What do you think?
Rate this book
Rascal Does Not Dream of… Light Novel #4
Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol
Sakuta had been waiting excitedly for a chance to spend time with Mai again, but instead he's greeted by a stranger who looks just like her. Apparently, Adolescence Syndrome has forced her to swap bodies with Nodoka Toyohama, a flashy up-and-coming idol...who also happens to be Mai's sister from a different mother! Now, forced to pretend to be the other, the sisters go about their respective lives as best they can but it seems like Nodoka is preoccupied with something besides walking in Mai's shoes...
192 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 9, 2015
40 people are currently reading
261 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
March 26, 2025
Unlike the first three books, this story lacked the perfect balance of comedy and drama; this time, it was more straight drama. I was unable to relate to this issue this time around, so a lot of the emotion was lost on me.
August 28, 2021
This is seriously becoming one of my favourite series ever, usually books are a solid 5 or 4 stars for me because the way they portray different teenage situations and emotions are so well done, and this one also has some important things and the themes around sisterly love-hate relationships are very well done, but contrary to the others, Nodoka kinda makes it hard to read. She is an extremely annoying character and it affected my reading. I’m very used to characters like Mai and Rio who are surprisingly mature, or characters like Koba and Kaede who still are immature and act more like kids but they don’t come off as strong and needy as Nodoka did.
I really wanted to slap this girl more than once because she just spent her time complaining like a five year old that doesn’t get her way. But I understand where she is coming from and all her frustration, while understandable, it wasn’t exactly acceptable. This different Adolescence Syndrome was interesting because we’re implying now that it doesn’t only affect the person with overwhelming emotions, but it also also affects those near them, and that’s an interesting concept, it ties nicely with the fact that you can truly affect others with your emotions, in here we’re seeing actual physical consequences. And now I’m scared to go into the next book because I know what’s coming. I saw the anime already, I already cried, and I’m so not ready for the next book.
I really wanted to slap this girl more than once because she just spent her time complaining like a five year old that doesn’t get her way. But I understand where she is coming from and all her frustration, while understandable, it wasn’t exactly acceptable. This different Adolescence Syndrome was interesting because we’re implying now that it doesn’t only affect the person with overwhelming emotions, but it also also affects those near them, and that’s an interesting concept, it ties nicely with the fact that you can truly affect others with your emotions, in here we’re seeing actual physical consequences. And now I’m scared to go into the next book because I know what’s coming. I saw the anime already, I already cried, and I’m so not ready for the next book.
June 20, 2025
Good book, even though the comedy part or scene is not a lot compared to the other book of this series I've read.
May 8, 2023
"Mamá solo la quería a ella"
En este volumen ahora vemos un caso bastante más sencillo de seguir pues tanto el síndrome como Futaba lo dejan obvio en las primeras páginas. Nodoka se siente terrible debido a que ella misma se siente inútil en comparación a su "perfecta" hermana.
Una vez escuché una frase bastante buena por parte de mi psicóloga "si quieres destruir a alguien, solo pasate comparándolo con los demás". La situación de Nodoka es muy dura y difícil, toda la vida se la paso siendo menospreciada por su madre y no porque ella la odiara o algo del estilo, si no porque ella desquitaba sus frustraciones y entregaba sus pesadas expectativas a su hija. Todo esto llegó al punto en que Nodoka dejó de creer en si misma como resultado del estrés constante ya que, el que te tengan altas expectativas (y además tengan forma física, en este caso, Mai) y no poder llegar a llenarlas, cala profundamente en el autoestima. Piensas que no importa que hagas o a que te dediques, nunca harás algo mínimamente decente a pesar del esfuerzo que pongas. El peligro de esta situación es que es una autodestrucción constante porque ahora no es alguien quien te menosprecia, eres tu mismo el qué te dice qué no vales nada y que eres un fracasado. Una vez dentro de la espiral es difícil superarlo.
Nodoka comenzó a ver que todo lo que ella hiciera, a comparación de su hermana, era insignificante y comenzó a sentirse inferior ya que todo a su alrededor le recordaba que no estaba "dando la talla". Nunca logro ser el centro de su grupo de idols, tenía una hermana absurdamente exitosa, su madre la corregía y comparaba a cada rato, cualquiera ante esta presión cedería y terminaría como mínimo, profindente deprimido.
Por medio del síndrome de la adolescencia y Nodoka experimentando el día a día de Mai se da cuenta que el peso de ser Mai Sakirajima no es poco presisamente y comienza a cuestionarse si realmente quiere alcanzar esos niveles de fama. También comienza a cuestionar su relación con su madre.
Me encanta cómo el autor aborda el tema de las relaciones humanas. Lógicamente una relación tan complicada no se puede resumir a un "te odio" o un "te amo". Muchas veces es una mezcla de los 2. "Te odio por compararme y exigirme demasiado pero te amo porque crecí contigo y eres mi madre" El sentimiento de Nodoka es contradictorio y eso esta bien, el sentir es algo muy complejo y reducirlo a unas palabras es imposible.
Mai: "Te odio por ser la hija del padre que me abandonó pero te amo porque eres la razón de que ame mi trabajo"
Nodoka: "Te odio porque todos te ven a ti y nadie a mi pero te amo porque eres la persona que más admiro en el mundo"
La parte que más me ha gustado es desde que Nodoka ve a su madre sonreir hasta que se devuelven sus cuerpos. Como clímax y resolución muy bien llevados.
Nodoka sumiendose en su propia tristeza al reconocer que el público prefiere ver a la Nodoka falsa a la Nodoka real, ella buscando una manera desesperada (aunque infantil, propio de ella) de validarse ante alguien obligando a Sakuta a ir por ella en el mar y, finalmente, la resolución con ella dándose cuenta que, aunque no es intrínsecamente malo vivir a la expectativa de los demás, la expectativa qué más importa es la de nosotros mismos. Nodoka decide ya no tratar de ser como su hermana, en cambio se encamina a tratar de ser ella misma y tomar sus propias decisiones y expectativas
El mensaje es hermoso sin duda alguna. Los conflictos de los personajes están tratados magistralmente y la reflexión acerca de los sentimientos hacia nuestras relaciones humanas es muy interesante. Un volumen a la altura de la serie
Se nota que el autor cada vez va puliendo más y más la manera de abordar estos temas y la exposición qué da a cada uno. Sin embargo, a gusto personal, este volumen ha sido el qué menos me ha gustado debido a que Nodoka a veces es muy fastidiosa. Aunque considero que es un excelente personaje, si hace un poco pesado querer ver más a profundidad su conflicto. Sin embargo creo que la actitud del personaje no hace qué sea un mal personaje, solo difícil de digerir porque su conflicto vaya que me ha encantado.
Con respecto a Mai y Sakuta, sus interacciones cada vez me gustan más y más. Probablemente una de mis parejas favoritas en la ficción.
En este volumen ahora vemos un caso bastante más sencillo de seguir pues tanto el síndrome como Futaba lo dejan obvio en las primeras páginas. Nodoka se siente terrible debido a que ella misma se siente inútil en comparación a su "perfecta" hermana.
Una vez escuché una frase bastante buena por parte de mi psicóloga "si quieres destruir a alguien, solo pasate comparándolo con los demás". La situación de Nodoka es muy dura y difícil, toda la vida se la paso siendo menospreciada por su madre y no porque ella la odiara o algo del estilo, si no porque ella desquitaba sus frustraciones y entregaba sus pesadas expectativas a su hija. Todo esto llegó al punto en que Nodoka dejó de creer en si misma como resultado del estrés constante ya que, el que te tengan altas expectativas (y además tengan forma física, en este caso, Mai) y no poder llegar a llenarlas, cala profundamente en el autoestima. Piensas que no importa que hagas o a que te dediques, nunca harás algo mínimamente decente a pesar del esfuerzo que pongas. El peligro de esta situación es que es una autodestrucción constante porque ahora no es alguien quien te menosprecia, eres tu mismo el qué te dice qué no vales nada y que eres un fracasado. Una vez dentro de la espiral es difícil superarlo.
Nodoka comenzó a ver que todo lo que ella hiciera, a comparación de su hermana, era insignificante y comenzó a sentirse inferior ya que todo a su alrededor le recordaba que no estaba "dando la talla". Nunca logro ser el centro de su grupo de idols, tenía una hermana absurdamente exitosa, su madre la corregía y comparaba a cada rato, cualquiera ante esta presión cedería y terminaría como mínimo, profindente deprimido.
Por medio del síndrome de la adolescencia y Nodoka experimentando el día a día de Mai se da cuenta que el peso de ser Mai Sakirajima no es poco presisamente y comienza a cuestionarse si realmente quiere alcanzar esos niveles de fama. También comienza a cuestionar su relación con su madre.
Me encanta cómo el autor aborda el tema de las relaciones humanas. Lógicamente una relación tan complicada no se puede resumir a un "te odio" o un "te amo". Muchas veces es una mezcla de los 2. "Te odio por compararme y exigirme demasiado pero te amo porque crecí contigo y eres mi madre" El sentimiento de Nodoka es contradictorio y eso esta bien, el sentir es algo muy complejo y reducirlo a unas palabras es imposible.
Mai: "Te odio por ser la hija del padre que me abandonó pero te amo porque eres la razón de que ame mi trabajo"
Nodoka: "Te odio porque todos te ven a ti y nadie a mi pero te amo porque eres la persona que más admiro en el mundo"
La parte que más me ha gustado es desde que Nodoka ve a su madre sonreir hasta que se devuelven sus cuerpos. Como clímax y resolución muy bien llevados.
Nodoka sumiendose en su propia tristeza al reconocer que el público prefiere ver a la Nodoka falsa a la Nodoka real, ella buscando una manera desesperada (aunque infantil, propio de ella) de validarse ante alguien obligando a Sakuta a ir por ella en el mar y, finalmente, la resolución con ella dándose cuenta que, aunque no es intrínsecamente malo vivir a la expectativa de los demás, la expectativa qué más importa es la de nosotros mismos. Nodoka decide ya no tratar de ser como su hermana, en cambio se encamina a tratar de ser ella misma y tomar sus propias decisiones y expectativas
El mensaje es hermoso sin duda alguna. Los conflictos de los personajes están tratados magistralmente y la reflexión acerca de los sentimientos hacia nuestras relaciones humanas es muy interesante. Un volumen a la altura de la serie
Se nota que el autor cada vez va puliendo más y más la manera de abordar estos temas y la exposición qué da a cada uno. Sin embargo, a gusto personal, este volumen ha sido el qué menos me ha gustado debido a que Nodoka a veces es muy fastidiosa. Aunque considero que es un excelente personaje, si hace un poco pesado querer ver más a profundidad su conflicto. Sin embargo creo que la actitud del personaje no hace qué sea un mal personaje, solo difícil de digerir porque su conflicto vaya que me ha encantado.
Con respecto a Mai y Sakuta, sus interacciones cada vez me gustan más y más. Probablemente una de mis parejas favoritas en la ficción.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 13, 2023
Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol - Exploring Adolescence and Relationships
Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol by Hajime Kamoshida is a thought-provoking novel that delves into the complexities of adolescence, relationships, and the challenges of growing up in a digital age. While the title may raise eyebrows, the novel offers more depth than meets the eye.
Kamoshida's storytelling skilfully blends elements of romantic and slice-of-life genres to create a narrative that resonates with readers. The everyday struggles of the characters mirror real-life experiences, allowing readers to connect with their emotions and dilemmas. The exploration of the digital world and its impact on relationships adds a relevant and contemporary layer to the story.
The protagonist, Character Name, is a relatable figure who grapples with the universal challenges of adolescence. His interactions with supporting characters provide insights into the dynamics of friendship, love, and self-discovery. Kamoshida
The plot, while meandering at times, effectively captures the essence of the characters' journey. The novelskilfully navigates through various scenarios, each offering a glimpse into the characters' growth and inner conflicts. The exploration of the protagonist's relationship with the siscon idol is particularly intriguing, shedding light on the intricacies of fandom and celebrity culture.
Kamoshida's writing style is accessible and conversational, making it easy for readers to immerse themselves in the story. The novel
In comparison to other novels in the genre, Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol stands out with its focus onrelatable characters and their emotional journeys. While some other works may delve into more intense or fantastical scenarios, this novel excels in portraying the authenticity of teenage experiences.
In conclusion, Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol is a thoughtful exploration of adolescence, relationships, and the influence of the digital world. Kamoshida's relatable characters and engaging storytelling create a narrative that captures the essence of growing up in the modern age. Readers seeking a contemplative and emotionally resonant read will find this novel a worthwhile experience.
Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol by Hajime Kamoshida is a thought-provoking novel that delves into the complexities of adolescence, relationships, and the challenges of growing up in a digital age. While the title may raise eyebrows, the novel offers more depth than meets the eye.
Kamoshida's storytelling skilfully blends elements of romantic and slice-of-life genres to create a narrative that resonates with readers. The everyday struggles of the characters mirror real-life experiences, allowing readers to connect with their emotions and dilemmas. The exploration of the digital world and its impact on relationships adds a relevant and contemporary layer to the story.
The protagonist, Character Name, is a relatable figure who grapples with the universal challenges of adolescence. His interactions with supporting characters provide insights into the dynamics of friendship, love, and self-discovery. Kamoshida
effortlessly capturesthe nuances of teenage emotions, creating a cast of characters that feels authentic and relatable.
The plot, while meandering at times, effectively captures the essence of the characters' journey. The novel
Kamoshida's writing style is accessible and conversational, making it easy for readers to immerse themselves in the story. The novel
balancesmoments of introspection with lighthearted banter, capturing the ebb and flow of teenage interactions. The inclusion of digital communication and social media elements adds a contemporary touch to the narrative.
In comparison to other novels in the genre, Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol stands out with its focus on
In conclusion, Rascal Does Not Dream of Siscon Idol is a thoughtful exploration of adolescence, relationships, and the influence of the digital world. Kamoshida's relatable characters and engaging storytelling create a narrative that captures the essence of growing up in the modern age. Readers seeking a contemplative and emotionally resonant read will find this novel a worthwhile experience.
November 15, 2022
Once again, another smash hit in the Rascal Does Not Dream series!
I've seen a few people argue that this is the weakest entry in the series, and while I can't necessarily say I disagree with that assertion, I ultimately believe that it doesn't really matter. This was another excellent novel, it didn't hit me as much as the previous entries (at least until the end anyway, though I knew I was going to cry during that scene, it always reduces me to tears whenever I watch the anime) it was still amazing all the way through!
There aren't as many differences between this and the anime for the most part. Most of the elements cut out from the anime seemed to just add more context or lengthen certain scenes, so it made sense to reduce them like they did. The only real differences I noticed were some elements at the end of the book and Nodaka's relationship with Sakuta. Outside of that, the anime and the light novel are nearly identical, which decently surprised me.
This arc is probably my favorite in the anime, next to Keade's, and I loved experiencing it again. I'm looking forward to being absolutely obliterated when I read the next book. Let's go baby!
I've seen a few people argue that this is the weakest entry in the series, and while I can't necessarily say I disagree with that assertion, I ultimately believe that it doesn't really matter. This was another excellent novel, it didn't hit me as much as the previous entries (at least until the end anyway, though I knew I was going to cry during that scene, it always reduces me to tears whenever I watch the anime) it was still amazing all the way through!
There aren't as many differences between this and the anime for the most part. Most of the elements cut out from the anime seemed to just add more context or lengthen certain scenes, so it made sense to reduce them like they did. The only real differences I noticed were some elements at the end of the book and Nodaka's relationship with Sakuta. Outside of that, the anime and the light novel are nearly identical, which decently surprised me.
This arc is probably my favorite in the anime, next to Keade's, and I loved experiencing it again. I'm looking forward to being absolutely obliterated when I read the next book. Let's go baby!
March 18, 2024
*Listened to the audiobook.
Another fun story with. This time Sakuta has to deal with a body switch. While the base for the plot in these books are not terribly original they are handled with care. The characters are likeable and their stories are believable and relatable. The author also gives a good amount of time for each character so they feel fleshed out. The relationship about Mai and her half-sister was well done and sweet. As I've come to expect, we get another cliffhanger so on to book 5 I go.
Another fun story with. This time Sakuta has to deal with a body switch. While the base for the plot in these books are not terribly original they are handled with care. The characters are likeable and their stories are believable and relatable. The author also gives a good amount of time for each character so they feel fleshed out. The relationship about Mai and her half-sister was well done and sweet. As I've come to expect, we get another cliffhanger so on to book 5 I go.
January 10, 2025
I really don’t know how to give this book, it wasn’t that entertaining compared to the others I really liked from this series. This adolescence syndrome was very predictable from the beginning, so it didn’t surprise me or make me feel like I couldn’t put the book down type. I was about to give this a 2 stars, but a 3 star is what I ended wanting to give it when the resolution happened.
March 22, 2025
More of the same quality. I can say that I am a fan of this series and I like the books more than the anime. But this is my least favorite girl thus far. She is very much a tsundere trope and it's a trope that I'm not at all interested in. Still the main character keeps me coming back. More on him next time.
April 4, 2021
I swear I read this for Sakuta and his quips!!!!!
Story’s moving along and it’s always good! I always fly through these volumes. I can’t wait for next one.
Story’s moving along and it’s always good! I always fly through these volumes. I can’t wait for next one.
April 25, 2021
Fantastic book and a great continuation of the series.
December 14, 2021
This volume takes a Freaky Friday turn, and manages to entertain throughout.
February 1, 2022
This isn't bad but I think I like it the least out of the four I've read so far.
February 23, 2023
Wonderful
April 9, 2023
The two sisters switch places as they sort out their relationship and familial stressors. It was pretty good.
January 7, 2025
A fun, amusing and light hearted story that manages to swing some good emotional punches.
December 13, 2025
It occurs to me I'm basically reading a family drama - divorces, neglected children, child star exploitation, sibling rivalry.
October 23, 2021
Terribly witty. The sister with the sister complex was less than endearing, but I found that I didn’t care. The dialogue was too entertaining.
April 5, 2021
I love this series. That being said this is probably my least favorite story arc. Nodoka is just so annoying. But even then the series is great. Even with the preternatural aspects of adolescence syndrome that the series has -- it balances talking about serious issues while still being fun, silly, cute, a bit crass, and entertaining as all get out. This one takes a look at jealousy, and expctations (both from yourself and from parents). And of course the continuing relationship of Mai and Sakuta.
I am, as always, looking forward to the next one.
I am, as always, looking forward to the next one.
December 18, 2021
Siscon Idol is often considered one of weaker arcs in the Seishun Buta Yarou anime. While not necessarily untrue, I do think this storyline is better served in narrative format with some real tearjerker moments near the end.
Next is the Kaede arc. I'm not ready 😢
Next is the Kaede arc. I'm not ready 😢
November 9, 2018
這集是普遍評價最差的一集
但我不覺有比較差，但也沒覺得比較好
跟前面三集差不多啊
看到這裡已經很明顯看得出小說客群還是以青少年為主
內容都是對學生很重要對地球無關緊要的生死大事啊
姊控和香也沒比較討人厭不曉得為啥鄉民都討厭
但我不覺有比較差，但也沒覺得比較好
跟前面三集差不多啊
看到這裡已經很明顯看得出小說客群還是以青少年為主
內容都是對學生很重要對地球無關緊要的生死大事啊
姊控和香也沒比較討人厭不曉得為啥鄉民都討厭
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews