E-ARC Review - Thank you so much to NetGalley for this ARC!
4.5⭐️
“We’re all too focused being worried about what people think of us to spend time judging others, you know? So, like screw it. Be who you are.” - My new life motto, but also a quote from one of the several amazing stories included in this anthology.
I had such a great time reading this glorious collection. It had a little bit of everything: romance, friendships, coming of age stories, mysteries, superheroes, you name it! But the best part about all of these stories was the constant LGBTQIAP+, POC, and disability rep. They were such awesome, personal, lovely, sometimes heartbreaking, sometimes joyful stories that I know I will carry in my heart for a long time. Can’t wait to read more from all of these authors!
Here’s a bit more about each of the stories featured in this collection:
- Never Have I Ever, by Karen M. McManus
A good girl, a bad boy, and a game of Never Have I Ever gone all the way wrong. It was equal parts funny, tense, and surprising! I thought I knew where the story was going, but nope! Loved the ending!
- Like Before, by Maurene Goo
It’s the summer before senior year, and Pepper plans one last Hail Mary sleepover to save her friendships. This story packed a punch, it was sweet and raw and super emotional. Get your tissues out for this one!
- Old Rifts and Snowdrifts, by Kayla Whaley
An unexpected snowstorm traps Eleanor at her job in the flower shop, alongside someone she swore she’d never speak to again. This was such a heartwarming story and I adored Eleanor’s POV. Loved the disability rep, especially when portrayed as the love interest! I could read a whole novel with Nori as the main character.
- Con Nights, Parallel Hearts, by Marieke Nijkamp
Friends camp out overnight outside the big Con center to meet the creator of their favorite show. The city air feels full of possibility, and Quinn wonders if tonight will finally be the night she shares her deepest, darkest secret with them. This story was so damn gut wrenching. Many a hot, angry tear was shed. But I loved the parallel universe theme, it gave the story a really cool twist!
- Kiss the Boy, by Amanda Joy
As president of student council, Ayana’s in charge of making sure the school’s most anticipated event of the year goes without a hitch. But she and her friends have a more important plan to see through: finally get Ayana to kiss her longtime crush. This adorable “will they/won’t they” love story is the perfect amounts of funny, nostalgic, and sweet. It almost made me miss high school! Almost!
- Creature Capture, by Laura Silverman
Abby likes the game Creature Capture. A lot. And on the night they release the long sought after Loch Ness, Abby drags her best friend Curtis along in the hopes of catching one to complete her index, and finally putting away these so-called childish things for good. My younger inner self has probably never identified with a character more than with Abby. This “day in the life of a shy, nerdy girl” story was like looking into my past! I adored it! Especially the important lesson she learns at the end of the story. A+ for originality.
- Shark Bait, by Tiffany D. Jackson
Candice and her mom moved to Martha’s Vineyard to start a new life after an awful split with her dad. And that’s where she meets blue-eyed, blond haired Hunter. He’s a peaceful place for Candice to land, but is he really everything he seems? And is this new life what she really wants? This story touched on some great discussions about race and family dynamics. I enjoyed the premise a lot, though I feel like it would have fit better in a longer format, because I wanted to know so much more about the main characters! Also, that ending was excellent!
- A Place to Start, by Nina LaCour
Claude and Jamie are new stepsiblings, and after their mothers’ long wedding day, all they want to do is head home. But what do they do when their brand new, perfectly decorated house doesn’t make them feel at home? I’m such a sucker for sibling stories, so this was a real treat. It was a little sweet, a little sad, and a lot relatable. Nina LaCour painted a really vivid picture with her words.
- When You Bring a Dog to Prom, by Anna Meriano
Noemi is helping her best friend Jayla pull off her vision of the perfect prom, even though Noemi’s version of that included Jayla’s twin brother Jayden as her prom date. But Jayden shows up with a last minute date, and their emotional support golden retriever. Will this end up being the perfect prom or a perfect disaster? This story was really fun, it had great pacing, and I loved seeing a diverse cast of characters just letting loose and not having the story center around their diversity. Just a group of friends having the perfect, chaotic night. I want more stories like this!
- Missing, by Kathleen Glasgow
Kate had just lost her mother, which was why the idea of ghost hunting with her group of friends, or ghosts in general, intrigued her. Their destination was the local abandoned Lunatic Asylum, and Kate had to drag her quiet, weird little sister Lissy along with them while their dad worked. But their visit to the asylum started off strange and only got stranger from there. This story was such a great break from the lighter, happier stories in this collection. It was so spooky and weird, and I wanted to know so much more!! Kathleen Glasgow set the eerie scene beautifully, and the way the story ended was perfection.
- What About Your Friends, by Brandy Colbert
In her freshman year, Michaela joins Brockert College’s annual dance marathon, but she didn’t expect to run into her former best friend Eleanor there... whom she had completely ghosted while traveling through Europe. Can these two friends find a way to bridge the gap between them after Michaela’s failed gap year? This was such a sweet friendship story, and the awkward “are we still friends” situation is so relatable. The dance marathon was a really creative setting for this story. Also, now I’m going to have TLC’s What About Your Friends stuck in my head, so thanks Brandy!
- Under Our Masks, by Julian Winters
Tristan Jackson is a masked vigilante, studying for Algebra by day and fighting supervillains by night. But when his school crush asks for his help to stake out Tristan’s alter alter-ego Raven, he seizes the opportunity to get closer to him. Will Tristan reveal his true identity to Arash? Or, more importantly, his true feelings? Ok, this is it. This is my favorite story in this collection. A teenaged superhero hanging out with his crush all night? I need someone to make this into a TV show. Also, I adored Julian’s writing. Those lines about feeling obligated to announce ourselves to make others comfortable? I felt those words in my sternum. More of this, please!
- The Ghost of Goon Creek, by Francesca Zappia
Sydney Endrizzi is known all over Goon Creek as the resident expert on the paranormal, which always made her feel like an outsider at school. So when a few of her classmates ask to tag along on her yearly outing to find the Ghost of Goon Creek, she’s very confused and a little apprehensive. But Sydney quickly learns appearances can be deceiving, and that making friends may actually be easier than finding a ghost. This story is one I wish my younger self had read. I kind of want to buy a copy of just this story and distribute it across all my local high schools, so kids can realize sooner how many more friends they could have if they just put themselves out there! I loved this story and the spooky setting! I kind of wanted it to be a little spookier, but the fact that it ended up being the origin story of a Scooby-doo-like gang was enough for me. I would love to follow them on more adventures.