Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Diamond District Mystery #1

A Murder is Forever

Rate this book
Out of options, and money, unemployed journalist Mimi Rosen goes to work for her father's gem company in New York City's Diamond District, though the two don't always get along. When Mimi's diamond-dealer cousin Yosef is murdered, seemingly over a $4 million pink diamond, Mimi discovers that the stone is key to a scandal involving bribery and murder, which may even implicate members of her own family.

216 pages, Paperback

Published October 13, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rob Bates

4 books86 followers
Rob Bates has written about the diamond industry for 30 years. He is currently the news director of JCK, the leading publication in the jewelry industry. He has won 12 editorial awards for his work.

His first novel in the Diamond District Mystery Series, A Murder is Forever, was published by Camel Press in October 2020. It was called a “sprightly debut” by Publishers Weekly, which said that “readers will look forward to Mimi’s further adventures.”

The second novel, Murder is Not a Girl’s Best Friend, was published by Camel Press in February 2022. Booklist said it offers “not only an engaging sleuth with an amusingly snarky sense of humor but also a cleverly constructed plot rich with fascinating tidbits about the diamond trade.”

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
28 (39%)
4 stars
27 (38%)
3 stars
13 (18%)
2 stars
2 (2%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
Profile Image for "Avonna.
1,546 reviews603 followers
December 30, 2020
Check out all of my reviews: https://www.avonnalovesgenres.com

A MURDER IS FOREVER (The Diamond District Mystery Series Book #1) by Rob Bates is the first book in a new amateur sleuth cozy mystery series set in New York City’s Diamond District.

Mimi Rosen is an unemployed journalist with no prospects and out of money. She reluctantly goes to work doing the books for her father’s gem company in the Diamond District of NYC.

Diamond dealing can be a dangerous profession and when Mimi’s cousin, Yosef is murdered it is assumed to be a gang related robbery, but the last 24 hours of Yosef’s life, lead Mimi to believe there is something more going on that all revolves around a large pink diamond her cousin was trying to sell.

As Mimi learns more about the diamond industry, she believes her cousin was involved in a scandal that involves bribery and murder all related to the pink diamond. Another death considered a suicide and a personal attack on Mimi’s life make Mimi more determined than ever to solve Josef’s murder no matter the consequences.

This mystery was well paced with enough twists and red herrings to keep me turning the pages and an interesting setting in NYC’s Diamond District. This book immerses the reader in the close familial diamond business and the orthodox Jewish culture in the area without slowing the pace in the mystery itself. Mimi is an interesting main character that I had mixed feeling about. On the surface, you feel sympathy for her situation, but as you read on you realize that she brought many of her personal problems on herself. As she deals with the murder, she once again is jumping into a situation she is not prepared to handle. All the secondary characters were interesting, but some seemed more caricature than realistic.

Overall, an entertaining and interesting mystery.
Profile Image for Jypsy .
1,524 reviews68 followers
December 11, 2020
Thank you PICT for a complimentary copy. I voluntarily reviexwed this book. All opinions expressed are my own.

A Murder Is Forever
The Diamond District Mystery Series
By: Rob Bates

REVIEW ☆☆☆☆

A Diamond Is Forever, maybe. A Murder Is Forever, definitely. I can't imagine working in the diamond district, and after reading this story, I don't really want to. Diamonds are a serious business with a sharp edged hint of danger. I learned a lot of information about an industry that seems to hide itself well. From the front of the store to the backrooms, the story has drama, mystery and tension. The characters are intelligent and determined with witty interactions and good chemistry. I enjoyed the overall experience of reading this book, and I would recommend it.
Profile Image for Annarella.
14.4k reviews175 followers
January 1, 2021
This is an excellent debut for a new mystery series.
It’s highly entertaining and well written, a gripping story that kept me hooked till the end.
I loved the descriptions of the diamond business world and of the Jewish traditions, both are well researched and I learned a lot about diamonds and how they are sold&bought.
The mystery is full of twists and turns and it kept me guessing. I think there’s a lot of potential in this series that could become a favourite of mine.
I had some issues with Mimi, the MC, as I found her a bit too harsh and reckless. She’s facing a lot of problems and looking for solutions but at the same time it seems she’s looking for further troubles and it’s hard to root for her. I’m sure she will become wiser and her social skills will improve in the next installment.
It’s an interesting and engrossing read that I recommend.
Many thanks to Rob Bates and Partner in Crime for this ARC, all opinions are mine
Profile Image for Kathleen.
1,482 reviews35 followers
January 21, 2021
In A Murder Is Forever, book one of The Diamond District Mystery Series, author Rob Bates transports the reader to New York City's Diamond District located on 47th Street between Fifth and Six Avenues, for an intriguing mystery story that will keep the reader guessing and turning the pages.

Just when you think diamonds are forever ... Mimi Rosen finds out that A Murder Is Forever too ...

Mimi Rosen is an unemployed journalist who works part-time as the bookkeeper at her father's gem store, Max Rosen Diamond Company. When her cousin Yosef Levine, a small-time diamond dealer is murdered in a robbery, Channa Morgenstern, Yosef's newly engaged fiancee, doesn't think Yosef's murder was random but rather a set up, and she asks Mimi to investigate the murder.

What looks like a classic robbery / murder case is anything but that when Mimi starts to dig into the Diamond District's industry located on 47th Street, and comprised mostly of Orthodox / Hasidic Jewish families and companies. The more Mimi digs into her cousin's diamond dealing business and the diamond industry, the more she is warned to leave it alone, but she is determined to reveal the truth and seek justice for her cousin's murder, even if someone wants to permanently stop her.

Author Rob Bates weaves a slow-building and suspenseful tale that follows Mimi's investigation to uncover the truth behind the murder of her cousin. I loved reading this action-packed story. Mimi's observations and digging during the investigation kept me intrigued as she slowly put the pieces of the mystery puzzle together.

The reader will be easily drawn into this richly descriptive plot that will keep them guessing as long hidden secrets, family dramas, a growing list of possible suspects, motives, and clues are uncovered, while leaving the reader completely shocked by the surprise ending.

I would be remiss if I didn't mention how much I enjoyed the author's rich description of New York City's Diamond District, and I was fascinated by the background into the Jewish culture and community, who are the mainstay of the diamond industry on 47th Street.

I look forward to reading the next book in The Diamond District Mystery Series.

A Murder Is Forever has enough drama, tension, action, dark secrets, intrigue, and unexpected twists and turns that will take the reader on one heck of a thrilling roller coaster ride.

Disclaimer: I received a copy of the book from the author / publisher in exchange for my honest review and participation in a virtual book tour event hosted by Partners In Crime Virtual Book Tours.

https://jerseygirlbookreviews.blogspo...
14 reviews
December 22, 2020
An enjoyable fast paced diamond thriller

Showing his experience of the diamond industry, Rob’s written an Enjoyable thriller based on his real insight into a tight knit community and the potential of institutional corruption by a few can all too easily destroy, trust, lives and relationships - Rob’s created an interesting character is his ‘sleuth’ I trust she’ll be back for another adventure
Profile Image for Jeremiah.
315 reviews4 followers
November 3, 2020
What a fun read! This one has it all: engaging characters, humor and a plot that had me guessing until the end. While this book is a solid mystery, I'd also recommend it as a journalism textbook--Bates offers effective tips on how to investigate a story and interview sources. I'm looking forward to the next book in the series!
Profile Image for Tam Sesto.
913 reviews18 followers
October 30, 2025
It was easy to like Mimi. There were times she came across quite depressing, but you couldn’t help but root for her. You can tell the author knows the diamond business as it was a character in the book itself. I’m not that familiar with the Jewish community, so this book provided me with some interesting insights into their traditions and practices. The story progressed smoothly, and the ending was satisfying.

My review is voluntary and all comments and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Jane Pettitt.
662 reviews40 followers
December 13, 2020
I enjoyed the story very much, first book in series Mimi accepts a job with her father max , but she really is a journalist . Yosef her cousin is murdered but they didn’t the diamond, Mimi is investigating and things done add up ,
Profile Image for Debbie Rozier.
1,525 reviews95 followers
January 26, 2021
About the Book: Mimi Rosen is working as an accountant in her father’s diamond dealer business after being laid off from her editing job. Her cousin, Yoseph, has recently acquired a 3 carat pink diamond. The day after becoming engaged Yoseph is shot after fighting back from a robbery attempt. But..it’s not that cut and dry. Mimi dusts off her journalist’s skills to find out exactly what happened to Yoseph when things don’t add up.


My thoughts: This is a great read with easy dialogue and a mystery that kept me guessing. I like it when the murder occurs earlier in the book and then the rest of the book works on solving the mystery and this read did that perfectly. I also learned about the inner workings of the diamond business and enjoyed the richness of the Jewish culture that the book provided.
Thank you to @partnersincrimevbt for a copy to read and review.
Profile Image for Margaret Yelton.
2,146 reviews47 followers
January 31, 2021
A Murder Is Forever is the first book in (The Diamond District Mystery Series) written by Rob Bates. This was a new author for me and as with all new authors you don't know whether you will enjoy their books or not. Having said that I found the book to be very well written, and a storyline that kept me turning pages until the very end. This is one business that I know absolutely nothing about, but the author seems well researched and interested in learning more. I found the book to be full of many twists and turns, and I would definitely recommend this read to others.

I received a copy of the book from the author and #partnersincrimetours and am under no obligation to leave a favorable review, all opinions expressed here are my own.
246 reviews1 follower
January 6, 2021
Dreams lost and found. This book has them. There are also some nightmares in there.

Mimi is an out of work journalist who is working part-time for her father. It's not what she wants to do, but it's necessary in order to pay her rent and buy things like food.

She finds a friend in the office receptionist, but that turns into a not so friendly relationship as Mimi tries to find out who murdered her cousin.

You'll meet some interesting characters and be surprised when the murderer is revealed.

Thank you, Mr. Bates. I'm looking forward to seeing what kind of trouble Mimi next gets into next.

***Book provided without charge by PICT.***
Profile Image for Daniel Ford.
Author 2 books27 followers
October 27, 2020
New charts will have to be made to explain how off the charts this book is. The cover deserves a New York City diner backdrop and a Greek coffee cup, but, alas, pandemic. Filled with the author’s signature humor and intelligence, A Murder Is Forever not only made me homesick for the city, but also for the quirky industry where I started my career.
Profile Image for Patty Young.
22 reviews1 follower
February 1, 2021
Enjoyed this book! Fast moving story set in the Diamond District. Murder and shady business practices. If you've ever visited 47th street, you'll want to read this! Looking forward to his 2 other books.
Profile Image for Stefani.
38 reviews1 follower
December 24, 2021
Tight plot and appealing characters, Rob Bates leads us through the complicated dealings of the Diamond District and murder. Thoroughly enjoyed and can’t wait to read more about MImi
1 review
February 4, 2023
I'm usually a rom-com kinda girl but I do enjoy the occasional detective story so long as it doesn't turn into a thriller. I love all things sparkly and am looking to move into the gemstones industry professionally myself so have been "researching*" which is how I came across Rob's books. It's a must if you're interested in gemmology, jewellery and love fiction!

*Researching summed up in this order = googling jewellery books, GIA, science-based textbooks, YouTube videos, companies and podcasts, stumbling across the JCK podcast, researching Rob and Victoria and their articles online, then somewhere down the internet black hole probably at a ridiculous hour when I should have long been asleep (you know how it is when the lines of research, further learning, nosy-parker turned stalker get blurred), I discovered to my delight Rob's books and, kerching, like magic they were ordered.

Anyhoo...

Rob's book was one I couldn't put down once I started the first chapter. He had me hooked.

Not only was this a fab book with some excellent red herrings and plot twists but it really gives you an insight into the Diamond District in New York and you can tell Rob knows his industry in all things gemstones, journalism and New York life. The part that was a real surprise though and which I thoroughly enjoyed was diving into Jewish culture and customs and learning some Yiddish! A wonderful treat as a linguist!

I also could relate so much to Mimi Rosen, her personality, the faux pas, but also where she is in life--starting over after a divorce-- and love that, unlike most happily ever afters, you don't always need to have a knight in shining armour at the end. I love that I could connect to the book and Mimi. And I like that I felt as if I were actually standing on 47th Street. The descriptions make you feel you are there and you can visualise it so vividly. I even started looking up places and names from the book which further imbedded this feeling that the story was real because these places actually exist!

The dialogue was really great between the characters and the structure and flow worked seamlessly with a super plot to allow me to just lose myself in the book. I also loved that I didn't need to "work out" the sentences and re-read them as some writers try to sound clever and use complex sentence structure which puts me off. My current job takes up so much headspace that I am mentally fatigued at the end of the day or first thing in the morning on my commute home so I really appreciate clear writing where I don't have to interpret the meaning first from a linguistic perspective but can unwind, relax and just absorb the story. Rob nailed it.

I bought both Rob's books together so am now 1/3 of the way through the second and I honestly hope there is a 3rd coming soon! I am learning so much about the jewellery industry from a whole new perspective and really enjoying the detective aspect of trying to work out who dunnit! Mazal Tov Rob and thank you for writing this story! LOVED IT!
2 reviews
October 15, 2022
Got a complimentary book form harlequin readers. Great book good concept I wasn’t expecting who it was but i wasn’t surprised either the book is very small but it seemed as if the they were repeating the same facts over and over again, trying to get more pages in. Everything kind of made little sense at the end but if written a little more properly could have been a phenomenal book.
Profile Image for Rob Bates.
Author 4 books86 followers
Want to Read
January 26, 2023
All right, I don't want to rate this book, because I wrote it, and rating it feels kind of dumb. I'm also incapable of judging it. A lot depends on my mood. But I appreciate all those who read it and am happy to answer questions!

Rob
455 reviews1 follower
January 26, 2025
3.5 stars. A friend recommended “A murder is forever “ as I have never heard of the book nor the author.
It’s a fast reading book involving the diamond trade on 47th Street in Manhattan. Enjoyable yet at times challenging and confusing.
Profile Image for Tambra.
879 reviews8 followers
November 15, 2022
Great book. Interesting story, Cant wait to read more.
Profile Image for Anna.
54 reviews
October 29, 2026
Kind of mid. Liked the mystery aspect but never was really hooked
Profile Image for Joan.
4,585 reviews142 followers
December 14, 2020
This is a very interesting mystery set in the diamond district in New York City. The diamond dealers highlighted in this novel are Jewish. I happily learned quite a bit about diamonds, how they are graded and marketed. I also learned quite a bit about Jewish traditions and culture too. (So that's why the women wear wigs.)

The mystery itself is well done. It revolved nicely around the idea of how diamonds are valued. Mimi, the heroine is a out of work journalist bent on solving the murder. I always find it interesting when a male author writes a female lead character. Mimi's character is relatively well done but a bit too impulsive for my taste. I didn't like that she alienated so many people and told so many lies. I think a woman who suspected she might be the next one killed would have made better choices. And in New York City in early evening, are there really no people on the sidewalks or subway entrances to see an attack?

This is a good debut novel from an author who really knows the setting in which he placed the mystery. The writing style is straight forward, making for a pleasant read. I look forward to reading another novel featuring a wiser Mimi.

I received a complimentary digital copy of this book through Partners in Crime Virtual Book Tours. My comments are an independent and honest review.
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews