3.5 stars
Lily is busier than ever running her tea shop and cooking breakfast for her grandmother's B&B guests. Grandma Rose is eager for Lily to meet her old friend Sandra from Iowa and Sandra's granddaughter Heather. They're on the Cape for a family reunion. Since Heather married, moved to New York and became a wealthy widow, they haven't seen much of each other. When unexpected guests arrive, Heather's in-laws, the you-know-what hits the fan when they all start complaining and yelling. When Heather's brother-in-law Ed dies after eating at Tea By the Sea, the police suspect it was something he ate or drank and once again have to close the shop and go through everything. Lily is horrified and terrified the incident will negatively affect her business. Bernie is certain it was murder as everyone ate the same thing and no one else got sick. Only Ed. He was the only one to drink some kind of healthy herbal tea conconction. Someone had to have poisoned Ed but how could they have done so in plain sight of everyone? It had to have been one of the family members. Bernie sets out to investigate the family's financial dealings and pushes Lily to interview suspects. It's just like a novel! Poor Lily really doesn't want to get involved but if it helps the police wrap things up sooner, the sooner she can open her business again. When Lily, Bernie and Rose are nearly killed, they know they must be close but they don't have a clue! Who could have done such a horrible deed?
I liked this mystery much better than the previous one but I still didn't love it. The mystery part is excellent. The clues weren't there pointing the way and I never guessed. I didn't see the twist coming either. The thought crossed my mind that a certain character was the murderer but then I thought "Oh guess not." I was certain it was someone obvious for obvious reasons. I almost never get distracted by red herrings like that wow!
Cozy wise, this story is a bit lacking. I LOVE tea! I love scones, I love clotted cream and jam on my scones, I love pastries... I do not love Cape Cod so you would think this barely there Cape Cod locale would appeal to me. It doesn't because I know the Cape well enough not to get a Cape Cod vibe. My Cape smells like low tide, shellfish and pollution. My Cape has sandy dunes, beach grass, seagulls eating trash, sandbars for miles at low tide, boats, diging for clams, lobsters, stuffies, clam bakes, salt water taffy and always always sand everywhere! Miraculously there's NO sand in Victoria-On-Sea. The only thing Cape Cod to me, which is still generic, is going to the candy shop in town for ice cream. My siblings, cousins and I all have happy memories of the penny candy store. Never tea rooms. I've never even passed by a tea room but I Googled and there are a few. I would have placed Lily's tea room at a historic inn not adjacent to a Victorian house turned B&B.
The other thing I don't like about the story is the characters. They're very flat and unrealistic. Lily is Ok but she's kindof a pushover. She finally loses her cool a bit in this book with Bernie but mostly she lets everyone else tell her what to do. I appreciate how hard she works though and how dedicated she is to her business. Bernie annoys the heck out of me! She is obnoxious as all get out. She comes into her best friend's place of business- a business Lily needs to SELL food to survive- and proceeds to stand around the kitchen eating the food meant for paying customers and prevents actual employees from doing their actual jobs. She also hangs around the B&B kitchen eating food meant for paying guests, then offers said food to the police without asking or checking to see if there's any more food left! Bernie lacks an understanding of how hard Lily has to work to stay afloat. She thinks Lily should just be able to take off any time she wants to go on a hare-brained fishing for clues expedition. Bernie changes her mind about her book 18 times a day based on whatever is happening. Lily does tell her to quit it and come up with an outline. Why doesn't she plan a series? She can have her romance be a slow burn, have zany unrealistic adventures throughout multiple books each with a different plot. She could plot more books and not a series and cover all her ideas. PICK ONE to start with and set the ball rolling. Bernie's chronic procrastination is going to bite her on the butt some day soon. At least she seems to be getting along better with Matt even if she won't date him yet.
Rose also annoys me. She's awful to her granddaughter and seems to prefer Bernie. Rose also prefers sleeping in, gossipping with Edna and listening in on police investigations more than she likes work. She's toned down a bit in this book since her friend is visiting. I think she doesn't want to scare off her friend by being too caustic and rude. Simon is a prince! He jumps in to help out when Lily needs him, no questions asked, no favors needed, he just does it. They have an easy relationship with witty banter now. I agree with Lily that she doesn't have time for a summer fling but I bet he sticks around. Edna is toned down too. She likes to gossip but this time her gossip is helpful and useful. She knows she's contributing to the investigation and promises not to reveal anything they tell her to her husband, the newspaper editor. Cheryl and Marybeth, Lily's only two employees, work nearly as hard as Lily. Marybeth has an accident in this one and it seems pretty serious but it's never fully addresses after the fact. I like her. She and her mom have a great relationship. They trade barbs but they have a bond that shows they love each other, unlike the McHenry clan.
The police are awful. Detective Chuck Williams is a moron and should have been sacked for bungling the last case. He shouldn't have even been involved in the first place. He's lazy, stupid and incompetent. Detective Amy Raymond is a strong, intellgent woman. She's tough but willing to keep an open mind and listen to what citizens have to tell her. She respects Lily and doesn't dismiss Lily's concerns the way Williams does. If he doesn't get fired after this I will be disgusted.
There are SOOO many new characters. Rose's friend Sandra is the matriarch of a large clan. She's a wealthy Iowan on the board of many charities and non-profits. She and Rose go way back to their early married days but haven't seen each other since Rose's husband died and she moved to Cape Cod. Sandra seems nice. She's a loving grandmother but also concerned for the behavior of her great-grandchildren who are out of control. Sandra is closest to her granddaughter Heather. Heather is a young widow. Her husband invented something with computers and made a fortune but he was promptly killed by a taxi leaving Heather a wealthy widow. Heather doesn't seem to miss him too much. Bernie thinks Heather enjoys showing off her wealth and I agree. She mentions money a lot, her NYC connections and wears designer clothing. Still, she must be lonely. Her parents and brother didn't approve of her marriage to a much older man and only her grandmother stood by her. Heather proves to be kind and generous to her extended family, even inviting her late husband's brother and his wife to the family reunion.
Sandra's children are grown and still act like teenagers. Her son Brian doesn't seem to appreciate the family reunion at all. He's non-confrontational but does have opinions about what he wants to do and who is going to pay for it. His wife Darlene is a gold digger and mooches off Heather. Darlene is kind of whiny and not very pleasant. Their son Lewis is a terrible father who has spoiled his son. He is cranky and always complaining. His wife Julie-Anne is toxic. She's absolutely horrid. Julie-Anne is unnecessary cruel, taunting her enemy. She's so spoiled she wants what she wants and gets what she wants. She is also mooching off Heather's money. She has a past with Ed, Heather's brother-in-law, and Sandra won't gossip but it's obvious these two had a relationship and he chose to marry Tricia, who is the nicest of the bunch. Ed is one of those HAW-HAW men who ignores the advice of his doctor he doesn't like, thinks he knows best and is an air dreamer. Tricia is lovely though. I feel so bad for her when her husband dies and she's left alone without friends or family. Everyone is horrid to her when all she can do is lie in bed and cry. I don't believe she killed her own husband but she had the means-the bag with the gross grassy tea was in her purse! I don't want her to be the killer. She seems so nice.
Lewis's daughter Amanda is a typical teen, needing her phone glues to her face or ear 24/7. She's your average eye rolling, like OMG get me out of this place teen. Her brother, Tyler, is horrid. He's spoiled, selfish, stupid and doesn't learn from his mistakes. He ignores his father with a smirk because his awful mother smothers and spoils him. I don't think either of them murdered Ed though. They're too self-absorbed.
So who did kill Ed?
I might read the third book. I might save it for summer or next time I visit the Cape and see if being there helps me feel the setting more. I'd love to go to afternoon tea instead of being forced to look at and smell seafood and grilled meat. (There's always pasta though which I do love but I get enough of that at home.)
There are a couple of recipes included. You can guess how the author spent the COVID quarantine period of 2020!