I preordered this book 6 months ago after it was mentioned in the SF&F group and I read this in the description: "Flowers for the Sea is a dark, dazzling debut novella that reads like Rosemary's Baby by way of Octavia E. Butler."
Uhh, yes please.
Then I promptly forgot about the book, and having preordered it. I am not a preorderer. I can count on both hands with fingers left over the number of books that I've preordered in my life, so, when this book, or novella, appeared in my kindle a few weeks ago, I was like "What the heck is this?"
I quickly remembered once I reread the book description though, and then I got excited to read it.
And now I've read it, and... yeah. I wouldn't say that Rosemary's Baby is an apt comparison... but it's not NOT apt? It just depends on what you take from Rosemary's Baby, I guess. They do both deal with unusual pregnancies, but to me, that's where the similarities end.
For me, Rosemary's Baby is less about the baby than it is about the gaslighting and the abuse and the cult and the rape and the manipulation and use of Rosemary herself. It's HER story, to me. The story of the plot to use her to obtain the baby she carries. The baby is just the end goal, one that she has no part in aside from incubator.
But in Flowers for the Sea, those external to our main character have no part to play in her pregnancy (other than sperm donation, obviously), or how it develops - all of that is dependent on who Iraxi is, and her own heritage and history and destiny. It's all about her - not external forces acting on her, as with Rosemary.
Anyway, all of that being said, I really did like this. My disagreement with the description comparison isn't a negative, it just set an expectation for a story that the author didn't write. I liked the story she DID write though, quite a lot. It's visceral, gritty, raw, and so, so angry. We don't have all of the history, all of the context, but what we do have is enough. This is the kind of story that only offers a bit of itself, but makes you want to examine and re-examine for more. All of the edges are hazy and undefined, but the points are sharp as needles.