2.25 Stars. This was disappointing to say the least. I saw that the early reviews –by friends whose opinions I trust- were not very good for this book. I went in cautiously, but still hoping that I would enjoy this. I’ve loved books that others didn’t and I’ve disliked books that were popular, so maybe something similar would happen here. Instead, I’m sorry to say that this book was not a match for me at all.
The book is actually in two parts. Part one, which is exactly 45% of the book, was actually quite good. This story should have been turned into a novella and ended right when part one was over. I would have rated it at least 3.5 stars if not more. The problem is once part two started, the book went downhill and just kept going. I would actually recommend to people who might read this book, read part one, enjoy it, and stop the book there. I really wished that is what I would have done but instead I kept reading.
In the second half of the book, a random person enters the book and we are stuck in never ending flashbacks to try to make up for the fact that we don’t know, or care at all, about this new person. It’s like Shea wrote this book backwards. You don’t start long, seemingly to have nothing to do with the point of the book, flashbacks after the 50% mark. If you want us to care about this random character, than you start the book with the characters as teenagers, introducing us to this person, and then you put us in the present time for the rest of the book. If you do it this way, when this random stranger pops up, she’s not an actual stranger because we know who she is and we might actually care about her. Instead, she was just a random person taking up pages that needed to be spent on other characters. This was such a bazaar writing choice that I can’t get my head around it.
I’m a big fan of epilogues, especially for romance books. The one thing about epilogues is that they are not endings and should not be used as one. An epilogue is a bonus scene for us readers and in romance they normally show the couple getting engaged, married, having babies, or some other sweet romantic bonus moment. Unfortunately, this book decided to use the epilogue as an ending. It felt extremely gimmicky, and almost like it was there to trick us readers. It was a totally lame ending and just another thing that ruined this book for me.
I could go into how the main character was flawed –partially for reasons I still don’t even get- and that she showed no growth or character redemption. I could get into how hard it was telling what were flashbacks and what was current so I would have to stop reading and then reread certain parts. And I could go into how we never truly got to learn anything about who the “random stranger” character is now as an adult, but honestly I’m just feeling a bit exhausted. It’s weird to say but I found reading this book and writing this review pretty draining. I hate to be so negative when this is Shea’s full-length debut, but I have to be honest.
It won’t be a surprise but this is a book that I can’t recommend. If you are reading this book I would seriously suggest stopping when part one ends. This review would have been so different if this story would have been part one as a novella only. And because I liked the beginning, I can see potential in Shea, I just don’t know how this story got so off the tracks for my personal tastes.
A copy was given to me for a honest review.