What do you think?
Rate this book
Georgian Gentlemen #2
An Uncommon Earl
Alexander Allerton, the Earl of Bloxley’s, greatest desire is to alleviate the suffering of the poor and less fortunate of England. So when his hackney carriage is involved in an accident that results in the death of one of those he is determined to help, he is devastated. Alexander vows to keep the promise he makes to the injured woman as she takes her final breaths: he will not rest until he finds her young son.
After a crippling accident years ago, Jane Hadford is accustomed to being largely ignored at social events. But being overlooked has allowed her to hone her observational skills—and she quickly perceives that all is not well with the handsome Lord Bloxley. When an unexpected opportunity arises to talk to the earl, he surprises them both by sharing with her his fruitless search for the child. Touched by Lord Bloxley’s story and by his desire to make things right, Jane determines to help him fulfill his promise. What she cannot anticipate, however, is that the quest she has chosen to undertake will bring into her life a small boy who will steal her heart and a gentleman who might well do the same.
After a crippling accident years ago, Jane Hadford is accustomed to being largely ignored at social events. But being overlooked has allowed her to hone her observational skills—and she quickly perceives that all is not well with the handsome Lord Bloxley. When an unexpected opportunity arises to talk to the earl, he surprises them both by sharing with her his fruitless search for the child. Touched by Lord Bloxley’s story and by his desire to make things right, Jane determines to help him fulfill his promise. What she cannot anticipate, however, is that the quest she has chosen to undertake will bring into her life a small boy who will steal her heart and a gentleman who might well do the same.
266 pages, Paperback
Published April 5, 2021
69 people are currently reading
1110 people want to read
About the author
Sian Ann Bessey
39 books1,085 followersSian Ann Bessey was born in Cambridge, England, but grew up on the island of Anglesey off the coast of North Wales. She left her homeland to attend university in the U.S., where she earned a bachelor's degree in communications with a minor in English.
She began her writing career as a student, publishing several magazine articles while still in college. Since then she has published historical romance and romantic suspense novels, along with a variety of children's books. She is a USA Today best selling author and a Whitney Award finalist.
Although Sian doesn't have the opportunity to speak Welsh very often anymore, she can still wrap her tongue around, "Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch." She loves to travel and experience other cultures, but when she's home, her favorite activities are spending time with her family, cooking, and reading.
She began her writing career as a student, publishing several magazine articles while still in college. Since then she has published historical romance and romantic suspense novels, along with a variety of children's books. She is a USA Today best selling author and a Whitney Award finalist.
Although Sian doesn't have the opportunity to speak Welsh very often anymore, she can still wrap her tongue around, "Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch." She loves to travel and experience other cultures, but when she's home, her favorite activities are spending time with her family, cooking, and reading.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 315 reviews
January 5, 2021
An Uncommon Earl is not only the must-read book of the year, it is a brilliantly written story to be savored. With characters who jump off the page, Sian Ann Bessey transports her readers to eighteenth century England with such detail you can smell the flowers, hear the horse-drawn carriages, and experience every emotion of those living within the pages. The story itself includes sweeping highs, crushing lows, and moments you can’t help but laugh out loud or let the tears fall. This book is truly a masterpiece.
August 10, 2023
This book just exudes kindness. Perfect comfort read.
3.5 🌟 rounded up. I liked the book. The storyline is extremely predictable, but the H & h are very likeable. Asher, the 3 yr old orphan, adds a lot of sweetness to the plot.
I'm so happy to have finally read a historical romance that has some meat in it.Not just fluff and pettiness. The strong social theme, though used very often, is very welcome.
Recommended : 👍
3.5 🌟 rounded up. I liked the book. The storyline is extremely predictable, but the H & h are very likeable. Asher, the 3 yr old orphan, adds a lot of sweetness to the plot.
I'm so happy to have finally read a historical romance that has some meat in it.Not just fluff and pettiness. The strong social theme, though used very often, is very welcome.
Recommended : 👍
April 5, 2021
4.5 Stars!
This book is the second edition to the Georgian Gentleman series by Bessey. I really enjoyed the first book but I think this one might be my new favorite.
Sian has such a talent for weaving rich historical fiction, fact and language into her stories that the history and the romance almost share the stage equally and that is something I quite enjoyed. You always are learning about history as you read her books and it really makes the whole story that much more immersive, and feel very well researched. I loved learning about the history and practice of chimney sweeps and the laws surrounding them!
Alexander is such a fantastic male lead. He strives for the common good of all and steps up for the underprivileged. Jane has struggles and challenges all her own but not once does she let those define her and she wasn’t afraid to use her voice to stand up for her own well being.
The plot is just as good as the relationship development that you really don’t get a dull moment. There are some sweet and swoony moments, humor, sorrow and good conflict. Overall a fantastic read and would highly recommend for those who love this genre.
PS: everyone needs an Aunt Millward. If you know...you know. ♥️
This book is the second edition to the Georgian Gentleman series by Bessey. I really enjoyed the first book but I think this one might be my new favorite.
Sian has such a talent for weaving rich historical fiction, fact and language into her stories that the history and the romance almost share the stage equally and that is something I quite enjoyed. You always are learning about history as you read her books and it really makes the whole story that much more immersive, and feel very well researched. I loved learning about the history and practice of chimney sweeps and the laws surrounding them!
Alexander is such a fantastic male lead. He strives for the common good of all and steps up for the underprivileged. Jane has struggles and challenges all her own but not once does she let those define her and she wasn’t afraid to use her voice to stand up for her own well being.
The plot is just as good as the relationship development that you really don’t get a dull moment. There are some sweet and swoony moments, humor, sorrow and good conflict. Overall a fantastic read and would highly recommend for those who love this genre.
PS: everyone needs an Aunt Millward. If you know...you know. ♥️
May 6, 2021
I love these characters! Alexander and Jane were easy to get to know and see how perfect they are for each other. It was fun to see them discover that for themselves as they work together to find the child and also uncover some troubling secrets. The way Alexander fights for improved working conditions for children, specifically chimney sweeps, is admirable and shows his patience and determination through the slow process. He sees Jane for who she truly is and values her the way society doesn't. The pace of the book is steady and as the mystery slowly unfolds I didn't want to put it down. The romance is sweet and blooms naturally as the friendship and affection between Alexander and Jane deepens. Another wonderful book from a favorite author!
Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.
Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.
April 11, 2024
This is my favorite of the series so far!
April 4, 2021
Oh my heart! The entirety of this book was amazing. I learned so much about aspects of this time period that I didn’t know about before. I love learning history through stories and add some great romance and you have a making of a great book. I loved the characters! I want to be brave like Jane and marry a man like Alexander. Alexander, Earl of Bloxley, was actually introduced in the author’s book The Noble Smuggler. There is no need to read them in order, but I do recommend that.
I highly recommend this book.
I highly recommend this book.
April 10, 2021
Another great story from Sian Ann Bessey! I almost read it in a day but couldn't stay awake past 2 a.m. Finishing it was the first thing I did when I woke up. I think I liked this second book in the Georgian Gentlemen series more than The Noble Smuggler, and I really enjoyed that one. This one deserves more than 5 stars.
Alexander Allerton, the Earl of Bloxley, is certainly a most uncommon Earl. He doesn't care much for parties and musicales; he prefers to use his influence and position in society to help those in the working class. The children of the poor who are forced to work as chimney sweeps as young as 5 years old. At the same time Alexander is fighting for the chimney sweep bill in parliament, he's looking for a 3 year old whose mother was killed in a carriage accident.
Jane Hadford isn't looking to fall in love and get married. Having suffered severe injuries from a riding accident several years ago, she reluctantly goes to societal events with her family. It's at one of these, that she meets Alexander, and ends up helping him locate the little boy whose mother died.
What a story! I love how Sian seamlessly weaves in historical facts from the era in which the story takes place. I don't know which character I loved the most--Alexander, Jane or Aunt Millward. Alexander and Jane are so kind-hearted and want to help those who are less fortunate. They're simply perfect for each other, and have such a swoony romance. Who doesn't love a spunky, older, aunt? Aunt Millward has some of the best scenes and I thought she was hilarious. I'd love to have an Aunt Millward in my life. Oh, and the epilogue is the best!!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher Covenant Communications, and also bought a digital copy. All thoughts and opinions I've expressed in this review are my own.
Alexander Allerton, the Earl of Bloxley, is certainly a most uncommon Earl. He doesn't care much for parties and musicales; he prefers to use his influence and position in society to help those in the working class. The children of the poor who are forced to work as chimney sweeps as young as 5 years old. At the same time Alexander is fighting for the chimney sweep bill in parliament, he's looking for a 3 year old whose mother was killed in a carriage accident.
Jane Hadford isn't looking to fall in love and get married. Having suffered severe injuries from a riding accident several years ago, she reluctantly goes to societal events with her family. It's at one of these, that she meets Alexander, and ends up helping him locate the little boy whose mother died.
What a story! I love how Sian seamlessly weaves in historical facts from the era in which the story takes place. I don't know which character I loved the most--Alexander, Jane or Aunt Millward. Alexander and Jane are so kind-hearted and want to help those who are less fortunate. They're simply perfect for each other, and have such a swoony romance. Who doesn't love a spunky, older, aunt? Aunt Millward has some of the best scenes and I thought she was hilarious. I'd love to have an Aunt Millward in my life. Oh, and the epilogue is the best!!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher Covenant Communications, and also bought a digital copy. All thoughts and opinions I've expressed in this review are my own.
February 21, 2021
This series is becoming a new favourite! This book sucks you in from almost the first page, I literally could not put it down. Bessey is the master of historical fiction. Just the right amount of genuine historical events, subtly woven into the backstory, is a unique element of each of her books. There’s a select few authors who do this well, and Sian Ann Bessey is in the top of that list.
I appreciate the accuracy of the language, it is so nice to read a book set in the UK that has all the little words and phrases from home that sometimes get overlooked by American authors. Bessey is from the UK, and it’s an added bonus for me as a reader to get all those extra nuggets of words I just don’t hear everyday anymore.
Both Alexander and Jane are instantly likable characters, which means you can connect quickly with empathy for them both. Neither of them without challenges, and Janes were certainly unique. As the story progressed, it’s clear that Bessey was not just going to tell a simple tale of two people finding a genuinely good partner. This story had plot twists and edge of your seat moments! I loved the depth to this story that will fully immerse you into their world, and sheer contented at the end.
I’m loving the Georgian Gentlemen series! Can’t wait for more.
I appreciate the accuracy of the language, it is so nice to read a book set in the UK that has all the little words and phrases from home that sometimes get overlooked by American authors. Bessey is from the UK, and it’s an added bonus for me as a reader to get all those extra nuggets of words I just don’t hear everyday anymore.
Both Alexander and Jane are instantly likable characters, which means you can connect quickly with empathy for them both. Neither of them without challenges, and Janes were certainly unique. As the story progressed, it’s clear that Bessey was not just going to tell a simple tale of two people finding a genuinely good partner. This story had plot twists and edge of your seat moments! I loved the depth to this story that will fully immerse you into their world, and sheer contented at the end.
I’m loving the Georgian Gentlemen series! Can’t wait for more.
April 26, 2024
The romance in this is slow-moving, but very sweet. I love Asher's obsession with "fwogs".
April 27, 2021
***4.5 Stars***
An Uncommon Earl is a jewel. It is a rare find that you want to enjoy every moment that it lasts. Sian Ann Bessey has a writing style that pulls me into the story and creates characters that I love.
The Earl of Bloxley is an "uncommon" Earl. He actually cares about the less fortunate and will do all that he can to be an advocate for them. His determination to fulfill a dying flower girl's request and make conditions safer for young workers is admirable.
Jane Hadford is his confidant as well as his fellow sleuth. They are on the hunt for a small boy who was given up to a foundling home. Their compassion drew me to them and sweetened the story for me.
This book has many things to recommend it. It is a good clean romance with elements of a mystery. It's a story of unconditional love and acceptance of others who may be different or less fortunate. The characters are well developed and the pacing was wonderful. The book will leave you feeling good and with hope for a better world.
Source: I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
An Uncommon Earl is a jewel. It is a rare find that you want to enjoy every moment that it lasts. Sian Ann Bessey has a writing style that pulls me into the story and creates characters that I love.
The Earl of Bloxley is an "uncommon" Earl. He actually cares about the less fortunate and will do all that he can to be an advocate for them. His determination to fulfill a dying flower girl's request and make conditions safer for young workers is admirable.
Jane Hadford is his confidant as well as his fellow sleuth. They are on the hunt for a small boy who was given up to a foundling home. Their compassion drew me to them and sweetened the story for me.
This book has many things to recommend it. It is a good clean romance with elements of a mystery. It's a story of unconditional love and acceptance of others who may be different or less fortunate. The characters are well developed and the pacing was wonderful. The book will leave you feeling good and with hope for a better world.
Source: I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
May 22, 2022
I am in a state of twitter-pated bibliophile ecstasy over this one! I'm calling it a Regency even though the series title is Georgian Gentlemen. From my pokey attempts at research it looks like the Georgian and Regency eras overlapped for a decade or so and this book has all the divine elements I've come to love in a Regency Romance.
Let's start with our hero, shall we? A very uncommon Earl so the title is spot on! Alexander is the rare kind of nobleman who cares about the plight of the poor and the rights of the working class. His work in parliament is concentrated on benefitting both. Absolutely loved the social justice elements of this novel.
Of course, he's highly sought after as husband material but the only woman who has caught his eye is Miss Jane Hadford but no one would consider her an advantageous match because...well, you have to read the book to find out. Just know that Jane isn't like all the other flighty females flitting about London's Season. She's compassionate and intelligent and eager to help the Earl on his quest to grant a dying mother's last wish.
What follows is a charming blend of bantering wits, oh-so-very-proper (mostly) letter exchanges and even a country outing or two. Along with the desperate search for an orphaned boy and the even more desperate bid to save him once found.
I listened to the audible edition narrated by Jason Tatom and, while I prefer a female narrator, I quite enjoyed Tatom's performance.
Let's start with our hero, shall we? A very uncommon Earl so the title is spot on! Alexander is the rare kind of nobleman who cares about the plight of the poor and the rights of the working class. His work in parliament is concentrated on benefitting both. Absolutely loved the social justice elements of this novel.
Of course, he's highly sought after as husband material but the only woman who has caught his eye is Miss Jane Hadford but no one would consider her an advantageous match because...well, you have to read the book to find out. Just know that Jane isn't like all the other flighty females flitting about London's Season. She's compassionate and intelligent and eager to help the Earl on his quest to grant a dying mother's last wish.
What follows is a charming blend of bantering wits, oh-so-very-proper (mostly) letter exchanges and even a country outing or two. Along with the desperate search for an orphaned boy and the even more desperate bid to save him once found.
I listened to the audible edition narrated by Jason Tatom and, while I prefer a female narrator, I quite enjoyed Tatom's performance.
July 3, 2023
The tale of Alexander (the Earl of Bloxley) and Jane is a sweet and endearing one indeed.
I loved the letters this couple exchanged in regards to their searches and situations and it allowed the reader a glimpse of them--Alexander's strength and determination and Jane's quiet, gentle ways. Although they're each flawed, they are beautiful in their combined efforts and connection.
The characters are beautifully written and I especially loved seeing Aunt Millward, as she is a dear favorite of mine in this series.
This was a difficult time period for the lower class and the story of Asher reminds me of an ancestor of my husband's. There are probably many similar stories of those who didn't have wealth and it's a touch heartbreaking to learn about how these children survived. Bessey does a brilliant job of enlightening the reader, while also warming the heart.
Content: mild romance; talk of working very young children in precarious situations, even resulting in death
I loved the letters this couple exchanged in regards to their searches and situations and it allowed the reader a glimpse of them--Alexander's strength and determination and Jane's quiet, gentle ways. Although they're each flawed, they are beautiful in their combined efforts and connection.
The characters are beautifully written and I especially loved seeing Aunt Millward, as she is a dear favorite of mine in this series.
This was a difficult time period for the lower class and the story of Asher reminds me of an ancestor of my husband's. There are probably many similar stories of those who didn't have wealth and it's a touch heartbreaking to learn about how these children survived. Bessey does a brilliant job of enlightening the reader, while also warming the heart.
Content: mild romance; talk of working very young children in precarious situations, even resulting in death
May 19, 2024
Climbing boys
5 stars
Good story. Our heroine fell from a horse and so walks badly with a cane. Our hero is an earl whose hackney ran over a flower seller and now he's on a mission to find her child....great descriptions.
5 stars
Good story. Our heroine fell from a horse and so walks badly with a cane. Our hero is an earl whose hackney ran over a flower seller and now he's on a mission to find her child....great descriptions.
March 27, 2025
2 stars
Bland, unremarkable.
Bland, unremarkable.
October 17, 2025
neviem čím to je, ale dosť si idem túto sériu 😂
April 19, 2021
I had no idea just how bad conditions would have been during this time period for young workers. I’m talking about really young workers, 4 to 7 years old. I loved the way author Sian Ann Bessey brought that to light in this novel. And the way that some of the gentry may have been trying to fix the problem as well. This story, especially the historically accurate parts touched me deeply.
Another thing I really loved about this one is that our heroine, Jane, is crippled from an accident. This brings her a lot of hardships. People were unkind and uncaring. But she rose above all of that and was able to show love to those that needed it around her. That was one of my very favorite things!
The Earl of Bloxley, Alexander, is one of the gentry trying to fix the problems he saw in society. I love how he was willing to work hard to fix things. And he was kind, even when others weren’t to Jane. And to anyone he felt needed his help.
This is a beautiful story. I loved reading it!
I was sent a copy of An Uncommon Earl as a gift from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Another thing I really loved about this one is that our heroine, Jane, is crippled from an accident. This brings her a lot of hardships. People were unkind and uncaring. But she rose above all of that and was able to show love to those that needed it around her. That was one of my very favorite things!
The Earl of Bloxley, Alexander, is one of the gentry trying to fix the problems he saw in society. I love how he was willing to work hard to fix things. And he was kind, even when others weren’t to Jane. And to anyone he felt needed his help.
This is a beautiful story. I loved reading it!
I was sent a copy of An Uncommon Earl as a gift from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
April 29, 2021
I am in complete character love right now. Lord Bloxley (Alexander), Jane and little Asher literally stole my heart away. Oh and Aunt Millward! I cannot forget her! Great characters make great books.
Okay, yes. The whole story was good. I just love when a story includes real historical events that I can learn more about. In this case it was chimney sweeps and the law to change the age of the young workers. The book flowed gently and easily with a great buildup in the end and the sweetest epilogue but for me this book was all about those characters. They just shine bright throughout the whole book. Kind and gentle but strong Alexander who fights for the downtrodden, the underdog. Jane is observant, smart and brave. Her heart is so big and it expands to include sweet little Asher. I adored them all.
Clearly this was a delightful book. It made me happy.
Content: kissing, mild peril
- I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
Okay, yes. The whole story was good. I just love when a story includes real historical events that I can learn more about. In this case it was chimney sweeps and the law to change the age of the young workers. The book flowed gently and easily with a great buildup in the end and the sweetest epilogue but for me this book was all about those characters. They just shine bright throughout the whole book. Kind and gentle but strong Alexander who fights for the downtrodden, the underdog. Jane is observant, smart and brave. Her heart is so big and it expands to include sweet little Asher. I adored them all.
Clearly this was a delightful book. It made me happy.
Content: kissing, mild peril
- I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 6, 2021
I would give this a 3.5. While I enjoyed the book, there is definitely some lazy writing that one often finds in romance novels. Not a lot of relationship development before the two main characters are fully in love with each other. And there is a miraculous discovery that allows the heroine to go from not being able to have children to having them. Why do so many romance authors not allow the tension of not having children!? It would be ok.
But I enjoyed it overall.
But I enjoyed it overall.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Want to read
April 4, 2021Eligible for a 2021 Swoony Award, to nominate/vote click here: https://tinyurl.com/y593ce67vvvv
May 4, 2021
4.5
Fantastic vocabulary words throughout this sweet and uplifting story. Loved it.
Fantastic vocabulary words throughout this sweet and uplifting story. Loved it.
June 17, 2022
“You need a wife, Alexander! And it’s past time you find one!”
“You make it sound like finding a missing shoe!”
“It is! You simply need to find a good match.”
“Regardless if the fit causes you blisters?”
I loved this banter! It was throughout the entire story, and made it fun to listen to. I enjoyed this story more than book 1, and I’m not sure if that’s mostly due to the narrator being a male vs. female or the story, or the witty banter, but I recommend this audiobook!
This story starts out with a carriage accident and a death, but it is through this tragedy that Alexander makes a promise to find the woman’s child which leads to a mystery of missing children from a foundling home. Alexander is uncommon in the world of the ton because he is striving to help the poor and unfortunate and not just sweep it under the rug.
Then we meet the Hadfords, new to the neighborhood and ready for the social season to begin. Daughter, Jane, had a crippling accident years ago and tends to blend in to the wallpaper, but I’ve the years this has allowed her to become a keen detective and she observes things others tend to miss.
When these two get together they decide that TOGETHER they will find the child. What they didn’t expect, was all the others…
I enjoyed this audiobook, the characters, Jane in her “dotage” since she was told she would never be able to bear children becomes very attached to the children. So much so that she does the unthinkable and faces her fears!
I have to stop or I’ll give too much away. Just to read, or listen to, it!!
“You make it sound like finding a missing shoe!”
“It is! You simply need to find a good match.”
“Regardless if the fit causes you blisters?”
I loved this banter! It was throughout the entire story, and made it fun to listen to. I enjoyed this story more than book 1, and I’m not sure if that’s mostly due to the narrator being a male vs. female or the story, or the witty banter, but I recommend this audiobook!
This story starts out with a carriage accident and a death, but it is through this tragedy that Alexander makes a promise to find the woman’s child which leads to a mystery of missing children from a foundling home. Alexander is uncommon in the world of the ton because he is striving to help the poor and unfortunate and not just sweep it under the rug.
Then we meet the Hadfords, new to the neighborhood and ready for the social season to begin. Daughter, Jane, had a crippling accident years ago and tends to blend in to the wallpaper, but I’ve the years this has allowed her to become a keen detective and she observes things others tend to miss.
When these two get together they decide that TOGETHER they will find the child. What they didn’t expect, was all the others…
I enjoyed this audiobook, the characters, Jane in her “dotage” since she was told she would never be able to bear children becomes very attached to the children. So much so that she does the unthinkable and faces her fears!
I have to stop or I’ll give too much away. Just to read, or listen to, it!!
July 21, 2023
Oh man, I just loved this uncommon earl!! I loved how he could care less what society thought, but used his rank to do so much good. He was so thoughtful and caring for everyone, regardless of rank or station.
The romance in this was so good, and played along so well with the plot of the story to find Asher and set things right. I thoroughly enjoyed both of our Main Characters and their dual POV. They both felt things so strongly and had their heads on straight. It was very nice to have a book that I enjoyed both so much.
The side characters in this were so strong too, and I loved them!! The aunt was an absolute favorite, and the story would not have been the same without her.
There were definitely some heavy topics in this that I think need to be addressed: child abandonment, death, infertility, child labor.
I listened to this on audio and just loved it!! The narrator was a male, and he did a great job. 100% recommend as a book and audio!
The romance in this was so good, and played along so well with the plot of the story to find Asher and set things right. I thoroughly enjoyed both of our Main Characters and their dual POV. They both felt things so strongly and had their heads on straight. It was very nice to have a book that I enjoyed both so much.
The side characters in this were so strong too, and I loved them!! The aunt was an absolute favorite, and the story would not have been the same without her.
There were definitely some heavy topics in this that I think need to be addressed: child abandonment, death, infertility, child labor.
I listened to this on audio and just loved it!! The narrator was a male, and he did a great job. 100% recommend as a book and audio!
September 20, 2025
This is part of Sian's Georgian Gentlemen series, and I vastly prefer it over her new series (the one about girls trying on costumes and falling back in time).
Our male lead is absolutely a gem, and I love that he falls in love with a female who is handicapped. She is caring, booksmart, independent, and has a cool aunt who is absolutely on her side for this whole ordeal of finding the missing boy.
A happy ending, and exactly what I needed after the books I read lately.
Our male lead is absolutely a gem, and I love that he falls in love with a female who is handicapped. She is caring, booksmart, independent, and has a cool aunt who is absolutely on her side for this whole ordeal of finding the missing boy.
A happy ending, and exactly what I needed after the books I read lately.
April 1, 2021
Another winner from Sian Ann Bessey! I adore this book, just like her others, because of her amazing ability to tell a story that gives you all the feels AND includes fascinating historical detail. She weaves the history into the story in such a natural way and mixes into a perfect blend of mystery, intrigue, and romance!
I have been waiting for this story since reading the last page of The Noble Smuggler and Alexander's story was as amazing as I anticipated. Jane is one of my new favorite heroines - I love her spunkiness and her genuine goodness. The romance between Alexander and Jane is so swoony! And the epilogue? Perfection!
Trust me. This is 5-star absolute must-read and has earned a place on my favorites shelf...right next to all of Sian's other books!
I received a complimentary copy of the book but a positive review was not required.
I have been waiting for this story since reading the last page of The Noble Smuggler and Alexander's story was as amazing as I anticipated. Jane is one of my new favorite heroines - I love her spunkiness and her genuine goodness. The romance between Alexander and Jane is so swoony! And the epilogue? Perfection!
Trust me. This is 5-star absolute must-read and has earned a place on my favorites shelf...right next to all of Sian's other books!
I received a complimentary copy of the book but a positive review was not required.
April 2, 2024
Well wasn't this just about the sweetest story. Jane and Alexander are just love as individuals and together and Asher was just too cute.
April 18, 2021
Loved this book! This is probably my favorite book by Sian I have read so far! I loved everything about it. The characters were wonderful. The story kept me engaged the whole time. I didn’t want to put it down the whole time I was reading. I loved the romance between the main characters and I loved how perfect they were for each other. I just loved this book so much that I highly recommend it to anyone!
I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors. A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.
I received a complimentary book from publishers, publicists, and or authors. A review was not required and all opinions and ideas expressed are my own.
July 23, 2021
Characters sometime make all the difference and in this book they truly did! What a wonderful collection of characters in this book ...I truly want the next book to discuss Phoebe and her future! Trust me you will love Jane, Alexander and Asher and not be able to put this book down. I've said it before and it's definitely true here as well...I LOVE finding new, to me, authors and now I just want to read everything by Sian Ann Bessey. Happy reading!!
October 31, 2021
My dear Lady Bessey,
You write such incredible stories. I adored this story about Alexander, Jane, and Asher. I sincerely loved how Alexander and Jane bloomed from quiet acquaintance, to friends borne of mutual goals to a couple with deep regard and love for one another. I always appreciate a good friendship before deeper feelings of love between protagonists, and you accomplished that so well.
Other wonderful things I loved are the way you wrote in the varied accents and voices of the characters (that makes it easier to hear in my head), particularly little Asher’s inability to use the letter R. I also really appreciated the history in this book. You are masterful at including historical elements without making me feel like I’m reading a dry textbook or being info dumped. I also love the uniqueness to these stories. I had no idea child labor at such young ages was so widespread a problem. I also enjoyed hearing more about the Foundling Hospital.
I love little Asher so much. Including him in this story was pure brilliance. Having stories where children are so important to the overall plot is unique and you wrote that in so well. I simply adored him.
I also love how different from the “norm” Alexander and Jane both are. Jane’s pure heart and willingness to go against the typical expectations made for a wonderful heroine. I love her! I also really like how hard Alexander worked to make conditions better for the climbing boys. The prevailing attitudes of the day regarding the working class, and the young children forcibly employed in terrible conditions, are disturbing in the extreme. I really appreciated the idea that there were people of influence who felt that those ideas weren’t right and fought for change.
Both books in this Georgian Gentleman series are so, so good and I am looking forward to reading the next book. Thank you for providing such wonderful books for me to read.
Yours,
Jessica
*Note: contains child labor (extremely young children); child abuse, including purposely withholding food from a child to stunt growth; death; injury related to accident; child trafficking
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW: Read by Jason Tatum—He’s a good reader. I like his accents and vocal inflections and emotions. But I do always smile a bit when a male reader pitches his voice higher for a female character.
Foods in book:
Bread and honey
Bread pudding
Spiced buns
Quotes I loved:
His tall, proud berating was enough to make any young lady’s heart flutter, but as far as Jane was concerned, he had been his most gallant while crouched in the dirt with Asher.
“Patience and courage are a challenging combination.” -Jane
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
You write such incredible stories. I adored this story about Alexander, Jane, and Asher. I sincerely loved how Alexander and Jane bloomed from quiet acquaintance, to friends borne of mutual goals to a couple with deep regard and love for one another. I always appreciate a good friendship before deeper feelings of love between protagonists, and you accomplished that so well.
Other wonderful things I loved are the way you wrote in the varied accents and voices of the characters (that makes it easier to hear in my head), particularly little Asher’s inability to use the letter R. I also really appreciated the history in this book. You are masterful at including historical elements without making me feel like I’m reading a dry textbook or being info dumped. I also love the uniqueness to these stories. I had no idea child labor at such young ages was so widespread a problem. I also enjoyed hearing more about the Foundling Hospital.
I love little Asher so much. Including him in this story was pure brilliance. Having stories where children are so important to the overall plot is unique and you wrote that in so well. I simply adored him.
I also love how different from the “norm” Alexander and Jane both are. Jane’s pure heart and willingness to go against the typical expectations made for a wonderful heroine. I love her! I also really like how hard Alexander worked to make conditions better for the climbing boys. The prevailing attitudes of the day regarding the working class, and the young children forcibly employed in terrible conditions, are disturbing in the extreme. I really appreciated the idea that there were people of influence who felt that those ideas weren’t right and fought for change.
Both books in this Georgian Gentleman series are so, so good and I am looking forward to reading the next book. Thank you for providing such wonderful books for me to read.
Yours,
Jessica
*Note: contains child labor (extremely young children); child abuse, including purposely withholding food from a child to stunt growth; death; injury related to accident; child trafficking
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW: Read by Jason Tatum—He’s a good reader. I like his accents and vocal inflections and emotions. But I do always smile a bit when a male reader pitches his voice higher for a female character.
Foods in book:
Bread and honey
Bread pudding
Spiced buns
Quotes I loved:
His tall, proud berating was enough to make any young lady’s heart flutter, but as far as Jane was concerned, he had been his most gallant while crouched in the dirt with Asher.
“Patience and courage are a challenging combination.” -Jane
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
September 24, 2025
Overview:
Language 🤐: Clean
Romance ❤️🔥: Only Kisses (non descriptive)
Violence ⚔️: There’s reference to abuse and mistreatment of children nothing overly descriptive
⚠️malnourishment, children in danger, several death occurs and are talked about not overly descriptive, this deals with child labor laws in a way so talks about why this is pushed for I could see the things talks about being very upsetting because they are supposed to be⚠️
Tropes/Micro tropes
- Strangers to friends to lovers
- Slow Burn
- Disability Rep
- Eccentric match making aunt
- Common working together to better a life of a child
- Stating something is lovely and agreeing while looking at her
- One Horse
- Rescues her
- Carries Her
- Letter Writing
My Thoughts:
This story was delightful! It was so fun seeing Alexander after meeting his character in the first book! You definitely don’t need the background from that book to enjoy this own but it’s good to have in my opinion.
Alexander is a character that you can admire and cheer for. I love the wonderful causes that these characters champion in this series. In this Alexander is working to pass a reform for the boys who work with chimneys sweeps. It’s wonderful to read about a character of such upstanding morals and integrity, while still seeing him have realistic struggles and emotions in the things which he faces.
Jane’s character was truly wonderful. I loved following her story and feeling her struggles and resilience in overcoming her situation and limitations. It’s inspiring to read stories about characters with such determination and grit.
The romances is definitely more of a subplot and something that sneaks up on these characters but that is the type of romance I love to read about.
The issues that were tackled during this book were fascinating there was a wide range of emotions that I felt while listening to this story. I love the little bits of history I get to learn about or see how things could have been dealt with during this time period. I think this book does a great job of crafting a wonderful story while dealing with some very heavy topics.
Language 🤐: Clean
Romance ❤️🔥: Only Kisses (non descriptive)
Violence ⚔️: There’s reference to abuse and mistreatment of children nothing overly descriptive
⚠️malnourishment, children in danger, several death occurs and are talked about not overly descriptive, this deals with child labor laws in a way so talks about why this is pushed for I could see the things talks about being very upsetting because they are supposed to be⚠️
Tropes/Micro tropes
- Strangers to friends to lovers
- Slow Burn
- Disability Rep
- Eccentric match making aunt
- Common working together to better a life of a child
- Stating something is lovely and agreeing while looking at her
- One Horse
- Rescues her
- Carries Her
- Letter Writing
My Thoughts:
This story was delightful! It was so fun seeing Alexander after meeting his character in the first book! You definitely don’t need the background from that book to enjoy this own but it’s good to have in my opinion.
Alexander is a character that you can admire and cheer for. I love the wonderful causes that these characters champion in this series. In this Alexander is working to pass a reform for the boys who work with chimneys sweeps. It’s wonderful to read about a character of such upstanding morals and integrity, while still seeing him have realistic struggles and emotions in the things which he faces.
Jane’s character was truly wonderful. I loved following her story and feeling her struggles and resilience in overcoming her situation and limitations. It’s inspiring to read stories about characters with such determination and grit.
The romances is definitely more of a subplot and something that sneaks up on these characters but that is the type of romance I love to read about.
The issues that were tackled during this book were fascinating there was a wide range of emotions that I felt while listening to this story. I love the little bits of history I get to learn about or see how things could have been dealt with during this time period. I think this book does a great job of crafting a wonderful story while dealing with some very heavy topics.
April 9, 2025
Perhaps it’s my heart for orphans or perhaps it was Bessey’s writing style but The Uncommon Earl was a hard book to put down while reading. It’s the second book of the Georgian Gentlemen, however, it could be read as a stand alone in my opinion.
I love Bessey’s writing style as she has a knack for drawing the reader in while still involving historical elements that are rather deep and intense. I appreciate her ability to give full attention to the historical elements while weaving a sweet story.
Alexander and Jane’s story is so delightful to read. Perhaps Jane was a refreshing character due to the story that I had read previously but I admired her strength and fortitude displayed all the while she had an inner struggle. Alexander was the focus man but determined and very down to earth. Who couldn’t help but cheer for them as the navigated their life circumstances?
This book, you will want to sit and read in one day, but unfortunately, life catches up with most of us. Good luck and enjoy.
I love Bessey’s writing style as she has a knack for drawing the reader in while still involving historical elements that are rather deep and intense. I appreciate her ability to give full attention to the historical elements while weaving a sweet story.
Alexander and Jane’s story is so delightful to read. Perhaps Jane was a refreshing character due to the story that I had read previously but I admired her strength and fortitude displayed all the while she had an inner struggle. Alexander was the focus man but determined and very down to earth. Who couldn’t help but cheer for them as the navigated their life circumstances?
This book, you will want to sit and read in one day, but unfortunately, life catches up with most of us. Good luck and enjoy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 315 reviews