In my estimates, the Word on Fire Bible consists of approximately 70% commentary and theology and 30% Bible text (the gospels). It’s nearly impossible to go more than half a page into God’s word before you’re hit with man’s word. On numerous occasions throughout, Catholic doctrine feels forced into places it doesn’t belong, especially in regard to the Eucharist. For Protestants and non-believers, this may come across as off-putting as it did for me.
In addition to that, Bishop Baron is incredibly verbose. As someone who majored in English, I’m no stranger to challenging language, but it feels completely unnecessary in a Bible meant for those reading it for the first time. Often Bishop Baron quotes Latin or Greek words then subsequently places their translation in parenthesis. You’re constantly left wondering why he quoted the foreign language to begin with as it serves no purpose in an English language Bible. The feeling I got was that the commentary wants to come across as being smart for the sake of being smart rather than illustrating a meaningful point.
Of course, the gospels themselves are excellent. The Bible is also beautiful. I love the opacity of the pages, the gold art gilding, the gold foil stamping on the cover, the black leather (even if it has a cardboard liner) and more. Despite my criticism that there’s too much added text that often comes across as unnecessarily verbose, there was still a fair amount of commentary that added to my knowledge and understanding of the Bible. The analysis of various pieces of famous art and buildings was always a refreshing breather as well.
I’m left torn between rating this a 2 and a 3, however I’ve sided with a 3 for now.
If you’re already a Catholic, I suspect you will appreciate this Bible more than Protestants and non-believers. However, if you’re new to Christianity, I would suggest reading either the gospels by themselves or another “study” Bible. It’s not to say that the Word on Fire Bible is bad but rather to say that it’s marketing would lead one to believe that it’s for first time readers of the Bible when in reality, it’s meant for those interested in copious amounts of commentary and Catholic doctrine. Which is fine. Just not my personal preference nor what I expected based on their marketing.
The best way to summarize my feeling towards the Word on Fire Bible is to say that by the time I reached the book of John, I was thoroughly burnt out and only finished it for the sake of finishing it because I hate the idea of reading 400+ pages only to give up with 20% to go. I sincerely wish I had just re-read the gospels by themselves. I easily could have read through them 2-3 times in the amount of time it took me to slog through the Word on Fire Bible’s commentary.