Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Truths About COVID #3

Unreported Truths About Covid-19 and Lockdowns: Part 3: Masks

Rate this book
Former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson presents the third installment in the best-selling series that offers an honest counterpart to credulous media coverage about the risks of the coronavirus and ways to stop it.Unreported Truths Part 1 focused on the way we count deaths from COVID-19. Part 2 explained lockdowns. But Part 3 covers a topic even more central to our lives - the evidence that masks do or do not work to reduce the spread of the coronavirus.For months, public health experts have proclaimed, "My mask protects you, while yours protects me." Governments all over the world now make people wear face coverings in public. But the proof that masks do any good is far weaker than almost anyone understands.Like Parts 1 and 2, this section draws on primary sources like Centers for Disease Control and World Health Organization reports, along with news articles, government documents, and scientific papers. It will give you a new perspective on whether masks work - and the truthful and accurate information you need as the debate over mask requirements rages on.Please This booklet contains only the third section of Unreported Truths. Parts 1 and 2 are available separately.

39 pages, Paperback

Published November 24, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Alex Berenson

47 books1,735 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
727 (80%)
4 stars
138 (15%)
3 stars
22 (2%)
2 stars
9 (<1%)
1 star
11 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 107 reviews
Profile Image for Henry.
941 reviews82 followers
November 25, 2020
Just like the first two installments in Berenson's "Unreported Truths" series, he just reports the facts and the sources for them. Form your own conclusions
Profile Image for Bill Powers.
Author 3 books112 followers
December 1, 2020
Unreported Truths About Covid-19 and Lockdowns: Part 3: Masks


In part 3, Berenson focuses on the effectiveness of masks, in particular mandatory use of masks, on the spread of the virus. Some key take-aways:

• Despite the evidence that masks are of extremely marginal benefit at most for source control, public health authorities continue to insist on them. The most obvious reasons are not medical but political.
• The “good” reason is that masks are a visible totem that we are all working together against the coronavirus. We cannot all be physicians or nurses, but as they work to save lives, we all can sacrifice in this small way.
• But the worst reason of all is that mask mandates appear to be an effort by governments to find out what restrictions on their civil liberties people will accept on the thinnest possible evidence. They are the not-so-thin edge of the wedge. Today, we must wear masks. Tomorrow we’ll need negative Covid tests to travel between countries. Or vaccines to go to work. I wish masks worked. I wish we didn’t have to fight about them. But they don’t. And we do.

Berenson makes clear that N-95 masks do work. They only work the way they were designed if they are professionally fitted to the user, which most in our current circumstances are not. The surgical masks and regular cloth masks simply do not provide significant protection to the wearer or others near them.

Berenson has reviewed the data and presented the pros and cons of wearing a mask and allows us to come to our own conclusions. This neutral way of presenting “news” was once the norm. Unfortunately, today the “news” is mostly someone’s or some entity’s point of view to which we are expected to conform or be labeled whatever the derogatory “ist” term of the week is.

Again, Berenson has done an excellent job. This is what real reporting used to look like. It’s been a long time since I have seen it. I look forward to the continuation of this series. Every thinking person should read it!
Profile Image for Heather Hunter.
19 reviews
November 28, 2020
Mask unmasked

Thank you for bravely putting the truth out. You’ve also put all the source information right with what was written or said. It a sad time to live in an era that information and knowledge has advanced so far only to be censored. We see just how far positions can and will go.
Profile Image for Sean McGowan.
869 reviews35 followers
December 5, 2020
This series of booklets have been really helpful. They are written by a man that has spent the last year combing through all the research and evidence on everything from the effectiveness of lockdowns to the use of masks. This third installment is on the use of mask wearing. His conclusion, after piles of research and looking at studies from the past on the effectiveness of masks to prevent spread of respiratory illness to the present, is that masks are simply not effective in preventing spread. They neither protect you or other people. Highly recommended.
Profile Image for Mike.
715 reviews7 followers
December 5, 2020
I am amazed at the lack of press coverage for this book. I’m less amazed at the lack of science supporting a mask mandate. I’m more amazed at the willingness of so many people to be swayed by a political argument. I highly recommend this book!
Profile Image for Mika Auramo.
1,132 reviews37 followers
May 16, 2021
Yhdysvaltalaisen toimittaja-kirjailijan Alex Berensonin menestyssarja Unreported truths about covid-19 and lockdowns on tämän kirjan myötä kerinnyt kolmanteen osaan, ja nyt suurennuslasin alla ovat kasvomaskit.

Kirjasessa lähdetään raportoimaan kasvomaskeja koskevia (mediassa esitettyjä) väitteitä ja kuvitelmia. Lähteinä on käytetty monipuolisesti tutkimuksia, lehtiartikkeleita ja asiantuntijoiden ja politiikkojen Youtube-videoita. Yhdysvalloissakin Anthony Fauci aikoinaan sanoi ihan julkisesti, ettei kirurgisista kasvomaskeista ole mitään hyötyä, ja keväällä 2021 ääni on muuttunut kellossa, sillä niitä tyrkytetään pikkulapsillekin, vaikkei olekaan olemassa hyötyjä tukevaa tieteellistä näyttöä. Jos tarkkoja ollaan, markettimaskeja ei tulisi kutsua muuksi kuin hengityssuojaimiksi, ja niiden teho on olematon viruksia vastaan, eikä kirurgisia maskejakaan tulisi käyttää kirjoittajan mukaan hengityssuojaimina. Berenson listaa muutamia kliinisiä tutkimuksia, joiden mukaan on ylivoimaista näyttöä, etteivät kangas- ja kirurgiset naamiot suojaa käyttäjäänsä hengitystieviruksilta. Esimerkiksi keväällä 2020 Tanskassa järjestettiin 5000 tuhannen ihmisen tutkimus, jossa puolet käytti maskeja koko ajan ja toinen puoli ei. Johtopäätöksissä todettiin, ettei maskien käyttämättä jättäminen vaikuttanut tilastollisesti merkitsevästi Sars-Cov-2-infektoitumiseen. WHO:n mukaan (vielä kesäkuussa 2020) kasvomaskien hyödyllisyyttä ei kyetty tieteellisin tutkimuksin osoittamaan.

Aika usein törmää harhaluuloihin, että pärskiminen ja ilmassa leviävät isommat aerosolit olisivat syypäinä suurempaan sairastumisriskiin kuin normaali kanssakäyminen. Varmaan siksi Suomessakin on ollut kiellettyä karaoket baareissa ja toitotetaan turvaväleistä, jollaiset vaihtelevat metristä pariin metriin eri maissa. Berenson viittaa Kevin P. Fennellyn tutkimukseen, jossa osoitettiin, että alle viiden mikronin aerosolipartikkelit saattoivat sisältää jopa yhdeksän kertaa enemmän flunssavirusta kuin paljon isommat partikkelit (koronavirus on noin 0,1 mikronia).

Paljon on ollut julkisuudessa myös epäilyjä, että oireettomat koronapositiiviset olisivat todellinen uhka sairastuttaa muita, ja tässäkin asiassa muuan Fauci oli alkujaan (2020 tammikuussa) ihan eri linjoilla kuin nykyään, eikä hän pitänyt oireettomia koronapotilaita minkäänlaisena viruksen levittämisen uhkana. Vielä kesällä 2020 WHO:n epidemologi Maria Van Kerkhove julisti lehdistötilaisuudessa, että oireettomat koronapotilaat eivät tartuta tai se on erittäin harvinaista. Tässä välissä viitataan kiinalaiseen tutkimukseen Wuhanissa, jossa päädyttiin johtopäätökseen, että oireettomien tartuttavuus on enintään 0–2 prosentin luokkaa.

Lopputulemana voidaan Berensonia mukaillen todeta, että erityyppisten kasvomaskien käytöstä ja käyttöpakoista jokapäiväisessä elämässä on tullut pitkälti politisoitunutta kampanjointia, johon on saatu yhdistettyä tieteellistä spekulointia, tutkimustulosten ja erilaisten anekdoottien vahvaa liioittelua. On lisäksi luotu vimmaista sosiaalista painetta, ja maskeja käyttämättömiä on eri puolilla maailmaa demonisoitu milloin narsistisiksi sosiopaateiksi tai muuten vain omaa napaa tuijottaviksi itsekkäiksi idiooteiksi. Kasvonaamareista on ikään kuin tullut jonkinlainen julkinen toteemi, yhteenkuuluvaisuuden, tottelevaisuuden ja sosiaalisen vastuullisuuden symboli kanssaihmisillle: minä suojaan sinua ja sinä suojaat minua – vaikkei sille suojaamiselle näytä olevan luotettavia tieteellisiä perusteita. Toisaalta maskien massakäytöllä on vahva psykologinen pelotevaikutus: kukaan ei ole suojassa tältä ”tappajavirukselta”, ja parempi on vain painua rokotejonoon muiden jatkoksi kerta toisensa jälkeen…
231 reviews1 follower
December 3, 2020
Ring around the rosie

I've read the three of these pamphlets that have come out so far. My biases are libertarian and conservative. I am also in a vulnerable group having recently had open heart surgery. These are my take away from the series to date:
1- We can no better control a pandemic than could the Athenians, the Roman's or the English in the 17th century,
2-we are in the midst of a panic and the voices claiming to follow the science are following their hearts not their heads,
3-The government and media have ulterior motives for their countermeasures.
4-Alex needs pictures to bolster his arguments,
5-if we give up freedom for security we shall not long have either (Franklin paraphrased)
Profile Image for Traci Evans.
3 reviews
November 26, 2020
Another fantastic unreported truth

Unfortunately we don’t have a real independent mainstream media and a large part of the country believes any talking head’s opinion that masks work. It’s difficult to pull together the facts that they don’t, and this book is a great resource in that effort. As everything we get from our “leaders” regarding this virus seems to be ineffective, incorrect, and always leans toward the most totalitarian option, one must come to the conclusion that they are extremely stupid or worse. This ”2 week break to slow the spread” has caused far more death and destruction than the virus and WE the people must stand against this illiberal nonsense. We must not allow these totalitarians to steal our liberty.
Profile Image for Isaiah Espinoza.
138 reviews
November 27, 2020
Controversial

Johnny Rotten said it best,” Ever get the feeling you’re being cheated?” It’s been a thought in the back of my mind as I remember people like Fauci saying masks were not necessary before changing his mind. People think but are afraid to ask the question because they become a demonized kook. The infection rate is indeed going up and at least is my state, masks are required. So how effective is it? Masks are visible and create the illusion of safety. Stick with the one thing that has remained consistent, the N95 mask is effective.
28 reviews2 followers
November 27, 2020
The sheep won’t read this and if they did they wouldn’t accept it.

I’m astounded at what people in the United States will trade for a little perceived security. “Civil rights? Sure, you can take them as long as I’m not the 2 in 1,000 people that might die of COVID.” The founding fathers would be shocked at what ignorant cowards most Americans have become.
Profile Image for james .
287 reviews48 followers
September 5, 2023
Cleaning up the old Kindle. I've previously read this series of booklets from Alex Berenson.

The topic is of course demagogued by the extreme ends of the spectrum, little if any middling position, highly politicized, and often ignoring actual facts by those of both sides on the topic.

In part the confusion and angst is magnified by media, low-information people, and the inevitable vague (intentional or not) use of terms.

To the latter, much confusion exists when the simple word of 'mask' was bandied about and seldom did those saying the word specify what type of mask they were referring to.

I found this work well written with a good deal of reference citations available publicly. That is not to say I either endorse or reject the conclusions; just that the author supports his arguments with academic references as opposed to being a simple opinion fluff piece. As to the validity of his conclusions, you'll have to make up your own mind.
Profile Image for Richard Grebenc.
353 reviews17 followers
December 1, 2020
It is good to get various perspectives, especially on matters as serious as the pandemic. One always has to ask: Who benefits from actions taken and advice given (or mandated) in a given situation? Many officials and organizations have taken to heart Winston Churchill's words: "Never let a good crisis go to waste.”
Profile Image for R.J. Thyme.
2 reviews
November 28, 2020
aweful... terrible arguments and very biased. I don't have an opinion of masks but this guy is awful at making unbiased writings. His arguments are weaker than the ones he rails against. the slightest bit of critical thinking and you can see right through this guy
Profile Image for BARBARA KINER.
1 review2 followers
December 8, 2020
A must read!

Alex Berenson does his homework and then produces valuable information that is unbiased, simple facts, which are hard to find these days. The information that he provides for us is unavailable unless we have the time and ability to do the extensive research he has done and is vital for all of us to incorporate into our thinking in order to make the important decisions we need to make during this difficult time, this pandemic.
Profile Image for Priscilla.
53 reviews2 followers
December 8, 2020
Another amazing book about the C19

I never thought this book would show so much evidence about masks. I mean, the thing is made out of a piece of thin paper and the sides are not sealed on the side of your face. In the end, I think it is just a common curiosity kind of thing.
I really hope there is a few more installments of Alex Barenson's c19 series.
Where I live, a bandana is considered safe, even though the entire botton is free and you and breath normally.
Profile Image for Jim Dowdell.
195 reviews15 followers
December 17, 2020
This little pamphlet shows the real science that you can follow. The government response to COVID is a scam exposed. The take away from this booklet is to wonder what country we live in now.
I strongly recommend that everyone read this and then maybe we can demand to return to the old normal.
3 reviews
November 25, 2020
Science is as science does.

Just straight forward facts and the science to back them up. At a cost just a little above the N95 I must continue to wear to see patients. Sigh...
Profile Image for Amit GR.
55 reviews1 follower
December 6, 2020
Again, the voice of reason

I’m a physician and I have been following this calamity since the beginning. What’s astounding is that most of us are willing to give up on reason and science because we have been told to be afraid — I have become the “crazy heretic” who wants to see science before giving in. Shame on all of us for forgetting what courage and science looks like and, instead, becoming fearful drones at the beck and call of charlatans like Fauci and (cough) the WHO
1 review
December 5, 2020
Fact checked. Science based. Yes and yes.

As with part 1 & 2, part three is well done and utilized validated and credible sources. Something I wish our “journalists” on our so called news outlets could provide. Everyone wants the “fast food” version of news, meaning they don’t want to take the time to ensure the news is credible with solid sources of true science. You don’t get the fast food version here. Berenson provides all the sources that are highly credible. Thanks Mr. Berenson.
6 reviews1 follower
November 26, 2020
Once again, Alex Berenson cuts through the conventional narrative and explores (with extensive footnotes) what the scientists are ACTUALLY saying about the effectiveness of masks in stopping the spread of COVID-19. Unfortunately for those who view masking with almost a religious fervor, the news is not good. Despite the press hype, most masks have been proven to NOT stop the small viral particles, and masking has become method of "virtue signalling" and showing that people are "on the team". Unfortunately, the tiny virus particles don't care all that much about whether you use a mask or not. However, Mr. Berenson does not dwell too much on this social aspect, with the majority of the book being on the reports of the actual scientific and epidemic studies. As he says repeatedly, he wishes masks worked, but they really don't.

It should be noted that this third installment of this series was again almost censored by some "WOKE weenie" at Amazon. Although it goes against "conventional wisdom" this book is not "disinformation", but primarily a compilation of existing reports from credible sources. IMHO, WOKE means "WithOut Knowledge and Experience". I wish that people at Amazon would stop trying to decide what we should see and let us decide for ourselves whether something is worthwhile.
5 reviews
Read
November 28, 2020
A Straightforward Cited Account About the Efficacy of Masks in Public Settings

Berenson lays out the facts without spin or cherry picking data.
He is clear and concise and fully supports his points with sourced research and documentation. He treats his readers with respect unlike writers and journalists who lecture their audiences with hyperbole and the use of testimonials. This is a must read for anyone who feels that decisions affecting the masses should be based upon a critical analysis of all the data.
43 reviews5 followers
November 29, 2020
Mask Totem

This Part 3 was very informative and easier to understand than the previous 2 Parts. Personally, I never thought masks did anything but wore it as a totem. It’s unfortunate that the people in power don’t investigate issues so that they can make fully informed decisions. Evidently, politicians are not concerned with science but only how far they can push the issue to seize our rights.
3 reviews
November 26, 2020
Follow the science. Really follow the science.

Berenson does this, providing many current and historic studies on whether masking helps anything involving spreading or protecting viral inspections. He is also frank in noting the emotional and political forces which are at play in the COVID-19 world, and reversals of position by health officials following governmental masking policy actions. We are being deceived about masking effectiveness in order to support political masking policy, against the evidence provided by science.
435 reviews1 follower
February 5, 2021
A different viewpoint about mask wearing. It's not a political viewpoint, but one based on facts and studies. In a free society, people should be able to get opposing viewpoints and make their own decisions. Unfortunately, even in our country, this is no longer the case.
If you want read the information given by the CDC, WHO, Dr. Fauci, and all the rest of the experts BEFORE mask wearing became political, read this book.
Profile Image for Chad.
328 reviews
August 19, 2021
Solid information with sources sited.
2 reviews
November 26, 2020
Bucks the “sky is falling” media narrative

In short there are no clinical trials to prove masks work. I would wager 95 percent of mask pushers wouldn’t have a clue as to what their vitamin D level currently is. I wonder what the men that charged the beaches at Normandy would think about this pitiful generation.
181 reviews
November 1, 2021
As in the previous booklets the author argues that masks are only effective when N95 are used which are expensive but surgical masks which most people use only protect 50%. Hence no need to impose them! Indeed surgical masks are not a perfect protection but 50% protection is certainly not negligible.
Profile Image for Leib Mitchell.
574 reviews13 followers
March 31, 2021
Book Review
5 stars
Tonic for maskholes
*******

The purpose of my reading this book was by way of seeking explanation.

1. Why are these infections NOT as virulent as what people would believe if they read the newspaper?

-I happen to be (somewhat) Haredi, and at our synagogue, we have not been wearing masks since a couple of months after Purim last year.

-We have four Kollels in this city where people sit in the same room with each other for hours and hours on end every single day 5 days a week with no masks, and there have been exactly zero illnesses / deaths.

Why?

2. Why does the spread of the disease not seem to depend on masks?

It seems like there have been several (Stateside) waves of the disease, and they don't seem to depend on masking, which has only gotten more intense over time.

Why didn't the disease just vanish as mask use went up?

3. These studies cited by "experts" suggest a lot of things that seem to be empirically false. Could it be because they are laboratory studies that (typically) have low external validity?

Could it be because they are observational studies?

In vitro studies?

*******

In addition to those questions, what did I learn that I didn't quite come expecting?

1. Not all masks are equal, and the masks that really do filter out coronavirus particles are so expensive and technical as to be impractical. (N95 respirators have to be fitted.)

2. Even if you have a mask that is not sealed all the way around, wearing a mask to prevent escape of 0.1-micron size particles is the logical equivalent of having a pool with a peeing section and a non-peeing section.

3. Yes, there are actually studies out there that demonstrate that the type of masks that Joe Everyman can buy at Walmart have no effect. And at least one of these studies that Berenson cited was published something like three quarters of a century ago.

4. There is a randomized trial that was done in Denmark that Berenson cites: 5,000 people, half with masks and half without. After one month, there were 53 people infected in the maskless group compared to 42 in the masked group. (Not much different to chance.)

5. (Who even thought of this?): Viral load varies with droplet size, and some droplet sizes transmit the disease much better than others. Droplet size is not constant, but more like a (Gaussian/other) distribution. The mechanics work out such that the overwhelming majority of masks are not helpful.

6. There are a lot of reversals on the part of the government over time. sometimes the virus is transmitted asymptomatically, and other times it is not. Seems to only depend on the political pressure of moment.

7. WHO epidemiologists have done contact tracing, and they do not find secondary transmissions from asymptomatic people. (Maria vanKerkhove).

8. China tested 10 million people in Wuhan, and they found 303 positive tests. 100% of whom were asymptomatic. And zero further positives from 1,174 close contacts of same.

*******
Some things that I already know, but which bear repeating:

1. On one end of the ontinuum of evidence is anecdotes, and on the other is double blind /randomized trials. There are other tools in between, but much of the current research that feeds into The Hysteria is closer to the anecdotal end.

2. Asymptomatic transmission really is not a thing. or, at least, it is not a thing about which we should be worried. (Fauci, at press conference: ".....in all the history of respiratory born viruses of any type, asymptomatic transmission has never been the driver of outbreaks. The driver of outbreaks is always a symptomatic person.")

3. The masking arguments are NOT about disease transmission, but more about: i) virtue signaling and; ii) the development/testing of a tool that is meant to infringe upon civil liberties.

*******

One minor quibble, and that is that it is completely inappropriate to refer to a "theory" as "proven."

*******

These broadsides are starting to get better with time.

In Berenson's last book, half of the pages were blank and his reference formatting was not good.

That has been improved here.

No wasted pages, but no page numbers that I can reference.

Verdict: I recommend this book a bit more strongly than the other two because the chain of the evidence is much longer. The earliest cited paper here was from 1945.

Even if you had to purchase all three of the books separately, and you spent an extra five bucks it would be worth it to calm your mental health down.

A mass psychosis/panic is simultaneously quite trite/interesting to watch, but I can't live it. And no one else should, either.

And in that case, these broadsides are priceless.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 107 reviews