این دومین کتابی است که از محمد حسین محمدی خواندهام و انتظارات مرا آنطور که باید برآورده نکرد. اگرچه بعد از اینکه مصاحبهای از خود نویسنده دیدم، تا حد زیادی بعضی از نقاط ضعف کتاب برایم قابل توجیه شد اما همچنان دوست داشتم خاطرهی خوبی که از خواندن داستانهای کوتاه محمدی در ذهن داشتم را برایم تداعی کند اما موفق نشده بود.
For a short story writer, not a very exceptional long story narrator! The story is told by two characters, which I think, could be the only reason to continue reading. Too much details and descriptions have made the book hard to follow. But still as an Afghan immigrant in Iran, I could deeply relate to the characters and as if I was already aware of their future, which will be dark and disappointing, just like their past. All in all, it is a fair work of literature to get familiar with the world and fears and dreams of an Afghan family.