What do you think?
Rate this book
RWBY #3
Roman Holiday
In the future-fantasy world of RWBY, Rooster Teeth's hit animated webseries, teens train to become warriors. Join the fight in this epic official original novel from E.C. Myers and RWBY's head writers!
Don't miss this exclusive, original story straight from award-winning author E.C. Myers and RWBY's head writers, Kerry Shawcross and Miles Luna!
Don't miss this exclusive, original story straight from award-winning author E.C. Myers and RWBY's head writers, Kerry Shawcross and Miles Luna!
320 pages, Paperback
First published September 7, 2021
54 people are currently reading
419 people want to read
About the author
E.C. Myers
108 books404 followersE.C. Myers was assembled in the U.S. from Korean and German parts and raised in Yonkers, NY by his mother and the public library. He is a graduate of the Clarion West Writers Workshop and a member of the prolific NYC writing group Altered Fluid. In the rare moments when he isn't writing, he blogs about Star Trek at The Viewscreen, reads constantly, plays video games, watches films and television, sleeps as little as possible, and spends far too much time on the internet. His first novel, FAIR COIN, won the 2012 Andre Norton Award for Young Adult Science Fiction and Fantasy.
WATTPAD: http://www.wattpad.com/user/ecmyers
WATTPAD: http://www.wattpad.com/user/ecmyers
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
Read
September 7, 2021I wrote this! During a pandemic! Whew. That was a thing.
September 21, 2021
This book was so much fun! This origin story of Neopolitan and Roman's partnership had incredible character developement and tied in nicely to the RWBY universe that we already know and love. Definitely my favorite of the RWBY books!
September 8, 2021
I'm not good at reviews, so, all I can say is: I've loved RWBY since I was introduced to the series back in 2014. I have loved every bit of it, from the world-building, to the creatures, characters, music, and the story as it has evolved, and with the release of books in the series (After The Fall, Before The Dawn, and Fairy Tales of Remnant) it has only increased the immersiveness I've felt for the franchise. This book doesn't keep up with the heroes, but it's a backstory of two seemingly loved characters, Roman Torchwick, and Neopolitan, and how they met, so, almost immediately, I'm caught, and tugged back into the World of Remnant. If you like the series, then you'll like this book! As well, after seeing her, barely, throughout the course of the show, Neopolitan has proven to be less favorable by myself, but this book puts her in a better light, more amusing, and even gives a little bit of pity to her. Seeing her interactions with Roman, too, have proven very fun!
September 15, 2025
3.5 stars
Okay, this was okay. It was fun. I think it was somewhat well written and well constructed.
I just happen to not particularly care about Roman Torchwick and Neopolitan. Do I understand them better now? Probably a bit, yeah.
I know these two are fan favourites, so if you liked them, you will probably love this book. They really get to shine.
I did like the focus on how Neo’s mutism made people underestimate her, not understand her or try to force her to communicate in a way they wanted, only for Roman to look at her and be able to understand her so easily, because he takes her as the person she is.
There were a lot of points that made me go: Oh, so that's how they end up there in the show. So, a lot of little easter eggs strewn across for fans of RWBY to link together. That was fun!
All in all: fun, not necessary, but probably very appreaciated by fans of the show and especially fans of Neo and Roman.
Okay, this was okay. It was fun. I think it was somewhat well written and well constructed.
I just happen to not particularly care about Roman Torchwick and Neopolitan. Do I understand them better now? Probably a bit, yeah.
I know these two are fan favourites, so if you liked them, you will probably love this book. They really get to shine.
I did like the focus on how Neo’s mutism made people underestimate her, not understand her or try to force her to communicate in a way they wanted, only for Roman to look at her and be able to understand her so easily, because he takes her as the person she is.
There were a lot of points that made me go: Oh, so that's how they end up there in the show. So, a lot of little easter eggs strewn across for fans of RWBY to link together. That was fun!
All in all: fun, not necessary, but probably very appreaciated by fans of the show and especially fans of Neo and Roman.
January 28, 2023
"Do you hear me?"
Trivia pretended to wince and covered her ears. She rolled her eyes. Obviously. I'm mute, not deaf.
Disclaimer. The following review contains unmarked spoilers for RWBY Volumes 1 up to 8.
I've been a RWBY fan for nearly three years now - I discovered the series right before Covid swept Europe away, so believe me when I say I distinctly remember. And while my all-time favourite characters of the series are RWBY - Ruby, Weiss, Blake and Yang - themselves, obviously, my next-favourite one is, without any doubt whatsoever, Neopolitan. Neo. Love her. I mean, seriously, how can't you love her? She's just so great. I absolutely adore her, her character and her behaviour, the way she expresses her thoughts without saying anything. As I am writing this, Volume 9 is almost going out into the world and she's come such a long way. I've always believed that she's destined to, in the end, change sides and get some kind of a redemption arc - and you have to take these things slow, of course, but I'm not-so-secretly hoping that Vol. 9 will finally be the time when it'll happen.
So, you get me, right? I love her. So I just had to read this book about her background - and Roman's too, even though he only features in the first three volumes, of course. Roman is so charismatic and has that dry sense of humour that makes you laugh, even if he's a villain. Anyway, I was incredibly excited to read about them when they were younger, and the creators don't disappoint. There's a clear evolution visible in the first chapters of the book, where the two characters are still much younger than in the rest of the story, and especially with Trivia/Neo you can slowly see how she becomes the character I know from the show.
It takes a while before the story itself takes off; most of the first one hundred pages is just getting to know the two characters, the people around them, and seeing them growing up a bit. Afterwards, things start happening - and as it turns out, there are a lot of things happening. Pretty incredible, everything that's present in this book. There's fun and humour, thrills and excitement, cliffhangers and plottwists. Basically, it's everything I was going for. The only thing I do miss a bit is some kind of... link with the show itself, because that's not there. I was half expecting that the book would end with a final chapter, or an epilogue, a flashforward, with them being around Beacon Academy or maybe even crossing paths with Ruby or someone else... Was such a scene really necessary? Nope, of course it wasn't. I just would've liked this book even more then. Thankfully, I already do.
Oh, one more thing. Just look at that cover! Now that is something!
8.4/10
Trivia pretended to wince and covered her ears. She rolled her eyes. Obviously. I'm mute, not deaf.
Disclaimer. The following review contains unmarked spoilers for RWBY Volumes 1 up to 8.
I've been a RWBY fan for nearly three years now - I discovered the series right before Covid swept Europe away, so believe me when I say I distinctly remember. And while my all-time favourite characters of the series are RWBY - Ruby, Weiss, Blake and Yang - themselves, obviously, my next-favourite one is, without any doubt whatsoever, Neopolitan. Neo. Love her. I mean, seriously, how can't you love her? She's just so great. I absolutely adore her, her character and her behaviour, the way she expresses her thoughts without saying anything. As I am writing this, Volume 9 is almost going out into the world and she's come such a long way. I've always believed that she's destined to, in the end, change sides and get some kind of a redemption arc - and you have to take these things slow, of course, but I'm not-so-secretly hoping that Vol. 9 will finally be the time when it'll happen.
So, you get me, right? I love her. So I just had to read this book about her background - and Roman's too, even though he only features in the first three volumes, of course. Roman is so charismatic and has that dry sense of humour that makes you laugh, even if he's a villain. Anyway, I was incredibly excited to read about them when they were younger, and the creators don't disappoint. There's a clear evolution visible in the first chapters of the book, where the two characters are still much younger than in the rest of the story, and especially with Trivia/Neo you can slowly see how she becomes the character I know from the show.
It takes a while before the story itself takes off; most of the first one hundred pages is just getting to know the two characters, the people around them, and seeing them growing up a bit. Afterwards, things start happening - and as it turns out, there are a lot of things happening. Pretty incredible, everything that's present in this book. There's fun and humour, thrills and excitement, cliffhangers and plottwists. Basically, it's everything I was going for. The only thing I do miss a bit is some kind of... link with the show itself, because that's not there. I was half expecting that the book would end with a final chapter, or an epilogue, a flashforward, with them being around Beacon Academy or maybe even crossing paths with Ruby or someone else... Was such a scene really necessary? Nope, of course it wasn't. I just would've liked this book even more then. Thankfully, I already do.
Oh, one more thing. Just look at that cover! Now that is something!
8.4/10
September 11, 2021
Typical in these RWBY novels, the world building is easily the best part - but I still actually enjoyed seeing Roman be Roman and Neo (or Trivia) become Neo. Really fun fight scenes, use of semblances, and schemes!
I thought it was off that the two MCs don't even meet until halfway through, and the actually development of their relationship seemed a bit rushed. Roman sees that Neo is halfway decent and smart - and is suddenly all about training her and bringing her on heists. He's got a soft spot for young people (at least a bit with the Malachite twins and yknow not wanting them to die lol) but it seemed fast imo.
Neo herself doesn't really know why she decided to stick around Roman, but is very devoted and loyal by the end without a real realization on her part. But they do have great chemistry and a really entertaining relationship. The way they communicate is funny and sweet, and I have to admit it makes the way Roman went out in V3 have more of an impact. But Neo really shines in this, once she starts using her Semblance, its so fun. She comes out of her shell and becomes the slightly insane reckless and cocky Neo we know and love.
I do have to say the actual criminal element is VERY basic. It's nice to see a bit of how Mistral operates, but with Vale its just very...simple. Corrupt politicians and useless cops, crime bosses that are taken out way too easy, and even the huntsmen were underwhelming to see in a fight (I mean the bank heist was in Vale - would it KILL Meyers to throw Qrow a bone?? Just a little cameo I beg you)) plus the names were just killing me. Brick and Mortar? Roch Szalt? Not the most creative imo
But again, I came to really like their relationship, which is the point of the book. Wish they spent more time actually getting to know each other rather than just saying how they met, but any Neo and Roman fan would definitely love to see more of their favorites.
I thought it was off that the two MCs don't even meet until halfway through, and the actually development of their relationship seemed a bit rushed. Roman sees that Neo is halfway decent and smart - and is suddenly all about training her and bringing her on heists. He's got a soft spot for young people (at least a bit with the Malachite twins and yknow not wanting them to die lol) but it seemed fast imo.
Neo herself doesn't really know why she decided to stick around Roman, but is very devoted and loyal by the end without a real realization on her part. But they do have great chemistry and a really entertaining relationship. The way they communicate is funny and sweet, and I have to admit it makes the way Roman went out in V3 have more of an impact. But Neo really shines in this, once she starts using her Semblance, its so fun. She comes out of her shell and becomes the slightly insane reckless and cocky Neo we know and love.
I do have to say the actual criminal element is VERY basic. It's nice to see a bit of how Mistral operates, but with Vale its just very...simple. Corrupt politicians and useless cops, crime bosses that are taken out way too easy, and even the huntsmen were underwhelming to see in a fight (I mean the bank heist was in Vale - would it KILL Meyers to throw Qrow a bone?? Just a little cameo I beg you)) plus the names were just killing me. Brick and Mortar? Roch Szalt? Not the most creative imo
But again, I came to really like their relationship, which is the point of the book. Wish they spent more time actually getting to know each other rather than just saying how they met, but any Neo and Roman fan would definitely love to see more of their favorites.
April 14, 2024
4/14/24
I went into this not being the biggest fan of Roman or Neo. I always wondered what the FNDM saw in them that I didn’t.
But now?
I’m obsessed with them.
This story takes two characters who are interesting on their own and adds, in my opinion, a very necessary backstory that makes them 20x more compelling.
I’ve rewatched RWBY numerous times since I got into the show. I’m doing another rewatch right now before Rooster Teeth goes bye bye, and having the information from this book during volumes 1-3 added so much depth to every Roman and Neo appearance.
And don’t get me started on how it makes Neo’s actions post volume 3 make *so* much sense.
Also I genuinely cannot think about volume 9 Neo and this book. I will actually cry.
ANYWAY. I love this. I love them.
I went into this not being the biggest fan of Roman or Neo. I always wondered what the FNDM saw in them that I didn’t.
But now?
I’m obsessed with them.
This story takes two characters who are interesting on their own and adds, in my opinion, a very necessary backstory that makes them 20x more compelling.
I’ve rewatched RWBY numerous times since I got into the show. I’m doing another rewatch right now before Rooster Teeth goes bye bye, and having the information from this book during volumes 1-3 added so much depth to every Roman and Neo appearance.
And don’t get me started on how it makes Neo’s actions post volume 3 make *so* much sense.
Also I genuinely cannot think about volume 9 Neo and this book. I will actually cry.
ANYWAY. I love this. I love them.
November 7, 2021
the pink one so terrify, loved it
January 4, 2023
Wow this book actually made me care about Roman Torchwick for approximately 2.5 seconds.
July 11, 2025
First of all: RWBY!!!!!
Second of all: if you want to read this book, first watch all of RWBY, all the way through Volume 9, because that volume of RWBY will give you an even more integrated view into the main character of this book, Neapolitan. I gotta say, this was exactly what I needed to complete the view of both Roman Torchwick and Trivia “Neapolitan” Vanille. Good job with the story!!
The writing sounds AI generated, like the other E. C. Meyers RWBY novels. Don’t read the other ECM RWBY novels. Read this one though!!
Second of all: if you want to read this book, first watch all of RWBY, all the way through Volume 9, because that volume of RWBY will give you an even more integrated view into the main character of this book, Neapolitan. I gotta say, this was exactly what I needed to complete the view of both Roman Torchwick and Trivia “Neapolitan” Vanille. Good job with the story!!
The writing sounds AI generated, like the other E. C. Meyers RWBY novels. Don’t read the other ECM RWBY novels. Read this one though!!
February 4, 2022
It was good to finally here some backstory for Neo she's always be surrounded in mystery.
October 31, 2021
I'm bised AF. I adore and love anything RWBY and this was no exception.
I love that they give us the villain's backstory. Specially these two, Neo and Roman are really loved characters and I loved getting to know their origins and how they get together.
now when I re-watch RWBY I'll be seeing them with different eyes and even more fondness.
I have to admit, I did not expect this book to be set in before (I believe it's before? don't mind me I get confused easily with timelines) it all, since the other two books where set parallel to the main story so that was a surprise!
I do have to admit I was kind of disappointed at how fast paced this one was, it kind of makes sense to be this way but also missed the world building from the previous books. But I understand that we're revisiting locations we know so there's not much need to that other than the aspects that are relevant to this side of the story.
I also loved getting to know the twins, I always found them quite interesting so knowing more about them was fun! I would've never expected them to be in this book tho.
So yeah, overall it was a blast, I can't help myself with any RWBY content and I always enjoy it and I'm so sad it's over I hope we get another book because I really enjoy getting to know Remnant and it's citizens like this, in various formats. It adds so much to both the way I see the characters and to the main story.
I love that they give us the villain's backstory. Specially these two, Neo and Roman are really loved characters and I loved getting to know their origins and how they get together.
now when I re-watch RWBY I'll be seeing them with different eyes and even more fondness.
I have to admit, I did not expect this book to be set in before (I believe it's before? don't mind me I get confused easily with timelines) it all, since the other two books where set parallel to the main story so that was a surprise!
I do have to admit I was kind of disappointed at how fast paced this one was, it kind of makes sense to be this way but also missed the world building from the previous books. But I understand that we're revisiting locations we know so there's not much need to that other than the aspects that are relevant to this side of the story.
I also loved getting to know the twins, I always found them quite interesting so knowing more about them was fun! I would've never expected them to be in this book tho.
So yeah, overall it was a blast, I can't help myself with any RWBY content and I always enjoy it and I'm so sad it's over I hope we get another book because I really enjoy getting to know Remnant and it's citizens like this, in various formats. It adds so much to both the way I see the characters and to the main story.
October 2, 2021
Just a quick review here since I do not ever really review books. I'd like to make two points regarding this book.
The author, E.C. Meyers has now written 4 of these companion pieces to the RWBY animated series. And I truly believe that his storytelling has gotten better with each one. Especially with this book, I am drawn further and further into the lore of the RWBY world of Remnant. Mr. Meyers takes the characters already set up by the series and makes them even more interesting. They come to life on the pages as well as they do on the screens, and in some cases, they become more flushed out with the written medium than the series. In this case, a fan favorite Roman Torchwick gets the long awaited spotlight and everyone's favorite mute, Neo gets the origin story we all wanted too. Side note, major props to Mr. Meyers for writing a story with an unspeaking character. That is NOT an easy task. I have actively steered away from that character trait in my books.
Brett Salter
The second point I want to make as a huge fan of RWBY, is that I believe that the writers of the show are doing a marvelous version of continuing Monty's vision the best that they can. It's true that the show is not the same as it used to be. The original things that drew me to the series are not at the forefront anymore, but it is STILL one of my favorite shows. However, this is not about the show. This is about the book. And I want to leave you with this final thought. I believe that E.C. Meyers is excelling and exceeding all expectations when it comes to the written canon of the series. I cannot wait for the next installment to get a scintillating insight into some of the secondary characters, which are some of my favorites, that only Mr. Meyers can provide.
Enjoy this book if you like the show or anything about the RWBY series. Ages 10 and up. Hopefully it sparks an overactive imagination in its readers.
The author, E.C. Meyers has now written 4 of these companion pieces to the RWBY animated series. And I truly believe that his storytelling has gotten better with each one. Especially with this book, I am drawn further and further into the lore of the RWBY world of Remnant. Mr. Meyers takes the characters already set up by the series and makes them even more interesting. They come to life on the pages as well as they do on the screens, and in some cases, they become more flushed out with the written medium than the series. In this case, a fan favorite Roman Torchwick gets the long awaited spotlight and everyone's favorite mute, Neo gets the origin story we all wanted too. Side note, major props to Mr. Meyers for writing a story with an unspeaking character. That is NOT an easy task. I have actively steered away from that character trait in my books.
Brett Salter
The second point I want to make as a huge fan of RWBY, is that I believe that the writers of the show are doing a marvelous version of continuing Monty's vision the best that they can. It's true that the show is not the same as it used to be. The original things that drew me to the series are not at the forefront anymore, but it is STILL one of my favorite shows. However, this is not about the show. This is about the book. And I want to leave you with this final thought. I believe that E.C. Meyers is excelling and exceeding all expectations when it comes to the written canon of the series. I cannot wait for the next installment to get a scintillating insight into some of the secondary characters, which are some of my favorites, that only Mr. Meyers can provide.
Enjoy this book if you like the show or anything about the RWBY series. Ages 10 and up. Hopefully it sparks an overactive imagination in its readers.
September 7, 2021
Neo and Roman the Best Partners in Crime
Roman Tortwick always works alone. That is, until he meets Neopolitan in Vale. Stories in Remnant are never happy forever. Steal, deceive, and survive with everybody's favorite crime duo as they learn who they are, and find meaning in their tragic lives. An origin story guaranteed to be action-packed, emotional, bittersweet, and a highly-anticipated read for any Rwby fan. I leave out romance because it's not written as one. Chibi Neo has been bold enough to call Roman her dum-dum, and she references the chibiverse in a drawing she does. Reguardless of how you feel about Neo's feelings towards Roman, in this book he is in deliberately stated friendship with her. Some people were more concerned with him being a little older, than him being a bad influence. Rest-assured the 18-year old Neo does not date Roman in this book. Please give it a try.
Roman Tortwick always works alone. That is, until he meets Neopolitan in Vale. Stories in Remnant are never happy forever. Steal, deceive, and survive with everybody's favorite crime duo as they learn who they are, and find meaning in their tragic lives. An origin story guaranteed to be action-packed, emotional, bittersweet, and a highly-anticipated read for any Rwby fan. I leave out romance because it's not written as one. Chibi Neo has been bold enough to call Roman her dum-dum, and she references the chibiverse in a drawing she does. Reguardless of how you feel about Neo's feelings towards Roman, in this book he is in deliberately stated friendship with her. Some people were more concerned with him being a little older, than him being a bad influence. Rest-assured the 18-year old Neo does not date Roman in this book. Please give it a try.
September 12, 2021
RWBY is one of my favorite animated shows of all time because of its awesome characters, so I loved this book for giving me the backstories I had been wondering about for the past eight seasons. Getting to read from Neo and Roman's perspectives was really special, and I enjoyed the tie-ins to other characters in the show as well. There were no surprises in the plot for me personally as there were in the past RWBY novels, but it was a quick, enjoyable read. I recommend to anyone who is a fan of the show, and especially to those of us who still miss Torchwick.
September 16, 2021
This was cute and fun, exactly what I was hoping for! Backstory for these two is something I've always wanted. They're charismatic enough to carry the story by themselves, and I only wish there was more of the same.
September 19, 2021
BACKSTORY TIME!
Roman is objectively the best villain. Bad guy, sure, but a classy bad guy. And I absolutely love getting Neo's backstory, she is now my crime child, I have adopted her. The only danger in having read this as soon as it came out is, now I have to wait forever for the next one.
Roman is objectively the best villain. Bad guy, sure, but a classy bad guy. And I absolutely love getting Neo's backstory, she is now my crime child, I have adopted her. The only danger in having read this as soon as it came out is, now I have to wait forever for the next one.
October 22, 2021
Very fun to finally get a back story for these two, I excepted a bit more but it was good for the most part.
September 12, 2023
I am soooo in love with Torchwick
November 18, 2024
Accurate rating: 3.5 out of 5
Let me admit that I never was interested in Rooster Teeth's RWBY when it first came out. I heard about it a couple of times, but I never watched it. That changed when I stumbled across a TV Tropes' Self-Demonstrating page (i.e. a character describing themselves in the first-person view) for Neopolitan (an antagonist from RWBY) that I read. Shortly after, I became interested to watch the series and reading this book to know more about Neo, because her unique character design, inability to speak, and backstory sounded intriguing.
When I picked up this book and finished it, I feel that I got my money's worth (for the most part, but more on that later).
I'll start off by saying that Neopolitan's character arc is the best aspect of this book. To explain, Neopolitan was formerly known as Trivia Vanille, a shy, meek girl born under the Vanille family. Her parents, Jimmy and Carmel, emotionally abuse their daughter for being imperfect (read, their daughter suffers from this inability to speak, along with having heterochromatic eyes; one brown, one pink). The two aren't fond of their daughter spending time playing with her "imaginary friend" named Neopolitan, and hearing Trivia pin the blame on Neo, whenever the former would cause mischief around the house.
As Trivia grows up, she becomes dependent on Neo. The two would often sneak out of their parents' large mansion. The two would shoplift, deal with bullies, and cause trouble, all in an effort to get away from home. In spite of this, Trivia's parents caught wind of what their daughter is doing, and punish her by imprisoning in her home for a majority of her life. While that's going on, Trivia begins to realize that Neo is more than an imaginary friend; Neo is actually a manifestation of Trivia's power (called Semblance in the world of RWBY), containing all of the rage, liberation, and power Trivia bottled up inside. With this, Trivia begins to harness this power, slowly embracing her new persona as Neo, and being able to disguise herself as other people perfectly, from head to toe. Elsewhere, a young crook named Roman Torchwick (a street urchin who was abandoned by his mother at a young age) is looking to make a name for himself, committing crimes wherever he goes. The two characters eventually meet-up, and create an alliance for themselves, to get back at the enemies they made.
What I really enjoy about Trivia's descent into Neopolitan is her backstory: Her abusive childhood was portrayed in a realistic, if admittedly, uncomfortable manner. But not in a disgusting, tone-deaf manner, it was really sad. There are a few passages where the narration touches on this, talking about how Trivia's parents were embarrassed about their daughter's appearance and muteness, and how Trivia blamed her parents for not putting her in a school that fits her needs. I feel that readers who love Neo's character from RWBY, or those who suffered from similar situations that Trivia/Neo goes through in the story can take comfort in getting emotionally attached to her. As one who's autistic and has ADHD, I was able to connect with Trivia's character arc, very well. There were genuine moments of pathos that made me feel what Trivia/Neo felt, and that helped me to read this book from start to finish. In addition, it was cool to have the story give humanizing traits for Neo and Roman (two villain protagonists), possibly as a nod to how the fandom loves these two characters from the show (i.e. to use TV Tropes' lingo here, the RWBY fandom uses the "Draco In Leather Pants" trope, enjoying Roman and Neo in spite of their actions).
However, there are a few things in this book that hold it back from being amazing. Disregarding the tell-y prose and numerous tense swaps, I feel that the book is a little bit short for my liking. It's around 300 pages long, and to be honest, I think it would've been better if it was 50-100 pages longer. Had the story spent more time fleshing out Roman's backstory instead of it being told in a sentence (what was it like for him living in an orphanage? Did he suffer from abuse? Neglect?), and spent more time building the partnership between Roman and Neo, I feel that this book could've been more emotional, and more enjoyable than what we got. Additionally, this book assumes you've seen a good chunk of RWBY to make sense of the characters and setting, so I think this isn't a good starting point for those looking to get into the series.
For what the book's worth, I feel like it was good. Not awful, but outstanding. But, those who love the series will get more enjoyment out of this.
Let me admit that I never was interested in Rooster Teeth's RWBY when it first came out. I heard about it a couple of times, but I never watched it. That changed when I stumbled across a TV Tropes' Self-Demonstrating page (i.e. a character describing themselves in the first-person view) for Neopolitan (an antagonist from RWBY) that I read. Shortly after, I became interested to watch the series and reading this book to know more about Neo, because her unique character design, inability to speak, and backstory sounded intriguing.
When I picked up this book and finished it, I feel that I got my money's worth (for the most part, but more on that later).
I'll start off by saying that Neopolitan's character arc is the best aspect of this book. To explain, Neopolitan was formerly known as Trivia Vanille, a shy, meek girl born under the Vanille family. Her parents, Jimmy and Carmel, emotionally abuse their daughter for being imperfect (read, their daughter suffers from this inability to speak, along with having heterochromatic eyes; one brown, one pink). The two aren't fond of their daughter spending time playing with her "imaginary friend" named Neopolitan, and hearing Trivia pin the blame on Neo, whenever the former would cause mischief around the house.
As Trivia grows up, she becomes dependent on Neo. The two would often sneak out of their parents' large mansion. The two would shoplift, deal with bullies, and cause trouble, all in an effort to get away from home. In spite of this, Trivia's parents caught wind of what their daughter is doing, and punish her by imprisoning in her home for a majority of her life. While that's going on, Trivia begins to realize that Neo is more than an imaginary friend; Neo is actually a manifestation of Trivia's power (called Semblance in the world of RWBY), containing all of the rage, liberation, and power Trivia bottled up inside. With this, Trivia begins to harness this power, slowly embracing her new persona as Neo, and being able to disguise herself as other people perfectly, from head to toe. Elsewhere, a young crook named Roman Torchwick (a street urchin who was abandoned by his mother at a young age) is looking to make a name for himself, committing crimes wherever he goes. The two characters eventually meet-up, and create an alliance for themselves, to get back at the enemies they made.
What I really enjoy about Trivia's descent into Neopolitan is her backstory: Her abusive childhood was portrayed in a realistic, if admittedly, uncomfortable manner. But not in a disgusting, tone-deaf manner, it was really sad. There are a few passages where the narration touches on this, talking about how Trivia's parents were embarrassed about their daughter's appearance and muteness, and how Trivia blamed her parents for not putting her in a school that fits her needs. I feel that readers who love Neo's character from RWBY, or those who suffered from similar situations that Trivia/Neo goes through in the story can take comfort in getting emotionally attached to her. As one who's autistic and has ADHD, I was able to connect with Trivia's character arc, very well. There were genuine moments of pathos that made me feel what Trivia/Neo felt, and that helped me to read this book from start to finish. In addition, it was cool to have the story give humanizing traits for Neo and Roman (two villain protagonists), possibly as a nod to how the fandom loves these two characters from the show (i.e. to use TV Tropes' lingo here, the RWBY fandom uses the "Draco In Leather Pants" trope, enjoying Roman and Neo in spite of their actions).
However, there are a few things in this book that hold it back from being amazing. Disregarding the tell-y prose and numerous tense swaps, I feel that the book is a little bit short for my liking. It's around 300 pages long, and to be honest, I think it would've been better if it was 50-100 pages longer. Had the story spent more time fleshing out Roman's backstory instead of it being told in a sentence (what was it like for him living in an orphanage? Did he suffer from abuse? Neglect?), and spent more time building the partnership between Roman and Neo, I feel that this book could've been more emotional, and more enjoyable than what we got. Additionally, this book assumes you've seen a good chunk of RWBY to make sense of the characters and setting, so I think this isn't a good starting point for those looking to get into the series.
For what the book's worth, I feel like it was good. Not awful, but outstanding. But, those who love the series will get more enjoyment out of this.
February 5, 2022
Here we go...
I was relatively late to the RWBY watching party, but after watching the series, I got hooked and 8 volumes better, I was reminded of why I appreciated Neo so much. This author has done a good job with the other two books, but this one was a LOT different. Sure, I was not a fan of Torchwick in the series, I think this book took a chance to show the charismatic, lovable, and mischievous side of Torchwick.
But that's about where it ends.
Because although this was a relatively quick read that I had started a while back, I realized the story went too fast to the point that it seemed like I was fast-forwarding through this book. It wasn't boring. But it wasn't the best, either. We start with the first half of the book establishing the past of Neo (Trivia Vanille) and Roman Torchwick, who grew up as an orphan in the streets.
Were their backstories interesting? Yes.
Was it necessary to spend half a book on that? NOT AT ALL.
And ultimately, this led to the downfall of this book. I was absolutely hyped for this book, but after reading it, I am only filled with nostalgia and a bittersweet taste left behind. Neo throughout the book was portrayed as a rich girl who threw a tantrum to be seen since she couldn't be heard. One of the reasons I enjoy her character in the series is because she's one of the only disabled characters in the RWBY universe. She's completely mute and although we don't get a clear answer as to whether this was from birth or not, her actions speak louder than her words. She also just seems to throw one tantrum over another to the point that it becomes destructive. In the end, I ended up feeling like this portrayal of her wasn't accurate enough to how the show portrays her.
Now, onto Torchwick.
I hated this dude with a living passion. He lasted for 3 seasons and while he went off with a bang, people missed him because of him being a funny villain. I missed him because it caused Neo so much pain. This story gives us the chance to love Torchwick and to enjoy his quick-witted nature. I do appreciate that he didn't judge Neo for being mute, but I do blame him for trusting her too quickly. It was almost like he was desperate for someone to be by his side. And seriously.
STEALING COFFEE?
That is not the Torchwick we see in the series, but I suppose it makes sense as he does become ambitious enough to steal more and be more known. There were some nice moments between them, but the idea of friendship between them seemed a bit forceful, considering the entire fandom saw it as them being more of a Bonnie and Clyde type of couple.
Yes, I inevitably form a part of this opinion.
Now, the stakes weren't high enough and the motivations to steal coffee seemed like it was straight out of a middle school novel. The pacing starting from like Chapter 13 and forward was too fast to the point that the narrative was almost disjointed. In a twisted way, it makes sense given that they both are criminals, but the ending was abrupt and each chapter afterward was like:
1. create a plan.
2. face complications.
3. Boom! We were successful.
4. Oh no, somebody got kidnapped.
5. I will save you (and vice versa)
And the repeated use of this led to the end being flat and dissatisfying for me.
Thus, the 3 stars.
Roman will be my favorite in the books, but it will also let me sympathize with him more in the series as I rewatch it again. As for Neo...
She will always be better in the series.
That is all I have to say.
I was relatively late to the RWBY watching party, but after watching the series, I got hooked and 8 volumes better, I was reminded of why I appreciated Neo so much. This author has done a good job with the other two books, but this one was a LOT different. Sure, I was not a fan of Torchwick in the series, I think this book took a chance to show the charismatic, lovable, and mischievous side of Torchwick.
But that's about where it ends.
Because although this was a relatively quick read that I had started a while back, I realized the story went too fast to the point that it seemed like I was fast-forwarding through this book. It wasn't boring. But it wasn't the best, either. We start with the first half of the book establishing the past of Neo (Trivia Vanille) and Roman Torchwick, who grew up as an orphan in the streets.
Were their backstories interesting? Yes.
Was it necessary to spend half a book on that? NOT AT ALL.
And ultimately, this led to the downfall of this book. I was absolutely hyped for this book, but after reading it, I am only filled with nostalgia and a bittersweet taste left behind. Neo throughout the book was portrayed as a rich girl who threw a tantrum to be seen since she couldn't be heard. One of the reasons I enjoy her character in the series is because she's one of the only disabled characters in the RWBY universe. She's completely mute and although we don't get a clear answer as to whether this was from birth or not, her actions speak louder than her words. She also just seems to throw one tantrum over another to the point that it becomes destructive. In the end, I ended up feeling like this portrayal of her wasn't accurate enough to how the show portrays her.
Now, onto Torchwick.
I hated this dude with a living passion. He lasted for 3 seasons and while he went off with a bang, people missed him because of him being a funny villain. I missed him because it caused Neo so much pain. This story gives us the chance to love Torchwick and to enjoy his quick-witted nature. I do appreciate that he didn't judge Neo for being mute, but I do blame him for trusting her too quickly. It was almost like he was desperate for someone to be by his side. And seriously.
STEALING COFFEE?
That is not the Torchwick we see in the series, but I suppose it makes sense as he does become ambitious enough to steal more and be more known. There were some nice moments between them, but the idea of friendship between them seemed a bit forceful, considering the entire fandom saw it as them being more of a Bonnie and Clyde type of couple.
Yes, I inevitably form a part of this opinion.
Now, the stakes weren't high enough and the motivations to steal coffee seemed like it was straight out of a middle school novel. The pacing starting from like Chapter 13 and forward was too fast to the point that the narrative was almost disjointed. In a twisted way, it makes sense given that they both are criminals, but the ending was abrupt and each chapter afterward was like:
1. create a plan.
2. face complications.
3. Boom! We were successful.
4. Oh no, somebody got kidnapped.
5. I will save you (and vice versa)
And the repeated use of this led to the end being flat and dissatisfying for me.
Thus, the 3 stars.
Roman will be my favorite in the books, but it will also let me sympathize with him more in the series as I rewatch it again. As for Neo...
She will always be better in the series.
That is all I have to say.
March 1, 2023
Alright so I'm currently giving this 3-stars. Debating if I wanna do 4-stars, but I'm sticking with 3 for now.
Overall, the book was good. It gave us a clear backstory between the two characters Roman and Neo. They were both written very well. They didn't feel different from how they appeared in the show so it still felt like the characters I know and love. Secondly, it was nice to see old and familiar faces in this book and see how people are connected. Lastly, questions that were raised when watching the show seemed to have been answered in this book as well which was really nice.
However I do have some negative thoughts. For starters, some of the actions and decisions from the characters happened way too quick. I felt as if Neo's decision to "go bad" and join Roman was way too fast and there was no build up to it. Heck, overall the pacing in the book was fast and there was no build up for every situation that was about to happen. It would have been nice to see their thought process a bit more that way it would have allowed us to understand these characters more as well.
Now, what about Cinder? When RWBY first aired Roman was already in cahoots with Cinder. How did that happen? I was kind of hoping that there would have been a final chapter or something that would have discussed that, but nothing came of it. So, to this day I'm still questioning how Roman and Cinder ended up working together. I'm assuming we will never know now unless there is miraculously another book in this series that goes into Roman and Neo's life together a bit more and the introduction of Cinder into their story. Probably won't happen, but one can dream. Right?
But yeah, I'm gonna leave this at 3-stars for now. It wasn't a bad book, really! As someone that enjoys RWBY this was an enjoyable read to get more content and background information for the show, I just wish it was written a bit better.
Overall, the book was good. It gave us a clear backstory between the two characters Roman and Neo. They were both written very well. They didn't feel different from how they appeared in the show so it still felt like the characters I know and love. Secondly, it was nice to see old and familiar faces in this book and see how people are connected. Lastly, questions that were raised when watching the show seemed to have been answered in this book as well which was really nice.
However I do have some negative thoughts. For starters, some of the actions and decisions from the characters happened way too quick. I felt as if Neo's decision to "go bad" and join Roman was way too fast and there was no build up to it. Heck, overall the pacing in the book was fast and there was no build up for every situation that was about to happen. It would have been nice to see their thought process a bit more that way it would have allowed us to understand these characters more as well.
Now, what about Cinder? When RWBY first aired Roman was already in cahoots with Cinder. How did that happen? I was kind of hoping that there would have been a final chapter or something that would have discussed that, but nothing came of it. So, to this day I'm still questioning how Roman and Cinder ended up working together. I'm assuming we will never know now unless there is miraculously another book in this series that goes into Roman and Neo's life together a bit more and the introduction of Cinder into their story. Probably won't happen, but one can dream. Right?
But yeah, I'm gonna leave this at 3-stars for now. It wasn't a bad book, really! As someone that enjoys RWBY this was an enjoyable read to get more content and background information for the show, I just wish it was written a bit better.
November 10, 2021
No offense to Team Coffee but I liked this choice better, to follow RWBY's most charismatic villain and one of the bright spots to come out of the never-ending train wreck that is RWBY's production. At points it really made me miss early season RWBY even more. I feel like it was a little contrived to work in as many known minor characters as it did, but it's forgivable. Characterization was a little spotty, some things just felt out of character but I think it was more hit than miss. My biggest problems with it are probably spoilers so consider that the warning. I thought the angle that Trivia (what color does that invoke, exactly?) becomes her own imaginary friend - kinda-sorta - was a bit... lame I guess. Neo, or at least her semblance, actually seems more powerful here at times than she seems in the show, when she should probably have a more linear progression. Trivia/Neo gets way too many of these moments where she marvels that something she gets to do or wear finally feels "like her" when that kind of thing should only come about once, maybe twice in a story, not four or five or six. I feel like Torchwick trusts her a bit too fast and definitely shouldn't have fallen for the same tracker twice - honestly even the first one feels dubious. Scrolls feel too one-to-one with smart phones here, sure there always was clear overlap, but they were somewhat different and Remnant has never seemed to have a modern internet before.
If I was rating this more technically I would put it at three stars, but when it gets the characterization right it's a lot of fun. My favorite is probably when Torchwick complains about carrying Neo's father to open the hand scanner and Neo mimes that he should have just cut off his hand. Sure he wasn't a good dad but that is cold.
If I was rating this more technically I would put it at three stars, but when it gets the characterization right it's a lot of fun. My favorite is probably when Torchwick complains about carrying Neo's father to open the hand scanner and Neo mimes that he should have just cut off his hand. Sure he wasn't a good dad but that is cold.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 25, 2024
(3.5 stars) Emerald/Mercury has my whole heart but Roman/Neo is a close second so obviously I went into this biased af. Ugh I have such a soft spot for partners in crime. I loved learning more about Neo and Roman's backstories and how they first met. The reciprocity in their relationship is so sweet and it's great to see how they implicitly trust one another without needing to exchange words (which is what makes them such a formidable tag team, as we see in the show) and I love that they choose to stick together time and again.
Honestly between all the hijinks and heists, this whole spinoff just made me more salty about canon events because the writers truly offed one of the best villains far too soon. There's so much lost potential and it also made me think there should've been more interactions between Roman and Emerald because the two of them actually have very similar backgrounds as street rats who built their strength from the ground up and did what they had to in order to survive.
I will say this book reads very YA leaning middle grade. So while Neo kissing him on the cheek and Roman getting all blushy was super cute, I think part of me wanted a little more LOL.
Favorite line: "She didn’t really care about running things, or cornering the market on Dust. She just wanted to do whatever she wanted. And for the moment, what she wanted was to help Roman set the world on fire."
Honestly between all the hijinks and heists, this whole spinoff just made me more salty about canon events because the writers truly offed one of the best villains far too soon. There's so much lost potential and it also made me think there should've been more interactions between Roman and Emerald because the two of them actually have very similar backgrounds as street rats who built their strength from the ground up and did what they had to in order to survive.
I will say this book reads very YA leaning middle grade. So while Neo kissing him on the cheek and Roman getting all blushy was super cute, I think part of me wanted a little more LOL.
Favorite line: "She didn’t really care about running things, or cornering the market on Dust. She just wanted to do whatever she wanted. And for the moment, what she wanted was to help Roman set the world on fire."
April 23, 2023
Easily the best of the RWBY books so far. 'Roman Holiday' was so unique compared to the rest of the series. It is essentially a prequel to two of the series' antagonists, Roman and Neo. It reminded me heavily of books like 'Six of Crows', however. Rather than being focused on Grimm and huntresses, 'Roman Holiday' was a crime thriller set in the same universe. It also had great representation, not only for LGBT characters but also for disabilities. As any fan of the series will know, Neo is mute, and Myers handles that well here.
My only criticism, which is also kind of a compliment, is that I wish it were longer. This book does jump a significant amount of time towards the end. I would have liked to spend a little more time with the characters, developing their relationship before their conclusion. Myers likely had a word limit, however, so I cannot be too critical.
Overall, I would recommend 'Roman Holiday' to any RWBY fan. I'm not sure how much sense it will make if you haven't watched the first three Volumes of the show, and it is certainly essential to read before the ninth! I greatly enjoyed it, however.
My only criticism, which is also kind of a compliment, is that I wish it were longer. This book does jump a significant amount of time towards the end. I would have liked to spend a little more time with the characters, developing their relationship before their conclusion. Myers likely had a word limit, however, so I cannot be too critical.
Overall, I would recommend 'Roman Holiday' to any RWBY fan. I'm not sure how much sense it will make if you haven't watched the first three Volumes of the show, and it is certainly essential to read before the ninth! I greatly enjoyed it, however.
December 19, 2021
Neopolitian and Roman Torchwick are the Bonnie and Clyde of Vale.
Roman Holiday is the third RWBY novel and the first to be a prequel story to the series, which explores the origins of Roman Torchwick and Neopolitian and their partnership.
It was especially fun reading Neo, who in my opinion is the star of this novel. She doesn’t speak at all yet E.C. Myers did a fantastic job conveying her expressiveness and charming personality in his writing. Neopolitian was already pretty cool, however this book has made her a favorite.
I didn’t like Roman at first, but he certainly came around and became more enjoyable in the end. Despite Roman being somewhat of an Anarchist, the reason I don’t see them like Joker and Harley is because that was an incredibly abusive relationship. Neo makes Roman a “better person” and though Neo you’re able to enjoy him more.
Of the three novels released so far, Roman Holiday is my favorite. As with all of the novels, I look forward to seeing how these stories and character explorations help make RWBY an even more enjoyable series.
Roman Holiday is the third RWBY novel and the first to be a prequel story to the series, which explores the origins of Roman Torchwick and Neopolitian and their partnership.
It was especially fun reading Neo, who in my opinion is the star of this novel. She doesn’t speak at all yet E.C. Myers did a fantastic job conveying her expressiveness and charming personality in his writing. Neopolitian was already pretty cool, however this book has made her a favorite.
I didn’t like Roman at first, but he certainly came around and became more enjoyable in the end. Despite Roman being somewhat of an Anarchist, the reason I don’t see them like Joker and Harley is because that was an incredibly abusive relationship. Neo makes Roman a “better person” and though Neo you’re able to enjoy him more.
Of the three novels released so far, Roman Holiday is my favorite. As with all of the novels, I look forward to seeing how these stories and character explorations help make RWBY an even more enjoyable series.
April 22, 2023
The last 140 pages more than made up for the first bit of the book!
I was pretty unhappy at the beginning and i couldnt belive it was the over halfway point before they finally met, but the Roman and Neo content i was looking for delivered!
I wish we'd gotten more emotion from trivia in regards to her parents, i often couldnt pin point the reason for some of her actions and feelings. I also would've liked to know more about romans trauma. I think it really wouldve brought the characters more to life if i understood their traumas more.
But alas i really enjoyed this and i think it was a great addition to the rwby universe.
Also no one can convince me that theyre not in love🥰
Safety:
*not a romance book*
-Roman several times mentions using womens affections for him to his own gain, and mentions a womans cleavage being distracting for him. This was before he met Neo.
-10 years apart, shes 18 and hes 28 when they meet
-end with a feeling of happiness but if you watch the show you know how they end up.
I was pretty unhappy at the beginning and i couldnt belive it was the over halfway point before they finally met, but the Roman and Neo content i was looking for delivered!
I wish we'd gotten more emotion from trivia in regards to her parents, i often couldnt pin point the reason for some of her actions and feelings. I also would've liked to know more about romans trauma. I think it really wouldve brought the characters more to life if i understood their traumas more.
But alas i really enjoyed this and i think it was a great addition to the rwby universe.
Also no one can convince me that theyre not in love🥰
Safety:
*not a romance book*
-Roman several times mentions using womens affections for him to his own gain, and mentions a womans cleavage being distracting for him. This was before he met Neo.
-10 years apart, shes 18 and hes 28 when they meet
-end with a feeling of happiness but if you watch the show you know how they end up.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 6, 2025
I can't tell if I am biased because this book is based on my all time favourite show since I was around 2015 and I get to see the backstory of one of my favourite characters but this is honestly one of the best books I've read Icl. We get to see how Neo grew up and how Roman and Neo's relationship came about and developed and honestly after volume 9 that shit hurts. Roman being Neo's only friend for her whole life as he is the only person who understands her especially cause she is mute and sees her as a normal person makes you understand more of her emotions especially near the end of volume 8. Neo since Romans death has been more driven probably because she wants to pursue Roman's crime goals and her pure emotion in volume 8 hurts way more after reading this. And now she stayed in the ever after it's like seeing her let go. I hope we get to see more of her but a lot of people have said that may be the end of her story but I'm praying 🙏🙏
I don't know if any of this made sense cause I yapppedd
I don't know if any of this made sense cause I yapppedd
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 2, 2025
Roman holiday is a Prequel/Spinoff and Midquel to Rwby now heads up I adore the original series but honestly a spinoff focusing on relatively minor characters and developing the world especially parts of it that where lacking in development for one reason or another
The book explores the origins of Roman and Neo. Just as always Roman steals the show as always and Neo works way better in a book than show. I adore Neo but actually being able to hear her thoughts rather then guess based on her body language.
And Roman is great as always but being in a book is a great way to expand his character without having to recast is actor after he passed away.
The expansion of Vale as a city rather than a school and Mystral since it was barely used in the main series, and hey doing so made the malachite twins and little miss memorable characters. I love the world of RWBY and focusing on smaller things rather then the world ending battle of the main series its great.
im glad i finally got around to this book, and hope we can get more spinoffs expanding the world in the near future
The book explores the origins of Roman and Neo. Just as always Roman steals the show as always and Neo works way better in a book than show. I adore Neo but actually being able to hear her thoughts rather then guess based on her body language.
And Roman is great as always but being in a book is a great way to expand his character without having to recast is actor after he passed away.
The expansion of Vale as a city rather than a school and Mystral since it was barely used in the main series, and hey doing so made the malachite twins and little miss memorable characters. I love the world of RWBY and focusing on smaller things rather then the world ending battle of the main series its great.
im glad i finally got around to this book, and hope we can get more spinoffs expanding the world in the near future
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews