So much to say. I actually liked this story but the writing has issues and normally I'd not review a book I wasn't asked to review. I chose this book. I wasn't asked to review it (just to make that very clear). But I think it's worth it to give some feedback.
I like the story. A lot actually. But it completely lacks emotion. And it needs a rewrite and several edits. I tried to submit edit suggestions via kindle (that is an option when you hold a word or sentence down) but I think this was self published so who knows if the author will see them. Hopefully he looks or knows he can look.
In parts it got confusing because there weren't smooth transitions between scenes. I normally fall in love with characters easily but I didn't with any of these. If they all died I'd not have been heart broken. But yet I still really liked the story and even think if better written it could be a nice series.
Here's what I think was well done, the history and the details. It was all just cold. You could tell this author had been a soldier (I am married to a retired Major) and I thought he likely was a doctor (and was right after reading the bio). He also did a great job with the history (minus the use of Gringo at that time but who cares). I love history and being a Native Texan, have a particular love for Texas History and as a former homeschool mother, have taught it. Plus I'm a genealogist and having family who fought for the independence of TX, I am super critical of those writing about TX. I'm from Houston, live near San Antonio, married a Mexico (actually from Mexico) who loves history and knows it well too. This wasn't truly about history much but what little there was, was accurate. That's actually rare. I also ran the military details past my husband....spot on. My only bother was the huge amount of typos and the cold 'facts only 'details. Another piece of evidence that this was written by a soldier/doctor. Just the facts ma'am. It felt more like a briefing than a novel. It seemed like a recounting of details of something that happened instead of a colorful, emotional, action packed, thrilling story. And it certainly could have been with a bit more editing. It had those elements but they weren't written to bring those out. And the cover must go. I almost didn't read it for that alone. It screams dime store western from about the 1950s. Or teen graphic novel. I could see a tween boy picking this up. Maybe that was the intention but a cover is important when selling a book. Ask any successful author. Plus I'm hoping a doctor wouldn't right a novel for a tween boy that had unmarried characters having sex. It was however super clean. So don't get me wrong. It didn't describe the acts we just know it happened. And I think I only remember MAYBE one cuss word. It's clean!
I wasn't going to review this and didn't want to be as brutally honest as I am here. But I see so much potential in this book and hope it can be redone and succeed. I think this is the author's first book (by what is written in his bio) so hopefully he can get a good editor or publisher to help him rework it to what I think it can be. It's close. Just needs some help with wording and edits. And I'm certainly no editor. I only submitted what I saw that was so very obvious.