book carries. Overall, reading Rundell’s writing was an absolute pleasure.
My rating: 4/5
Thank you so much Bloomsbury India for the gorgeous ARC of The Good Thieves!
Author: Katherine Rundell
Publisher: Bloomsbury
Genre: Middle grade
The Good Thieves by Katherine Rundell is a middle-grade novel filled with action, adventure, fun, hope, friendship and all. The story takes off with our protagonist Vita Marlowe who was on her way from Liverpool to Newyork with her mother Julia to meet her grandfather Jack who had been cheated out of his ancestral home by a greedy Newyork millionaire Victor Sorrotore. On seeing the injustice done to her grandfather, Vita was determined to set things right. So she devises a plan to outwit her enemy (Sorrotore) along with her newly found friends Arkady (an animal tamer), Samuel (a trapeze artist) and Silk (a lockpicker). Together the four set on an adventure to reclaim Hudson Castle from the evil hands of Sorrotore.
Rundell had so vividly presented the 1930’s New york. I liked the setting and the narration. What I loved most about this book were the characters. Vita Marlowe was one of the strongest female protagonists I have ever read in fiction. Rundell had very strongly registered a message through Vita’s character that with determination anything is possible despite the physical disabilities. Samuel’s character had set an example that with dedication and hard work one would be able to achieve his/her dream despite the limitations. More than the plot, I liked the moral this book carries. Overall, reading Rundell’s writing was an absolute pleasure.
My rating: 4/5
Thank you so much Bloomsbury India for the gorgeous ARC of The Good Thieves!
July 13, 2024
Loved this very well-written tale. It was the perfect read aloud book for a recent family road trip as it kept both the kids and the adults entertained.
June 27, 2019
I was lucky enough to meet Katherine Rundell and get a signed copy of this fabulous book when she was giving a talk about the importance of adults reading children's literature. Preaching to the converted with me, being a Children's Author myself, but a very good talk.
It was extra special for me to meet Katherine as in her role as a Competition Judge, she has twice picked my writing out of the masses.
Anyway, onto my thoughts: The Good Thieves.
In short, LOVED IT!
I have to admit that I've loved all of her books, but I think this is my fav. Mainly because it's so completely thrilling without for one moment dropping the quality in the writing.
We follow Vita, our hero, scarred from polio, desperate to right a terrible injustice. Her grandfather's castle has been conned from him by a NY Gangster. In order to save the castle, Vita has to recruit an acrobat, an animal trainer and a locksmith to stage a heist to steal back an emerald, stashed within the castle walls. A fantastic David and Goliath story that had me gripped, with the backdrop of 1930s NY - pure joy. Extra nice to see a physically disabled character in a book that is not the villain.
Not only a ripping yarn, but also beautifully and skilfully done; it was like reading a song.
It was extra special for me to meet Katherine as in her role as a Competition Judge, she has twice picked my writing out of the masses.
Anyway, onto my thoughts: The Good Thieves.
In short, LOVED IT!
I have to admit that I've loved all of her books, but I think this is my fav. Mainly because it's so completely thrilling without for one moment dropping the quality in the writing.
We follow Vita, our hero, scarred from polio, desperate to right a terrible injustice. Her grandfather's castle has been conned from him by a NY Gangster. In order to save the castle, Vita has to recruit an acrobat, an animal trainer and a locksmith to stage a heist to steal back an emerald, stashed within the castle walls. A fantastic David and Goliath story that had me gripped, with the backdrop of 1930s NY - pure joy. Extra nice to see a physically disabled character in a book that is not the villain.
Not only a ripping yarn, but also beautifully and skilfully done; it was like reading a song.
June 17, 2021
That was so fun!!!! I finished this book in about a day and a half, and every minute of it was thoroughly enjoyable. The characters were excellent, and I really loved them all. The concept was quite interesting, and all the different skill sets were used very well in the plot. I absolutely LOVED the writing style with the idea of time jumping occasionally, and it was overall just beautifully written. So fun! I can’t wait to read more books by this author!
October 31, 2019
must a book be 'good'? is it not enough to have found families, bound together with love and loyalty despite their differences? and maybe even a heist?
October 20, 2025
GEWELDIG
June 27, 2019
Review : The good thieves by Katherine Rundell is a tale that emanates hope, determination, compassion and above all the message that nothing is impossible if you put your heart to it.
Vita our protagonist is one, amazing spirit who vows to bring back the lost smile of her grandfather after, his castle where he spent all his life and on which all his fond memories embed is snatched away by the evil Sorrotore, our ruthless villain. She builds her unusual and unconventional troupe with the likes of Silk,a pick pocket who is an orphan; Arkady, who is mesmerized by animals and birds and vice versa. Samuel, her third band member is an aspiring gymnast who also has his own hidden secret.
I will do it for the glory! We'll go down in history - like Robin Hood! The Good Thieves.
- Arkady.
The Good Thieves is a story of friendship and the battle of good against evil. It is humorous, witty and fast paced. I cannot emphasize enough on how Katherine Rundell has perfectly represented the character of Vita, a disabled but iron willed polio survivor. She has amazing planning skills and is not one to be messed with. The glam and glitz of the 1930's New York circus is vividly narrated and we get to see how Vita, is drawn by it. Vita's exceptional love for her family is something that took my heart away. Silk, as a character has more sharp edges than Vita, owing to how she has fended herself ever since her parents demise. Arkady, in my opinion was soft spoken and the kind who could never even imagine to hurt a fly. Samuel, on the other hand fights for his passion and is a true example of following your dreams.
The best defense when you have done something wrong is anger.
- Silk
I opine that middle graders especially could learn a lot from this absolutely unputdownable adventure story in terms of the versatile characters that are drastically different from each other but complete paradigm in every sense.
THE GOOD THIEVES by KATHERINE RUNDELL is an adventured to be embarked upon and enjoyed both by children, middle graders and adults alike.
Vita our protagonist is one, amazing spirit who vows to bring back the lost smile of her grandfather after, his castle where he spent all his life and on which all his fond memories embed is snatched away by the evil Sorrotore, our ruthless villain. She builds her unusual and unconventional troupe with the likes of Silk,a pick pocket who is an orphan; Arkady, who is mesmerized by animals and birds and vice versa. Samuel, her third band member is an aspiring gymnast who also has his own hidden secret.
I will do it for the glory! We'll go down in history - like Robin Hood! The Good Thieves.
- Arkady.
The Good Thieves is a story of friendship and the battle of good against evil. It is humorous, witty and fast paced. I cannot emphasize enough on how Katherine Rundell has perfectly represented the character of Vita, a disabled but iron willed polio survivor. She has amazing planning skills and is not one to be messed with. The glam and glitz of the 1930's New York circus is vividly narrated and we get to see how Vita, is drawn by it. Vita's exceptional love for her family is something that took my heart away. Silk, as a character has more sharp edges than Vita, owing to how she has fended herself ever since her parents demise. Arkady, in my opinion was soft spoken and the kind who could never even imagine to hurt a fly. Samuel, on the other hand fights for his passion and is a true example of following your dreams.
The best defense when you have done something wrong is anger.
- Silk
I opine that middle graders especially could learn a lot from this absolutely unputdownable adventure story in terms of the versatile characters that are drastically different from each other but complete paradigm in every sense.
THE GOOD THIEVES by KATHERINE RUNDELL is an adventured to be embarked upon and enjoyed both by children, middle graders and adults alike.
August 29, 2019
Katherine Rundell's books have magic in them. As Young-Girl-Adventure stories, they are on my top ten list. The Wolf Wilder and Rooftoppers are utterly enchanting - so why did this one fall flat? Perhaps Rundell's fascination with climbing roofs and jumping out of windows is wearing a bit thin? No, I think she has all the disparate bits she needs to stitch her story, but she's left some sloppy threads. What's the significance of the cat tattoos? Ditto the ring stolen by the villain and then by the heroine? Does she really expect us to believe a child can jump out a third story window and stick a landing on top of a car? A disappointment, this one.
March 10, 2022
To me this book was basically Six of Crows but for kids. It was a cute heist story containing a troop a kids with different skills. I appreciated that the main character had a physical limitation but she didn’t let that hold her back in any way. The story was completely predictable but in a satisfying way. I loved that there was a message in this story about caring for your elders and looking out for your family.
December 15, 2024
Let-us-get-a-team-together-to-pull-off-a-heist, always makes for a fun time. Throw in a couple circus performers, a pickpocket/lock-picker, and a knife throwing girl and you’ve got yourself something to write about. I love how descriptive Rundell’s writing. I listened to the audio so I don’t know if this had illustrations like Impossible Creature, but the visuals she put forth in prose were impressive.
April 29, 2019
Absolutely adored this.
September 28, 2021
Sympathique, sans plus
June 25, 2023
Afacan Beşler gibi eski çocuk kitapları tadında bir serüven romanı ❤
December 5, 2020
Unfortunately, Rundell is getting a little repetitious. This time we get a bunch of singular talents, including two from a circus. We get horsemanship (Cartwheeling in Thunderstorms) and acrobatic climbing (Rooftoppers).
The setting is New York City, apparently in Prohibition era (there is mention of a speakeasy). I wish the historical aspects were more based in fact. It could be that Hudson Castle could be partly inspired by Bannerman's Castle or Carrollcliffe in NY, but there is no author's note to confirm this.
In addition to only a vague sense of history, there are also some things that seem to be introduced solely for the purpose of expressing Rundell's modern viewpoints, such as the circus elephant. And there's the black African boy, who is loved by and accepted by everyone except the racist American villains. I realize that Rundell has background in Zimbabwe, but it still feels like forced Diversity. Along with him, we have English, Irish, and Russian immigrants among the "good guys" but everyone is happily equal and friendly.
In terms of the villains, I think it was a poor choice to name one Dillinger, because it's not the notorious John Dillinger. Were all the other surnames already in use? Back to the forced Diversity, I note that we have an Italian villain (Victor Sorrotore) who, unlike all the historical Prohibition-era Italian American bad guys, doesn't have an Italian crime family but instead is more equal opportunity in his hiring practices. Why? I guess we don't want to have any implications that Italian Americans all have mafia connections. Another thing that stuck out was the NYPL librarian, Miss Sutton, "a tall Latina woman" - why? Maybe for noted NYPL librarian Pura Belpre, but she was up in Harlem, where there was a large Puerto Rican population. Why not just have this exceptionally minor character be unnamed and undescribed - is it just to have an opportunity to Diversify? And I forgot that Vita herself has polio and a gimpy leg. (And yet she's always running from danger.) Oh, and she's ginger! How many of the Diversity checkboxes did we tick?
As in Rooftoppers, there are rationalized lies told by Vita to her family. We get the b.s. "promises" made right to the adult's face that are at that very moment known to be false or hedged. It's a poor trait for a heroine (and for a young reader) and it's lazy for Rundell to be using it again. And all the kids do this rationalized lying - even among themselves!
The presence of a Lipizzaner stallion and a lost jewel made me think of the much better book The Star of Kazan by Eva Ibbotson. These aren't the most essential aspects of this book, but there is a crucial reveal at the end that reinforces the similarity. I can't imagine that Rundell hadn't read the earlier book. She is well-versed in children's literature, and the other two books of hers that I've read immediately reminded me of Ibbotson (who is a wonderful model, but please don't borrow the details).
In an overall way, this also reminded me somewhat of the Mysterious Benedict Society books, but it's probably better (certainly it's less bloated). The illustrations are kind of that childish style too.
I did like the clever twist that pushes the story to its climax. It was set up well. The denouement was sort of dopey, wrapping everything up in a overly-perfect bow.
This was the first of Rundell's books that I read in print. I was very disappointed to see that it is presented in dumbed-down "pseudo-paragraph" style, where two or just one sentences are presented before a carriage return. In audio format it's not noticeable, but it grates on me to see such non-paragraphs on the page. I saw this in another newer author (Lauren Wolk) too. I feel like these authors are better writers than this, and it must be an editorial decision. Maybe I'm just an optimist....
Rundell has a lot of good things going for her, and I want to like her books, but at least the ones that I have read have each had significant flaws.
The setting is New York City, apparently in Prohibition era (there is mention of a speakeasy). I wish the historical aspects were more based in fact. It could be that Hudson Castle could be partly inspired by Bannerman's Castle or Carrollcliffe in NY, but there is no author's note to confirm this.
In addition to only a vague sense of history, there are also some things that seem to be introduced solely for the purpose of expressing Rundell's modern viewpoints, such as the circus elephant. And there's the black African boy, who is loved by and accepted by everyone except the racist American villains. I realize that Rundell has background in Zimbabwe, but it still feels like forced Diversity. Along with him, we have English, Irish, and Russian immigrants among the "good guys" but everyone is happily equal and friendly.
In terms of the villains, I think it was a poor choice to name one Dillinger, because it's not the notorious John Dillinger. Were all the other surnames already in use? Back to the forced Diversity, I note that we have an Italian villain (Victor Sorrotore) who, unlike all the historical Prohibition-era Italian American bad guys, doesn't have an Italian crime family but instead is more equal opportunity in his hiring practices. Why? I guess we don't want to have any implications that Italian Americans all have mafia connections. Another thing that stuck out was the NYPL librarian, Miss Sutton, "a tall Latina woman" - why? Maybe for noted NYPL librarian Pura Belpre, but she was up in Harlem, where there was a large Puerto Rican population. Why not just have this exceptionally minor character be unnamed and undescribed - is it just to have an opportunity to Diversify? And I forgot that Vita herself has polio and a gimpy leg. (And yet she's always running from danger.) Oh, and she's ginger! How many of the Diversity checkboxes did we tick?
As in Rooftoppers, there are rationalized lies told by Vita to her family. We get the b.s. "promises" made right to the adult's face that are at that very moment known to be false or hedged. It's a poor trait for a heroine (and for a young reader) and it's lazy for Rundell to be using it again. And all the kids do this rationalized lying - even among themselves!
The presence of a Lipizzaner stallion and a lost jewel made me think of the much better book The Star of Kazan by Eva Ibbotson. These aren't the most essential aspects of this book, but there is a crucial reveal at the end that reinforces the similarity. I can't imagine that Rundell hadn't read the earlier book. She is well-versed in children's literature, and the other two books of hers that I've read immediately reminded me of Ibbotson (who is a wonderful model, but please don't borrow the details).
In an overall way, this also reminded me somewhat of the Mysterious Benedict Society books, but it's probably better (certainly it's less bloated). The illustrations are kind of that childish style too.
I did like the clever twist that pushes the story to its climax. It was set up well. The denouement was sort of dopey, wrapping everything up in a overly-perfect bow.
This was the first of Rundell's books that I read in print. I was very disappointed to see that it is presented in dumbed-down "pseudo-paragraph" style, where two or just one sentences are presented before a carriage return. In audio format it's not noticeable, but it grates on me to see such non-paragraphs on the page. I saw this in another newer author (Lauren Wolk) too. I feel like these authors are better writers than this, and it must be an editorial decision. Maybe I'm just an optimist....
Rundell has a lot of good things going for her, and I want to like her books, but at least the ones that I have read have each had significant flaws.
July 31, 2019
Wow I guess this month was really good for me. I have finished the month with another beautiful book from a middle-grade genre. The story is basically a treasure hunt for a lion's eyes sized emerald necklace. Protagonist Vita Marlowe, new in New York came with her mother Julia to return her grandfather Jack Marlowe to London. He was cheated by a New York based mafia Victor Sorrotore. He befooled him & took away his ancestral Hudson castle. So now Vita has destined herself to return that castle to her beloved grandfather. And to accomplish this mission, she took help of three other persons. Silk who is efficient with her lock picking talent, Samuel who is an expert trapeze artist & Arcady who is an animal tamer and son of an owner of Russian Circus group. Vita who is also skilled with her knife throwing talent, and she has got a penknife which will be another weapon to deal with Sorrotore and his goons. Now this talented team will do this in such an adventurous way, which will keep you attracted to the story like you are reading stories of Peter Pan or Tom Sawyer.
.
.
The most super-fun thing about this book is, author Katherine has portrayed each character with fantastic visualization and individualities. Like Vita who can do anything for her grandfather, whether she has overlooked her physical inabilities. Silk who wants to left pick pocketing and want to live a normal life and for that she joined them to help Vita. Arcady who showed his strong friendship towards Vita & Samuel, who wants to fly high with his amazing talents. The story is set in 1920/30’s New York, after the First World War. The book is full of thrill, adventure, dramatic, friendship and didactic. It’s a complete package and well worth reading. If you don’t want to pick a middle-grade novel, this pick it as an adventure one. Thanks Bloomsbury India for the gifted proof copy.
Ratings : 4.5/5
Displaying 1 - 30 of 530 reviews