What do you think?
Rate this book
Because India Comes First: Reflections on Nationalism, Identity and Culture
For the last few decades, Ram Madhav—formerly the national general secretary of the Bharatiya Janata Party—has been observing and participating in Indian politics. Drawing from his years of involvement in politics, Madhav’s essays discuss a range of issues that are at the heart of contemporary debates in India: democracy as the responsibility of the head of state, rule of law, peace and public order, Mahatma Gandhi and Gandhi-ism, Ambedkar’s ideals, empowerment of women, Indian judiciary, the Ram Janmabhoomi case, abrogation of Article 370, the legacies of Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Arun Jaitley, and Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s learnings in governance.
Because India Comes First also delves into the decisions made by the BJP-led government over the last few years, diplomatic relationships with India’s neighbours and the confrontations with China. Madhav enquires into Indian policymaking and asserts that, going ahead, it must put India first. He calls out liberal fascism, deconstructs our understanding of terrorism in India, argues that opposition to the Citizenship (Amendment) Act is intellectually dishonest, explores how learnings from Black Lives Matter can be applied in the Indian sphere and explains why protests should be rooted in Martin Luther King Jr.’s non-violent approach and not anarchy. The essays in this volume weave a broad tapestry of India’s growth into a soft power, and predicts how it will shape up over the next few decades. A must read for those who believe in the new idea of India, and for those who accept that there are two sides to every debate.
Because India Comes First also delves into the decisions made by the BJP-led government over the last few years, diplomatic relationships with India’s neighbours and the confrontations with China. Madhav enquires into Indian policymaking and asserts that, going ahead, it must put India first. He calls out liberal fascism, deconstructs our understanding of terrorism in India, argues that opposition to the Citizenship (Amendment) Act is intellectually dishonest, explores how learnings from Black Lives Matter can be applied in the Indian sphere and explains why protests should be rooted in Martin Luther King Jr.’s non-violent approach and not anarchy. The essays in this volume weave a broad tapestry of India’s growth into a soft power, and predicts how it will shape up over the next few decades. A must read for those who believe in the new idea of India, and for those who accept that there are two sides to every debate.
- GenresIndia
298 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 30, 2020
8 people are currently reading
70 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
January 21, 2021
I'd like to thank Indic Book Club and Indic Academy for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book. I started reading the book on the very same day I got it and I was amused at the way this once a swayam sevak has penned his thoughts. He has a seva manobhava to his nation and I guess it's something in built in the swayam sevaks. I realised in the first chapter itself that I'm reading the words of someone who is highly eloquent and thoughtful.
This book has 53 essays by Ram Madhav ji which ranges from the topics of our countries historical figures like Mahatma Gandhi, Ambedkar, Shyam Mukherjee, Deendayal Upadhyaya and their principles to the political aspects of the past and present India. He beautifully explains what a democracy is and how a democracy can be successful with the joint dedication of both the citizens and the ruling governments. He emphasises the non violence resistance of Gandhi which inspired great personalities like Nelson Mandela and Martin King Luther Jr which should be inculcated in our approach addressing the far left and liberal ecosystem that's hell bent to create the recent BLM alike protests in India. He is very very centrist in his words and when one reads what he has written one would realise that this person is a man of patriotism in him. As the title depicts Ram Madhav shows the readers that no matter what India should be brought first.
The first part was very gentle but as I moved to the second part I realised the resisting power in his words. He calls out the Kashmiri gupkar gang that has been depriving the fellow Kashmiri brethren in the name of azadi instigating hate in them. He sharply points out at the blunders that I've been caused by Nehruvian dynasty and doesn't hesitate to direct the readers' attention to the current successes and failures. What he wrote about CAA, 370 Article abrogation and what NRC means to Assam literally changed my perspectives. I hadn't known that thoroughly about these issues.
He talks of the essence of Indian civilisation and Indic culture as well urges one to ponder over many facts.
The writer doesn't stop there, he writes about the diplomacy and the bilateral/multilateral relations India has. He indicates the changes that India has been witnessing since 2014. This was also something that Aabhas Maldahiyar in his Ex Communist Manifesto talks about. The Indian relations with Pakistan and China have gone from passive to active. How to deal with China, the sensitivity of the bilateral relations with it and how China has been trying to fool us with the famous 'Panchsheel' is greatly explained by Ram Madhav. Now, this was something very novel that I learnt through the book. One could also learn what China exactly is through his essays.
He reminds us the moral commitment we have with the Tibetans and urges us to join them solidifying their hope to go back to their home explaining the beautiful relationship we have with them.
When Morarjee Desai said "We both are two branches of same tree" Dalai Lama answered "You're the tree and we are the branches"
My personal experience with this book was tremendous. I had expected this book to be very complex since it was written by someone who's highly experienced in polity however his simple writing made the whole book a piece of cake. He makes sure his messages are driven home. The writer is very neutral and is very honest but so gentle with his words. I was pretty much surprised when I realised how much this book influenced me because there were minute things that I couldn't have understood. I had my own presumptions and doubts which got cleared away.
The author doesn't take sides with anyone or any political party, he takes sides with only one- India.
In the end, I learnt a great deal and could see things through different perspectives.
I recommend this book to everyone to read. It's a must read! Especially if you want to clear your doubts on the recent acts which have been falsified by certain leaders and writers I advice you to hear the realities from Ram Madhav ji.
This is a book penned by a humble nationalist to the reader with the only intention, to mold him into a better citizen who puts his mother land first Because India Comes First.
This book has 53 essays by Ram Madhav ji which ranges from the topics of our countries historical figures like Mahatma Gandhi, Ambedkar, Shyam Mukherjee, Deendayal Upadhyaya and their principles to the political aspects of the past and present India. He beautifully explains what a democracy is and how a democracy can be successful with the joint dedication of both the citizens and the ruling governments. He emphasises the non violence resistance of Gandhi which inspired great personalities like Nelson Mandela and Martin King Luther Jr which should be inculcated in our approach addressing the far left and liberal ecosystem that's hell bent to create the recent BLM alike protests in India. He is very very centrist in his words and when one reads what he has written one would realise that this person is a man of patriotism in him. As the title depicts Ram Madhav shows the readers that no matter what India should be brought first.
The first part was very gentle but as I moved to the second part I realised the resisting power in his words. He calls out the Kashmiri gupkar gang that has been depriving the fellow Kashmiri brethren in the name of azadi instigating hate in them. He sharply points out at the blunders that I've been caused by Nehruvian dynasty and doesn't hesitate to direct the readers' attention to the current successes and failures. What he wrote about CAA, 370 Article abrogation and what NRC means to Assam literally changed my perspectives. I hadn't known that thoroughly about these issues.
He talks of the essence of Indian civilisation and Indic culture as well urges one to ponder over many facts.
The writer doesn't stop there, he writes about the diplomacy and the bilateral/multilateral relations India has. He indicates the changes that India has been witnessing since 2014. This was also something that Aabhas Maldahiyar in his Ex Communist Manifesto talks about. The Indian relations with Pakistan and China have gone from passive to active. How to deal with China, the sensitivity of the bilateral relations with it and how China has been trying to fool us with the famous 'Panchsheel' is greatly explained by Ram Madhav. Now, this was something very novel that I learnt through the book. One could also learn what China exactly is through his essays.
He reminds us the moral commitment we have with the Tibetans and urges us to join them solidifying their hope to go back to their home explaining the beautiful relationship we have with them.
When Morarjee Desai said "We both are two branches of same tree" Dalai Lama answered "You're the tree and we are the branches"
My personal experience with this book was tremendous. I had expected this book to be very complex since it was written by someone who's highly experienced in polity however his simple writing made the whole book a piece of cake. He makes sure his messages are driven home. The writer is very neutral and is very honest but so gentle with his words. I was pretty much surprised when I realised how much this book influenced me because there were minute things that I couldn't have understood. I had my own presumptions and doubts which got cleared away.
The author doesn't take sides with anyone or any political party, he takes sides with only one- India.
In the end, I learnt a great deal and could see things through different perspectives.
I recommend this book to everyone to read. It's a must read! Especially if you want to clear your doubts on the recent acts which have been falsified by certain leaders and writers I advice you to hear the realities from Ram Madhav ji.
This is a book penned by a humble nationalist to the reader with the only intention, to mold him into a better citizen who puts his mother land first Because India Comes First.
January 24, 2021
Thanks to @indicacademy @indicbookclub
"Because India Comes First" is a one of the most concise analysis of current political affairs and key government decisions I have read in a long time.
Written as a series of essays in five sections, it makes for bite sized reading for those too busy to read detailed comprehensive history.
The section on correcting historical decisions, from Kashmir to Assam, is a brilliant and much needed synopsis. These episodes spanning decades have been beyond a viewspan of any single generation, which makes it difficult for most to place it within the context of current governance. It is further made difficult by both, complete absence of this information in education system and even more serious distortions by political opportunists.
The book starts with first section on..what does Indian Democracy mean?
Democracy is often seen as a Western idea imported from the British and planted in India. However, such an import if alien is unlikely to take root if it's basic ideas are not pre-existing in culture of the nation.
Ram Madhav's elaboration on political ethos of Indian RajDharma , actions of Gandhi, Vivekananda in Gandhian thought, all point to the Democratic fabric of India which has always existed. The Universal Suffrage and Republic's institutional structure are just the next level of tools and techniques on it's natural evolutionary path. Ideas of Dharma, Tyaga, Sarve api Sukhinah santu...are as much foundations of Democratic thought as Liberty, Fraternity, Equality, and make foundations of our Democratic polity distinctly Indic.
Further, Ananda , Charitra, Sheel, LokKalyan...these are our guiding values. We can and must learn from other Democracies, but we need not ape or depend on West for these ideas or the next evolutionary steps.
At the same time, Ram Madhav is unforgiving in pointing out the improvements we need in our mechanisms...whether it is Judiciary or dangers to it from Politics of Creed to NGOs led "Leaderless Revolution" overpowering State institutions.
Ram Madhav is great at illustrating these fundamental concepts of their corruption..in our contemporary ailments like Sabarimala issue to Ayodhya case postponements.
In addition to being a history lesson on political thought behind many positions of BJP and it's generations of leaders, the Indic thought section gives a wider perspective for vision that motivates BJP.
Far from being a reactionary nostalgic Hindutva that liberals accuse it of, this section firmly convinces reader of the depth and maturity of vision for future of our civilization in modern world.
The third section then details the import of this thought in actions of BJP govts, from Late Atalji to Narendra Modi. It shows the maturing and changing of thoughts as BJP evolved from a party in opposition to one in power. From Somnath to Ayodhya and comparisons with Warsaw cathedral and Hagia Sophia, to Women's empowerment , CAA and continuous social reform, this is explanation of it's many actions to an audience which may have not been following it for a few decades.
The last two sections are where the author takes on the world. From Liberal Fascism in West and intellectual void in USA to incitement of civil rebellion in India. A post covid world and India to new age of foreign policy engagement with Israel, Saudi Arabia, author covers the ground. With most chapters dedicated to China, it is clear where the greated foreign policy challenge to India comes from.
This book is a must read, specially for the young and those who have not been keen observers of BJP's intellectual evolution.
Those unaware of the long and deep thought will risk themselves being misled by the same "wolf" crying characters, who saw communalism in RamJanmabhoomi demand instead of a logical and long desired civilizational assertion and justice.
"Because India Comes First" is a one of the most concise analysis of current political affairs and key government decisions I have read in a long time.
Written as a series of essays in five sections, it makes for bite sized reading for those too busy to read detailed comprehensive history.
The section on correcting historical decisions, from Kashmir to Assam, is a brilliant and much needed synopsis. These episodes spanning decades have been beyond a viewspan of any single generation, which makes it difficult for most to place it within the context of current governance. It is further made difficult by both, complete absence of this information in education system and even more serious distortions by political opportunists.
The book starts with first section on..what does Indian Democracy mean?
Democracy is often seen as a Western idea imported from the British and planted in India. However, such an import if alien is unlikely to take root if it's basic ideas are not pre-existing in culture of the nation.
Ram Madhav's elaboration on political ethos of Indian RajDharma , actions of Gandhi, Vivekananda in Gandhian thought, all point to the Democratic fabric of India which has always existed. The Universal Suffrage and Republic's institutional structure are just the next level of tools and techniques on it's natural evolutionary path. Ideas of Dharma, Tyaga, Sarve api Sukhinah santu...are as much foundations of Democratic thought as Liberty, Fraternity, Equality, and make foundations of our Democratic polity distinctly Indic.
Further, Ananda , Charitra, Sheel, LokKalyan...these are our guiding values. We can and must learn from other Democracies, but we need not ape or depend on West for these ideas or the next evolutionary steps.
At the same time, Ram Madhav is unforgiving in pointing out the improvements we need in our mechanisms...whether it is Judiciary or dangers to it from Politics of Creed to NGOs led "Leaderless Revolution" overpowering State institutions.
Ram Madhav is great at illustrating these fundamental concepts of their corruption..in our contemporary ailments like Sabarimala issue to Ayodhya case postponements.
In addition to being a history lesson on political thought behind many positions of BJP and it's generations of leaders, the Indic thought section gives a wider perspective for vision that motivates BJP.
Far from being a reactionary nostalgic Hindutva that liberals accuse it of, this section firmly convinces reader of the depth and maturity of vision for future of our civilization in modern world.
The third section then details the import of this thought in actions of BJP govts, from Late Atalji to Narendra Modi. It shows the maturing and changing of thoughts as BJP evolved from a party in opposition to one in power. From Somnath to Ayodhya and comparisons with Warsaw cathedral and Hagia Sophia, to Women's empowerment , CAA and continuous social reform, this is explanation of it's many actions to an audience which may have not been following it for a few decades.
The last two sections are where the author takes on the world. From Liberal Fascism in West and intellectual void in USA to incitement of civil rebellion in India. A post covid world and India to new age of foreign policy engagement with Israel, Saudi Arabia, author covers the ground. With most chapters dedicated to China, it is clear where the greated foreign policy challenge to India comes from.
This book is a must read, specially for the young and those who have not been keen observers of BJP's intellectual evolution.
Those unaware of the long and deep thought will risk themselves being misled by the same "wolf" crying characters, who saw communalism in RamJanmabhoomi demand instead of a logical and long desired civilizational assertion and justice.
January 25, 2021
Thank you again indic book academy for this wonderful book.Ram Madhav ji done a very good job by compiling his essays in form of a book.i thoroughly enjoyed his views & style of explaining complex issues in simple vocabulary. Various complex issues during times of independence to present day which have etra ordinary challenging situations found an balancing explanation through his views.Generally we dont read topics which doesn't intrest us much,but this book paves way to dwell/explore more regarding topics regarding kashmir issue,ram mandir,global governence &india's role in it.still these topics are more relevent and i believe ram madhav ji shed a proper light on these wide range of topics.One last thing is,no matter you believe in ideology of RW/LW you will not regret reading this book.I always find Right wing scholars are more liberal than so called liberals.Such one person is Ram madhav ji and hope you too enjoy his balanced views.
September 22, 2023
(At the time of writing this review) Since 90% of the reviewers for this book have thanked Indic Book club and Indic academy, I feel that it makes sense for me to declare, I am not associated with the said clubs and I have read this book on my own accord, for following two reasons.
a) Even if my political and economic ideology tilts left (The political compass confirmed it), I believe in reading viewpoints of the other side to understand why they stand there where they stand.
b) In the crowd of the troll army and tv news propagandists, it is difficult to find saner and calmer voices that can be listened to. I found Ram Madhav to be one such sane voice.
This book that contains many of the newspaper and magazine articles written by Ram Madhav voicing RSS's stand on several controversial issues from the domestic - Ram Mandir, Kashmir, CAA to India's international policies on Israel, Russia and China. When I came to read this book, I knew that I probably would disagree with many of the author's views, however, I intend to know his and his organization's stand on these important issues that define the modern day Indian politics. I am happy that Madhav doesn't make his stand ambiguous as many intellectuals often do. He paints the world in clear black and white shades, which makes it easier to view where he stands. Mahatma Gandhi and Ambedkar - decent. Nehru - bad. Modi - messiah. China - enemy. Russia - friend. Liberals - propagandists. et al.
It is evident from the writings of the author, that he is definitely very well read intellectual. Ram provides evidence based arguments, which makes the pieces thought provoking. However, the book failed to engross and educate me as I had expected. The reason - Articles published as opinion pieces in magazines and newspapers assume a certain prior knowledge of the reader, the author usually glosses over the context without providing much explanations on the issue on hand, rather focusing directly on their takes. When read later point of time, it challenges the memories of the readers to recollect the context. Hence, books that are primarily compilations of author's articles published at various points of time, are not always as informative, as a lay reader expects to be. Also, such compilations don't have a coherent narrative.
a) Even if my political and economic ideology tilts left (The political compass confirmed it), I believe in reading viewpoints of the other side to understand why they stand there where they stand.
b) In the crowd of the troll army and tv news propagandists, it is difficult to find saner and calmer voices that can be listened to. I found Ram Madhav to be one such sane voice.
This book that contains many of the newspaper and magazine articles written by Ram Madhav voicing RSS's stand on several controversial issues from the domestic - Ram Mandir, Kashmir, CAA to India's international policies on Israel, Russia and China. When I came to read this book, I knew that I probably would disagree with many of the author's views, however, I intend to know his and his organization's stand on these important issues that define the modern day Indian politics. I am happy that Madhav doesn't make his stand ambiguous as many intellectuals often do. He paints the world in clear black and white shades, which makes it easier to view where he stands. Mahatma Gandhi and Ambedkar - decent. Nehru - bad. Modi - messiah. China - enemy. Russia - friend. Liberals - propagandists. et al.
It is evident from the writings of the author, that he is definitely very well read intellectual. Ram provides evidence based arguments, which makes the pieces thought provoking. However, the book failed to engross and educate me as I had expected. The reason - Articles published as opinion pieces in magazines and newspapers assume a certain prior knowledge of the reader, the author usually glosses over the context without providing much explanations on the issue on hand, rather focusing directly on their takes. When read later point of time, it challenges the memories of the readers to recollect the context. Hence, books that are primarily compilations of author's articles published at various points of time, are not always as informative, as a lay reader expects to be. Also, such compilations don't have a coherent narrative.
February 20, 2021
In today's world of social media, we see that different narratives are formed by different groups and it does not take much time to reach people through internet and social media. This Internet and social media revolution has made it easy to spread any information rapidly, but at the same time, it has become very difficult for a common people to decide which information is right and which is wrong in this era of agenda and propaganda. Specially when these issues are of national importance, it becomes even more necessary to get a clear picture of it. This ambiguity increases manifold, when most of the people has developed a habit of forming their opinion from one liner based on their own biases.
In such a situation, here comes a book that not only talks about various issues related to India but also breaks all the false narratives that has been propagated by breaking india forces to confuse the masses.
"Because India Comes First" written by Ram Madhav, is a compilation of detailed articles on all those topics, that we must have discussed at some point in last five to ten years. Be it the issues of Indian judicial system, law and order, democracy or Ram Janmabhoomi, the issue of Section 370, CAA, NRC etc. The historical context of all these topics and its complete interpretation in the present circumstances has been explained very clearly in this book. Along with that, there is a detailed discussion on the views of Mahatma Gandhi and Gandhism, Bhimrao Ambedkar, the legacy of Atal Bihari Vajpayee, etc. A detailed analysis of the decisions taken by the Narendra Modi government in the last five-seven years and its impact on country and international arena can also be found in this book.
The author has also broken the notion of Akhand Bharat under which it is believed to strategically occupy Pakistan, Bangla Desh, Afghanistan and Myanmar etc. In fact, the author makes it very clear that "Akhand Bharat is a cultural and people centric idea. Its not about redrawing the boundaries of our countries by army aggression." While talking about RSS and referring to RSS Sangh chalak Mohan Bhagvat's statement that "There is no Hindu Rastra without Muslims", author calls it a welcome move by RSS. However, this can still be a debatable subject because there can be many interpretations of this statement and author fails to explain that in detail.
Apart from this, the entire history of Ram temple and Somnath temple and related facts in the present context has also been highlighted, which is good to know.
The author Ram Madhav, also talks about Corona Crisis and India's "Bhagirathi" contribution in fighting it. Along with this, he has added that while many countries of the world are talking about protectionism, there is a need for mutual understanding and partnership between different countries to fight the global pandemic like Corona. At the end of this book, there is a discussion on the history of the India-China dispute and India's unclear policies to resolve it. With the example of Russia, he has also been explained that what kind of policies India will have to follow to deal with the China border dispute.
By and large, its a must read book for those, who believes in the idea of India and have a willingness to understand the topics concerning India in contemporary world.
In such a situation, here comes a book that not only talks about various issues related to India but also breaks all the false narratives that has been propagated by breaking india forces to confuse the masses.
"Because India Comes First" written by Ram Madhav, is a compilation of detailed articles on all those topics, that we must have discussed at some point in last five to ten years. Be it the issues of Indian judicial system, law and order, democracy or Ram Janmabhoomi, the issue of Section 370, CAA, NRC etc. The historical context of all these topics and its complete interpretation in the present circumstances has been explained very clearly in this book. Along with that, there is a detailed discussion on the views of Mahatma Gandhi and Gandhism, Bhimrao Ambedkar, the legacy of Atal Bihari Vajpayee, etc. A detailed analysis of the decisions taken by the Narendra Modi government in the last five-seven years and its impact on country and international arena can also be found in this book.
The author has also broken the notion of Akhand Bharat under which it is believed to strategically occupy Pakistan, Bangla Desh, Afghanistan and Myanmar etc. In fact, the author makes it very clear that "Akhand Bharat is a cultural and people centric idea. Its not about redrawing the boundaries of our countries by army aggression." While talking about RSS and referring to RSS Sangh chalak Mohan Bhagvat's statement that "There is no Hindu Rastra without Muslims", author calls it a welcome move by RSS. However, this can still be a debatable subject because there can be many interpretations of this statement and author fails to explain that in detail.
Apart from this, the entire history of Ram temple and Somnath temple and related facts in the present context has also been highlighted, which is good to know.
The author Ram Madhav, also talks about Corona Crisis and India's "Bhagirathi" contribution in fighting it. Along with this, he has added that while many countries of the world are talking about protectionism, there is a need for mutual understanding and partnership between different countries to fight the global pandemic like Corona. At the end of this book, there is a discussion on the history of the India-China dispute and India's unclear policies to resolve it. With the example of Russia, he has also been explained that what kind of policies India will have to follow to deal with the China border dispute.
By and large, its a must read book for those, who believes in the idea of India and have a willingness to understand the topics concerning India in contemporary world.
July 19, 2021
Thank you Indic Book club for sending this wonderful book.
This Book by Ram Madhav Ji is an amazing tool for you to know about the many issues that happened and happening in our country.
Completely justifying the title "Because India Comes first" this book is definitely gonna give you some wow moment many times. Author, the swayamsevak himself wrote this book in the form of essays and touches various topics that you must know and yes, what a keen observer he is!!. From emphasizing on India's great knowledge and rich history to how can India become Vishwaguru. He explains all. I really loved the way he starts the book from the very first of the book itself and said:
"India fascinated many. One unbroken civilisation that has lived on for millennia and made its mark globally through numerous significant intervention over an uninterrupted history, the India story has been told and retold a number of times by those charmed by its grace and grandeur. Through its living history of over five millenia, India has offered invaluable gems of wisdom enriching all of mankind"
Etat Desha Prasutasya Sakashat Agrajanmanah
Swam Swam Charitam Siksheran Prithivyam Sarv Manavah
(This was proclaimed in Manusmriti, one of the oldest constitutions of India. It means, 'Men all over the world would come to beseech lessons in character through the lives of the great men born in this country'
Likewise, he used the quotes from our various dharmic scriptures and enlighten us about our great knowledge we have.
Ram Madhav Ji also tells us about the contribution of many of leaders and policy makers such as Mahatama Gandhi, B.R. Ambedkar, Deen Dayal Upadhyay, M.S. Golwalkar etc.
The book also have the dedicated chapters that are based on the blunders did by our previous governments and leaders and we have to face the consequences today. One such chapter is on Kashmir issue. The complete politics of Kashmir is explained in a very crisp manner with the proper accounts from history. Later, he takes us through on CAA, NRC, Ayodhya's Ram Mandir and India-China conflict too. The books ends with a chapter on Covid Pandemic and the new world order.
Also, if you think that Author is a BJP spokesperson and he will be based in his writings. No! He isn't. Thorough out the book, he remains complete neutral and many times write about the steps that must need be taken by his government because it will benefit the nation.
Written in a simple language, it is a highly recommended book for everyone.
This Book by Ram Madhav Ji is an amazing tool for you to know about the many issues that happened and happening in our country.
Completely justifying the title "Because India Comes first" this book is definitely gonna give you some wow moment many times. Author, the swayamsevak himself wrote this book in the form of essays and touches various topics that you must know and yes, what a keen observer he is!!. From emphasizing on India's great knowledge and rich history to how can India become Vishwaguru. He explains all. I really loved the way he starts the book from the very first of the book itself and said:
"India fascinated many. One unbroken civilisation that has lived on for millennia and made its mark globally through numerous significant intervention over an uninterrupted history, the India story has been told and retold a number of times by those charmed by its grace and grandeur. Through its living history of over five millenia, India has offered invaluable gems of wisdom enriching all of mankind"
Etat Desha Prasutasya Sakashat Agrajanmanah
Swam Swam Charitam Siksheran Prithivyam Sarv Manavah
(This was proclaimed in Manusmriti, one of the oldest constitutions of India. It means, 'Men all over the world would come to beseech lessons in character through the lives of the great men born in this country'
Likewise, he used the quotes from our various dharmic scriptures and enlighten us about our great knowledge we have.
Ram Madhav Ji also tells us about the contribution of many of leaders and policy makers such as Mahatama Gandhi, B.R. Ambedkar, Deen Dayal Upadhyay, M.S. Golwalkar etc.
The book also have the dedicated chapters that are based on the blunders did by our previous governments and leaders and we have to face the consequences today. One such chapter is on Kashmir issue. The complete politics of Kashmir is explained in a very crisp manner with the proper accounts from history. Later, he takes us through on CAA, NRC, Ayodhya's Ram Mandir and India-China conflict too. The books ends with a chapter on Covid Pandemic and the new world order.
Also, if you think that Author is a BJP spokesperson and he will be based in his writings. No! He isn't. Thorough out the book, he remains complete neutral and many times write about the steps that must need be taken by his government because it will benefit the nation.
Written in a simple language, it is a highly recommended book for everyone.
March 8, 2021
Because India Comes first : The time I received the book, I felt like immediately picking it up and complete the reading .Reading this book gives a feeling of Ram Madhav is on driving seat and you have unhindered access to rear view mirror. The journey begins with Bharat becoming Independent and democratic ideology shaping it , often we had opportunity to read ideologies of Neru-Gandhi and other ideological perspectives were side-lined & yet they existed , Ram Madhav share a glimpse of perspectives holded by Dr.B. R Amdedkar , Shri M.S Golwalkar & Deendayal Updahaya. I could relate with Shri Golwalkar on Samrasta (equality of emotion and feelings).
Immediately after achieving independence, we had to deal with an issue which till date remains point of contention with our neighbour in west, yes! Ram Madhav dives deep in to Kashmir issue, from historic background till abrogation of Article 370, this books gives political perspective to Kashmir issue and also touches the social, economic and cultural facets which got impacted due to Special Status to Kashmir.
In going fast forward the book gives you glimpse of Atal Bihari Vajpayee & L.K Advani era and historic background of Ram Mandiar issue and how Supreme Court was persuaded to consider it as a matter of importance. Soon this book brings attention towards history of Citizenship Act and latest protest which were organised to roll back Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), reading these chapters gives insights of what has been missed by mainstream media.
And in last section of book, Ram Madhav focuses of India China relationship which touched rare peaks & deep troughs in recent past, this section touches Tibet, Covid and impct of pandemic on world order.
Very fascinating journey along with very gracefully withholding criticism of Congress and Prime Misters from Congress Party.
Thanks to Indic Book Club
Immediately after achieving independence, we had to deal with an issue which till date remains point of contention with our neighbour in west, yes! Ram Madhav dives deep in to Kashmir issue, from historic background till abrogation of Article 370, this books gives political perspective to Kashmir issue and also touches the social, economic and cultural facets which got impacted due to Special Status to Kashmir.
In going fast forward the book gives you glimpse of Atal Bihari Vajpayee & L.K Advani era and historic background of Ram Mandiar issue and how Supreme Court was persuaded to consider it as a matter of importance. Soon this book brings attention towards history of Citizenship Act and latest protest which were organised to roll back Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), reading these chapters gives insights of what has been missed by mainstream media.
And in last section of book, Ram Madhav focuses of India China relationship which touched rare peaks & deep troughs in recent past, this section touches Tibet, Covid and impct of pandemic on world order.
Very fascinating journey along with very gracefully withholding criticism of Congress and Prime Misters from Congress Party.
Thanks to Indic Book Club
February 24, 2021
Thanks to Indic Book Club, Ram Madhav for this wonderful book. Happy to post a review.
Review of the book 'Because India Comes First' by Sri Ram Madhav.
About the author:
Ram Madhav is an Indian politician who served as the National General Secretary of BJP and as member of the National Executive of the RSS.
Discussion meets are being held all across India to celebrate the launch of his book.
About the book:
The book is a compilation of 53 independent essays organized as a ‘String of Pearls’. This inherent structure is one of the wonderful qualities of the book - the reader has the option to choose to read any essay at random and yet not lose sight of the big picture. The underlying thread connecting the essays are issues of nationalism, Indic culture and national identity. The book evokes interest in various current topics by providing relevant history of their origin and the people involved.
Essays in the book touch upon current hot topics. The everyday common man tends to have multiple questions regarding important current events and more often than not, scouring through Google to find answers proves to be an ineffective strategy. However, Mr. Madhav manages to provide a clear, direct and fact-based perspective on these issues based on events, both recent and past. The narrative has the reader completely immersed as they travel through history and back, all the while discussing complex issues like CAA, NRC and many other topics of national interest.
Highlighted here are a few topics that I think brings out the essence of the book:
Spirit of Democracy:
The good side of Gandhi - The author has penned a few essays on Mahatma Gandhi. While Mahatma Gandhi’s name is being mired in controversy today, Mr. Madhav chooses to portray Gandhiji’s virtuosity instead. The book brings out some of the personal sacrifices that Gandhiji had to suffer through to uphold his values. Shedding light on this facet of the Father of our nation gives readers a balanced perspective by portraying Gandhiji’s thought process and how the world was affected positively by his actions.
Article 370 abrogation:
The essays detail the origin and interactions between leaders that led to the creation of Article 370 and the birth of Gupkar’s movement. The deceit and falsehood involved are truly shocking.
Roots of Citizenship Act:
The book explains how the partition was a source of the problem, how the politics of Pakistan and Bangladesh had a strong bearing and how each of the great leaders, Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, and Indira Gandhi, contributed in worsening the situation.
Overall conclusion:
There are many more gems that open up multiple dimensions for the reader. I strongly recommend the book for every patriot of the nation.
Review of the book 'Because India Comes First' by Sri Ram Madhav.
About the author:
Ram Madhav is an Indian politician who served as the National General Secretary of BJP and as member of the National Executive of the RSS.
Discussion meets are being held all across India to celebrate the launch of his book.
About the book:
The book is a compilation of 53 independent essays organized as a ‘String of Pearls’. This inherent structure is one of the wonderful qualities of the book - the reader has the option to choose to read any essay at random and yet not lose sight of the big picture. The underlying thread connecting the essays are issues of nationalism, Indic culture and national identity. The book evokes interest in various current topics by providing relevant history of their origin and the people involved.
Essays in the book touch upon current hot topics. The everyday common man tends to have multiple questions regarding important current events and more often than not, scouring through Google to find answers proves to be an ineffective strategy. However, Mr. Madhav manages to provide a clear, direct and fact-based perspective on these issues based on events, both recent and past. The narrative has the reader completely immersed as they travel through history and back, all the while discussing complex issues like CAA, NRC and many other topics of national interest.
Highlighted here are a few topics that I think brings out the essence of the book:
Spirit of Democracy:
The good side of Gandhi - The author has penned a few essays on Mahatma Gandhi. While Mahatma Gandhi’s name is being mired in controversy today, Mr. Madhav chooses to portray Gandhiji’s virtuosity instead. The book brings out some of the personal sacrifices that Gandhiji had to suffer through to uphold his values. Shedding light on this facet of the Father of our nation gives readers a balanced perspective by portraying Gandhiji’s thought process and how the world was affected positively by his actions.
Article 370 abrogation:
The essays detail the origin and interactions between leaders that led to the creation of Article 370 and the birth of Gupkar’s movement. The deceit and falsehood involved are truly shocking.
Roots of Citizenship Act:
The book explains how the partition was a source of the problem, how the politics of Pakistan and Bangladesh had a strong bearing and how each of the great leaders, Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, and Indira Gandhi, contributed in worsening the situation.
Overall conclusion:
There are many more gems that open up multiple dimensions for the reader. I strongly recommend the book for every patriot of the nation.
February 18, 2021
First of all, I would like to thank Indic Book Academy for providing this book to me.
'Because India Comes First' by BJP leader Ram Madhav is a collection of essays written by him over 12 years from 2008 to 2020.
One good thing about the author's writing is that he presents a matter from different perspectives (what do the liberals think about this?) before offering his own opinion and analysis, thus providing a complete overview to the reader. He offers lessons of history, analysis of recent issues and a brief outlook towards the future. Wide-ranging issues including controversial ones like Article 370, Gandhi, Nehru, CAA-NRC, Ram Mandir, and relations with Pakistan & China have been covered. The book also offers some insight into the working and the mindset of RSS, the Vajpayee years and the 6 years of Modi govt. However, I would have liked some more clarity and detail in these insights. Many times, I felt the author's views to be in contrast with the reality of the way BJP and RSS work. Since the book is composed of a collection of essays, it might feel discontinuous at times.
All in all, I found the book quite provocative- it forces you to think, to revisit your thoughts and to strongly agree or disagree with the author. In the age of misunderstood tweets and jingoistic TV debates, the author offers an alternative way of developing your knowledge and understanding of critical issues.
'Because India Comes First' by BJP leader Ram Madhav is a collection of essays written by him over 12 years from 2008 to 2020.
One good thing about the author's writing is that he presents a matter from different perspectives (what do the liberals think about this?) before offering his own opinion and analysis, thus providing a complete overview to the reader. He offers lessons of history, analysis of recent issues and a brief outlook towards the future. Wide-ranging issues including controversial ones like Article 370, Gandhi, Nehru, CAA-NRC, Ram Mandir, and relations with Pakistan & China have been covered. The book also offers some insight into the working and the mindset of RSS, the Vajpayee years and the 6 years of Modi govt. However, I would have liked some more clarity and detail in these insights. Many times, I felt the author's views to be in contrast with the reality of the way BJP and RSS work. Since the book is composed of a collection of essays, it might feel discontinuous at times.
All in all, I found the book quite provocative- it forces you to think, to revisit your thoughts and to strongly agree or disagree with the author. In the age of misunderstood tweets and jingoistic TV debates, the author offers an alternative way of developing your knowledge and understanding of critical issues.
April 13, 2021
I want to thank the Indic Book Club (https://indicbookclub.com/) and Indic Academy (https://www.indicacademy.org) for generously sending me a copy of this book for review.
I want to preface my review by describing the nature of this book and consequently my expectations prior to reading it. The book is a collection of essays penned by Shri Ram Madhavji, who is an Indian politician and member of the current political establishment. That being said, while this book is divided into many sub-themes, they are not always in chronological order and they do not always further expand upon an idea that was mentioned in the preceding chapter. Hence, each chapter or each essay has to also be read and evaluated as a standalone, in addition to drawing more general macro trends about the author's views and experiences. Secondly, given that the author is a centre-right politician, the reader should not expect him to take very rigid or partisan stances on hotly debated issues. I do not mean this as a criticism. I started the book with this understanding and saw it being consistently reflected till the very end. I believe there is also certain value to politicians not taking hard stances in public forums, especially those on sensitive topics. While society needs partisan views on all sides of the spectrum in order to bring new ideas, it also needs people who maintain enough integrity and faith of all in order to take constructive action towards a mutually amenable future. Here I am not making a statement about the author, I have not followed his political life, but a statement on why I do not consider non-partisan writing by political personalities as warranting criticism of their work.
That being said I really liked the range of topics covered by the book. They were quite contemporary, and even those which were written some 5-6 years ago held relevance give much to think about when one has the hindsight of 2021. At the same time, I also wish that there was a deeper analysis of the author's ideas, especially because so many times I felt the chapter ended right when the background had been set and the conversation had just started. I am aware that this is a constraint of the book's format, and perhaps other writings by the author can give more detailed insight to those of us searching for more.
My second critique is that the author, despite coming from a party with more cultural roots and being associated with Indic organisations, chose to incorporate his ideas (and many ancient Indian ideas) within a universalist, modern framework of liberal scholars and Western democracies. I believe an Indian leader speaking for the resurgence of our culture and way of life, should endeavour to root his writings and messaging with the traditional knowledge systems which have witnessed violent suppression in the past and abject ignorance in the present. Indian systems have their own nuanced meanings and planes of reality for knowledge that cannot be retrofitted because knowledge and truth are not universal. This is not to say those modern ideas such as peace, liberty, secularism etc., that the author often refers to, cannot be part of nation-building but rather to say that the conceptual foundations need to be homegrown and imported ideas should be tested against those conceptual foundations instead of vice-versa. Only then can they ever be effective and thus meaningful in the true sense. I wanted such a perspective, not for a "feel-good" factor, but because the intellectual foundations of our knowledge systems have remained stagnant for long and need to first be revived through conversation which this book could have contributed towards.
All that being said, I really enjoyed reading the book. I learnt more about subjects I thought I already knew much about, and liked the simple yet effective communication skills of the author. I liked how the author had his own experiences to share and his own way of seeing historical events that have shaped this country (rather than a general trope as is common with many popular personalities). If I had to rationalise the title of this book, I'll say that while it may appear that the author is being chauvinistic or nationalistic (as it is called these days) towards his own country, he is, in fact, presenting a world-view that Indian values and goals of co-existence, welfare and justice are not just our own but also those of the world we live in; hence, who we are as a people is not divorced of our progress in this globalised world, it is rather that which we can bring to it.
I want to preface my review by describing the nature of this book and consequently my expectations prior to reading it. The book is a collection of essays penned by Shri Ram Madhavji, who is an Indian politician and member of the current political establishment. That being said, while this book is divided into many sub-themes, they are not always in chronological order and they do not always further expand upon an idea that was mentioned in the preceding chapter. Hence, each chapter or each essay has to also be read and evaluated as a standalone, in addition to drawing more general macro trends about the author's views and experiences. Secondly, given that the author is a centre-right politician, the reader should not expect him to take very rigid or partisan stances on hotly debated issues. I do not mean this as a criticism. I started the book with this understanding and saw it being consistently reflected till the very end. I believe there is also certain value to politicians not taking hard stances in public forums, especially those on sensitive topics. While society needs partisan views on all sides of the spectrum in order to bring new ideas, it also needs people who maintain enough integrity and faith of all in order to take constructive action towards a mutually amenable future. Here I am not making a statement about the author, I have not followed his political life, but a statement on why I do not consider non-partisan writing by political personalities as warranting criticism of their work.
That being said I really liked the range of topics covered by the book. They were quite contemporary, and even those which were written some 5-6 years ago held relevance give much to think about when one has the hindsight of 2021. At the same time, I also wish that there was a deeper analysis of the author's ideas, especially because so many times I felt the chapter ended right when the background had been set and the conversation had just started. I am aware that this is a constraint of the book's format, and perhaps other writings by the author can give more detailed insight to those of us searching for more.
My second critique is that the author, despite coming from a party with more cultural roots and being associated with Indic organisations, chose to incorporate his ideas (and many ancient Indian ideas) within a universalist, modern framework of liberal scholars and Western democracies. I believe an Indian leader speaking for the resurgence of our culture and way of life, should endeavour to root his writings and messaging with the traditional knowledge systems which have witnessed violent suppression in the past and abject ignorance in the present. Indian systems have their own nuanced meanings and planes of reality for knowledge that cannot be retrofitted because knowledge and truth are not universal. This is not to say those modern ideas such as peace, liberty, secularism etc., that the author often refers to, cannot be part of nation-building but rather to say that the conceptual foundations need to be homegrown and imported ideas should be tested against those conceptual foundations instead of vice-versa. Only then can they ever be effective and thus meaningful in the true sense. I wanted such a perspective, not for a "feel-good" factor, but because the intellectual foundations of our knowledge systems have remained stagnant for long and need to first be revived through conversation which this book could have contributed towards.
All that being said, I really enjoyed reading the book. I learnt more about subjects I thought I already knew much about, and liked the simple yet effective communication skills of the author. I liked how the author had his own experiences to share and his own way of seeing historical events that have shaped this country (rather than a general trope as is common with many popular personalities). If I had to rationalise the title of this book, I'll say that while it may appear that the author is being chauvinistic or nationalistic (as it is called these days) towards his own country, he is, in fact, presenting a world-view that Indian values and goals of co-existence, welfare and justice are not just our own but also those of the world we live in; hence, who we are as a people is not divorced of our progress in this globalised world, it is rather that which we can bring to it.
February 23, 2021
A very good collection of easy, detailing chapter from Indian history and culture, thoroughly researched and eloquently presented.
November 3, 2021
To read the book “Because India comes first” one needs to set aside their prejudices and ideology preferences. One must also forget the ideology of the writer Ram Madhav. This is being said because not letting go of those pre hold notions will lead to an hinderance in the understanding of the book. Like the name of the book suggests a reader must read this book with the empathy of why this country that we call our motherland must come first for him or her. One needs to read this book with a clear mind, with the sole identity of being a “Bharatiya” and then the joy of reading this book unravels.
This book beautifully portrays the notion of India and the different points in its history. It gives a summarized version of some of the important movements in the Indian history and the need of those movements. Its also gives a look into some of the architects who contributed to the notion that is India and its wellbeing. The book is divided in 5 parts. It contains essays and articles that the author has written and spoken over times in various platforms.
Part 1: The spirit of democracy, in this section the author overwhelmingly depicts his thoughts on Mahatma Gandhi, BR Ambedkar, MS Golwalkar, Deendayal Upadhyaya. The author gives his opinion on how they worked and their struggle for making India a better place. This gives a clear view on how an individual with knowledge, clarity of mind, truth and will power can contribute to the betterment of the country. Through the ideas of Raj dharma, the principles of Vivekananda and its influence on Gandhism, they converge to the point that democracy is an ancient knowledge to the ethos of India and the democratic fabric has always existed in India since the ancients.
Part 2 consists of essays and articles on Ramjanmabhoomi and the movement, Article 370, NRC. This section gives a good ides on why it is important to correct the wrongs of the past. They represented a tangled history of India. Without untangling this event, there is a hindrance to build a new nation that is full of confidence and pride of its heritage. It also gives us an idea on why strong leaders are needed, who can defy the norm, go against the flow of wind and set a path that have impact in future.
In part 3 the author put forward some strong views. He presents a topic from a different point of view that is easy to understand and then put forwards his analysis on it. The articles on Atal Bihari Vajpayee, RSS, BJP Narendra Modi give a proper understanding on the functioning and internal work ethics of the Sangh Parivar. The reading on Somnath and Ayodhya are refreshing. The need for civilization and identity assertion are clearly and precisely written. Through this one can understand why the knowledge of history and its events are needed. For eg. unfortunate incidents happening to women in present India nowhere represent the mentality of people of yore days where women were revered and held in high esteem.
The essays in Part 4 Facing the facts, speaks on the topics like: the liberals of India, handling of terror by UPA government, the CAA, the intellectuals of our country who are incoherent and speak for only one side. These essays give an insight on how the liberal democracies of the world are failing to address the multiple challenges and are falling into the trap of political correctness. The incapabilities of UN and its associated organizations to handle major crisis of the world has been appalling. This part also highlights the struggle of the people in India who identify themselves as liberals; for they are caught in a whirlpool where their justification for the views and opinion they hold dear are unraveling and the lies are outed.
The last part consists of opinions of the author on relationship of India with Israel, USA, China. It asserts the emergence of a NEW INDIA. An India that must learn from its past and not compromise on its principle and development. That India must learn form Israel and how to deal and navigate the US – India strategics alliance on terror, trade, security without giving the US an upper hand. The author forwards his views on how to navigate the enigma that is China and its associated problems like OBOR, CPEC, china views on Arunachal Pradesh. While China have always asserted it right and implemented its wolf warrior diplomacy, India on its part in the past has tried to molly coddle China which failed time again and again. The part of highlight the unfortunate covid-19 pandemic that has provided India with an opportunity to assert it importance as a global leader and under the leadership of PM Narendra Modi to some extent it has been possible.
Overall, this book is a must read for those wondering souls who are trying to identify with the idea why India must come first for each and every citizen of this country.
This book beautifully portrays the notion of India and the different points in its history. It gives a summarized version of some of the important movements in the Indian history and the need of those movements. Its also gives a look into some of the architects who contributed to the notion that is India and its wellbeing. The book is divided in 5 parts. It contains essays and articles that the author has written and spoken over times in various platforms.
Part 1: The spirit of democracy, in this section the author overwhelmingly depicts his thoughts on Mahatma Gandhi, BR Ambedkar, MS Golwalkar, Deendayal Upadhyaya. The author gives his opinion on how they worked and their struggle for making India a better place. This gives a clear view on how an individual with knowledge, clarity of mind, truth and will power can contribute to the betterment of the country. Through the ideas of Raj dharma, the principles of Vivekananda and its influence on Gandhism, they converge to the point that democracy is an ancient knowledge to the ethos of India and the democratic fabric has always existed in India since the ancients.
Part 2 consists of essays and articles on Ramjanmabhoomi and the movement, Article 370, NRC. This section gives a good ides on why it is important to correct the wrongs of the past. They represented a tangled history of India. Without untangling this event, there is a hindrance to build a new nation that is full of confidence and pride of its heritage. It also gives us an idea on why strong leaders are needed, who can defy the norm, go against the flow of wind and set a path that have impact in future.
In part 3 the author put forward some strong views. He presents a topic from a different point of view that is easy to understand and then put forwards his analysis on it. The articles on Atal Bihari Vajpayee, RSS, BJP Narendra Modi give a proper understanding on the functioning and internal work ethics of the Sangh Parivar. The reading on Somnath and Ayodhya are refreshing. The need for civilization and identity assertion are clearly and precisely written. Through this one can understand why the knowledge of history and its events are needed. For eg. unfortunate incidents happening to women in present India nowhere represent the mentality of people of yore days where women were revered and held in high esteem.
The essays in Part 4 Facing the facts, speaks on the topics like: the liberals of India, handling of terror by UPA government, the CAA, the intellectuals of our country who are incoherent and speak for only one side. These essays give an insight on how the liberal democracies of the world are failing to address the multiple challenges and are falling into the trap of political correctness. The incapabilities of UN and its associated organizations to handle major crisis of the world has been appalling. This part also highlights the struggle of the people in India who identify themselves as liberals; for they are caught in a whirlpool where their justification for the views and opinion they hold dear are unraveling and the lies are outed.
The last part consists of opinions of the author on relationship of India with Israel, USA, China. It asserts the emergence of a NEW INDIA. An India that must learn from its past and not compromise on its principle and development. That India must learn form Israel and how to deal and navigate the US – India strategics alliance on terror, trade, security without giving the US an upper hand. The author forwards his views on how to navigate the enigma that is China and its associated problems like OBOR, CPEC, china views on Arunachal Pradesh. While China have always asserted it right and implemented its wolf warrior diplomacy, India on its part in the past has tried to molly coddle China which failed time again and again. The part of highlight the unfortunate covid-19 pandemic that has provided India with an opportunity to assert it importance as a global leader and under the leadership of PM Narendra Modi to some extent it has been possible.
Overall, this book is a must read for those wondering souls who are trying to identify with the idea why India must come first for each and every citizen of this country.
March 4, 2021
I had seen Shri Ram Madhav during debates, when he had not joined BJP. That was era when only few good orators and knowledgeable person BJP and RSS had and Ram Madhav was one of them. In this book the author has expressed his views on vide range of subjects i.e Gandhi, Amdedkar, 370, Ayodhya case, internal and external. Since the author is said to be instrumental in forming NDA govt. in J&K, he has discussed issues related to J&K elaborately. A very well balanced thoughts. However, I would like to draw attention of the author on following:-
• The author has discussed Gandhi and gandhism in many chapters of the book, but he shies away in discussing Savarkar. Perhaps, it might be due to fear of Congress and left. Problem with BJP and RSS is that for their every action they seek approval from Congress and left.
• About Gandhism, I would like to say that ‘by way of Gandhism, the world has devised a tool to keep India meek and docile. When Obama or anyone else praises Gandhi, they are actually befooling us, because when it comes them they bombard Afganistan, Iraq, Syria or anyone they like, they don’t follow gandhism there.
• In Chapter 27, the author quotes Dr. Rajendra Prasad “ The Somnath temple signifies that the power of reconstruction is always greater than the power of destruction.” I don’t agree with author or Dr. Rajendra Prasad, because still there are 30,000 temples which were destroyed, are still with the destroyer and no govt. has done anything to hand over them to Hindus. The author has discussed Hagia Sophia here. Like the same the Hindu society had expected that after partition Govt. will hand over all destroyed temples to Hindus, but successive govt. has fooled Hindus.
• Chapter-29 – I would like to correct the author that in Valmiki Ramayan after returning to Ayodhya, Devi Sita had wished to stay in jungle.
• In chapter 32 author talks about govt policy of “justice to all, but appeasement to none”. Here I would like to draw attention of the author that Congress govt. had done only lip service with regard to appeasement, but it is BJP govt. has done maximum appeasement. They proudly say that they have granted maximum number of scholarship to muslims.
• In subsequent chapter, the author discussed BLM in US, but he fails to notice that George Floyd was a criminal like Tabrej or Akhlak.
• The author has rightly pointed out about people’s behaviour in democracy. If one reads Sita Ram Goel books, he can figure out that our country is under seize by imperialistic forces of Islam, Christianity and Communism. One can not deal with them in democratic ways.
• Author discusses India’s stand on Israel-Palestine issue – to resolve the conflict through dialogue. But same time author says that ‘in a war, there wouldn’t be anything called disproportionate force, too didn’t matter’. I am surprised that the author does not suggest same way while dealing with terrorist state Pakistan. Why doesn’t the author tells his govt to shed gandhian way and follow Israel way.
• I totally agree with author that, it China not Pakistan which is India’s No. 1 enemy. I also feel that threat from Bangladesh is even bigger than that of Pakistan.
• I salute the courage of author that while dealing with china, we shoul follow boldness of Boris Yeltsin.
• Again I ask author that when he quotes Prof. Steve Cohen ‘India is the most lethargic country when it comes to indigenous production of weapons’. Where is gandhism?
• Finally, the author holds high regards for Dalai Lama, but does Dalai Lama knows about imperialistic ambitions of neo-Boddhists in India and what is his position on this issue.
Good book but I have reduced one star due to author's view on Gandhism.
• The author has discussed Gandhi and gandhism in many chapters of the book, but he shies away in discussing Savarkar. Perhaps, it might be due to fear of Congress and left. Problem with BJP and RSS is that for their every action they seek approval from Congress and left.
• About Gandhism, I would like to say that ‘by way of Gandhism, the world has devised a tool to keep India meek and docile. When Obama or anyone else praises Gandhi, they are actually befooling us, because when it comes them they bombard Afganistan, Iraq, Syria or anyone they like, they don’t follow gandhism there.
• In Chapter 27, the author quotes Dr. Rajendra Prasad “ The Somnath temple signifies that the power of reconstruction is always greater than the power of destruction.” I don’t agree with author or Dr. Rajendra Prasad, because still there are 30,000 temples which were destroyed, are still with the destroyer and no govt. has done anything to hand over them to Hindus. The author has discussed Hagia Sophia here. Like the same the Hindu society had expected that after partition Govt. will hand over all destroyed temples to Hindus, but successive govt. has fooled Hindus.
• Chapter-29 – I would like to correct the author that in Valmiki Ramayan after returning to Ayodhya, Devi Sita had wished to stay in jungle.
• In chapter 32 author talks about govt policy of “justice to all, but appeasement to none”. Here I would like to draw attention of the author that Congress govt. had done only lip service with regard to appeasement, but it is BJP govt. has done maximum appeasement. They proudly say that they have granted maximum number of scholarship to muslims.
• In subsequent chapter, the author discussed BLM in US, but he fails to notice that George Floyd was a criminal like Tabrej or Akhlak.
• The author has rightly pointed out about people’s behaviour in democracy. If one reads Sita Ram Goel books, he can figure out that our country is under seize by imperialistic forces of Islam, Christianity and Communism. One can not deal with them in democratic ways.
• Author discusses India’s stand on Israel-Palestine issue – to resolve the conflict through dialogue. But same time author says that ‘in a war, there wouldn’t be anything called disproportionate force, too didn’t matter’. I am surprised that the author does not suggest same way while dealing with terrorist state Pakistan. Why doesn’t the author tells his govt to shed gandhian way and follow Israel way.
• I totally agree with author that, it China not Pakistan which is India’s No. 1 enemy. I also feel that threat from Bangladesh is even bigger than that of Pakistan.
• I salute the courage of author that while dealing with china, we shoul follow boldness of Boris Yeltsin.
• Again I ask author that when he quotes Prof. Steve Cohen ‘India is the most lethargic country when it comes to indigenous production of weapons’. Where is gandhism?
• Finally, the author holds high regards for Dalai Lama, but does Dalai Lama knows about imperialistic ambitions of neo-Boddhists in India and what is his position on this issue.
Good book but I have reduced one star due to author's view on Gandhism.
April 7, 2025
Because India Comes First is a collection of insightful essays penned by Mr. Ram Madhav - formerly the national spokesperson of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh(RSS) and general secretary of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).
Pouring his deep understanding of the political journey of India, he touches upon both sides of the debate. Starting by exploring the spirit of democracy from the time of independence, he proceeds to appreciate the Gandhian values that inspired more than 50 countries to free from the yoke of dictatorships and monarchies. His admiration of Gandhi is aptly captured in the statement: “You can love him, pretend to love him or hate him – but you can’t ignore him”. In his further essays he provides the perspectives of Dr. B.R Ambedkar, Shri Guruji M.S. Golwalkar and Shri Deendayal Upadhyaya on democracy.
The next section of essays, which I personally found very impressive, deal with the historic blunder related to Kashmir, abrogation of Article 370 and National Register of Citizens (NRC) for Assam. These essays dive deep in exposing the victimhood politics, the slow yet definite realization by the people of Kashmir and the immense opportunities being made available to them in recent years. The concept of Akhanda Bharat is also clearly explained as a cultural and people-centric idea, as against the ill-spread ideas of re-drawing the boundaries.
The further essays on Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Ram Mandir Movement, RSS, Citizenship Act, Challenges to Global Governance etc are profoundly insightful to appreciate their immense value in putting India on the world map as a dependable partner and a world leader.
The last section of essays talks about India’s relationship with the world and more specifically with China. Tiger’s relationship with Dragon has always been on the edge, but the responsible Head of States, matured foreign policies and mutually beneficial trade negotiations have been able to contain the bitter-sweet tiffs. China’s provocation in Arunachal Pradesh, it’s high-handedness with Dalai Lama and Tibet have been diplomatically handled by India, even though India could do much better on this front. In dealing with China for the border issues, Mr. Ram Madhav has smartly nudged the government to look at Israel’s stand. He has penned an inspiring essay titled, Shalom Al Yisrael , where he rightfully points out Israel’s imperfections and its share of excesses and mistakes but critically examines Israel’s stance with its neighbors and their perpetual fight for every inch of land. Israel’s achievement in last seven decades is an immensely inspirational saga.
To conclude, in these essays, he makes earnest efforts in putting India first in all aspect. Irrespective of the political ideologies, he does not shy away from crediting the rightful opposition members for their efforts in bringing a positive change in the political landscape, but at the same time, he does not spare the wrong doings of some over-zealous and myopic leaders of the past. He also points out the need for current leaders to up their ante in dealing with neighbors and try to establish a stable flourishing environment for a better world. His politically unbiased observations in simple language without any jargons, makes this book an interesting read.
Pouring his deep understanding of the political journey of India, he touches upon both sides of the debate. Starting by exploring the spirit of democracy from the time of independence, he proceeds to appreciate the Gandhian values that inspired more than 50 countries to free from the yoke of dictatorships and monarchies. His admiration of Gandhi is aptly captured in the statement: “You can love him, pretend to love him or hate him – but you can’t ignore him”. In his further essays he provides the perspectives of Dr. B.R Ambedkar, Shri Guruji M.S. Golwalkar and Shri Deendayal Upadhyaya on democracy.
The next section of essays, which I personally found very impressive, deal with the historic blunder related to Kashmir, abrogation of Article 370 and National Register of Citizens (NRC) for Assam. These essays dive deep in exposing the victimhood politics, the slow yet definite realization by the people of Kashmir and the immense opportunities being made available to them in recent years. The concept of Akhanda Bharat is also clearly explained as a cultural and people-centric idea, as against the ill-spread ideas of re-drawing the boundaries.
The further essays on Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Ram Mandir Movement, RSS, Citizenship Act, Challenges to Global Governance etc are profoundly insightful to appreciate their immense value in putting India on the world map as a dependable partner and a world leader.
The last section of essays talks about India’s relationship with the world and more specifically with China. Tiger’s relationship with Dragon has always been on the edge, but the responsible Head of States, matured foreign policies and mutually beneficial trade negotiations have been able to contain the bitter-sweet tiffs. China’s provocation in Arunachal Pradesh, it’s high-handedness with Dalai Lama and Tibet have been diplomatically handled by India, even though India could do much better on this front. In dealing with China for the border issues, Mr. Ram Madhav has smartly nudged the government to look at Israel’s stand. He has penned an inspiring essay titled, Shalom Al Yisrael , where he rightfully points out Israel’s imperfections and its share of excesses and mistakes but critically examines Israel’s stance with its neighbors and their perpetual fight for every inch of land. Israel’s achievement in last seven decades is an immensely inspirational saga.
To conclude, in these essays, he makes earnest efforts in putting India first in all aspect. Irrespective of the political ideologies, he does not shy away from crediting the rightful opposition members for their efforts in bringing a positive change in the political landscape, but at the same time, he does not spare the wrong doings of some over-zealous and myopic leaders of the past. He also points out the need for current leaders to up their ante in dealing with neighbors and try to establish a stable flourishing environment for a better world. His politically unbiased observations in simple language without any jargons, makes this book an interesting read.
March 20, 2022
Firstly a big note of thanks to the IBC Curators. The book ‘Because India Comes First’ is a collection of 53 independent essays organized. Packed with facts and data, it makes for an engaging read regardless of political leanings.
As I’m publishing this review Shri Ram Madhav has rejoined Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh's All India Executive Wing and has come out with his fourth book titled ‘The Hindutva Paradigm’. In addition to his duties in the RSS organization the prolific author is also part of India Foundation, an influential think tank as a board of Governor.
In his previous stint as General Secretary of the BJP played a crucial role in handling matters in Jammu and Kashmir after the Abrogation of Article 370. And this fact is evident reading through essays under ‘Confronting History’- especially Chapters 11- through to Chapter16; which are arguably amongst the best essays in the book. Which is on the geopolitical hot potato that is Kashmir. The reader is made to revisit history, understand all the stakeholders involved, and take stock of the circumstances in which the original legislation of Article 306A.
It is an excellent reference for general public to revisit- with Kashmir Files being in prime time focus currently.
In the current Social Media age where the readers have a receding attention span is it is all too common to see fact free rhetorical arguments, and moral grandstanding- it was refreshing that solid facts and data being used to back arguments in favor of Article 370 Abrogation.
On Kashmir, he had said that with the abrogation of Article 370, grassroot leaders were coming up against the hegemony of a few families. He had added that it was the responsibility of the people of the country to make Kashmiris feel that they are part of the 1.3-billion-strong family.
All the essays are interesting and thought provoking in equal measure. This is the overarching theme in other chapters as well. While I was expecting politically rooted arguments; the detailing was riveting be it the context, the history, the repercussions are all packed in –which makes it and is a must read for the General public. The quotes referenced be it Arnold Toynbee, George Cœdès, WB Yeats, or VS Naipaul are pitch perfect and well placed.
Criticism if I may is to point out lack of reference to Indic Philosophy and thinkers. For instance Kautikya's 'Arthashastra' could have been cited as against Sun Tzu's 'Art of War'. But having said that I reckon that has more to do with the fact that these fifty-three essays written by Shri Ram Madhav has been over several years targeted for a print audience.
Because India comes First is a must read not just for political observers, but anyone interested in understanding the Indian Civilizational-State.
As I’m publishing this review Shri Ram Madhav has rejoined Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh's All India Executive Wing and has come out with his fourth book titled ‘The Hindutva Paradigm’. In addition to his duties in the RSS organization the prolific author is also part of India Foundation, an influential think tank as a board of Governor.
In his previous stint as General Secretary of the BJP played a crucial role in handling matters in Jammu and Kashmir after the Abrogation of Article 370. And this fact is evident reading through essays under ‘Confronting History’- especially Chapters 11- through to Chapter16; which are arguably amongst the best essays in the book. Which is on the geopolitical hot potato that is Kashmir. The reader is made to revisit history, understand all the stakeholders involved, and take stock of the circumstances in which the original legislation of Article 306A.
It is an excellent reference for general public to revisit- with Kashmir Files being in prime time focus currently.
In the current Social Media age where the readers have a receding attention span is it is all too common to see fact free rhetorical arguments, and moral grandstanding- it was refreshing that solid facts and data being used to back arguments in favor of Article 370 Abrogation.
On Kashmir, he had said that with the abrogation of Article 370, grassroot leaders were coming up against the hegemony of a few families. He had added that it was the responsibility of the people of the country to make Kashmiris feel that they are part of the 1.3-billion-strong family.
All the essays are interesting and thought provoking in equal measure. This is the overarching theme in other chapters as well. While I was expecting politically rooted arguments; the detailing was riveting be it the context, the history, the repercussions are all packed in –which makes it and is a must read for the General public. The quotes referenced be it Arnold Toynbee, George Cœdès, WB Yeats, or VS Naipaul are pitch perfect and well placed.
Criticism if I may is to point out lack of reference to Indic Philosophy and thinkers. For instance Kautikya's 'Arthashastra' could have been cited as against Sun Tzu's 'Art of War'. But having said that I reckon that has more to do with the fact that these fifty-three essays written by Shri Ram Madhav has been over several years targeted for a print audience.
Because India comes First is a must read not just for political observers, but anyone interested in understanding the Indian Civilizational-State.
March 21, 2021
Because India Comes First - Ram Madhav
Will you be the fish that asks “what the hell is water?” A recollection of an instructive story by the author made me ponder on the things that we take for granted. Through the collection of 50+ essays Ram Madhav provokes the reader to take a pause and think about the several aspects of the current affairs in India.
What I liked was how the author devoted the very first section to democracy and explained how it was not a western import but is at the core of the Indic thought as mentioned in the Vedas and the Smritis. The author notes that success of democracy even if it is embedded in our fabric will depend on the proper functioning of all pillars of democracy and draws on the principles of great personalities like Gandhiji, Mandela, Vivekananda, MS Golwalkar to strengthen democracy. Although one can read the book in any order, this first section on democracy and Indic thought seems to form the basis for the rest of the book and a reader may appreciate the author’s thoughts on Nationalism and Culture through the lenses of the first section.
An “aha” moment for me was when the author uses Gandhiji’s quotes and anecdotes from Ramayana and Mahabharata to propose the way forward for feminist movement after women empowerment and security have been addressed. However, the most revealing parts of the book for me were the essays on Article 370 abrogation, NRC in Assam, and CAA. I found these sections to be very informative and sometimes shocking as the author presented the facts, talks about the origins without any bias. Furthermore, I found the author’s stance on Panchsheel eye opening and his criticism of past governments (including BJP’s govt) for their passive stance on China & Tibet balanced. Finally, although the author concludes by offering a way forward for India by providing some interesting insights, it needs to be seen how it plays out in the real world.
The author’s style is simple and lucid - making it easier for the reader to understand complex political matters. Some essays may be read as pro-Modi but they need to be read in the context of past failures of Indian Govt. when faced with the same issues. Besides, the author also presented a balanced fact-based view of past and present leadership. Most of the essays leave you wanting for more which I found to be a limitation of the book - maybe the author wants you to pursue on your own after piquing your interest.
To sum up, it is a must-read book to have a well rounded awareness of Indic thought and Indian politics and would recommend everyone irrespective of their political stance to read it to get a glimpse of India and its current affairs.
Will you be the fish that asks “what the hell is water?” A recollection of an instructive story by the author made me ponder on the things that we take for granted. Through the collection of 50+ essays Ram Madhav provokes the reader to take a pause and think about the several aspects of the current affairs in India.
What I liked was how the author devoted the very first section to democracy and explained how it was not a western import but is at the core of the Indic thought as mentioned in the Vedas and the Smritis. The author notes that success of democracy even if it is embedded in our fabric will depend on the proper functioning of all pillars of democracy and draws on the principles of great personalities like Gandhiji, Mandela, Vivekananda, MS Golwalkar to strengthen democracy. Although one can read the book in any order, this first section on democracy and Indic thought seems to form the basis for the rest of the book and a reader may appreciate the author’s thoughts on Nationalism and Culture through the lenses of the first section.
An “aha” moment for me was when the author uses Gandhiji’s quotes and anecdotes from Ramayana and Mahabharata to propose the way forward for feminist movement after women empowerment and security have been addressed. However, the most revealing parts of the book for me were the essays on Article 370 abrogation, NRC in Assam, and CAA. I found these sections to be very informative and sometimes shocking as the author presented the facts, talks about the origins without any bias. Furthermore, I found the author’s stance on Panchsheel eye opening and his criticism of past governments (including BJP’s govt) for their passive stance on China & Tibet balanced. Finally, although the author concludes by offering a way forward for India by providing some interesting insights, it needs to be seen how it plays out in the real world.
The author’s style is simple and lucid - making it easier for the reader to understand complex political matters. Some essays may be read as pro-Modi but they need to be read in the context of past failures of Indian Govt. when faced with the same issues. Besides, the author also presented a balanced fact-based view of past and present leadership. Most of the essays leave you wanting for more which I found to be a limitation of the book - maybe the author wants you to pursue on your own after piquing your interest.
To sum up, it is a must-read book to have a well rounded awareness of Indic thought and Indian politics and would recommend everyone irrespective of their political stance to read it to get a glimpse of India and its current affairs.
April 6, 2021
More often than not we lament the lack of Indian narrative in Indian politics. This book serves to bridge that gap. Ram Madhav reflects on the myriad issues of nationalism, identity, and culture from a different lens than what is usually used in the zeitgeist. This book is also good because of its candor of taking up issues and personalities and then providing a historical, civilizational, and philosophical context to them.
The first section deals with the luminaries of founding fathers and those who have been relegated to a secondary position in the political milieu. This section gives the due to Gandhi and Ambedkar as their contribution in the genesis of the nation is considered to be paramount. However, what was refreshing to find were the chapters on Golwalkar and Deen Dayal Upadhyay.
The second chapter looks at the issue of Indian identity in the Indian nation state. The piece on Kashmir has a strong, bold outlook and Ram Madhav clearly elaborates the rationale behind the abrogation of the temporary constitutional sections that prevented full assimilation of the state with the union. It also delves on the history and reasons behind the exercise of NRC and why it is necessary for the nation to have strong borders.
The third section is an inward-looking reflection where he provides his views on Vajpayee Ji and Arun Jaitley and their ability to have cordial relations with people across the political spectrum. It also discusses how with times there has been a change in the views of the RSS, and how with times their views on certain issues like Ram Mandir has not changed.
The fourth section takes to task the ‘liberals’ who have their own agenda to pursue without any rationale. This section highlights the doublespeak of these people on terrorism, CAA, and equality. The fifth section is by far the best discussion on India’s external affairs. It discusses the undying friendship between India and Israel and what we can learn from them. And it also has very clear views on the Chinese actions and aspirations at the Asian and global area. I sincerely hope the clarity is passed on to the Ram Madhav’s colleagues in the government.
This book provides a new take on many of the topics oft discussed and many of those that have not been given their due limelight. It touches the topics of polity, culture, democracy, terrorism, citizenship and persecution, and India’s external affairs. While, it was expected that the book will lionize certain Individuals, the last section does provide a view on how the image of India can be improved upon, especially in the aftermath of COVID-19.
The first section deals with the luminaries of founding fathers and those who have been relegated to a secondary position in the political milieu. This section gives the due to Gandhi and Ambedkar as their contribution in the genesis of the nation is considered to be paramount. However, what was refreshing to find were the chapters on Golwalkar and Deen Dayal Upadhyay.
The second chapter looks at the issue of Indian identity in the Indian nation state. The piece on Kashmir has a strong, bold outlook and Ram Madhav clearly elaborates the rationale behind the abrogation of the temporary constitutional sections that prevented full assimilation of the state with the union. It also delves on the history and reasons behind the exercise of NRC and why it is necessary for the nation to have strong borders.
The third section is an inward-looking reflection where he provides his views on Vajpayee Ji and Arun Jaitley and their ability to have cordial relations with people across the political spectrum. It also discusses how with times there has been a change in the views of the RSS, and how with times their views on certain issues like Ram Mandir has not changed.
The fourth section takes to task the ‘liberals’ who have their own agenda to pursue without any rationale. This section highlights the doublespeak of these people on terrorism, CAA, and equality. The fifth section is by far the best discussion on India’s external affairs. It discusses the undying friendship between India and Israel and what we can learn from them. And it also has very clear views on the Chinese actions and aspirations at the Asian and global area. I sincerely hope the clarity is passed on to the Ram Madhav’s colleagues in the government.
This book provides a new take on many of the topics oft discussed and many of those that have not been given their due limelight. It touches the topics of polity, culture, democracy, terrorism, citizenship and persecution, and India’s external affairs. While, it was expected that the book will lionize certain Individuals, the last section does provide a view on how the image of India can be improved upon, especially in the aftermath of COVID-19.
April 24, 2021
Because India Comes First - Ram Madhav
Will you be the fish that asks “what the hell is water?” A recollection of an instructive story by the author made me ponder on the things that we take for granted. Through the collection of 50+ essays Ram Madhav provokes the reader to take a pause and think about the several aspects of the current affairs in India.
What I liked was how the author devoted the very first section to democracy and explained how it was not a western import but is at the core of the Indic thought as mentioned in the Vedas and the Smritis. The author notes that success of democracy even if it is embedded in our fabric will depend on the proper functioning of all pillars of democracy and draws on the principles of great personalities like Gandhiji, Mandela, Vivekananda, MS Golwalkar to strengthen democracy. Although one can read the book in any order, this first section on democracy and Indic thought seems to form the basis for the rest of the book and a reader may appreciate the author’s thoughts on Nationalism and Culture through the lenses of the first section.
An “aha” moment for me was when the author uses Gandhiji’s quotes and anecdotes from Ramayana and Mahabharata to propose the way forward for feminist movement after women empowerment and security have been addressed. However, the most revealing parts of the book for me were the essays on Article 370 abrogation, NRC in Assam, and CAA. I found these sections to be very informative and sometimes shocking as the author presented the facts, talks about the origins without any bias. Furthermore, I found the author’s stance on Panchsheel eye opening and his criticism of past governments (including BJP’s govt) for their passive stance on China & Tibet balanced. Finally, although the author concludes by offering a way forward for India by providing some interesting insights, it needs to be seen how it plays out in the real world.
The author’s style is simple and lucid - making it easier for the reader to understand complex political matters. Some essays may be read as pro-Modi but they need to be read in the context of past failures of Indian Govt. when faced with the same issues. Besides, the author also presented a balanced fact-based view of past and present leadership. Most of the essays leave you wanting for more which I found to be a limitation of the book - maybe the author wants you to pursue on your own after piquing your interest.
To sum up, it is a must-read book to have a well rounded awareness of Indic thought and Indian politics and would recommend everyone irrespective of their political stance to read it to get a glimpse of India and its current affairs.
Will you be the fish that asks “what the hell is water?” A recollection of an instructive story by the author made me ponder on the things that we take for granted. Through the collection of 50+ essays Ram Madhav provokes the reader to take a pause and think about the several aspects of the current affairs in India.
What I liked was how the author devoted the very first section to democracy and explained how it was not a western import but is at the core of the Indic thought as mentioned in the Vedas and the Smritis. The author notes that success of democracy even if it is embedded in our fabric will depend on the proper functioning of all pillars of democracy and draws on the principles of great personalities like Gandhiji, Mandela, Vivekananda, MS Golwalkar to strengthen democracy. Although one can read the book in any order, this first section on democracy and Indic thought seems to form the basis for the rest of the book and a reader may appreciate the author’s thoughts on Nationalism and Culture through the lenses of the first section.
An “aha” moment for me was when the author uses Gandhiji’s quotes and anecdotes from Ramayana and Mahabharata to propose the way forward for feminist movement after women empowerment and security have been addressed. However, the most revealing parts of the book for me were the essays on Article 370 abrogation, NRC in Assam, and CAA. I found these sections to be very informative and sometimes shocking as the author presented the facts, talks about the origins without any bias. Furthermore, I found the author’s stance on Panchsheel eye opening and his criticism of past governments (including BJP’s govt) for their passive stance on China & Tibet balanced. Finally, although the author concludes by offering a way forward for India by providing some interesting insights, it needs to be seen how it plays out in the real world.
The author’s style is simple and lucid - making it easier for the reader to understand complex political matters. Some essays may be read as pro-Modi but they need to be read in the context of past failures of Indian Govt. when faced with the same issues. Besides, the author also presented a balanced fact-based view of past and present leadership. Most of the essays leave you wanting for more which I found to be a limitation of the book - maybe the author wants you to pursue on your own after piquing your interest.
To sum up, it is a must-read book to have a well rounded awareness of Indic thought and Indian politics and would recommend everyone irrespective of their political stance to read it to get a glimpse of India and its current affairs.
March 13, 2021
Book review: Because India Comes First by Ram Madhav
A collection of 51 essays/articles written over span of 5-6 years, by Shri Ram Madhav, for newspapers and blogs, this book is an informative read to get through the various aspects of home politics, ideologies to international politics. The book presents the side of writer which is not of a politician, but an administrator, journalist and an intellectual.
The book is divided into 5 segments in which approximately 10 articles are dedicated to each, namely, The spirit of democracy, Confronting history, A view from within, Facing the facts, India and the World. The nature, themes and ideas of the essays maintain a beautiful balance between personal and impersonal aspects of the subject they are talking about. They are not a mere ranting about the personal ideological precursors and prejudices, but a logical and rational assessment of situations based on facts, sometimes, the facts which are not before the common public. The knowledge filled in the essays of world politics shows avid reading and dedication of the writer as strategist of the prime political party of this country. His unabashed acceptance of failure of Indian leaders in dealing with issues with China, and the crooked truth of Panchsheel are eye opening. Critical viewpoint in regard of Tibet issue is impressive and shows a way forward. Writer’s commitment with the ideas of Mahatma Gandhi, Ambedkarji and democratic values can be felt all through the books, as you get to know about them in the initial essays. As we start reading more and more essays the interest and anxiety to know more about the circumstances increases. And, the culmination of the book by the segment of world politics is a cherry on the pie. One can start reading the book from the topic of their choice, but starting from the first one to the last segment has a greater impact and binding with style of the writer.
Talking about the language and style of writing, is simple and lucid. There seems no bragging about intellectualism, yet a substantial grounding of deep knowledge can be readily understood. A person having basic knowledge of history and politics can very easily get to the context of the articles and enhance his or her knowledge base with the reading of these essays.
thankyou Indic Academy for giving me this opportunity to read and review this book
A collection of 51 essays/articles written over span of 5-6 years, by Shri Ram Madhav, for newspapers and blogs, this book is an informative read to get through the various aspects of home politics, ideologies to international politics. The book presents the side of writer which is not of a politician, but an administrator, journalist and an intellectual.
The book is divided into 5 segments in which approximately 10 articles are dedicated to each, namely, The spirit of democracy, Confronting history, A view from within, Facing the facts, India and the World. The nature, themes and ideas of the essays maintain a beautiful balance between personal and impersonal aspects of the subject they are talking about. They are not a mere ranting about the personal ideological precursors and prejudices, but a logical and rational assessment of situations based on facts, sometimes, the facts which are not before the common public. The knowledge filled in the essays of world politics shows avid reading and dedication of the writer as strategist of the prime political party of this country. His unabashed acceptance of failure of Indian leaders in dealing with issues with China, and the crooked truth of Panchsheel are eye opening. Critical viewpoint in regard of Tibet issue is impressive and shows a way forward. Writer’s commitment with the ideas of Mahatma Gandhi, Ambedkarji and democratic values can be felt all through the books, as you get to know about them in the initial essays. As we start reading more and more essays the interest and anxiety to know more about the circumstances increases. And, the culmination of the book by the segment of world politics is a cherry on the pie. One can start reading the book from the topic of their choice, but starting from the first one to the last segment has a greater impact and binding with style of the writer.
Talking about the language and style of writing, is simple and lucid. There seems no bragging about intellectualism, yet a substantial grounding of deep knowledge can be readily understood. A person having basic knowledge of history and politics can very easily get to the context of the articles and enhance his or her knowledge base with the reading of these essays.
thankyou Indic Academy for giving me this opportunity to read and review this book
August 11, 2021
When an ordinary reader picks it up, (s)he proceeds with a perception on it—immaterial of side—due to the ideological affiliation of the author. This reflects in the content too. A collection of 53 essays, the book is divided in five parts, all of which focus on issues through cultural prism. The first part revolves around the impact of culture on Gandhi and his contemporaries, and vice-versa. This part essentially focuses on the misconceptions relating to relationship of Gandhi, Ambedkar with right wing and constitutional values.
This volume brings out the aspects of our constitutional history which have deliberately been ignored by the mainstream, the second part is truly educating about situation, problems and position of Kashmir. He also traces the historical blunders that led to the crisis of past decades and supplements them with his first-hand experience as an important part of the organisational setup of recent ruling dispensations in Kashmir.
The third parts deals with the aspects of cultural issues manifested as communal problems— like the author categorically rebutted the arguments against amendment of Article 370 in the previous part—he destroys arguments on Ayodhya and allied issues in this part. The essay on Sita is a treat to read. The next part deals with global cultural issues, cancel culture, situation of Israel vis-à-vis India etc. and the last part deals with Sino-Indian relations, with special emphasis on post-independence mistakes and Tibet.
As the author is a top office-bearer in RSS, the reader’s attention is automatically drawn to the contradictions in his approach on multiple instances and on can easily deduce from them the reflection of confusion in the ideology of Sangh lately. People wonder about RSS taking stands and making interpretations contrary to its historically settled positions, the book, through the contradictions of the text, gives a fair idea of sources and reasons of such ideological contradictions. However, if one wishes to read something substantial on the other side of the story of the problems we have faced lately, this should be a must read.
This volume brings out the aspects of our constitutional history which have deliberately been ignored by the mainstream, the second part is truly educating about situation, problems and position of Kashmir. He also traces the historical blunders that led to the crisis of past decades and supplements them with his first-hand experience as an important part of the organisational setup of recent ruling dispensations in Kashmir.
The third parts deals with the aspects of cultural issues manifested as communal problems— like the author categorically rebutted the arguments against amendment of Article 370 in the previous part—he destroys arguments on Ayodhya and allied issues in this part. The essay on Sita is a treat to read. The next part deals with global cultural issues, cancel culture, situation of Israel vis-à-vis India etc. and the last part deals with Sino-Indian relations, with special emphasis on post-independence mistakes and Tibet.
As the author is a top office-bearer in RSS, the reader’s attention is automatically drawn to the contradictions in his approach on multiple instances and on can easily deduce from them the reflection of confusion in the ideology of Sangh lately. People wonder about RSS taking stands and making interpretations contrary to its historically settled positions, the book, through the contradictions of the text, gives a fair idea of sources and reasons of such ideological contradictions. However, if one wishes to read something substantial on the other side of the story of the problems we have faced lately, this should be a must read.
August 17, 2024
Because India Comes First by Ram Madhav
While reading this book, one needs to set aside their prejudices and ideology preferences. One must also forget the ideology of the writer Ram Madhav. This is being said because not letting go of those pre hold notions will lead to an hinderance in the understanding of the book.One needs to read this book with a clear mind, with the sole identity of being a “Bharatiya” and then the joy of reading this book unravels.
The journey begins with Bharat becoming Independent and a democratic ideology shaping it. This book beautifully portrays the notion of India and the different points of history, a summarized version of some of the important movements in the Indian history. It also gives a look into some of the architects who contributed to the notion i.e. India and its wellbeing. The essays in Part 4 Facing the Facts, speaks on the topics like: Liberals of India, handling of terror by UPA government, the CAA, the intellectuals of our country who are incoherent and speak for only one side. These essays give an insight on how the liberal democracies of the world are failing to address the multiple challenges and are falling into the trap of political correctness. The incapabilities of UN and its associated organizations to handle major crisis of the world has been appalling. This part also highlights the struggle of the people in India who identify themselves as liberals; for they are caught in a whirlpool where their justification for the views and opinion they hold dear are unraveling and the lies are outed.
As the author is a top office-bearer in RSS, the reader’s attention is automatically drawn to the contradictions in his approach on multiple instances and on can easily deduce from them the reflection of confusion in the ideology of Sangh lately. People wonder about RSS taking stands and making interpretations contrary to its historically settled positions, the book, through the contradictions of the text, gives a fair idea of sources and reasons of such ideological contradictions.
While reading this book, one needs to set aside their prejudices and ideology preferences. One must also forget the ideology of the writer Ram Madhav. This is being said because not letting go of those pre hold notions will lead to an hinderance in the understanding of the book.One needs to read this book with a clear mind, with the sole identity of being a “Bharatiya” and then the joy of reading this book unravels.
The journey begins with Bharat becoming Independent and a democratic ideology shaping it. This book beautifully portrays the notion of India and the different points of history, a summarized version of some of the important movements in the Indian history. It also gives a look into some of the architects who contributed to the notion i.e. India and its wellbeing. The essays in Part 4 Facing the Facts, speaks on the topics like: Liberals of India, handling of terror by UPA government, the CAA, the intellectuals of our country who are incoherent and speak for only one side. These essays give an insight on how the liberal democracies of the world are failing to address the multiple challenges and are falling into the trap of political correctness. The incapabilities of UN and its associated organizations to handle major crisis of the world has been appalling. This part also highlights the struggle of the people in India who identify themselves as liberals; for they are caught in a whirlpool where their justification for the views and opinion they hold dear are unraveling and the lies are outed.
As the author is a top office-bearer in RSS, the reader’s attention is automatically drawn to the contradictions in his approach on multiple instances and on can easily deduce from them the reflection of confusion in the ideology of Sangh lately. People wonder about RSS taking stands and making interpretations contrary to its historically settled positions, the book, through the contradictions of the text, gives a fair idea of sources and reasons of such ideological contradictions.
March 21, 2022
Because India Comes First written by Ram Madhav reflects on Nationalism, Identity and Culture of India.
Ram Madhav - formerly the national spokesperson of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and general secretary of the Bharatiya Janata Party - has been observing and participating in Indian politics for the past few decades. The essays in this volume draw upon his long engagement with politics to discuss a range of issues that are in the heart of contemporary debates in India : democracy as the responsibility of the head of State, rule of law, peace and public order, Mahatma Gandhi and Gandhism, Ambedkar's ideals, empowerment of women, Indian Judiciary, the Ram Janmabhoomi case, abrogation of Article 370, the legacies of Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Arun Jaitley and Prime Minister Narendra Modi's learnings in governance.
Because India Comes First also delves into the decision made by the BJP-led government over the last few years, diplomatic relationships with India's neighbors and the confrontations with China. Madhav analyses India's history of policymaking and asserts that, going ahead, it must put India first. He calls out liberal fascism, deconstructs our understanding of terrorism in India, argues that opposition to the Citizebsh (Amendment) Act is intellectually dishonest, explores how learnings from Black Lives Matter can be applied in the Indian sphere and explains why protests should be rooted in Martin Luther King Jr's non-violent approach and not anarchy. These essays weave a broad tapestry of India's growth into a soft power, and predict how it will shape up over the next few decades. A must read for those who believe in the new idea of India, and for those who accept that there are two sides to every debate.
Ram Madhav - formerly the national spokesperson of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and general secretary of the Bharatiya Janata Party - has been observing and participating in Indian politics for the past few decades. The essays in this volume draw upon his long engagement with politics to discuss a range of issues that are in the heart of contemporary debates in India : democracy as the responsibility of the head of State, rule of law, peace and public order, Mahatma Gandhi and Gandhism, Ambedkar's ideals, empowerment of women, Indian Judiciary, the Ram Janmabhoomi case, abrogation of Article 370, the legacies of Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Arun Jaitley and Prime Minister Narendra Modi's learnings in governance.
Because India Comes First also delves into the decision made by the BJP-led government over the last few years, diplomatic relationships with India's neighbors and the confrontations with China. Madhav analyses India's history of policymaking and asserts that, going ahead, it must put India first. He calls out liberal fascism, deconstructs our understanding of terrorism in India, argues that opposition to the Citizebsh (Amendment) Act is intellectually dishonest, explores how learnings from Black Lives Matter can be applied in the Indian sphere and explains why protests should be rooted in Martin Luther King Jr's non-violent approach and not anarchy. These essays weave a broad tapestry of India's growth into a soft power, and predict how it will shape up over the next few decades. A must read for those who believe in the new idea of India, and for those who accept that there are two sides to every debate.
April 12, 2025
The book is divided into 5 sections
1st section is The spirit of democracy talking about gandhi, ambedkar and RSS folks. It was an average one and most of the things have been discussed and debated in the public domain already.
The 2nd section was confronting history with a major focus on Kashmir, article 370 loaded with good anecdotes. The section also touched NRC which was also decent.
The third section a view from within talked about BJP ICONS and the ram mandir andolan, a decent one with some crisp points here and there .
Fourth section Facing the facts was a good one. The article on citizenship act (35 in sequence) was well written and makes a strong case for CAA. EVEN THE essay know your terrorist was a well informed one.
The last section was a tricky one with MOST focus on Israel , with a clear stand taken on Israel .
Then mostly it discussed china , Tibet and Dalai Lama, with discussions how we are played along by the Chinese since decades and accepting the fact we are no match to them currently and need to really work hard to have a fair chance to give them a good fight.
But the last article on COVID WHICH compares Modi to Roosevelt was little too much,as it was more commentary and personal manifestation that it turns out this way . There was no factual discussion on it.
So I will say it's a good revision book on India' s current situation and its priorities and upcoming challenges.
1st section is The spirit of democracy talking about gandhi, ambedkar and RSS folks. It was an average one and most of the things have been discussed and debated in the public domain already.
The 2nd section was confronting history with a major focus on Kashmir, article 370 loaded with good anecdotes. The section also touched NRC which was also decent.
The third section a view from within talked about BJP ICONS and the ram mandir andolan, a decent one with some crisp points here and there .
Fourth section Facing the facts was a good one. The article on citizenship act (35 in sequence) was well written and makes a strong case for CAA. EVEN THE essay know your terrorist was a well informed one.
The last section was a tricky one with MOST focus on Israel , with a clear stand taken on Israel .
Then mostly it discussed china , Tibet and Dalai Lama, with discussions how we are played along by the Chinese since decades and accepting the fact we are no match to them currently and need to really work hard to have a fair chance to give them a good fight.
But the last article on COVID WHICH compares Modi to Roosevelt was little too much,as it was more commentary and personal manifestation that it turns out this way . There was no factual discussion on it.
So I will say it's a good revision book on India' s current situation and its priorities and upcoming challenges.
March 16, 2021
I would like to thank the Indic Book Club for providing me with a copy of the book for review. This book is a collection of articles penned by Ram Madhav on different issues ranging from ancient Indian wisdom and traditions to current geopolitical challenges and Covid-19.
Mr. Madhav has been associated with RSS and BJP throughout his public life so it was refreshing to read about his views on different topics such as democracy, NRC, CAA, abrogation of article 370 and 35A as it is rare for someone associated with the party in power to give such candid personal views.
In order to drive his point home, Mr. Madhav quotes numerous anecdotes ranging from ancient epics of Ramayan and Mahabharat to Gandhiji and Nelson Mandela and India and Israel. It is these anecdotes that save the book from being a complex piece of essays and makes it fit for reading by an expert and layman alike.
Another fascinating aspect of this book is how Mr. Madhav is able to throw lights on different facets of the personalities of his predecessors in the organization including Atal Bihari Bajpayee, K. B. Hedgewar, and M.S. Golwalkar.
To sum it up, Mr. Madhav takes you on the ride from ancient India to contemporary times and justifies why India matters and why it should be put first by every Indian.
Mr. Madhav has been associated with RSS and BJP throughout his public life so it was refreshing to read about his views on different topics such as democracy, NRC, CAA, abrogation of article 370 and 35A as it is rare for someone associated with the party in power to give such candid personal views.
In order to drive his point home, Mr. Madhav quotes numerous anecdotes ranging from ancient epics of Ramayan and Mahabharat to Gandhiji and Nelson Mandela and India and Israel. It is these anecdotes that save the book from being a complex piece of essays and makes it fit for reading by an expert and layman alike.
Another fascinating aspect of this book is how Mr. Madhav is able to throw lights on different facets of the personalities of his predecessors in the organization including Atal Bihari Bajpayee, K. B. Hedgewar, and M.S. Golwalkar.
To sum it up, Mr. Madhav takes you on the ride from ancient India to contemporary times and justifies why India matters and why it should be put first by every Indian.
March 16, 2021
First of all a big shout out to @indicacademy and @indicbookclub for giving me an opportunity to read this wonderful book. Normally, would never have chosen this book on my own as it is not one of my favourite genre. But boy, am I glad I got a chance to read this one !!
Because India comes first.... the title says it all. This seems to be the ideology behind all the essays in this book. The author, Ram Madhav ji, had a done a brilliant job with this book.
The book essentially contains small essays, divided into five parts, touching upon various topics ranging from Gandhi n Gandhian principles, to dharma and Indian culture to controversial subjects such as revocation of special status of Jammu Kashmir,CAA, n Assam issues. It also delves on the ideology of hindutva and what it truly means .
The role of India in the post covid world, amidst the changing global scenarios with relation to certain countries like Israel, Pakistan, US and of course China .
To some, this book might seem like a pro BJP campaign but it is nothing but the truth , an eye opener for many of us. It tells us the history which has never been taught in school or college.
I totally loved this book and recommend it to every Indian or for that matter to any person who wants a glimpse of India as it stands today .
Because India comes first.... the title says it all. This seems to be the ideology behind all the essays in this book. The author, Ram Madhav ji, had a done a brilliant job with this book.
The book essentially contains small essays, divided into five parts, touching upon various topics ranging from Gandhi n Gandhian principles, to dharma and Indian culture to controversial subjects such as revocation of special status of Jammu Kashmir,CAA, n Assam issues. It also delves on the ideology of hindutva and what it truly means .
The role of India in the post covid world, amidst the changing global scenarios with relation to certain countries like Israel, Pakistan, US and of course China .
To some, this book might seem like a pro BJP campaign but it is nothing but the truth , an eye opener for many of us. It tells us the history which has never been taught in school or college.
I totally loved this book and recommend it to every Indian or for that matter to any person who wants a glimpse of India as it stands today .
July 27, 2021
This book is about presenting India in its resplendent glory of past and aspirations for the future. The writer Ram Madhav is a well-known politician but the book has established him as an indisputable writer because instead of bearing a political ideology he has dealt with all aspects of this book in perfect balance. This book showcases different shades of history, polity, foreign relationships and in a nutshell, it’s about Indian-ness and its glorious pride. I pay my gratitude to Mr. Ram Madhav who has not only arranged all this knowledge with utter clarity in this book but also strengthened my interest in Indic thoughts and politics. Along with substantial content, the unique style and language of the writer binds us with its flow and gives us deep insight into contemporary topics. The book indeed is a pleasure to read and treasure to digest. The book has reconstructed and redefined my belief in the phrase “Because India Comes First”.
April 20, 2024
• Published by Rupa Publications, the book explores themes of democracy, culture, and foreign policy.
• Ram Madhav, a prominent figure within Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), and a think tank, provides a unique perspective on India's socio-political evolution.
• The book weaves together India's rich cultural heritage with contemporary issues, balancing traditional values with modern challenges.
• Madhav's essays highlight the feminization of strength and courage, India's strategic culture, and constitutional awareness.
• He navigates the political landscape, examining the BJP's ideological moorings and governance ethos under Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
• The book critiques oppositional politics and provides insights into India's foreign policy and strategic imperatives.
• The book is a seminal work for understanding India's political, cultural, and societal fabric.
July 3, 2021
I stumbled across this book accidentally , but it turned out to be one of the fantastic reads. It contains 50 odd essays which can be termed as light reads on varied topics ranging from Indian Freedom Struggle, Independence, Constitution, Emergency, the Kashmir struggle, as well as global topics such as foreign affairs, our challenges with Pakistan and China and so on . Through concise essays, the book attempts to give a background to the reader in one place on a lot of topics of national and international relevance. I’m glad I read this book
May 8, 2021
An Indic view point to international and internal policies of India put in short crisp chapters. Ram Madhav Ji goes beyond writing a mere political book, to give the reader's a chance to ponder on the questions and reach their own conclusions based on facts. A must read for someone who wants to understand India and her potential in a post-Covid world order.
March 10, 2023
Fantastic collection of articles and ideas from Ram Madhavji
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews