Richard Linklater's trilogy of critically acclaimed 'Before' films—Before Sunrise, Before Sunset and Before Midnight—depict the ongoing relationship and romantic destiny of two characters played by Julie Delpy and Ethan Hawke.
This collection of specially commissioned chapters explores the many philosophical issues raised in the films, including: the nature of love, romanticism and marriage, the meaning of life, the passage and experience of time, the narrative self, gender, death.
Including an introduction by the editors summarising the trilogy, and an interview with Julie Delpy in which she discusses the key themes of the films and the importance of studying philosophy, Before Sunrise, Before Sunset, Before Midnight: A Philosophical Exploration is essential reading for students of philosophy, aesthetics and film studies, and also of interest to those in closely related subjects such as literature and gender studies.
Hans Maes is Senior Lecturer in History and Philosophy of Art and Director of the Aesthetics Research Centre at the University of Kent (Canterbury, UK).
An excellent collection of essays which explore some of the philosophical quandaries inherent to and which arise from Richard Linklater’s Before trilogy - the aesthetic value of conversation; how the films attempt to logically “justify” romance/love; in what ways they represent the existential dread that stems from “relational vertigo”. A very serious read for sure but one that offers plenty of rewards for fans of these films or anyone broadly interested in film, aesthetics, or philosophy.
First of all, this is the first time that I'm reading a book after watching its movie!(although this is not an adaptation, but an analysis of the movie, but still)
Secondly, only 2 reviews of this book have been published till date and mine will be the third.
Now coming to what the book is about, it is a philosophical analysis and exploration of the "Before Trilogy" movie series starring Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy.
The very fact that the film offers us food for philosophical thought and that 10 guys, all being mainly researchers and/or professors of Film studies have analyzed the movies via their short essays is itself an achievement.
Speaking about myself, even I came reading this book, upon a friend's suggestion mainly because I also have been an admirer of the Before trilogy.
Since the book consists of 10 chapters written by different people, I'll briefly review individual chapters:
Chapter 1: The poetry of day-to-day life by Michael Smith A good analysis of the trilogy, this chapter draws great parallels with other movies as well. A good revision of the trilogy.
Chapter 2: Time and transcendence by Marya Schechtman More of a philosophical chapter; suitable for students of philosophy or film studies
Chapter 3: A trilogy of melancholy by Hans Maes Excellent analysis of the trilogy by drawing good parallels with other movies. A great explanation of melancholy.
Chapter 4: Relational Verigo in before midnight by Christopher Cowley Mostly only for philosophy students
Chapter 5: Epic Intimacy by Murray Smith Yet another chapter meant mostly for philosophy students.
Chapter 6: Romantic or Cynic : Romantic Attraction as justification by Diane Jeske Good analysis and exploration of the trilogy and of cynicism
Chapter 7: The many faces of conversation by Kalle Puolakka Good individual analysis (i.e. taking each movie one by one) of the trilogy
Chapter 8: Love, death and life's summum bonum: The before trilogy as memento mori by Anna Christina Ribeiro Profound quotes present. A good analysis of the trilogy, this chapter draws great parallels with the quotes of various philosophers.
Chapter 9: Falling in love with a film (series) by Katrien Schaubroeck and Hans Maes Great introductory paragraph. The only chapter of the entire book which has a good balance between philosophy (for students) readers and general interest readers (who have come here after watching the trilogy) Good quotes present throughout with insights from real/practical life.
Chapter 10: Romance,narrative,and the sense of a happy ending by James MacDowell Good analysis of the trilogy, I'm mostly neutral about this essay.
And lastly, the 1:1 interview with Julie Delpy, which was quite profound and worth reading for admirers of the trilogy.