In the light of the pandemic, old debates about whether science (and science writing) is political—many of which have been captured in the introductions of this anthology series—now seem small and antiquated. Science is undoubtedly political whether scientists want it to be or not, because it is an inextricably human enterprise. It belongs to society. It is interleaved with society. It is of society.
- Ed Yong, Editor of The Best Science and Nature Writing 2021
I originally tried reading this is April of 2022 and just...could not. The entire first section is about the nitty gritty of the pandemic and with other real life stuff going on at the time I couldn't concentrate on reading those articles, and found even a few paragraphs emotionally exhausting when I tried. So, now it's June of 2023 and - after finally getting this book back in as library hold - I finished it. (Barely. I still wasn't in a great place for some of the content, such as the chapter the focused on palliative care for cancer patients, but it's finished and before tomorrow's due date.)
The Best American series focuses on trying to curate the best stories/articles published in a given year; this one, obviously, focuses on articles that have something to do with science and/or nature that were published in 2020. As such, it's hardly unexpected that this book is broken into three categories: Contagion, Connections, and Consequences. The first focuses primarily on the pandemic: how race and access to healthcare affect patient outcomes; chronicling the state of the elder care industry and how that contributed to so many deaths in nursing homes; modern agribusiness, treatment of farmworkers, and the general unsustainability of US agriculture practices without immigrants; and other, similar topics. The second focuses on reexamining assumptions in science and how science as a field collectively treats people and other beings: the biography of a misremembered titan; musings on how animals are characterized and thought of; discussion of new research - or new perspectives on older research - regarding how people think, feel, and behave, as well as where we come from; and articles that strike a similar chord. The third and last section focuses primarily on drawing attention to things that are already problems and desperately need fixing: climate change in general as well as other specific issues, such anxiety over the havoc caused by invasive species and human meddling in the evolution of 'crowd pleasing' species; the long legacy of toxic waste, especially that which is in shallow waters near shore; the bioethics of genetic testing and the very real effects on the disabled community; the potential folly of allowing business to hide behind 'science!' as an excuse for terrible decisions/behavior; and similar issues.
When I first attempted to read this book, there were a ton of negative reviews that basically boiled down to complaints that the collection was 'too political or politically correct' or that 'such writing should have it's own book and not be in with science and nature articles,' which is...for a lack of a better word: dumb. Elke Mackenzie was a botanist of towering importance. The fact that she was also a transwoman and is still, even posthumously, treated badly by scientific institutions is something worth discussing. In reading The Unsung Heroine of Lichenology, I learned a lot about a scientist I'd never heard of before, a niche field, and a problem that's still pervasive and affects the scientific community today. Similarly, in The Scramble to Pluck 24 Billion Cherries in 8 Weeks, I learned a lot about the (in)stability of the modern food system, how agribusiness monocropping works, and the practical effects on the lives of the people who actually have to pick all that food even in the middle of a pandemic for little pay and often with no access to healthcare if they get sick. These are topics with a sociopolitical dimension to them, but that doesn't exclude them from being about nature or science.
Happily, in the intervening year, a lot of those kinds of reviews seem to have been pushed to the bottom of the listing, but in case anyone is still seeing them I reiterate: the collection is fine and, unless you were really on the ball with your pandemic reading, you're likely to learn a lot from the wide variety of topics and perspectives covered here.
That being said, even though this was a long and somewhat difficult read for me, I would recommend it. Even if one cannot take the time to read the entire book, I still suggest the following articles:
- The Scramble to Pluck 24 Billion Cherries in 8 Weeks by Brooke Jarvis
- Periwinkle, the Color of Poison, Modernism, and Dusk by Katy Kelleher
- The Unsung Heroine of Lichenology by Sarina Imbler
- Out There, Nobody Can Hear You Scream by Latria Graham
- A Toxic Secret Lurks in the Deep Sea by Rosanna Xia
- The Last Children of Down Syndrome by Sarah Zhang