Once again, here's a book that could have been really good if the author hadn't really messed it up.
I didn't like either the H or the h all that much, because (despite the hint that they're soulmates from the moment they meet) she was engaged, and while the OM turned out to be a real crappy creep, she didn't know that at the time, and her ring didn't stop her from sleeping with the H! As for him, he was 10 years older but still acted like horny frat boy, when he should have taken a step back and given them both space to think before shedding clothes! If they have true love, then it could stand to wait until the OM got back, and then she could have broken up with him before starting things with the H.
Instead, the author chooses that old (and STUPID) trope of the h misunderstanding something and running out on the H, telling him their night together was an impulsive mistake that she regretted. On her side, at least, she was only 20 but he was 30 and should have realized there was more to this about face, because she slept with him and hadn't slept with her fiancé. Instead, he gets hurt and angry and steps out of the picture, with only a cut glass bowl as a memento (sent as a wedding gift, a la Scott Fitzgerald's famous story, only here it fell flat).
Yes, she married the OM, though she had broken up with him after her night with the H, because the guy had bad health problems from working too hard, which his mom blamed on the h, and the woman actually told the h if he dies, it would be her fault! Already feeling guilty for cheating and breaking up with him, and knowing how fond her father was of him, when he tells her he wants to forget the past and start over she agrees, and they get married!
Talk about DUMB!!! She ended up with an alcoholic abuser and I can't help feeling she deserved not the abuse, but the unhappiness for being such an idiot! Had she just confronted the H with what she had (wrongly) discovered, he would have explained everything and then they wouldn't have had five years apart, and she wouldn't have been nearly raped by the OM/ex-husband who had begun stalking her!
To make things worse, when she and the H get together again there's a whole lot of stupidity first, most of it hers, as she keeps denying her feelings, and blaming him when they come to the surface. When she learns of the mistake she made five years ago and apologizes, she does it in such a half bitchy way (due to jealousy of the OW) that you wonder if she's sorry at all.
Then she goes into martyr mode, as she lets the OW (pretty much thrown into the story just to get the jealousy trope going) convince her that the H is still in love with his late wife, and the former independent (though somewhat bitchy) boss girl turns into little Mary Sue, and runs after him, declaring she wants to marry him, thinking to herself she'll settle for what he has to give and won't expect love.
Then, she gets into another mess when (yet again) she misunderstands something! UNBELIEVABLE!
They were both dumb, since she marries him thinking his heart will always be with his late wife and he marries her thinking she wants protection from her bat crap ex. Mr. and Mrs. Nincompoop!
What's even sillier, is the book starting out from the POV of a character that you think will be the OM in the story and play a major role in it, when in reality he just has a few scenes. He would have been a much better choice for the OM than that crazy guy.
But the worst part is, when she found out he lost his son, she supposedly felt terrible about that, but gets so wrapped up in her feelings about taking a back seat to his late wife that she forgets all about that. As for the H, he dismisses the past as being over and done with, a pretty callous way to think about the loss of a child! It's one thing to forget a spouse and marry again (many people do) but forget your child????? Ask anyone who's gone through that kind of pain if they forget and put it in the past and they'll tell you "NO!!!!!" You live with it, but it always hurts. This guy acted like his neighborhood restaurant closed or a TV show he liked got cancelled. Oh well, life goes on!
This book could have been a more serious one about an abusive marriage if it had been written differently. How about the H and h meeting while he's still grieving his wife and doesn't want to move on, so she gives up and marries the OM, then later she meets the H again when she'd divorced but is afraid to get involved because of her abusive marriage? Now, that would have been a heck of a lot better than this!