Appreciate the effort, but wasn't terribly useful.
The first part of the book is personal history -- how two people overcame difficulties to get into the Ivy League. It is interesting to see that in both cases the key to admission seemed to be to build up years of working very hard and being very determined -- and to have the audacity and aggressiveness to push the admissions office to take them.
The second part of the book is a long list of habits, tricks, strategies, and advice. I thought it was a little too directing -- the whole point of the first part of the book was that everyone does things differently, but the second half had to kind of be "do it our way!" or you don't really have a book. I also didn't care much for how much of the advice was about how to hit the checkpoints without doing the work. To be clear, the authors value learning for its own sake, but they clearly learned from their years in school that learning for the sake of a teacher is a fool's game, and gaming the system is perfectly acceptable. I don't disagree with that, but I'm not sure why you would be strive to enter a system you don't value -- why go to Brown just to work to get the grades without doing the work? Why not spend your time on something else?
It was interesting to pair this with some of what "Excellent Sheep" detailed -- the author there says that getting into an Ivy League school is difficult, but once you are there it is almost impossible to fail a class. Everyone expects at least an A- in every course, there is ridiculously high grade inflation, you don't have to work hard at all to pass a class. I don't know if that's true, but he makes an impressive case for it being so, and Learning Outside the Lines certainly backs that up -- much of the advice, for example, is about how to not read the assigned books.
Again, I'm not criticizing, just wondering why the authors went so far and no farther. Why, for example, be so justifiably disgusted with the school system but not recommend or discuss home schooling? Why disdain college but write a book about how to get into the most competitive schools and graduate? And I wonder, did they pay the $50,000 a year tuition in full for the privilege of attending a school they did not respect? Could they not have done more with their resources?
In any case, not a bad book to read, gives interesting perspectives and handy tips. There is a decent amount of cussing and other content that makes it not a good choice for a younger child to read alone, probably -- which is too bad, because I can see adolescents and upper elementary kids getting a lot out of the personal stories. Also, they discuss their youth organization, which is a good thing.