What do you think?
Rate this book
The Secret Starling
Clara has lived a life of solitude, home schooled under her mean uncle's strict regime . . .
Until now!
Her uncle's house has been losing staff and furniture as his fortunes fail, and finally he disappears himself, leaving Clara all alone in the giant manor with nothing but a wedge of 'guilt money'.
Luckily, streetwise Peter has been sent to stay . . . at least he has some experience of the real world and how to survive.
And the children are far from unhappy with their newfound freedom: a life of sliding down bannisters, making dens in Uncle's study, warming themselves by a fire of text books, playing sardines with the village children and living off nothing but boiled eggs and mashed potatoes has its appeal!
But then an interfering grown-up turns up with the unwelcome news that the house is to be sold.
Perhaps the mysterious ballet shoe that Stockwell the cat befriends has the answers to Clara's unknown past . . . a past that might hold the key to a better future . . .
Until now!
Her uncle's house has been losing staff and furniture as his fortunes fail, and finally he disappears himself, leaving Clara all alone in the giant manor with nothing but a wedge of 'guilt money'.
Luckily, streetwise Peter has been sent to stay . . . at least he has some experience of the real world and how to survive.
And the children are far from unhappy with their newfound freedom: a life of sliding down bannisters, making dens in Uncle's study, warming themselves by a fire of text books, playing sardines with the village children and living off nothing but boiled eggs and mashed potatoes has its appeal!
But then an interfering grown-up turns up with the unwelcome news that the house is to be sold.
Perhaps the mysterious ballet shoe that Stockwell the cat befriends has the answers to Clara's unknown past . . . a past that might hold the key to a better future . . .
Audiobook
First published May 2, 2019
19 people are currently reading
517 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
April 9, 2021
"
4.5
I usually read fiction or fantasy. Mystery passed by me long ago. But I found that I enjoyed this book! It rose up higher than my expectation.
Plot
12-year-old Clara Starling lives with her uncle/guardian at Braithwaite Manor. Her mother, Christobel Starling died giving birth to her and her father doesn't know she exists. Up till the age of 12, she lives on a strict routine until everything flips. Cook and James the butler get sacked.
She's abandoned in the village by her uncle who runs away. She treks back to Braithwaite Manor and starts taking care of herself with the help of her new friend Peter. When Amelia-Ann arrives, everything takes a turn for the worse.
There were no plot holes and only a few parts which aren't worth mentioning were predictable.
Writing
The writing was pretty normal and there were no repeating words. The tone was typical. If it was the librarian speaking then...
she was sweet. Typical.
Characters
Here's a line by the author...
---
"Despite her upbringing, Clara is unfailingly optimistic and has learnt about the world through the books she reads. I think this has given her a sense that anything is possible. Plus she has got through years and years of living with Uncle, which has made her quite Robust. A sort of 'if I got through that, I can get through anything' attitude.
Peter is more pragmatic, a mixture of tough and gentle. He is a really good adoptive grandson, kind and considerate, but he is also a bit wild, although always with the best of intentions."
---
I like both characters though I think Peter was worrying a bit too much.
overall
I think the book was really good and I liked almost everything about it.
Clara stepped forward. 'We have, actually,' she said. And a wave of victory swept through her as she reached under the horrible grey scratchy dress to retrieve the film canister of soup that was still tucked in the waistband of her jeans."- Ch 30, The Secret Starling
4.5
I usually read fiction or fantasy. Mystery passed by me long ago. But I found that I enjoyed this book! It rose up higher than my expectation.
Plot
12-year-old Clara Starling lives with her uncle/guardian at Braithwaite Manor. Her mother, Christobel Starling died giving birth to her and her father doesn't know she exists. Up till the age of 12, she lives on a strict routine until everything flips. Cook and James the butler get sacked.
She's abandoned in the village by her uncle who runs away. She treks back to Braithwaite Manor and starts taking care of herself with the help of her new friend Peter. When Amelia-Ann arrives, everything takes a turn for the worse.
There were no plot holes and only a few parts which aren't worth mentioning were predictable.
Writing
The writing was pretty normal and there were no repeating words. The tone was typical. If it was the librarian speaking then...
"'No, no, don't worry,' the librarian said hurriedly. 'I'll write you a temporary ticket for now. You can take the book today, my pet, and get the form signed when you're settled.'"
she was sweet. Typical.
Characters
Here's a line by the author...
---
"Despite her upbringing, Clara is unfailingly optimistic and has learnt about the world through the books she reads. I think this has given her a sense that anything is possible. Plus she has got through years and years of living with Uncle, which has made her quite Robust. A sort of 'if I got through that, I can get through anything' attitude.
Peter is more pragmatic, a mixture of tough and gentle. He is a really good adoptive grandson, kind and considerate, but he is also a bit wild, although always with the best of intentions."
---
I like both characters though I think Peter was worrying a bit too much.
overall
I think the book was really good and I liked almost everything about it.
May 2, 2019
An accomplished, well-crafted mystery with plenty of intrigue. A gloomy house on the moors; a mean, secretive uncle; a young girl with a mysterious past and a future under threat. Judith Eagle's charming debut reads like a classic from the very first page. With events woven around a smidge of fact, this should also appeal to fans of Emma Carroll and Lucy Strange.
January 30, 2023
I loved The Pear Affair by Judith Eagle, & when she sent me a copy of her newest MG I new I wanted to read this other book of hers I owned 1st before diving into the new 1. So happy I did! This was sooooooo good! Loved it. Clara Starling lives a life of dull rules, deadly routine, & flavorless meals under her cold uncle's strict regime—until the day Uncle disappears, leaving Clara alone in his old mansion. When streetwise orphan Peter & his rescue cat arrive unexpectedly, the children seize the chance to live by their own rules. But when the pair’s wild romps through the halls of Braithwaite Manor reveal a single, worn ballet slipper, they are hurled into a mystery that will lead to London’s glittering Royal Opera House & the unraveling of twisted Starling family secrets of poison, passion, & murder. This has a little bit of a gothic vibe, but is mainly just a delightful mystery with family secrets, & true friendship at the core. I loved this huge old manor, the mystery was also so intriguing, there’s an incredible MG cat, incredible characters, & more. Clara is a great MC, & your heart instantly falls for her. It’s so great seeing her finally get to feel “free”, & so heartwarming when she makes her 1st ever friends. Such great friends too. Loved the backstory of everything, & how so many different “puzzle pieces” connected to others that I didn’t even know would fit together lol. Brilliant! Loved the twists & turns, the adventure, & the incredible ending. Highly recommend. STUNNING cover & illustrations throughout by Jo Rioux too.💜
February 23, 2021
I think children will love the idea of living completely by themselves, sleeping in a den every night with a new friend and taking yourself off to London on the train to solve a mystery. Great for age 8+ keen on adventure and a bit of investigation.
March 28, 2021
Loved this book.
It was full of adventure.
I loved the big twist at the end of the book.
It was full of adventure.
I loved the big twist at the end of the book.
August 4, 2025
3.5 stars
Clara Starling lives with her mean old uncle in a huge manor on the desolate moors. One day without warning, he abandons her, leaving only a small bundle of cash. Clara decides to live on her own and enjoy the freedom of having no adults around to tell her what to do. Peter shows up at her door, claiming that her uncle arranged for Peter to stay at the manor while his grandmother is sick. The two children explore the manor and discover an old ballet slipper that may have belonged to one of the Starling family. They set out to follow the mystery of the ballet slipper and find that the Starlings have a terrible past full of murder and secrets.
This story is full of mystery and fun! I really liked the characters and all the wacky adventures. There are some very sweet family moments with Clara and her friends as they bond and support each other.
I really liked Clara's character. She is friendly and warm-hearted, but she is also starved for affection. She is very determined to solve this mystery of the ballet slipper, hoping it will give her some clues about her family; but what she is really searching for is a sense of belonging.
However, I had serious problems with Peter's character and with Amelia-Ann, Clara's new best friend. There is a scene where they both shoplift from stores, and proudly display the items they have stolen. They laugh like it's a big joke, and Clara goes along with it because she wants to fit in. This is never addressed again in the story. They don't return the items or pay for them. They never get punished for it. They don't confess or ask for forgiveness. They just trip along merrily in the rest of their adventures like nothing is wrong. These are the heroes of the story! Why are they shameless thieves?!? I'm very disappointed in the poor morals of this story.
The writing is charming and light-hearted. I read this entire book in one day because it was just such a quick and easy read. The chapters just fly by as the story captures your attention and your heart! Because I loved the characters so much and enjoyed so much of the story, it just made the shoplifting scene even more disappointing.
To see the objectionable content in this book, check it out on the Screen It First website! https://screenitfirst.com/book/the-se...
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for a free and honest review.
Clara Starling lives with her mean old uncle in a huge manor on the desolate moors. One day without warning, he abandons her, leaving only a small bundle of cash. Clara decides to live on her own and enjoy the freedom of having no adults around to tell her what to do. Peter shows up at her door, claiming that her uncle arranged for Peter to stay at the manor while his grandmother is sick. The two children explore the manor and discover an old ballet slipper that may have belonged to one of the Starling family. They set out to follow the mystery of the ballet slipper and find that the Starlings have a terrible past full of murder and secrets.
This story is full of mystery and fun! I really liked the characters and all the wacky adventures. There are some very sweet family moments with Clara and her friends as they bond and support each other.
I really liked Clara's character. She is friendly and warm-hearted, but she is also starved for affection. She is very determined to solve this mystery of the ballet slipper, hoping it will give her some clues about her family; but what she is really searching for is a sense of belonging.
However, I had serious problems with Peter's character and with Amelia-Ann, Clara's new best friend. There is a scene where they both shoplift from stores, and proudly display the items they have stolen. They laugh like it's a big joke, and Clara goes along with it because she wants to fit in. This is never addressed again in the story. They don't return the items or pay for them. They never get punished for it. They don't confess or ask for forgiveness. They just trip along merrily in the rest of their adventures like nothing is wrong. These are the heroes of the story! Why are they shameless thieves?!? I'm very disappointed in the poor morals of this story.
The writing is charming and light-hearted. I read this entire book in one day because it was just such a quick and easy read. The chapters just fly by as the story captures your attention and your heart! Because I loved the characters so much and enjoyed so much of the story, it just made the shoplifting scene even more disappointing.
To see the objectionable content in this book, check it out on the Screen It First website! https://screenitfirst.com/book/the-se...
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for a free and honest review.
December 10, 2020
BLOG|INSTAGRAM|TWITTER|YOUTUBE
Thank you to Edelweiss and the publisher for giving me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Full review closer to publication date.
This was one of the best middle-grade books I have ever read. The twists genuinely had me shocked, and this is coming from someone who often figures out thrillers well before I should have. I found it cohesive and understandable, which is really important for a book of this age group. It is a bit dark, with parents dying of suspicious circumstances and perhaps a murder or two, but with the popularity of a Series of Unfortunate Events, I can see this book selling well.
Thank you to Edelweiss and the publisher for giving me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Full review closer to publication date.
This was one of the best middle-grade books I have ever read. The twists genuinely had me shocked, and this is coming from someone who often figures out thrillers well before I should have. I found it cohesive and understandable, which is really important for a book of this age group. It is a bit dark, with parents dying of suspicious circumstances and perhaps a murder or two, but with the popularity of a Series of Unfortunate Events, I can see this book selling well.
May 3, 2019
What an absolute gem of a book! Poor Clara is abandoned by her uncle and left with only some banknotes in her pocket and a huge Manor House that’s falling apart and has been put up for sale. Along comes Peter and his adorable cat Stockwell and the adventure begins as they uncover the secrets of the house and her uncle. Perfect for fans of classic children’s fiction I tore through this book and it will have a permanent place on my shelf.
November 26, 2018
An accomplished début full of charm. A timeless tale of bold characters, unravellings of family secrets & a mysterious past. Destined to be a future classic & one of 2019’s top talents, Judith Eagle has all the hallmarks of the next Noel Streatfeild.
October 1, 2019
Enjoyable ‘orphan kids fight against the evil uncle’ type book. I do love an English setting
August 24, 2021
This is a Disney film of the future, I would think! Set in the 1970’s, it feels earlier than that; quaint a bit Blytonesque. This will be enjoyed by adults and children alike.
June 27, 2021
http://www.esmeraldaviaggielibri.it/i...
Insolite avventure a Braithwaite Manor di Judith Eagle, romanzo per ragazzi pubblicato da Garzanti il 10 giugno.
Questi sono i libri per ragazzi che amo leggere, queste sono le storie che voglio trovare e sono certa che se lo regalerete ai vostri figli e nipoti farete un figurone perché le avventure di Clara e Peter sono senza tempo e ricalcano i grandi classici per ragazzi che hanno segnato la vostra infanzia e adolescenza.
Se siete alla ricerca di una lettura per le vacanze adatta ai ragazzi delle medie avete trovato ciò che fa al caso vostro. Una bellissima storia in cui scopriranno l’importanza dell’amicizia e la forza che avere accanto qualcuno che ti supporta è in grado di donarti. Una storia che parla di famiglia, di addii, in cui misteri sepolti da tempo vengono risolti e tutto grazie al coraggio di una ragazzina davvero speciale.
Clara è costretta a vivere con uno zio che non l’apprezza particolarmente e che non perde occasione per farglielo capire. Clara cerca di darsi delle spiegazioni sul carattere dello zio e spera che un giorno suo padre venga a prenderla e la porti via. La fatiscente tenuta di Braithwaite Manor è l’unico posto che può chiamare casa, lei cerca sempre di vedere il lato positivo delle cose, ma non avere nessuno con cui giocare e niente di nuovo da vedere affliggerebbe chiunque. Le cose peggiorano quando lo zio licenzia la cuoca e l’istitutrice e le dice che devono lasciare la casa in cui vivono perché non può più permettersi di mantenerla. Tutto si immaginerebbe tranne essere abbandonata con 200 dollari in tasca e un biglietto con scritto Abbi cura di te.
Come potrebbe mai reagire una ragazzina di dodici anni a una cosa simile? Disperandosi? Correndo da qualcuno che conosce? Niente di tutto questo…Poi un pensiero, chiaro come il sole. Niente più noiosissime abitudini. Niente più ordini. Niente più imposizioni. Era ovvio, non l’avrebbe detto a nessuno! Avrebbe preso il controllo, sarebbe andata a casa e, per una volta, avrebbe badato a sé stessa in totale autonomia. Immaginate poi la sorpresa di trovarsi davanti dopo pochi minuti un ragazzino che le dice di essere stato mandato a stare con il signor Edward Starling fino a che sua nonna non si sentirà meglio. Quando Clara spiega a Peter il suo piano lui pensa di tornare immediatamente a Londra insieme alla sua gatta Stockwell, ma Clara gli fa capire che insieme possono farcela e che vivere senza costrizioni sarà uno spasso. La banda presto si arricchisce di nuovi elementi che avranno un ruolo chiave, ma di cui non voglio svelarvi nulla.
Cosa possono fare dei bambini soli in una grande tenuta? Ovviamente sbirciare in ogni angolo e scovare dei veri e propri tesori, sarà così che troveranno una scarpetta da danza classica e inizieranno a indagare per scoprire a chi sia appartenuta e quale segreto possa custodire. Le avventure di Clara e Peter non si svolgeranno tutte nella tenuta, li porteranno a Londra alla ricerca della verità che viene celata da dodici lunghi anni. Cos’è successo alla madre di Clara? Chi è suo padre e che fine ha fatto? Oltre a tutti questi interrogativi Clara e Peter dovranno anche avere a che fare con qualcuno che trama nell’ombra per togliere di mezzo ogni indizio e appropriarsi dell’eredità di Clara.
Preparatevi giovani lettori perché Insolite avventure a Braithwaite Manor è un’avventura ricca di colpi di scena e segreti che vorrete risolvere. Amerete Clara e Peter, così diversi e complementari. Clara avventata, ottimista e coraggiosa, Peter sognatore, gentile e premuroso. Insieme sono una forza della natura e questa avventura renderà la loro amicizia indissolubile.
Insolite avventure a Braithwaite Manor di Judith Eagle, romanzo per ragazzi pubblicato da Garzanti il 10 giugno.
Questi sono i libri per ragazzi che amo leggere, queste sono le storie che voglio trovare e sono certa che se lo regalerete ai vostri figli e nipoti farete un figurone perché le avventure di Clara e Peter sono senza tempo e ricalcano i grandi classici per ragazzi che hanno segnato la vostra infanzia e adolescenza.
Se siete alla ricerca di una lettura per le vacanze adatta ai ragazzi delle medie avete trovato ciò che fa al caso vostro. Una bellissima storia in cui scopriranno l’importanza dell’amicizia e la forza che avere accanto qualcuno che ti supporta è in grado di donarti. Una storia che parla di famiglia, di addii, in cui misteri sepolti da tempo vengono risolti e tutto grazie al coraggio di una ragazzina davvero speciale.
Clara è costretta a vivere con uno zio che non l’apprezza particolarmente e che non perde occasione per farglielo capire. Clara cerca di darsi delle spiegazioni sul carattere dello zio e spera che un giorno suo padre venga a prenderla e la porti via. La fatiscente tenuta di Braithwaite Manor è l’unico posto che può chiamare casa, lei cerca sempre di vedere il lato positivo delle cose, ma non avere nessuno con cui giocare e niente di nuovo da vedere affliggerebbe chiunque. Le cose peggiorano quando lo zio licenzia la cuoca e l’istitutrice e le dice che devono lasciare la casa in cui vivono perché non può più permettersi di mantenerla. Tutto si immaginerebbe tranne essere abbandonata con 200 dollari in tasca e un biglietto con scritto Abbi cura di te.
Come potrebbe mai reagire una ragazzina di dodici anni a una cosa simile? Disperandosi? Correndo da qualcuno che conosce? Niente di tutto questo…Poi un pensiero, chiaro come il sole. Niente più noiosissime abitudini. Niente più ordini. Niente più imposizioni. Era ovvio, non l’avrebbe detto a nessuno! Avrebbe preso il controllo, sarebbe andata a casa e, per una volta, avrebbe badato a sé stessa in totale autonomia. Immaginate poi la sorpresa di trovarsi davanti dopo pochi minuti un ragazzino che le dice di essere stato mandato a stare con il signor Edward Starling fino a che sua nonna non si sentirà meglio. Quando Clara spiega a Peter il suo piano lui pensa di tornare immediatamente a Londra insieme alla sua gatta Stockwell, ma Clara gli fa capire che insieme possono farcela e che vivere senza costrizioni sarà uno spasso. La banda presto si arricchisce di nuovi elementi che avranno un ruolo chiave, ma di cui non voglio svelarvi nulla.
Cosa possono fare dei bambini soli in una grande tenuta? Ovviamente sbirciare in ogni angolo e scovare dei veri e propri tesori, sarà così che troveranno una scarpetta da danza classica e inizieranno a indagare per scoprire a chi sia appartenuta e quale segreto possa custodire. Le avventure di Clara e Peter non si svolgeranno tutte nella tenuta, li porteranno a Londra alla ricerca della verità che viene celata da dodici lunghi anni. Cos’è successo alla madre di Clara? Chi è suo padre e che fine ha fatto? Oltre a tutti questi interrogativi Clara e Peter dovranno anche avere a che fare con qualcuno che trama nell’ombra per togliere di mezzo ogni indizio e appropriarsi dell’eredità di Clara.
Preparatevi giovani lettori perché Insolite avventure a Braithwaite Manor è un’avventura ricca di colpi di scena e segreti che vorrete risolvere. Amerete Clara e Peter, così diversi e complementari. Clara avventata, ottimista e coraggiosa, Peter sognatore, gentile e premuroso. Insieme sono una forza della natura e questa avventura renderà la loro amicizia indissolubile.
July 29, 2023
main characters lack personality imo…
August 20, 2025
libro fantastico 🤩.
veramente scritto bene.
la parte iniziale è un po' noiosa ma verso il 4 capitolo inizia una storia magica che ti fa venire la voglia di continuare a leggere!
veramente scritto bene.
la parte iniziale è un po' noiosa ma verso il 4 capitolo inizia una storia magica che ti fa venire la voglia di continuare a leggere!
January 5, 2021
Review to come
February 25, 2022
What a fun read! It was action packed with so much heart. As a teacher, there is so much I can do with this story in the Classroom and I know that students will be HOOKED. Throughly enjoyed it!
June 19, 2021
For my review of this book, visit my YouTube Vlog at:
https://youtu.be/iJiiyTEb2ts
Enjoy!
https://youtu.be/iJiiyTEb2ts
Enjoy!
May 19, 2025
Cute middle reader book.
May 15, 2021
I received this book through Library Thing Early Reviewers and finally got to it last night. I loved it! In fact, I couldn't put it down, and ended up finishing it in one sitting.
This book reminded me of the mysteries I used to read when I was a young girl. Who doesn't love a mystery that starts with a creepy old house full of secrets, a mean and stingy uncle, with secrets of his own, and strange clues turning up that seem to contradict the only things Clara knows about her parents. And who did the ballet slipper Clara found under the floorboards at the Manor belong to?
When the boring routine of Clara's world is suddenly turned upside down, Clara is first stunned, but then decides that she is going to take things into her own hands for a change. When she unexpectedly finds a young boy who had arrived to stay during his granny's illness, the two put their heads together and decide that they need to get to the bottom of what is going on with Clara's uncle, who has vanished, abandoning Clara, and putting the only home she knows up for sale.
Along the way they find new friendships, trust, loyalty and their own bravery and strength, doing things they never thought they could. But they also learn about jealousy, greed, and the lengths some people will go to in order to get what they believe they deserve. Overcoming their fears together, Clara and Peter embark on their dangerous adventure, following clue after clue, until the truth is uncovered.
Full of surprises, some humour, and suspensefuil events that will keep readers wanting to know what will happen, this book is a delight! Highly recommended.
This book reminded me of the mysteries I used to read when I was a young girl. Who doesn't love a mystery that starts with a creepy old house full of secrets, a mean and stingy uncle, with secrets of his own, and strange clues turning up that seem to contradict the only things Clara knows about her parents. And who did the ballet slipper Clara found under the floorboards at the Manor belong to?
When the boring routine of Clara's world is suddenly turned upside down, Clara is first stunned, but then decides that she is going to take things into her own hands for a change. When she unexpectedly finds a young boy who had arrived to stay during his granny's illness, the two put their heads together and decide that they need to get to the bottom of what is going on with Clara's uncle, who has vanished, abandoning Clara, and putting the only home she knows up for sale.
Along the way they find new friendships, trust, loyalty and their own bravery and strength, doing things they never thought they could. But they also learn about jealousy, greed, and the lengths some people will go to in order to get what they believe they deserve. Overcoming their fears together, Clara and Peter embark on their dangerous adventure, following clue after clue, until the truth is uncovered.
Full of surprises, some humour, and suspensefuil events that will keep readers wanting to know what will happen, this book is a delight! Highly recommended.
November 7, 2021
My rating was orginally four stars, but as I thought about this book, and thought about what I had to say about it, I realized that I needed to give it three stars.
Why?
Because it's just okay. It could've been more, and it could've given me more, but it didn't.
What do I mean by this?
Well.
The way the mystery was solved sucked. I'm sorry, Eagle, but to me it did. I prefer a mystery that has clues hidden throughout the story, for example, with Serafina and the Black Cloak (spoiler alert for that book, btw) clues were given throughout the story about who Sefina's mother could be. Not only from her appearance, but also from traits she inherited from her mother.
I wish this book had gone the same route! Especially with (SPOILER) when the two main characters are revealed to be twins! The only clue given was the ear wiggling thing.. which was just.. meh. I wish more clues would've been given, like them both having grey eyes, or having a birthmark, or having similar features-- aka, dimples, pointed chins, etc.
And I know what you're gonna say, but they're FATERNAL twins! Yeah, and even fraternal twins look alike! Mary Kate and Ashley Olsen are two examples! I wish that the book had done this. Also, giving them similar personalities.
Speaking of personality, I feel like the main character kinda lacked one?
The book mentions that she's read classic literature, so, show how that's impacted her personality! Has it made her adventurous? Cautious? Soft spoken? Or, how has growing up in her uncle's house hold affected her? I feel like this is SORT of explored in the book, but I wish it could've been explored more! Why not have the main character be scared of speaking to people? Or have her be shy?
I dunno, I just wish there had been more OMPH.
Because while I like the story, it just doesn't have that sort of OMPH factor that really makes it stick out. Yes, the mystery is nice, and yes, I read it in one day (it was a nice short read) but it wasn't a read, I feel, that left an impact. And not all books have to be impactful, but I just wish this one had a been more thought to it, particularly in the ending! Where the main character finds her dad. I thought that was stupid. Like, how stupid is this dude? Did he just believe that some random kid claiming to be his daughter was his? I think it would've been nice to have a scene where the main character (Clara? I think??) has to prove that she's his daughter! Maybe by using a birthmark? Or realizing they both have a rare eye color? I dunno.
I feel like this book could've done more, but it didn't, and while the story is okay, and I'd read the authors works again if I stumbled across it, I don't think I would actively seek out her work after reading this one.
Why?
Because it's just okay. It could've been more, and it could've given me more, but it didn't.
What do I mean by this?
Well.
The way the mystery was solved sucked. I'm sorry, Eagle, but to me it did. I prefer a mystery that has clues hidden throughout the story, for example, with Serafina and the Black Cloak (spoiler alert for that book, btw) clues were given throughout the story about who Sefina's mother could be. Not only from her appearance, but also from traits she inherited from her mother.
I wish this book had gone the same route! Especially with (SPOILER) when the two main characters are revealed to be twins! The only clue given was the ear wiggling thing.. which was just.. meh. I wish more clues would've been given, like them both having grey eyes, or having a birthmark, or having similar features-- aka, dimples, pointed chins, etc.
And I know what you're gonna say, but they're FATERNAL twins! Yeah, and even fraternal twins look alike! Mary Kate and Ashley Olsen are two examples! I wish that the book had done this. Also, giving them similar personalities.
Speaking of personality, I feel like the main character kinda lacked one?
The book mentions that she's read classic literature, so, show how that's impacted her personality! Has it made her adventurous? Cautious? Soft spoken? Or, how has growing up in her uncle's house hold affected her? I feel like this is SORT of explored in the book, but I wish it could've been explored more! Why not have the main character be scared of speaking to people? Or have her be shy?
I dunno, I just wish there had been more OMPH.
Because while I like the story, it just doesn't have that sort of OMPH factor that really makes it stick out. Yes, the mystery is nice, and yes, I read it in one day (it was a nice short read) but it wasn't a read, I feel, that left an impact. And not all books have to be impactful, but I just wish this one had a been more thought to it, particularly in the ending! Where the main character finds her dad. I thought that was stupid. Like, how stupid is this dude? Did he just believe that some random kid claiming to be his daughter was his? I think it would've been nice to have a scene where the main character (Clara? I think??) has to prove that she's his daughter! Maybe by using a birthmark? Or realizing they both have a rare eye color? I dunno.
I feel like this book could've done more, but it didn't, and while the story is okay, and I'd read the authors works again if I stumbled across it, I don't think I would actively seek out her work after reading this one.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 22, 2022
Clara lives in Braithwaite Manor with her uncle, a cold man who sternly enforces dull routines and a bland diet for Clara every day. She has never known life outside of the manor until one day, her uncle disappears without a trace, leaving Clara on her own for the first time. The very same day a plucky, streetwise orphan named Peter appears at the manor, telling Clara he’s been sent to stay with her and her uncle. Unperturbed to find the manor completely empty, the pair begin a life of fun and whimsy with new friends from the village, playing games at the manor until they discover a dusty old ballet shoe under the floorboards. It’s a clue, a hint about a family secret, and possibly the key to unlocking the mystery of Clara’s parentage once and for all. But when they start to investigate, Clara and Peter quickly realize that their search involves not just Clara’s family but Peter’s too, and the stakes get even higher when they suspect that poison, blackmail, and bribery are all wrapped up in the tangled truth.
The Secret Starling is a tough book to summarize. I suppose at the heart it’s a mystery, but it takes it’s time setting the stage and introducing the main issue that’s meant to be solved throughout the book. A good third of the story is wrapped up in Clara, Peter, and their other new friends making a mess of Braithwaite Manor after Clara’s uncle disappears, trying their hand at living on their own to mixed results but certainly always having a lot of fun. Once the main mystery gets going, it feels fast and complex, with Clara and Peter allowed to dash all over the place unaccompanied and undisturbed. They are pretty ingenious on their own and dig up a lot of good information. It mostly seems like their world is populated by a lot of adults who either believe them completely, or don’t trust them at all, depending on what response is needed to keep them barreling towards their goals. The story is a little chaotic but it’s a good time nonetheless, I only wish there had been slightly fewer elements or slightly more time to let things come together. There are a few things that cause a raised eyebrow (a horse in the manor, shoplifting, purposefully provoking an allergic reaction in a “villain” character, and the gosh darned blessed timing of the whole thing) but overall it works, it’s pretty fun, and I enjoyed the story. I won’t revisit this one, but I’ve been caught enough by the writing style to try the author’s other children’s mystery and see if the plot is stronger and more cohesive.
The Secret Starling is a tough book to summarize. I suppose at the heart it’s a mystery, but it takes it’s time setting the stage and introducing the main issue that’s meant to be solved throughout the book. A good third of the story is wrapped up in Clara, Peter, and their other new friends making a mess of Braithwaite Manor after Clara’s uncle disappears, trying their hand at living on their own to mixed results but certainly always having a lot of fun. Once the main mystery gets going, it feels fast and complex, with Clara and Peter allowed to dash all over the place unaccompanied and undisturbed. They are pretty ingenious on their own and dig up a lot of good information. It mostly seems like their world is populated by a lot of adults who either believe them completely, or don’t trust them at all, depending on what response is needed to keep them barreling towards their goals. The story is a little chaotic but it’s a good time nonetheless, I only wish there had been slightly fewer elements or slightly more time to let things come together. There are a few things that cause a raised eyebrow (a horse in the manor, shoplifting, purposefully provoking an allergic reaction in a “villain” character, and the gosh darned blessed timing of the whole thing) but overall it works, it’s pretty fun, and I enjoyed the story. I won’t revisit this one, but I’ve been caught enough by the writing style to try the author’s other children’s mystery and see if the plot is stronger and more cohesive.
February 22, 2021
Clara lives with her uncle in a gloomy, crumbling old mansion away from others on the spooky moors somewhere in the British Isles. Her uncle ignores her most of the time, and Clara is stuck each day with a governess teaching her the most boring lessons possible. She has no one to play with and nothing beyond books to stave off mind-bending boredom. Then one day, her uncle fires the cook, tells Clara to pack a bag, and drops her off in the nearby village. She decides to have a cake and tea while she waits, and when she reaches in her pocket, she finds 200 pounds in ten-pound notes and a note from her uncle letting her know he has dumped her there and left. She walks back to the old mansion and, when she arrives, finds a For Sale sign in front of the house and a boy named Peter and his cat waiting for her. He has been sent to stay there while his Granny is recovering from an illness. The two decide they need to fend for themselves and try to figure out why they have both ended up here, abandoned. They tell each other their separate stories and become fast friends. But it is when they find a hidden shoe that their greatest adventure and a true mystery begins.
Judith Eagle
Author Judith Eagle has created a real page-turner with plenty of tension and some very heroic and resourceful young characters. The mansion and the moors make for a perfect setting for this mystery. It is a moody place and a challenging place for these young characters, but when they are driven from it, the pace really picks up. Their problems become more dire and the mystery greater. But this is all wrapped up satisfactorily and has a sweet ending that will leave young readers content. The occasional fun illustrations by Jo Rioux add nicely to the story and will help to keep the kids turning the pages. I received an ARC of the American edition from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Judith Eagle
Author Judith Eagle has created a real page-turner with plenty of tension and some very heroic and resourceful young characters. The mansion and the moors make for a perfect setting for this mystery. It is a moody place and a challenging place for these young characters, but when they are driven from it, the pace really picks up. Their problems become more dire and the mystery greater. But this is all wrapped up satisfactorily and has a sweet ending that will leave young readers content. The occasional fun illustrations by Jo Rioux add nicely to the story and will help to keep the kids turning the pages. I received an ARC of the American edition from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
April 24, 2019
I saved this debut mystery-adventure specially so that it could be my first read of the new year, and I`m so glad I did as it got things off to a great start. It is the story of a girl named Clara, who lives with her emotionally negligent uncle, as he abandons her to fend for herself. Then the savvier Peter and his cat Stockwell arrive and it seems like life may actually be better for Clara, but soon they must unravel the mysteries of Clara`s past and save Clara`s deteriorating mansion, and themselves, from dangerous outside forces. Clara is such a classic book heroine, and I think a lot of people will adore her- she has had a really rather horrid childhood, she is bookish and best of all, she is extremely brave throughout all of the situations she faces, no matter how afraid she is. I also adored clever, caring Peter and their friend Amelia Ann, and of course Stockwell. The mystery element is also wonderful. While we learn fairly quickly who is posing a danger (it is very hard to talk about this part of the book without giving spoilers!), this only serves to make the antagonists more menacing, and I loved learning about the motivations behind their actions. I was totally glued to the book as I got further in, and I stayed up ridiculously late to finish it because I was just too worried about the characters and mystified about why things were happening that I simply couldn’t sleep without finding out. The ending and the revelations that come by the conclusion concluded this story so well, and I really love how things end for Clara and Peter. This is a really excellent, gripping story, and if you enjoy MG books in this vein then I`d highly recommend this one. 4.5/5
June 19, 2023
Upon finishing The Secret Starling—which took a scant three days—I was strongly reminded of that moment I finished The Penderwicks. I had that feeling that I had just witnessed a book out of time. I don't know why it works or how it got past modern editors. The story is a jumble, the characters veer in and out, the sequences stretch believability, and yet, the child in me jumped up and shouted, "More. More!"
A bunch of children have to fend for themselves in a ramshackle gothic manor and travel all around England searching for information on a lost relative. Mysterious circumstances, amazing coincidences, and cartoon villains lurk, and yet...it was satisfying.
The two things I most liked about this book were the hare-brained logic of the main characters, which honestly was so child-like as to be completely believable, and the comforting fictional elements: a pillow fort, a daring adventure, secret messages, intrigue, pudding for dinner!
As sure to enchant as A Series of Unfortunate Events, The Little White Horse, The Boxcar Children, or A Little Princess.
One note: I absolutely abhorred the cavalier attitude the author took to shoplifting. Minus one whole star for this sickening addition.
My edition has fun and funky art by Jo Rioux both on the cover and sprinkled inside. While the art style perfectly conveys the quirkiness, I'm not sure it matches the mood of the plot. Nevertheless, I wouldn't change a thing.
A bunch of children have to fend for themselves in a ramshackle gothic manor and travel all around England searching for information on a lost relative. Mysterious circumstances, amazing coincidences, and cartoon villains lurk, and yet...it was satisfying.
The two things I most liked about this book were the hare-brained logic of the main characters, which honestly was so child-like as to be completely believable, and the comforting fictional elements: a pillow fort, a daring adventure, secret messages, intrigue, pudding for dinner!
As sure to enchant as A Series of Unfortunate Events, The Little White Horse, The Boxcar Children, or A Little Princess.
One note: I absolutely abhorred the cavalier attitude the author took to shoplifting. Minus one whole star for this sickening addition.
My edition has fun and funky art by Jo Rioux both on the cover and sprinkled inside. While the art style perfectly conveys the quirkiness, I'm not sure it matches the mood of the plot. Nevertheless, I wouldn't change a thing.
April 24, 2022
An interesting little children's book. While the protagonist is (I think) about twelve, it is really suited to much younger children as the protagonist, Clara and her friend Peter are so very 'young' in their behaviour.
While published in 2019, this is set in the 1960's which allows for levels of naivety and isolation which would be impossible in todays society. Clara lives with her guardian, a very strict uncle, at Braithwaite Manor. Her mother, she has been told, died when Clara was born and her father never even knew she existed. Her only friends are the cook and the butler/ odd jobs man because Uncle does not hold with anything fun at all.
Then, one day, Uncle fires the cook and the butler, then tells Clara to pack her case. He then abandons her in the village and does not return.
Clara, with nothing else to do, walks back to Braithwaite Manor, only to find Peter there. Peter was meant to be staying with her and Uncle. At first, Clara and Peter revel in the freedom, but then strange information starts appearing and Clara starts to realise that everything Uncle told her might have been lies.
Like I said, a cute little, very innocent story, very suited to young children.
While published in 2019, this is set in the 1960's which allows for levels of naivety and isolation which would be impossible in todays society. Clara lives with her guardian, a very strict uncle, at Braithwaite Manor. Her mother, she has been told, died when Clara was born and her father never even knew she existed. Her only friends are the cook and the butler/ odd jobs man because Uncle does not hold with anything fun at all.
Then, one day, Uncle fires the cook and the butler, then tells Clara to pack her case. He then abandons her in the village and does not return.
Clara, with nothing else to do, walks back to Braithwaite Manor, only to find Peter there. Peter was meant to be staying with her and Uncle. At first, Clara and Peter revel in the freedom, but then strange information starts appearing and Clara starts to realise that everything Uncle told her might have been lies.
Like I said, a cute little, very innocent story, very suited to young children.
June 13, 2021
Thanks to Candlewick Press, Walker Books US for the ARC of this wonderful new middle-grade mystery. A gloomy mansion, Braithwaite Manor, set far away across the moors finds young Clara Starling, orphaned at birth by her mother, her and unknown to her father. Now she's in the hands of an Uncle, gloomy and stern, required only to see her once a day to inquire as to her schooling and health. Cold-mannered with not one loving feeling, Clara depends only on Cook and the Butler to help her grow plus a string of strange governesses who seem to last only a minute. Judith Eagle sets that tone as readers rush headlong into a mystery when a young boy, Peter, shows up. He's been sent by his Granny who's unwell but just before, Clara's uncle has declared the house is sold and they must leave. Fortunately, Clara is a fighter and sneaks back, figures she will make it on her own. She practically has anyway! Yes, the plot thickens, with the addition of Cook's children, a few kind adults, the mystery races away in its unraveling. I think readers will love the twists and turns that the mystery makes, with Clara and Peter leading the way with resolve.
July 2, 2019
Set in 1974 this story has all the hallmarks of a classic junior fiction mystery about families and their secrets. Clara is neglected and unloved and lives a life of crushing routine in her uncle’s mansion. Her fortunes change when her uncle disappears leaving Clara abandoned. After she meets Peter, a savvy worldly boy from London the pair have a great time running around the decaying mansion, free from adult interference. When an adult appears with news that the mansion is to be sold the pace really picks up as this turns into an exciting chase to solve a mystery. A hidden ballet shoe and a mystery involving Clara’s mother may hold the key to the mysterious secrets of Clara’s past. As Clara, Peter and their friend Amelia Ann embark on their adventure in London Clara has to leave her sheltered existence and learn whom to trust if she wants to discover her own identity. This is a fabulous read for mature readers from 9+.
July 8, 2019
Clara lives with her strict Uncle in their crumbling family manor. But when her Uncle abandons her with nothing more than a little bit of money, Clara is suddenly left all alone. When a young boy called Peter turns up at the house, him and Clara find some suspicious mysteries in the old manor that change everything. Clara starts to search for the truth about her mother’s death and uncovers more sinister secrets on the journey.
Strengths
The mystery presented in this story is very engaging and children will be kept hooked to find out how it unfolds. The resolution of the mystery is satisfying in a dramatic and extravagant style suited to children’s fiction. The characters are well written and I think middle grade readers will enjoy rooting for Clara and Peter.
Weaknesses
The first half of the book is quite slow going. The mystery did not unfold as quickly as expected for a children’s mystery novel and I expect that some children will not be engaged because of this.
The writing style is very classical, which will put some readers off. I personally ended up skim-reading from about 40% to the end.
Summary
Although the mystery element is amusing and intriguing, I don’t think my readers will pick this book up. I will not be purchasing a copy since there are other mystery books I would rather stock in my library.
Strengths
The mystery presented in this story is very engaging and children will be kept hooked to find out how it unfolds. The resolution of the mystery is satisfying in a dramatic and extravagant style suited to children’s fiction. The characters are well written and I think middle grade readers will enjoy rooting for Clara and Peter.
Weaknesses
The first half of the book is quite slow going. The mystery did not unfold as quickly as expected for a children’s mystery novel and I expect that some children will not be engaged because of this.
The writing style is very classical, which will put some readers off. I personally ended up skim-reading from about 40% to the end.
Summary
Although the mystery element is amusing and intriguing, I don’t think my readers will pick this book up. I will not be purchasing a copy since there are other mystery books I would rather stock in my library.
November 13, 2021
Set in a time before technology, twelve year old Clara Starling lived a boring and lonely life in a crumbling old British mansion with her strict uncle Edward. Her mother died when Clara was born and Clara never knew her father. One day her uncle disappears leaving her with a pocketful of money. Clara is unsure what to do having been sheltered from the outside world with no friends and now no uncle. Things change when Peter, an orphan boy her age arrives with his cat. He is expecting to be staying with Edward after his grandma has become ill but, soon the two abandoned children need to work together and solve a the mystery of the past and what has brought them together. Can they piece together the past with some clues found in the present?
A charming mystery story with an old-fashion feel that both children and adults can enjoy; I loved the illustrations as well.
4.5/5 stars
http://bibliophilebythesea.blogspot.c...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews