What do you think?
Rate this book
Amina's Voice #1
Amina's Voice
Goodreads Choice Award
Nominee for Readers' Favorite Middle Grade & Children's (2017)Amina has never been comfortable in the spotlight. She is happy just hanging out with her best friend, Soojin. Except now that she’s in middle school everything feels different. Soojin is suddenly hanging out with Emily, one of the “cool” girls in the class, and even talking about changing her name to something more “American.” Does Amina need to start changing too? Or hiding who she is to fit in? While Amina grapples with these questions, she is devastated when her local mosque is vandalized.
197 pages, Hardcover
First published March 14, 2017
501 people are currently reading
13572 people want to read
About the author
Hena Khan
51 books527 followersHena Khan writes books in a multitude of formats, including picture books, middle grade fiction, pick-your-path adventures, and graphic novels. Her stories are often centered around community, friendship, and family, and draw from her own experiences and culture. Hena’s novels include AMINA'S VOICE, MORE TO THE STORY, and DRAWING DEENA. She is the author of the Zayd Saleem Chasing the Dream, Zara’s Rules, and Super You! series. Hena’s picture books include GOLDEN DOMES AND SILVER LANTERNS, UNDER MY HIJAB, and IT'S RAMADAN, CURIOUS GEORGE, among others.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,598 reviews
October 6, 2017
Amina is a Pakistani-American Muslim girl who longs to find the courage to share her vocal talent with others and who struggles to remain loyal to her family’s culture and customs.
Though the opening pages identify Amina’s interest in overcoming her fear of singing in front of others, her driving want fades into the background as she tackles problems concerning her best friend, Soojin. Shortly thereafter, the prospect of a visiting uncle complicates her life further, followed by parental expectation that she participate in a forthcoming Quran competition. It’s a significant number of storylines to tackle in such a short middle-grade novel, and the narrative subsequently suffers from a lack of depth.
Nonetheless, Khan tackles several issues relevant to many young readers. Amina’s best friend, Soojin, is Korean. One of many things they have in common is their culture being mocked or misunderstood.
Like that time [Emily] pinched her nose and squealed while Julie said something smelled like it had died when Soojin brought kimchee in her lunch.
In addition to grappling with feelings of jealousy over Soojin’s decision to be friends with Emily, Amina is bothered by Soojin’s interest in changing her name to Susan once she and her parents become American citizens.
Don’t you like being Soojin?” I asked my best friend in a low voice, leaning across the table to make it harder for Emily to hear. “You’ve been Soojin your whole life. Aren’t you used to it?” [. . .]
“Really, Amina? I thought you, at least, would understand what it’s like to have people mess up your name every single day.” Soojin lets out her sigh again.
Soojin’s decision to pick a new name leads Amina to question her own identity. Should she change too? What adjustments can she make to better fit in at school?
Finally, when tragedy strikes her community in the form of a hate crime enacted on the local mosque, readers get a first-hand look at the devastation and pain caused by such thoughtless acts.
Amina’s fear of public singing returns shortly before the story concludes, providing a weak yet sufficient conclusion to her want identified in the book’s opening pages.
Amina’s Voice is a noteworthy contribution to children’s literature because it features a Muslim girl as its lead protagonist, but the overall story and simplistic writing leave much to be desired.
-
Special thanks to Salaam Reads for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Though the opening pages identify Amina’s interest in overcoming her fear of singing in front of others, her driving want fades into the background as she tackles problems concerning her best friend, Soojin. Shortly thereafter, the prospect of a visiting uncle complicates her life further, followed by parental expectation that she participate in a forthcoming Quran competition. It’s a significant number of storylines to tackle in such a short middle-grade novel, and the narrative subsequently suffers from a lack of depth.
Nonetheless, Khan tackles several issues relevant to many young readers. Amina’s best friend, Soojin, is Korean. One of many things they have in common is their culture being mocked or misunderstood.
Like that time [Emily] pinched her nose and squealed while Julie said something smelled like it had died when Soojin brought kimchee in her lunch.
In addition to grappling with feelings of jealousy over Soojin’s decision to be friends with Emily, Amina is bothered by Soojin’s interest in changing her name to Susan once she and her parents become American citizens.
Don’t you like being Soojin?” I asked my best friend in a low voice, leaning across the table to make it harder for Emily to hear. “You’ve been Soojin your whole life. Aren’t you used to it?” [. . .]
“Really, Amina? I thought you, at least, would understand what it’s like to have people mess up your name every single day.” Soojin lets out her sigh again.
Soojin’s decision to pick a new name leads Amina to question her own identity. Should she change too? What adjustments can she make to better fit in at school?
Finally, when tragedy strikes her community in the form of a hate crime enacted on the local mosque, readers get a first-hand look at the devastation and pain caused by such thoughtless acts.
Amina’s fear of public singing returns shortly before the story concludes, providing a weak yet sufficient conclusion to her want identified in the book’s opening pages.
Amina’s Voice is a noteworthy contribution to children’s literature because it features a Muslim girl as its lead protagonist, but the overall story and simplistic writing leave much to be desired.
-
Special thanks to Salaam Reads for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
July 31, 2020
Books like Amina's Voice are the reason why I started reading diverse middle-grade books. There is something so delightful and special about these books that capture the innocence, optimism, and wonder of children and their stories.
It follows young Amina Khokar, a Pakistani-American girl who lives with her parents and older brother in Milkauwee. Having just started middle school, Amina begins to feel that the things around her are changing, leaving her feeling a little lost and unsure of everything. Her best friend may not be her best friend anymore, her uncle from Pakistan is visiting, her older brother Mustafa is starting to enter the tumultuous period of 'independence', Amina may have to face her fear of performing in public with the upcoming Qu'ran reciting competition (that her parents entered her in without her knowing!) and the upcoming concert that Amina knows she'll sing amazingly in if her worries weren't in the way.
The story in Amina's Voice is simple, but that's what made it so utterly charming and lovely. Being twelve can be a rough time, especially when things are changing, and I adored Khan's portrayal of Amina's struggles: small, quiet, but absolutely significant. The explorations of friendships, family, growing up and faith were fantastic and earnest. Even though I'm a decade older than Amina, Khan's flawless writing transported me back to a time where I was twelve, making me empathize and connect deeply with Amina.
But, this book wasn't written for me; Amina's Voice is for young readers, and I'm pleased to say that this book is perfect for them and it makes me happy knowing that this book exists for young Muslim Pakistani readers. However, what anchors the story from the get-go is Amina herself; I utterly adored her. Compassionate, thoughtful, and conscientious, Amina was a lovely protagonist and a genuine pleasure to read about, and I'm certain many others will love her just as much as I did.
At the story's very core, Amina's Voice is about being true to oneself. There is a particularly heartbreaking scene towards the end of the book, and seeing it through the eyes of the young girl made it all the more devastating. However, the story ends far from a sad note. Instead, the ending of the book offers a hopeful message that emphasizes the importance of community, friendships, and working together to become stronger. It is a beautiful message, one that is hopeful, teaches meaningful lessons, and illustrates the beauty of bravery. An absolutely beautiful middle grade book, and I cannot recommend it enough.
Rating: 4.5 / 5 (rounded up to 5)
-
Is this book for you?
Premise in a sentence: A young Pakistani-American girl faces changes and her anxieties in a sweet middle-grade novel about bravery and community.
Perfect for: readers new to middle grade novels, and if you're in need of something lighthearted that also touches on important topics.
Genre: Middle grade, contemporary
Recommended? Absolutely! ❤️
-
This review and other book reviews can be found on my book blog, Read, Think, Ponder!
It follows young Amina Khokar, a Pakistani-American girl who lives with her parents and older brother in Milkauwee. Having just started middle school, Amina begins to feel that the things around her are changing, leaving her feeling a little lost and unsure of everything. Her best friend may not be her best friend anymore, her uncle from Pakistan is visiting, her older brother Mustafa is starting to enter the tumultuous period of 'independence', Amina may have to face her fear of performing in public with the upcoming Qu'ran reciting competition (that her parents entered her in without her knowing!) and the upcoming concert that Amina knows she'll sing amazingly in if her worries weren't in the way.
This Quran competition is something I want nothing to do with. I say a quick prayer that Mama wasn't paying attention and that she won't sign me up as everyone gets up and stands in neat rows.
The story in Amina's Voice is simple, but that's what made it so utterly charming and lovely. Being twelve can be a rough time, especially when things are changing, and I adored Khan's portrayal of Amina's struggles: small, quiet, but absolutely significant. The explorations of friendships, family, growing up and faith were fantastic and earnest. Even though I'm a decade older than Amina, Khan's flawless writing transported me back to a time where I was twelve, making me empathize and connect deeply with Amina.
But, this book wasn't written for me; Amina's Voice is for young readers, and I'm pleased to say that this book is perfect for them and it makes me happy knowing that this book exists for young Muslim Pakistani readers. However, what anchors the story from the get-go is Amina herself; I utterly adored her. Compassionate, thoughtful, and conscientious, Amina was a lovely protagonist and a genuine pleasure to read about, and I'm certain many others will love her just as much as I did.
At the story's very core, Amina's Voice is about being true to oneself. There is a particularly heartbreaking scene towards the end of the book, and seeing it through the eyes of the young girl made it all the more devastating. However, the story ends far from a sad note. Instead, the ending of the book offers a hopeful message that emphasizes the importance of community, friendships, and working together to become stronger. It is a beautiful message, one that is hopeful, teaches meaningful lessons, and illustrates the beauty of bravery. An absolutely beautiful middle grade book, and I cannot recommend it enough.
Rating: 4.5 / 5 (rounded up to 5)
-
Is this book for you?
Premise in a sentence: A young Pakistani-American girl faces changes and her anxieties in a sweet middle-grade novel about bravery and community.
Perfect for: readers new to middle grade novels, and if you're in need of something lighthearted that also touches on important topics.
Genre: Middle grade, contemporary
Recommended? Absolutely! ❤️
-
This review and other book reviews can be found on my book blog, Read, Think, Ponder!
April 29, 2018
If middle-grade fiction is your thing, don’t forget to check this book out. It is diverse - has a Muslim protagonist - and it is also one of those few books that doesn’t feature a romance and actually pulls it off.
Amina is a Pakistani-American, who lives in Milwaukee with her parents and her brother. She is a talented singer, but never got on stage after a disastrous stage-fright incident in her second grade. Her best friend Soojin’s new attitude, and a new friendly addition to their cafeteria table, makes Amina insecure. With the new background of middle-school, Amina has to endure the test of friendship, an horrifying event at her community center, and also explore her faith in an unwelcoming place she calls her home.
Pros -
• The writing style and narration were comparably good, than the other diverse books out there. Hena Khan’s voice is lucid and easy to read, which made the book even better.
• The exploration of cultural differences and morals were done without a note of criticism, or cynicism. Amina is comfortable in her American culture, but she doesn’t go on about how her Pakistani parents are naïve and conservative.
• Amina’s family was very relatable. I loved that Hena Khan decided to show the inner aspects of a Muslim family. Amina’s relationship with her parents, and her brother felt very close to home.
• The essence of a middle-grader and her insecurities were very well captured. Hena Khan definitely understands perspective, and she makes sure to let her readers live along with her character.
• Her concerns about people not getting her name right, Super relatable!!
• Amina’s mother is THE BEST.
• And yeah, Bollywood reference. Or more specifically, KUCH KUCH HOTA HAI reference! AAAAHHHH!!! It totally made my day.
Cons -
So there was this important part of the story, about Amina and her music. Hena Khan throws light on the acceptance of music in Islam, which is, like, super important. But I’m not sure she addressed it in a proper way. Like, yeah, music is deemed haram generally, that is, unacceptable in Islam. Most people don’t buy into it because many sources states that music was practiced in the Prophet’s time. While others say that the Quran has stated music as unnecessary provocation and waste of time. None of the cited sources are actually found to be reliable. But the novel states that music is acceptable, and a singer’s talent should be appreciated. Now, I am not against that part, but I wanted the book to let the reader’s choose whether or not they want to believe whatever she says, rather than making a choice themselves. Because, a book is a big influence on a person’s life, so any Muslim reading the book might think that it is completely fine to listen to music and tempted to do it even if they hadn’t been into songs earlier. Like, I was super into songs sometime back, but when I learned that music might be haram, I stopped listening to it, not wanting to risk it, but now the book tells me otherwise. I know, this is completely up to the person and his belief, but a book just cannot simply make its own laws on the behalf of religion.
Other than that, the book was completely enjoyable. It is important, and also it doesn’t misinterpret terrorism and islamophobia.
Overall, this book provides a good look into the life of a normal Muslim family, a middle-grader trying to overcome her fears, and the importance of community, friendships and unity. Totally recommended.
Amina is a Pakistani-American, who lives in Milwaukee with her parents and her brother. She is a talented singer, but never got on stage after a disastrous stage-fright incident in her second grade. Her best friend Soojin’s new attitude, and a new friendly addition to their cafeteria table, makes Amina insecure. With the new background of middle-school, Amina has to endure the test of friendship, an horrifying event at her community center, and also explore her faith in an unwelcoming place she calls her home.
Pros -
• The writing style and narration were comparably good, than the other diverse books out there. Hena Khan’s voice is lucid and easy to read, which made the book even better.
• The exploration of cultural differences and morals were done without a note of criticism, or cynicism. Amina is comfortable in her American culture, but she doesn’t go on about how her Pakistani parents are naïve and conservative.
“Basketball?” Baba frowns. “No, no. Why basketball? Timothy next door tells me his son is captain of the chess team. You should do that.
• Amina’s family was very relatable. I loved that Hena Khan decided to show the inner aspects of a Muslim family. Amina’s relationship with her parents, and her brother felt very close to home.
“I kind of want to tell him that I’m proud of him for making the team. And I wish he had been at dinner last night. But I don’t. We don’t say stuff like that to each other.”
• The essence of a middle-grader and her insecurities were very well captured. Hena Khan definitely understands perspective, and she makes sure to let her readers live along with her character.
“Because even though I don’t know why, something about Soojin wanting to drop her name makes me worry that I might be next.”
• Her concerns about people not getting her name right, Super relatable!!
• Amina’s mother is THE BEST.
• And yeah, Bollywood reference. Or more specifically, KUCH KUCH HOTA HAI reference! AAAAHHHH!!! It totally made my day.
Cons -
So there was this important part of the story, about Amina and her music. Hena Khan throws light on the acceptance of music in Islam, which is, like, super important. But I’m not sure she addressed it in a proper way. Like, yeah, music is deemed haram generally, that is, unacceptable in Islam. Most people don’t buy into it because many sources states that music was practiced in the Prophet’s time. While others say that the Quran has stated music as unnecessary provocation and waste of time. None of the cited sources are actually found to be reliable. But the novel states that music is acceptable, and a singer’s talent should be appreciated. Now, I am not against that part, but I wanted the book to let the reader’s choose whether or not they want to believe whatever she says, rather than making a choice themselves. Because, a book is a big influence on a person’s life, so any Muslim reading the book might think that it is completely fine to listen to music and tempted to do it even if they hadn’t been into songs earlier. Like, I was super into songs sometime back, but when I learned that music might be haram, I stopped listening to it, not wanting to risk it, but now the book tells me otherwise. I know, this is completely up to the person and his belief, but a book just cannot simply make its own laws on the behalf of religion.
Other than that, the book was completely enjoyable. It is important, and also it doesn’t misinterpret terrorism and islamophobia.
Overall, this book provides a good look into the life of a normal Muslim family, a middle-grader trying to overcome her fears, and the importance of community, friendships and unity. Totally recommended.
January 15, 2022
A feel-good middle grade story about growing up, learning life lessons and overcoming weaknesses.
It's the story about Amina who struggles with stage fright and her biggest dream is to become a great singer.
She has some unpleasant memories which made the situation worse. So she tried to remain in the shadows as much as possible when it comes to anything about any performance.
I appreciated the multicultural representation of the characters, talk about being immigrants and culture differences.
The writing highlights accurately the friendship dynamics of this age group and how parents keep comparing, have unrealistic expectations and putting their kids under pressure all the time. (It gets tiring, parents. It's never a good thing when you do these things. It makes things worse instead.)
The story gives a proper glimpse of family bonds, a different education system from what the immigrants used to know or see, growing up and being confused about everything that's changing in the lives of the young characters.
It's all about giving people a chance, more importantly giving ourselves a chance.
I didn't like because even when the main character is struggling everyday, she manages to judge her peers rather unfairly.
I just wish I liked the writing more. I feel the characters lacked depth as I went on reading. I wish it wasn't. Sometimes I felt like I was listening to a childish monologue here and there. And I wish the story didn't sound like a story I have read before.
Content warning for racist remarks and threats.
I would still say it's a good book for beginners. For me, it needed to be a little more convincing.
I love the cover. It feels like a hug.
It's the story about Amina who struggles with stage fright and her biggest dream is to become a great singer.
She has some unpleasant memories which made the situation worse. So she tried to remain in the shadows as much as possible when it comes to anything about any performance.
I appreciated the multicultural representation of the characters, talk about being immigrants and culture differences.
The writing highlights accurately the friendship dynamics of this age group and how parents keep comparing, have unrealistic expectations and putting their kids under pressure all the time. (It gets tiring, parents. It's never a good thing when you do these things. It makes things worse instead.)
The story gives a proper glimpse of family bonds, a different education system from what the immigrants used to know or see, growing up and being confused about everything that's changing in the lives of the young characters.
It's all about giving people a chance, more importantly giving ourselves a chance.
I didn't like because even when the main character is struggling everyday, she manages to judge her peers rather unfairly.
I just wish I liked the writing more. I feel the characters lacked depth as I went on reading. I wish it wasn't. Sometimes I felt like I was listening to a childish monologue here and there. And I wish the story didn't sound like a story I have read before.
Content warning for racist remarks and threats.
I would still say it's a good book for beginners. For me, it needed to be a little more convincing.
I love the cover. It feels like a hug.
May 21, 2020
if you see me deleting old ratings and reviews on the tl... blame this book for giving me a rating crisis
// buddy read with auntie
July 3, 2017
Middle Grade has always been, and will always be one of my favorite genres. The books are so pure, quite easy to get through, and always make me smile. Amina’s Voice isn’t any different.
I listened to this book as an audiobook, and I finished it in 2 days. It was incredible. I usually don’t tend to love audiobooks, I’m not even sure why, but the narration was perfect and really brought the story to life.
As for the story itself, it was quite amazing. Amina, our main character, has to deal with quite a lot, like her feeling like everything around her is changing and she might lose her best friend, her uncle from Pakistan coming to visit and the upcoming Quran competition that she’s participating in, and that she’s incredibly nervous about. It’s all quite simple, but it’s written in such a lovely and touching way that you can’t help but fall in love with it.
I felt the same about the characters, because I adored every single one of them. Amina is such a compassionate and gentle girl who tends to worry a lot, and I really felt for her. I also loved seeing her interact with her family, and especially her parents, with whom she has a very great relationship. I also really enjoyed seeing her interactions with her brother, because while her brother is really starting to turn into a teenager and tries to be cool, he still has some very soft moments when he’s around his sister.
Something that I also really appreciated about this book is that it really shows the importance of community after a (very relevant in today’s society) tragedy strikes. Seeing how everyone comes together and supports each other made me so happy that I started crying, and I really loved how hopeful the message of the book is.
Amina’s voice is a very important and hopeful book, and I really hope a lot more people are going to pick it up. They sure won’t regret it.
I listened to this book as an audiobook, and I finished it in 2 days. It was incredible. I usually don’t tend to love audiobooks, I’m not even sure why, but the narration was perfect and really brought the story to life.
As for the story itself, it was quite amazing. Amina, our main character, has to deal with quite a lot, like her feeling like everything around her is changing and she might lose her best friend, her uncle from Pakistan coming to visit and the upcoming Quran competition that she’s participating in, and that she’s incredibly nervous about. It’s all quite simple, but it’s written in such a lovely and touching way that you can’t help but fall in love with it.
I felt the same about the characters, because I adored every single one of them. Amina is such a compassionate and gentle girl who tends to worry a lot, and I really felt for her. I also loved seeing her interact with her family, and especially her parents, with whom she has a very great relationship. I also really enjoyed seeing her interactions with her brother, because while her brother is really starting to turn into a teenager and tries to be cool, he still has some very soft moments when he’s around his sister.
Something that I also really appreciated about this book is that it really shows the importance of community after a (very relevant in today’s society) tragedy strikes. Seeing how everyone comes together and supports each other made me so happy that I started crying, and I really loved how hopeful the message of the book is.
Amina’s voice is a very important and hopeful book, and I really hope a lot more people are going to pick it up. They sure won’t regret it.
May 21, 2020
Book 12 completed for #RamadanReadathon
Read
January 2, 2017Sweet, warm and reassuring - the right sort of story to start off 2017 with. There were several little moments that made me feel like I was reading about my own childhood, from Amina's sweet little prayer to be able to pronounce the "big haa" in Qu'ran classes properly (the struggle is real) to the huge suitcase of gifts from cousins Amina hasn't seen in person for years that her uncle lugs over to the United States. The discussion of Islamophobia is heartfelt and well done and echoes, almost painfully, how it feels to be in your own country and be reminded just how Other you are perceived and treated.
I am so honored to be part of Salaam Reads with a light like Hena, and I am glad that even if I didn't get to read this story as a kid, there are other kids who are going to be reading this in March and smiling and feeling warm inside.
I am so honored to be part of Salaam Reads with a light like Hena, and I am glad that even if I didn't get to read this story as a kid, there are other kids who are going to be reading this in March and smiling and feeling warm inside.
June 25, 2018
Mini review:
DNF
GR Ultimate Summer Reading Challenge: Diversify Yourself.
This book was recommended to me by my dear GR friend Fuzaila! Click on her name to read her review.
I did actually hear about this book last year. For some reason I had no idea what it was about. I think it just got buried in the hype of other releases. After reading Fuzalia's review I knew I had to try it! I was happy to see that my library had a copy. Unfortunately it wasn't for me.
The first few pages were really good! I could connect to Amina's situation. As I read on the writing style became annoying. Not sure what happened. It stopped keeping my interest. I couldn't find anything interesting about the book or the characters.
This was definitely a personal thing. I still recommend.
DNF
GR Ultimate Summer Reading Challenge: Diversify Yourself.
This book was recommended to me by my dear GR friend Fuzaila! Click on her name to read her review.
I did actually hear about this book last year. For some reason I had no idea what it was about. I think it just got buried in the hype of other releases. After reading Fuzalia's review I knew I had to try it! I was happy to see that my library had a copy. Unfortunately it wasn't for me.
The first few pages were really good! I could connect to Amina's situation. As I read on the writing style became annoying. Not sure what happened. It stopped keeping my interest. I couldn't find anything interesting about the book or the characters.
This was definitely a personal thing. I still recommend.
November 22, 2020
It helps me to listen to books like this on audio. In this case, Soneela Nankani reads Amina's story with perfect pitch and transports the reader/listener into her world. Set in Milwaukee, the book depicts a community that is ethnically inclusive. Yet, as a part of the story, a hate crime is committed against the Muslim community at their place of worship. This horrifying crime is the backdrop for cooperation among the different ethnic groups to heal and rebuild. I am looking forward to reading the sequel: 'Amina's Song.' Readers who like this title will also enjoy 'Other Words For Home' by Jasmine Warga.
January 29, 2018
"I wanted to say, 'But I do want to sing. More than anything.' But I didn't."
(p.109)
"After the first few measures, I forget everything for a moment and feel whole again, in spite of what happened earlier in the day. I play as if no one is listening, basking in the richness of sound."
(p. 170)
Amina has a wonderful singing voice, but she is a bit too shy to share it. That is, until she finds that she does want to and can express her gift, but only after feeling unsure of herself, her most important friendship, her values, and her place in the community after something terrible happens. And when she does find her place, and her voice, it'll bring tears to your eyes.
(p.109)
"After the first few measures, I forget everything for a moment and feel whole again, in spite of what happened earlier in the day. I play as if no one is listening, basking in the richness of sound."
(p. 170)
Amina has a wonderful singing voice, but she is a bit too shy to share it. That is, until she finds that she does want to and can express her gift, but only after feeling unsure of herself, her most important friendship, her values, and her place in the community after something terrible happens. And when she does find her place, and her voice, it'll bring tears to your eyes.
July 5, 2020
I really liked this one!! It was clearly written for a younger reader who does not quite know their religion yet and needs more explanation to what their God means when they say certain things in scripture. I learned a lot about people in Pakistan. Perfect for people who want diverse reads.
April 26, 2022
I can see why this book has such firm champions among the librarians of kid lit. This is a perfect modern middle grade, dealing with the new complexities of friendships and family relationships when middle school comes along and shakes things up. It also deals with politics, lightly, and a hate crime, but it does it in a way that is perfect for the young middle grade reader. I love shy Amina, and I really felt for her with her stage fright and her uncertainty in navigating the changes to her world.
April 5, 2023
A sweet, middlegrade story of a Pakistani-American girl, Amina, who is trying to overcome her insecurities about being in the spotlight, being a good friend, and finding the right balance between her roots and the American life. This made for a nice read during Ramadan, and is especially relevant in today's times.
Eid Mubarak!
December 6, 2020
Because even though I don’t know why, something about Soojin wanting to drop her name makes me worry that I might be next.
This was such a delightful read. I forgot how I love reading middle grade books. Full review to come.
This was such a delightful read. I forgot how I love reading middle grade books. Full review to come.
November 12, 2019
4.5* A heartfelt story of family, friendship, faith and finding your voice.
TW: Islamophobia, racism, hate crime.
TW: Islamophobia, racism, hate crime.
September 9, 2017
*This may qualify as Unpopular opinion*
A sweet and heartfelt story with a great cast of diverse characters. I'm spiritual but not religious so the parts with the church felt a bit alien to me *shrugs* I did love the sense of community though and how everyone supported each other, coming together when it mattered.
The food mentioned was interesting, and some of it I would to try (not much of a cook though haha) if I got the chance to.
The story moves quickly and is easy to get into, but the plot at times felt a bit lacking and uneven in some areas and rushed a bit in others. Would have loved to see some more things fleshed out.
The things I was more interested in seemed to be pushed into the background while the stuff I was 'meh' on took center stage.
Some things did surprise me in a pleasant though with one character despite one instance .
Treatment of the brother had me wanting to shake the parents a couple times.
I'm glad more diverse books are coming out into the market these days, books like these are important to get into kid's hands.
Overall, I'm glad I read it... just wished I could have loved it more.
A sweet and heartfelt story with a great cast of diverse characters. I'm spiritual but not religious so the parts with the church felt a bit alien to me *shrugs* I did love the sense of community though and how everyone supported each other, coming together when it mattered.
The food mentioned was interesting, and some of it I would to try (not much of a cook though haha) if I got the chance to.
The story moves quickly and is easy to get into, but the plot at times felt a bit lacking and uneven in some areas and rushed a bit in others. Would have loved to see some more things fleshed out.
The things I was more interested in seemed to be pushed into the background while the stuff I was 'meh' on took center stage.
Some things did surprise me in a pleasant though with one character despite one instance .
Treatment of the brother had me wanting to shake the parents a couple times.
I'm glad more diverse books are coming out into the market these days, books like these are important to get into kid's hands.
Overall, I'm glad I read it... just wished I could have loved it more.
May 12, 2020
this was adorable and heartwarming and put a huge smile on my face :) diverse middle grade books like this one are the absolute best and never fail to make me happy.
February 22, 2021
I read Amina's Voice over the last week in preparation of second book in the series, Amina's Song. In this sweet first book, readers get an opportunity to meet a Pakistani-American girl named Amina Khokar and gain an understanding of what her life is like growing up Muslim in the United States. While it's obvious that Amina has a beautiful voice and is talented as a pianist, she's terribly shy and gets nervous about performing in front of anyone. She faces the normal trials of middle school, including her best friend becoming friends with the former "mean girl" in their class. Meanwhile, at home, her uncle is visiting from Pakistan and Amina discovers the vastly different interpretations of their holy scriptures.
We witness Islamophobia in big and small ways, including the terrible event in which their beloved mosque is vandalized and burned. However, the community comes through in supporting their Muslim neighbors by searching for the criminals and offering support in cleaning and rebuilding. The family interaction was simply beautiful and the description of foods and cooking will have readers' mouths watering! Over the course of the story, Amina sees her father taking a stand for his beliefs and this helps empower Amina. And at the very end, we're left wondering if Amina's family will take a trip to visit the rest of their family in Pakistan. I'm excited to move on to book #2...
For more children's literature, middle grade literature, and YA literature reviews, feel free to visit my personal blog at The Miller Memo!!
We witness Islamophobia in big and small ways, including the terrible event in which their beloved mosque is vandalized and burned. However, the community comes through in supporting their Muslim neighbors by searching for the criminals and offering support in cleaning and rebuilding. The family interaction was simply beautiful and the description of foods and cooking will have readers' mouths watering! Over the course of the story, Amina sees her father taking a stand for his beliefs and this helps empower Amina. And at the very end, we're left wondering if Amina's family will take a trip to visit the rest of their family in Pakistan. I'm excited to move on to book #2...
For more children's literature, middle grade literature, and YA literature reviews, feel free to visit my personal blog at The Miller Memo!!
September 4, 2017
***This review has also been posted on Xpresso Reads
It's in the title of this review post but I am going to repeat it anyway: Amina's Voice is one of the most important books published this year and has clearly not gotten the hype it deserves. It's a middle grade book and I know a lot of people shy away from reading those because reading tastes vary but please don't overlook this book. Amina's Voice is such a wonderful, heartfelt book and deserves and infinite amount of love from everybody.
I should take a moment to say I am neither Muslim-American or Pakistani-American but Amina's Voice still resonated with and I found myself nodding along and feeling Amina's struggle with her cultural identity on a spiritual level. I grew up feeling similar struggles and even though it wasn't ~my story~, it felt really freeing to see that struggle reflected in a book I was reading and made the younger Rashika in me feel a little bit more at rest.
Amina's Voice deals with cultural identity, religious identity and that awkward transition from elementary school to middle school. Even if you went to junior high instead of elementary + middle school, I think we can all agree that 6th grade is weird as fuck. EVERYTHING CHANGES and yet nothing really changes. People who you thought you knew are different. Middle school is just a weird time in general.
Hena Khan also incorporates some food porn into the novel and my mouth was WATERING as I read (and my stomach craved a delicious, home cooked meal.) This book- if you haven't already gathered-deals with such serious issues and does so masterfully. Hena Khan knows her audience well and incorporates thought provoking discussions into the little things.
This is a book that should be in the hands of every middle schooler but young adults and adults can also take so much away from this beautifully, written novel. Don't sleep on Amina's Voice. READ IT and spread the love. We need so much more Muslim rep in children's lit and the existence of this delightful, #ownvoices book is a step in the right direction. Let's support these books though so we can get EVEN MORE.
*mic drop*
Note that I received an advanced copy of this book for review.
It's in the title of this review post but I am going to repeat it anyway: Amina's Voice is one of the most important books published this year and has clearly not gotten the hype it deserves. It's a middle grade book and I know a lot of people shy away from reading those because reading tastes vary but please don't overlook this book. Amina's Voice is such a wonderful, heartfelt book and deserves and infinite amount of love from everybody.
I should take a moment to say I am neither Muslim-American or Pakistani-American but Amina's Voice still resonated with and I found myself nodding along and feeling Amina's struggle with her cultural identity on a spiritual level. I grew up feeling similar struggles and even though it wasn't ~my story~, it felt really freeing to see that struggle reflected in a book I was reading and made the younger Rashika in me feel a little bit more at rest.
Amina's Voice deals with cultural identity, religious identity and that awkward transition from elementary school to middle school. Even if you went to junior high instead of elementary + middle school, I think we can all agree that 6th grade is weird as fuck. EVERYTHING CHANGES and yet nothing really changes. People who you thought you knew are different. Middle school is just a weird time in general.
Hena Khan also incorporates some food porn into the novel and my mouth was WATERING as I read (and my stomach craved a delicious, home cooked meal.) This book- if you haven't already gathered-deals with such serious issues and does so masterfully. Hena Khan knows her audience well and incorporates thought provoking discussions into the little things.
This is a book that should be in the hands of every middle schooler but young adults and adults can also take so much away from this beautifully, written novel. Don't sleep on Amina's Voice. READ IT and spread the love. We need so much more Muslim rep in children's lit and the existence of this delightful, #ownvoices book is a step in the right direction. Let's support these books though so we can get EVEN MORE.
*mic drop*
Note that I received an advanced copy of this book for review.
June 13, 2021
I have been noticing the hype about this book for a while.So, I decided to read it.
I have mixed feelings about this book.I will start with the good things-
• Interfaith Harmony
• Neat writing
• Presentation of Deshi(American-Pakistani) family
• Gorgeous cover
Now I will talk about the things I didn’t like-
• The plot(I couldn’t associate myself with the plot and didn’t get that urge to continue reading)
• Though this book has a beautiful message, this book is better suited for Middle school students
• The characters could be better
• To be honest, I was bored
Now some Q&A
Would I read the 2nd installment of this book?
Ans:I don’t think so
Would I read this author’s other books besides this franchise?
Ans:Her writing is marvelous.So, yeah.I will try other books.
I have mixed feelings about this book.I will start with the good things-
• Interfaith Harmony
• Neat writing
• Presentation of Deshi(American-Pakistani) family
• Gorgeous cover
Now I will talk about the things I didn’t like-
• The plot(I couldn’t associate myself with the plot and didn’t get that urge to continue reading)
• Though this book has a beautiful message, this book is better suited for Middle school students
• The characters could be better
• To be honest, I was bored
Now some Q&A
Would I read the 2nd installment of this book?
Ans:I don’t think so
Would I read this author’s other books besides this franchise?
Ans:Her writing is marvelous.So, yeah.I will try other books.
May 22, 2020
Amina’s Voice took me by surprise. I should never have doubted the countless glowing reviews that urged me to pick this up but I am so glad that its Goodreads Choice Award nomination pushed me to finally get my hands on it. Wow. Khan has such a lush, gorgeous writing style and she brought Amina’s story to life with such skill for a debut novelist.
Amina, our protagonist, had such a vibrant voice. I completely adored her and all of the secondary characters. Her relationships with her family and friends were fleshed out and played a pivotal role in the story. It was nice to see a healthy but realistic family dynamic in a contemporary like this, as well as friendship troubles that were not blown out of proportion. Amina herself goes such a transformation as she grows more comfortable in her skin. Her character arc made my heart melt with gooey feels.
I was impressed by how well Khan handled the struggles of being twelve. The incorporation of themes like friendship, family and faith made this such a powerful story that I know is going to touch the hearts of a lot of readers. Amina’s faith as a Pakistani-American Muslim was such an integral part of the story and while I tend to avoid books where religion is a main focus, the way that Khan included these discussions in the narrative felt natural and organic. I loved that there were so many positive interfaith relationships as well.
Overall? What a pleasant surprise. Amina’s Voice is a powerful and gorgeously written story that will stick with its readers long after the final page. I loved Amina and the cast. It is so important that novels like this continue to find popularity, especially in the middle-grade genre. I cannot wait to see what Khan comes out with next.
➸ Trigger warnings for .
Blog • Goodreads • Twitter • Instagram
Amina, our protagonist, had such a vibrant voice. I completely adored her and all of the secondary characters. Her relationships with her family and friends were fleshed out and played a pivotal role in the story. It was nice to see a healthy but realistic family dynamic in a contemporary like this, as well as friendship troubles that were not blown out of proportion. Amina herself goes such a transformation as she grows more comfortable in her skin. Her character arc made my heart melt with gooey feels.
I was impressed by how well Khan handled the struggles of being twelve. The incorporation of themes like friendship, family and faith made this such a powerful story that I know is going to touch the hearts of a lot of readers. Amina’s faith as a Pakistani-American Muslim was such an integral part of the story and while I tend to avoid books where religion is a main focus, the way that Khan included these discussions in the narrative felt natural and organic. I loved that there were so many positive interfaith relationships as well.
Overall? What a pleasant surprise. Amina’s Voice is a powerful and gorgeously written story that will stick with its readers long after the final page. I loved Amina and the cast. It is so important that novels like this continue to find popularity, especially in the middle-grade genre. I cannot wait to see what Khan comes out with next.
➸ Trigger warnings for .
Blog • Goodreads • Twitter • Instagram
February 21, 2018
One of my friends had seen this on a list of 'Must Read Diverse Audiobooks' and suggested I read it. There were parts I ADORED and really related to (the current Islamophobia situation in America, growing up Muslim in the US, trying to balance faith with life, judgmental family members, etc..). I wish this kind of book had been around when I was 11 or 12. I can see it being one of my favorites if I had read it earlier in life.
I would probably describe it as the middle school, lighter version of 'The Hate U Give,' in the sense where it has a protagonist dealing with current social issues, her and her community's social commentary and how she navigates the issues that pop up. It's not as jarring as 'The Hate U Give,' but I think it's an opportunity to talk about different faiths, hate crimes and what it means to be American.
It also introduces the reader to what life is like growing up in a Muslim family (again, it's a middle school book, so everything works out in the end). There were parts where the protagonist (Amina) had conversations with her parents and I swear, when Muslim parents have kids, they are given a script to memorize (no matter the nationality) on how to respond to certain situations. It was lifted verbatim from 11 year old Dina's life.
I would probably describe it as the middle school, lighter version of 'The Hate U Give,' in the sense where it has a protagonist dealing with current social issues, her and her community's social commentary and how she navigates the issues that pop up. It's not as jarring as 'The Hate U Give,' but I think it's an opportunity to talk about different faiths, hate crimes and what it means to be American.
It also introduces the reader to what life is like growing up in a Muslim family (again, it's a middle school book, so everything works out in the end). There were parts where the protagonist (Amina) had conversations with her parents and I swear, when Muslim parents have kids, they are given a script to memorize (no matter the nationality) on how to respond to certain situations. It was lifted verbatim from 11 year old Dina's life.
June 6, 2020
Vocea Aminei este povestea sensibilă a Aminei, o adolescentă de 12 ani, cu origini pakistaneze, care trebuie să găsească un echilibru între a-și face loc între colegele ei și a-și păstra tradițiile și a-și respecta religia. Ea este relevantă pentru „generația a doua”, copiii emigranților, născuți în Occident, care trebuie să filtreze prin propria lor personalitate moștenirea culturală, religioasă și să o îmbine armonios cu stilul de viață Occidental.
Amina și Soojin sunt cele mai bune prietene. Amina este pakistaneză, născută în Statele Unite, în timp ce Soojin este coreeancă, mutată în Statele Unite de la vârsta de 4 ani. Când Soojin se pregătește să depună jurământul pentru cetățenie, Amina simte cum prietena ei se îndepărtează de ea, apropiindu-se de Emily, una dintre popularele clasei. Soojin vrea să își schimbe numele cu unul englezesc, în timp ce Amina se teme că își va pierde prietena.
Cartea este foarte ușoară, destinată adolescenților, fără drame și subiecte dureroase, cu întâmplări relevante unei adolescente în situația Aminei. Cu siguranță în Amina se regăsesc multe tinere care provin din medii asemănătoare. Am admirat maniera moderată în care a abordat subiectele, atât cele religioase, cât și discrepanțele culturale dintre personaje.
Amina și Soojin sunt cele mai bune prietene. Amina este pakistaneză, născută în Statele Unite, în timp ce Soojin este coreeancă, mutată în Statele Unite de la vârsta de 4 ani. Când Soojin se pregătește să depună jurământul pentru cetățenie, Amina simte cum prietena ei se îndepărtează de ea, apropiindu-se de Emily, una dintre popularele clasei. Soojin vrea să își schimbe numele cu unul englezesc, în timp ce Amina se teme că își va pierde prietena.
Cartea este foarte ușoară, destinată adolescenților, fără drame și subiecte dureroase, cu întâmplări relevante unei adolescente în situația Aminei. Cu siguranță în Amina se regăsesc multe tinere care provin din medii asemănătoare. Am admirat maniera moderată în care a abordat subiectele, atât cele religioase, cât și discrepanțele culturale dintre personaje.
April 22, 2019
Star rating: 4.5 stars
This book was so close to being a 5 star read. A middle-grade novel that was both emotional but beautifully written. Amina is a young Pakistani-American Muslim girl who goes to middle school and leaves with her family. They all attend the local mosque. Amina is a talented but very shy singer. She loves The Voice (I do too!) But is sad when her best friend suddenly decides to hang out with another girl. After this, the local mosque gets targeted and many items end up destroyed and the building becomes too dangerous to enter. Hena Khan’s writing style gelled really well for me. I loved how the community all came together for those who really needed help and support after the mosque was destroyed. The pacing felt a little slow for me. I do recommend it!
This book was so close to being a 5 star read. A middle-grade novel that was both emotional but beautifully written. Amina is a young Pakistani-American Muslim girl who goes to middle school and leaves with her family. They all attend the local mosque. Amina is a talented but very shy singer. She loves The Voice (I do too!) But is sad when her best friend suddenly decides to hang out with another girl. After this, the local mosque gets targeted and many items end up destroyed and the building becomes too dangerous to enter. Hena Khan’s writing style gelled really well for me. I loved how the community all came together for those who really needed help and support after the mosque was destroyed. The pacing felt a little slow for me. I do recommend it!
June 18, 2017
I thought this book was amazing. It was full of interesting aspects of the Muslim community and I'm so happy that the other took the time to actually write it and give readers some insight to what it's like to maintain being a part of your own culture and community and adapting to another. The characters were all diverse and I loved that. This is a children's book so it definitely reads quickly; however, it was phenomenal and the writing is great. If you have a child that you're trying to expose to more diverse reads I would definitely recommend this one.
May 28, 2018
If you are looking for a fast-paced diverse read, I'd absolutely recommend Amina's Voice! This is a middle grade novel about a Pakistani-American girl named Amina (#OwnVoices representation) and her life in middle school and Sunday School at her local mosque.
I read this book in a handful of hours, so it's a very short read. On the one hand that made me even more excited to pick it up, but on the other it prevented the book from being more fleshed-out. That's probably to be expected from a book for younger audiences though.
content and trigger warnings for racism and islamophobia
I read this book in a handful of hours, so it's a very short read. On the one hand that made me even more excited to pick it up, but on the other it prevented the book from being more fleshed-out. That's probably to be expected from a book for younger audiences though.
content and trigger warnings for racism and islamophobia
September 4, 2017
cute and moving!middle grade diversity books are so important and i will ALWAYS read them.💕
May 3, 2017
A book doing well on representation and diversity, but lacking an interesting plot.
Amina's life is divided in 3 parts: middle school, music and religion. When a girl starts to befriend Amina's best friend, she feels threatened. On top of that, her uncle is visiting her family, so she has to behave well, according to the Quran.
I don't at all live in a religious environment so all the parts about behaving according to religious precepts or participating to the activities of the church community felt a bit alien. It didn't prevent them to be interesting on a cultural side, as all the stuff around food, and it was the only parts I enjoyed in the book, even more as it lacked a true plot or direction. Amina was in 6th grade (11-12yo according to Wiki), but seemed younger in my opinion and also very self centered. Her best friend was very happy to become a US citizen and to have the possibility to have a new first name, but Amina didn't share the joy because adapting to a new name was too strange (what a friend, maybe it's time to give her George to read...). She was also focused all the time on "she's stealing my best friend", which is in my opinion a totally boring plot, especially as I don't think people own their friends. The musical part was finally in the background, the focus being more on the family dynamics that I didn't really like, with the shaming the older brother suffered because he wasn't good enough at school (he seemed to have plenty of qualities and be a nice human being so why the focus on grades?). However, I expected that the uncle would be on the extremist side but it wasn't the case, which was nice. Overall it was a short book that I had difficulties to find interesting, which is a shame because there were some good ingredients in there.
Amina's life is divided in 3 parts: middle school, music and religion. When a girl starts to befriend Amina's best friend, she feels threatened. On top of that, her uncle is visiting her family, so she has to behave well, according to the Quran.
I don't at all live in a religious environment so all the parts about behaving according to religious precepts or participating to the activities of the church community felt a bit alien. It didn't prevent them to be interesting on a cultural side, as all the stuff around food, and it was the only parts I enjoyed in the book, even more as it lacked a true plot or direction. Amina was in 6th grade (11-12yo according to Wiki), but seemed younger in my opinion and also very self centered. Her best friend was very happy to become a US citizen and to have the possibility to have a new first name, but Amina didn't share the joy because adapting to a new name was too strange (what a friend, maybe it's time to give her George to read...). She was also focused all the time on "she's stealing my best friend", which is in my opinion a totally boring plot, especially as I don't think people own their friends. The musical part was finally in the background, the focus being more on the family dynamics that I didn't really like, with the shaming the older brother suffered because he wasn't good enough at school (he seemed to have plenty of qualities and be a nice human being so why the focus on grades?). However, I expected that the uncle would be on the extremist side but it wasn't the case, which was nice. Overall it was a short book that I had difficulties to find interesting, which is a shame because there were some good ingredients in there.
May 20, 2022
Amina is a Pakistani-American girl who is shy and likes to live in her comfort zone. Middle school is starting and her best friend is changing which bothers her. Her uncle, from Pakistan, is planning to visit them and her father respects him a lot. He doesn't want his brother to judge his children based on different cultural and religious views. All of these changes are scaring her plus her friends are motivating her to sing in public. Amina is a good but shy singer and unable to muster the courage to perform in public.
It is obviously targeted toward a younger audience and focuses on family dynamics, friend cycles, and facing the changes in life. It was a sweet and heartwarming tale for sure. The character development and siblings' bonding were good. Amina's internal fare was portrayed really well.
It is obviously targeted toward a younger audience and focuses on family dynamics, friend cycles, and facing the changes in life. It was a sweet and heartwarming tale for sure. The character development and siblings' bonding were good. Amina's internal fare was portrayed really well.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,598 reviews