One of the joys of e-books is that one can develop relationships with authors, including joining others as early or beta readers. In the case of DV Berkom, I was entranced with her Leine Basso series - a very kickass heroine and joined up, and asked to review her work ongoingly.
Retribution is a departure for Berkom. And, to a certain extent, that shows in the writing. Westerns are not a common subject nowadays. The era of Zane Grey is long gone. Even in movies, we aren't seeing Westerns - we are seeing modern stories with horses. So attempting to create the world as it might have been 100 years ago strips away a lot of the familiar world and forces an author to build a storyline and characters that stand out, above and beyond horses, sagebrush and Indians. The good news is that Claire Whitcomb is on the way to becoming a very solid character, although she's not quite there yet. Along the way, Berkom drops some hints at where she's heading, and so once again I find myself at an interesting place.
On one hand, I know an author needs to eat. An author needs to publish to eat. And it's smarter to stretch a story line over multiple volumes to 1) minimize world building, and 2) keep the story going. But on the other hand, the great, fat novels of the past seem to be disappearing. Writing seems to be heading towards episodic story telling. That may be the fault of the publishing ecology. But I get the feeling that we are in a world that seems to have given up on quality for quantity. The quality of the writing in Retribution is good - but we already know there are at least two more volumes to come, and I can't help but wonder what would have happened had they all been combined as one big story.
And I would be remiss if I didn't say that there's a certain attraction to the series style. I mean, I grew up on Tom Swift Jr, (and then found Tom Swift) and the Hardy Boys. I look forward to Berkom's Leine Basso works, and there are a number of other authors producing ongoing novels about singular characters that I read where a new volume is like a visit from an old friend. And I think that's the missing star (the fifth of five) - as an entry point to a new series, there's not enough of Claire Whitcomb's development and changes from a wife and mother to what appears to be an itinerant cowboy to have me look forward to what's next for her. Oh, I will read the net volume (and maybe more) but I wish Berkom had spent more time building her world.