What do you think?
Rate this book
All Come to Dust
Marcia Pullman has been found dead at home in the leafy
suburbs of Bulawayo. Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is onto
the case at once, but it becomes increasingly clear that there
are those, including the dead woman’s husband, who do not
want him asking questions.
suburbs of Bulawayo. Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is onto
the case at once, but it becomes increasingly clear that there
are those, including the dead woman’s husband, who do not
want him asking questions.
500 pages, Paperback
First published May 11, 2021
3 people are currently reading
64 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 35 reviews
March 3, 2022
This second novel by African author Bryony Rheam is crime fiction, a contrast to her earlier historical debut novel a decade ago. All Come to Dust introduces Chief Inspector Edmund Dube as he investigates the stabbing of a wealthy woman, Marcia Pullman. It is then discovered she died due to kidney failure and he is denied access to the case, police records and removed from the case. A series of flashbacks to 1979 provide Edmund’s backstory as he continues to investigate. A gentle paced police procedural with subtle insights into race, class, mental health, memory and colonialism as played out in the city of Bulawayo, Zimbabwe. Fiction’s newest memorable police detective makes for a pleasant read and three-and-a-half-star. With thanks to Parthian Books and the author, for an uncorrected advanced review copy for review purposes. As always, the opinions herein are totally my own and freely given, without persuasion.
February 20, 2022
When Marcia Pullman is found stabbed in her home in the Zimbabwean town of Bulawayo, Chief Inspector Edmund Dube has not the slightest idea what hornets’ net he is kicking. The seemingly nice and neat business woman obviously had some side affairs rather on the dark side and knew how to make people comply with her rules. Not only is the case complex, also in his police station Edmund is confronted with obstacles, someone tries to boycott his investigation. But he has learnt how life works and his ethics keep him fighting for truth no matter how many spanners are thrown in his works.
Bryony Rheam’s mystery “All Come to Dust” is a kind of classic murder investigation deeply rooted in the Zimbabwe culture. Many aspects of the novel can only happen in such surroundings and are a prerequisite to develop in the first place. The protagonist is a lonely wolf with a complex character and background who determinedly follows his mission.
What I liked most was how the complexity of the story slowly unfolds. What seems to be a rather simple case motivated by well-known motives, turns out to be an actual net of diverse motivations and intentions the characters follow. It is hard to detect where the actual danger comes from and with the protagonist fighting his own battles while solving a crime, the novel provides mysteries on different levels.
Even though the plot is masterly crafted, I found it a bit lengthy at times and would have preferred a more straight-forward investigation. The character development is also brilliantly done, but this also leads to a diversion of the actual mystery plot.
An interesting read which provided me with a lot of insight into a culture completely unknown to me.
Bryony Rheam’s mystery “All Come to Dust” is a kind of classic murder investigation deeply rooted in the Zimbabwe culture. Many aspects of the novel can only happen in such surroundings and are a prerequisite to develop in the first place. The protagonist is a lonely wolf with a complex character and background who determinedly follows his mission.
What I liked most was how the complexity of the story slowly unfolds. What seems to be a rather simple case motivated by well-known motives, turns out to be an actual net of diverse motivations and intentions the characters follow. It is hard to detect where the actual danger comes from and with the protagonist fighting his own battles while solving a crime, the novel provides mysteries on different levels.
Even though the plot is masterly crafted, I found it a bit lengthy at times and would have preferred a more straight-forward investigation. The character development is also brilliantly done, but this also leads to a diversion of the actual mystery plot.
An interesting read which provided me with a lot of insight into a culture completely unknown to me.
November 14, 2021
Byrony Rheam's well-crafted murder mystery takes a hard look at life in contemporary Zimbabwe. Much of the story takes place in a historically white suburb of Bulawayo. Several of the inhabitants are hard up after the runaway inflation, but those who have access to hard currency – in one way or another – are doing much better. The latter include Marcia Pullman and her husband who run a tour operation, but they clearly have many lucrative side interests.
Then Marcia is discovered dead in her home with a letter opener sticking out of her chest. Chief Inspector Edmund Dube goes to the scene, having wheedled a lift from a man at the police station who is arguing about a speeding fine. Dube realizes that there’s not enough blood and it’s clear that the victim was dead before she was stabbed. The pathologist, a friend of Marcia’s husband, agrees and says she died of natural causes. Nevertheless, the question of why she was stabbed remains. The crime is laid at the door of the recently dismissed gardener, but Edmund believes there's a lot more to it than that. However, the senior officers at the police station seem intent on thwarting his efforts to get to the bottom of the case.
Edmund identifies a cast of suspects: Marcia’s husband; the Pullmans’ maid and gardener; the peculiar neighbor; Janet Peters who was bullied by her, and has an invalid mother; a mysterious woman interested in Marcia's old records; and Craig Martin, who has publicly threatened her.
Superficially, the novel seems to follow the usual tropes of the detective story genre, but as the author delves into Edmund's past, the book's rich characterizations and subtle surprises remind one more of PD James than Agatha Christie. Nothing is as it seems.
My pick for the best African mystery of 2021.
Then Marcia is discovered dead in her home with a letter opener sticking out of her chest. Chief Inspector Edmund Dube goes to the scene, having wheedled a lift from a man at the police station who is arguing about a speeding fine. Dube realizes that there’s not enough blood and it’s clear that the victim was dead before she was stabbed. The pathologist, a friend of Marcia’s husband, agrees and says she died of natural causes. Nevertheless, the question of why she was stabbed remains. The crime is laid at the door of the recently dismissed gardener, but Edmund believes there's a lot more to it than that. However, the senior officers at the police station seem intent on thwarting his efforts to get to the bottom of the case.
Edmund identifies a cast of suspects: Marcia’s husband; the Pullmans’ maid and gardener; the peculiar neighbor; Janet Peters who was bullied by her, and has an invalid mother; a mysterious woman interested in Marcia's old records; and Craig Martin, who has publicly threatened her.
Superficially, the novel seems to follow the usual tropes of the detective story genre, but as the author delves into Edmund's past, the book's rich characterizations and subtle surprises remind one more of PD James than Agatha Christie. Nothing is as it seems.
My pick for the best African mystery of 2021.
November 5, 2021
I enjoyed the glimpses into Zimbabwe, and the story was entertaining, although needs a little work. It dragged out a bit and then became rushed, although overall a pleasant read.
Thanks to NetGalley, Parthian Books, and Bryony Rheam for my ARC.
Thanks to NetGalley, Parthian Books, and Bryony Rheam for my ARC.
January 29, 2022
The premise and description of this book was intriguing. The reading experience was not. Unfortunately this story wasn’t for me. The pacing was too slow to keep my attention. None of the characters were memorable.
Thank you to the publisher through Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to the publisher through Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
May 23, 2022
I am still recovering my deep love of reading following way too much time at home and isolated with world events overshadowing the pull of fiction. I chose this book because - mystery! That's always been a go-to genre in bad times. This book starts out strong and reveals its unexpected depth as it progresses. This is no Precious Ramotswe tale - as much as I enjoy those. Not only are social, political and personal issues present to give flavor to the stew. They become the meat and give the novel its heft. Thanks to NetGalley for providing an excellent reading experience.
July 19, 2021
“All Come to Dust” is a long-simmering stew, with the raw-ingredients of an old-fashioned detective mystery and the mélange of spices of post-colonial Zimbabwe breaking down and melding together to offer up something far more than you might have expected when you started. The writing itself is incredibly patient, only revealing itself slowly and at its own measured pace. But within it Rheam is able to slowly develop an assortment of characters. Each time we revisit someone we learn more about them, forcing us to be patient as they reveal themselves. Similarly, the sense of place is intense. I have never visited Zimbabwe, but the writing instantly brought me to Bulawayo, from the scent of the flowers in the trees to the piles of utterly useless bureaucratic paperwork at the police station. Without ever being heavy handed, the occasional use of vernacular language combined with really specific sensory descriptions to really make the setting its own character, and one that affects every other character in their own way.
The characters are well drawn out, if slowly, just playing on enough of tropes or archetypes to let the reader assume they know something prematurely. The story itself is both riveting and small, or enclosed, at the same time. It takes its time unspooling, and offers enough red herrings mixed with its clues along the way that you want to keep reading and don’t feel cheated out of a proper resolution. All the while it is a portrait of how class, race, and gender still function in contemporary Zimbabwe, not as much an indictment as it is just a laying bare of how injustice and privilege are still baked into everyday life, and the efforts different people take to escape such social shackles.
If you’re interested in a compelling detective story, you can find that here, and although surely this novel wraps itself in that affectation it is more than that. It was a joy to read, even as it slowed me down and insisted I take it at its own pace. Every aspect, from characters, to story, to writing, was deliberate and nothing felt rushed or hackneyed. The latter third of the book did feel a little more rushed than the first parts, though that is part and parcel with whodunits. There were some things that wrapped up a little too neatly, or quickly, again common in the genre but it didn’t feel entirely fitting with the rest of the story. It wasn’t enough to feel unearned, though, and the incredibly memorable primary character, who himself was more than just a copy-and-paste genre detective but actually someone who experienced growth and development throughout the story, was more than enough to give this novel high marks and a hearty recommendation.
I want to thank NetGalley and Parthian Books, who gave me a complimentary eARC in exchange for an honest review.
The characters are well drawn out, if slowly, just playing on enough of tropes or archetypes to let the reader assume they know something prematurely. The story itself is both riveting and small, or enclosed, at the same time. It takes its time unspooling, and offers enough red herrings mixed with its clues along the way that you want to keep reading and don’t feel cheated out of a proper resolution. All the while it is a portrait of how class, race, and gender still function in contemporary Zimbabwe, not as much an indictment as it is just a laying bare of how injustice and privilege are still baked into everyday life, and the efforts different people take to escape such social shackles.
If you’re interested in a compelling detective story, you can find that here, and although surely this novel wraps itself in that affectation it is more than that. It was a joy to read, even as it slowed me down and insisted I take it at its own pace. Every aspect, from characters, to story, to writing, was deliberate and nothing felt rushed or hackneyed. The latter third of the book did feel a little more rushed than the first parts, though that is part and parcel with whodunits. There were some things that wrapped up a little too neatly, or quickly, again common in the genre but it didn’t feel entirely fitting with the rest of the story. It wasn’t enough to feel unearned, though, and the incredibly memorable primary character, who himself was more than just a copy-and-paste genre detective but actually someone who experienced growth and development throughout the story, was more than enough to give this novel high marks and a hearty recommendation.
I want to thank NetGalley and Parthian Books, who gave me a complimentary eARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 29, 2021
Crime fiction with a central detective character is a favourite staple on the bookshelves. All Come To Dust by Bryony Rheam takes the stereotypes, shakes them out of the box and upends expectations. The first few pages take the reader into an “other” place, familiar yet strange. The colours, smells and the noises of suburban Bulawayo are woven throughout this book, creating an atmosphere that leaves a lingering smell of hot concrete, bright bloom bursts and a coating of orange dust on the tongue. A post colonial world that has aged relics from Britain trying to cling on to an outdated way of life while the pulse and chaos of modern Zimbabwe strains to burst through underneath.
Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is a diligent police officer who works methodically with a razor sharp instinct for the truth. Polite, deferential and softly spoken, he’s a man who puts up with the broken typewriters, scuffed shoes and the down at heel environs of his shabby Bulawayo police station. He realises not only is he the wrong person for the job, he is in the wrong place at the wrong time. Forced to ask for a lift from a stranger because the only working police car is being used elsewhere, he is light years away from his cherished schoolboy reading book world of traditional English policing.
At first slightly comical and almost pathetic – we soon come to realise that Edmund Dube is a sharp observant operator.
He is no Adam Dalgleish, Morse or even Poirot but could stand shoulder to shoulder with those literary detective creations as he starts his crime solving. The novel flits between present day and Dube’s 1970s upbringing in a world that has slowly disappeared. A bright African schoolboy, Dube’s childhood memories provide clues to his personality and deliver an intriguing mystery story arc.
Victim Marcia Pullman is the typical suburban social climber, a bully and a snob. Her murder – behind the closed security gates of a house staffed with sullen servants and an obnoxious husband – sparks a classic detective whodunnit. Bryony Rheam deftly draws a colourful cast of believable characters that have flaws, secrets and many human failings.
Chief Inspector Dube has to battle against corruption, ingrained racism and class prejudice as he works his way to the book’s conclusion. Bryony Rheam has created a richly detailed, hugely enjoyable and satisfying crime novel, dense with clues, twists and turns. It’s no surprise that this book has already gained prestigious awards in her native country.
A murder mystery with an African aura that refreshingly skews traditional reference points for English language crime fiction.
Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is a diligent police officer who works methodically with a razor sharp instinct for the truth. Polite, deferential and softly spoken, he’s a man who puts up with the broken typewriters, scuffed shoes and the down at heel environs of his shabby Bulawayo police station. He realises not only is he the wrong person for the job, he is in the wrong place at the wrong time. Forced to ask for a lift from a stranger because the only working police car is being used elsewhere, he is light years away from his cherished schoolboy reading book world of traditional English policing.
At first slightly comical and almost pathetic – we soon come to realise that Edmund Dube is a sharp observant operator.
He is no Adam Dalgleish, Morse or even Poirot but could stand shoulder to shoulder with those literary detective creations as he starts his crime solving. The novel flits between present day and Dube’s 1970s upbringing in a world that has slowly disappeared. A bright African schoolboy, Dube’s childhood memories provide clues to his personality and deliver an intriguing mystery story arc.
Victim Marcia Pullman is the typical suburban social climber, a bully and a snob. Her murder – behind the closed security gates of a house staffed with sullen servants and an obnoxious husband – sparks a classic detective whodunnit. Bryony Rheam deftly draws a colourful cast of believable characters that have flaws, secrets and many human failings.
Chief Inspector Dube has to battle against corruption, ingrained racism and class prejudice as he works his way to the book’s conclusion. Bryony Rheam has created a richly detailed, hugely enjoyable and satisfying crime novel, dense with clues, twists and turns. It’s no surprise that this book has already gained prestigious awards in her native country.
A murder mystery with an African aura that refreshingly skews traditional reference points for English language crime fiction.
August 1, 2021
All Come to Dust is a novel by a Zimbabwean set in modern Zimbabwe. On the surface it is a classic—and very complex—mystery. But I felt throughout as though there was a literary novel behind the scenes attempting to show itself behind the screen of a conventional mystery. The writing is often quite lovely, and the story is told from various points of view, each one shedding light not only on the diverse characters but also on the details of living in Zimbabwe. Add to this the fact that much of the suspense concerns the characters’ pasts, not the present murders of a disliked middle-class white woman, and you have a book that feels much more like literary fiction than a genre novel.
The mystery suffers somewhat. Its resolution is extremely clever, with one of those endings where you discover that every character’s story is an interlocking piece of the puzzle; but the clues leading up to the resolution are somewhat murky, often requiring cultural knowledge the average reader may not have (I didn’t). It takes a plot strategist and practiced writer like Agatha Christie to pull off the sleight of hand of showing the clues in such a way as to make them ignored but present enough in the subconscious for an “Aha—that was it!” moment at the end. This was not such a mystery, though it has enough of the trappings of a mystery to make the reader wonder exactly what it is trying to be. The reader who wants to be sure of the clues may need to reread the book—and this is a book that would stand up to rereading, primarily because of the vivid picture of Zimbabwe.
I found myself highlighting often, because of the vivid passages about Zimbabwe. Bryony Rheam’s slow, observant, and graceful writing calls to life the dusty roads, the smell of grasses, and the blossoms tossing in the trees, while limning an elderly generation of impoverished British non-leavers, a sleazy group of exploitative whites, and a mixed race underclass attempting only to find a job and make a contented life in a country where not even the electricity and water can be relied on. Bryany Rheam writes of this country with authority and astuteness. In Zimbabwe, she has found her ordained setting. I am not certain that the mystery is her genre. But I am sure she is a writer to watch; and I look forward to her next book with considerable eagerness.
I would like to think @netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review @allcometodust. I appreciated the opportunity to read such an intriguing study of another country by an author to watch.
The mystery suffers somewhat. Its resolution is extremely clever, with one of those endings where you discover that every character’s story is an interlocking piece of the puzzle; but the clues leading up to the resolution are somewhat murky, often requiring cultural knowledge the average reader may not have (I didn’t). It takes a plot strategist and practiced writer like Agatha Christie to pull off the sleight of hand of showing the clues in such a way as to make them ignored but present enough in the subconscious for an “Aha—that was it!” moment at the end. This was not such a mystery, though it has enough of the trappings of a mystery to make the reader wonder exactly what it is trying to be. The reader who wants to be sure of the clues may need to reread the book—and this is a book that would stand up to rereading, primarily because of the vivid picture of Zimbabwe.
I found myself highlighting often, because of the vivid passages about Zimbabwe. Bryony Rheam’s slow, observant, and graceful writing calls to life the dusty roads, the smell of grasses, and the blossoms tossing in the trees, while limning an elderly generation of impoverished British non-leavers, a sleazy group of exploitative whites, and a mixed race underclass attempting only to find a job and make a contented life in a country where not even the electricity and water can be relied on. Bryany Rheam writes of this country with authority and astuteness. In Zimbabwe, she has found her ordained setting. I am not certain that the mystery is her genre. But I am sure she is a writer to watch; and I look forward to her next book with considerable eagerness.
I would like to think @netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review @allcometodust. I appreciated the opportunity to read such an intriguing study of another country by an author to watch.
October 26, 2021
Marcia Pullman lay on her bed seemingly asleep, a small red rug lay across her legs and on the bedside table next to her was a half-full glass of water. If it weren't for the silver letter opener sticking out of her chest and the small bud of crimson that bloomed from where the blade went in, there was nothing whatsoever out of the ordinary about the scene.
"All Come to Dust" is a delightful Zimbabwean crime novel about a victim everyone hated, a detective determined to solve the mystery surrounding her death, and a host of possible suspects. Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is baffled by Marcia Pullman's early demise. Someone stabbed her, although it looks like she may have died before this happened. So, why would someone bother if the victim was already dead?
As soon as he begins to investigate, Edmund realises people close to and around Marcia are hiding things. The woman who discovered the body was a victim of Marcia's cruelty, while the latter's maid is avoiding giving answers about her movements on the day Marcia died. Marcia's husband seems to have connections high up in the largely corrupt police force, and another man is drawn into the saga after threatening to kill Marcia.
This is an interesting and often quirky examination of a crime that isn't a crime, investigated by a man who takes inspiration from books and movies. The reader is given the viewpoints of all the suspects, though it's hard to trust any of their narratives.
My only gripe with the book is that the large number of revelations are squeezed into only a couple of chapters at the end, making it feel a bit rushed. Otherwise, this is a highly enjoyable book, not only examining an interesting 'crime' but taking a look at a section of contemporary Zimbabwean society.
February 17, 2022
An interesting start, a plot full of promises but the story didn't keep my attention and feel flat.
Not my cup of tea.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine
Not my cup of tea.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine
April 21, 2022
Well, what an unexpected gem.
All Comes To Dust tells the story of black Police Officer Edmund investigating the murder of wealthy ex-pat Marcia Pullman in modern day Zimbabwe. I think the book succeeds because it engages the reader on many levels.
Firstly there is an excellent, convoluted, multi-layered murder mystery ala Agatha Christie or PD James. Or I should say there are three mysteries at play. Who (if anyone) murdered Marcia Pullman, who defiled her corpse and what happened to the McDougal family. The McDougal family were Edmund's mother's employers who took a special interest in Edmund, ensuring that he got a good education. However, one day during Edmund's childhood they just disappeared.
There is also a slightly comedic/tragic aspect to Edmund. He is a very shy, bookish introvert bumbling along in his investigation. He finds a collaborator in semi-alcoholic,white-trash, handyman Craig. Craig is a cynical and resentful man. Set this against the incompetent and corrupt background of the comically under resourced Zimbabwe Police Force and it can make for a situation ripe for ridicule.
In addition the author offers some very interesting takes on a culture that is alien to most western readers and one that would also seem to be in a slow decline. She gives a fascinating insight into the once powerful but now diminishing white Zimbabwe/ ex Rhodesian community.
As well as the regional insights into class, culture and colour of her community, the author also portrays parts of the universal human experience very well. Loneliness, religion, despair and hope are deftly handled. How the past comes back constantly and intertwines with the present is also a thread through out this intriguing novel.
The first part of the novel is steadily paced, but ramps towards the end and the denouement. Where Edmund gathers the suspects together and goes through their various, nefarious and complicated intrigues one by one. If there was a tweak to be made, I think the complex plot and numerous back stories, while all well done, means the narrative is possibly slightly too long.
I started this book expecting a bog standard cozy crime caper. I was pleasantly surprised. The balance of cozy to crime was just how I like it. The hinterland of excellent socio-political with a philosophical tinge writing was a huge bonus.
grumpyoldbooks.blogspot.com
All Comes To Dust tells the story of black Police Officer Edmund investigating the murder of wealthy ex-pat Marcia Pullman in modern day Zimbabwe. I think the book succeeds because it engages the reader on many levels.
Firstly there is an excellent, convoluted, multi-layered murder mystery ala Agatha Christie or PD James. Or I should say there are three mysteries at play. Who (if anyone) murdered Marcia Pullman, who defiled her corpse and what happened to the McDougal family. The McDougal family were Edmund's mother's employers who took a special interest in Edmund, ensuring that he got a good education. However, one day during Edmund's childhood they just disappeared.
There is also a slightly comedic/tragic aspect to Edmund. He is a very shy, bookish introvert bumbling along in his investigation. He finds a collaborator in semi-alcoholic,white-trash, handyman Craig. Craig is a cynical and resentful man. Set this against the incompetent and corrupt background of the comically under resourced Zimbabwe Police Force and it can make for a situation ripe for ridicule.
In addition the author offers some very interesting takes on a culture that is alien to most western readers and one that would also seem to be in a slow decline. She gives a fascinating insight into the once powerful but now diminishing white Zimbabwe/ ex Rhodesian community.
As well as the regional insights into class, culture and colour of her community, the author also portrays parts of the universal human experience very well. Loneliness, religion, despair and hope are deftly handled. How the past comes back constantly and intertwines with the present is also a thread through out this intriguing novel.
The first part of the novel is steadily paced, but ramps towards the end and the denouement. Where Edmund gathers the suspects together and goes through their various, nefarious and complicated intrigues one by one. If there was a tweak to be made, I think the complex plot and numerous back stories, while all well done, means the narrative is possibly slightly too long.
I started this book expecting a bog standard cozy crime caper. I was pleasantly surprised. The balance of cozy to crime was just how I like it. The hinterland of excellent socio-political with a philosophical tinge writing was a huge bonus.
grumpyoldbooks.blogspot.com
March 5, 2022
To simply describe this beautifully written, densely textured, novel as a murder mystery would be an egregious understatement. To describe it as a police procedural, or a maverick cop, or a psychological thriller – for it is all of these – would similarly undersell it. To set the scene, the story centres around Edmund Dube, a black Zimbabwean, at two specific points in his life. In 1979, aged seven (the Jesuitical age when personality is formed), he is almost the only non-white pupil at a prestigious school in Bulawayo, Rhodesia. His access to the school had been facilitated by Chief Inspector McDougal, for whom Edmund’s mother worked as a maid. Now, in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe, he is Detective Chief Inspector Edmund Dube. The cultural shifts evidenced in that name change underpin this book but are subliminal not overt. The reader doesn’t need to know the history because the writing provides the ambience.
When a woman is reported as murdered, Edmund rushes off to investigate and quickly establishes that the paperknife buried in the centre of her chest is not the murder weapon, because she was dead before she was stabbed. The deceased is a white woman, Marcia Pullman, part of the dwindling number of such individuals, rich, influential, a pillar of society and detested by almost everyone. Her husband is a beefy, obnoxious, functioning alcoholic who, on the face of it, runs a safari company. Both of these sound like stereotypes, caricatures, but in this writer’s hands they are neither. Edmund begins an investigation but is swiftly removed from the case (if a natural death embellished with a dagger actually constitutes a case) and side-lined, ridiculed. Clearly the Pullman’s have enormous influence within this kleptocracy. Edmund, and an unlikely (indeed random) assistant, must try to resolve if there is a murder; if so who is the murderer; what illegal activities surround the Pullman’s apparent control of the local powers-that-be? And what connection, if any, is there with his childhood?
The quality of the writing, the skilful use of metaphor, the sense of place, the depth of the characterisation, the intricacy of the plot, combine to produce a singular work. This book is way above five stars.
I would like to thank NetGalley, the publishers and the author for providing me with a draft proof copy for the purpose of this review.
When a woman is reported as murdered, Edmund rushes off to investigate and quickly establishes that the paperknife buried in the centre of her chest is not the murder weapon, because she was dead before she was stabbed. The deceased is a white woman, Marcia Pullman, part of the dwindling number of such individuals, rich, influential, a pillar of society and detested by almost everyone. Her husband is a beefy, obnoxious, functioning alcoholic who, on the face of it, runs a safari company. Both of these sound like stereotypes, caricatures, but in this writer’s hands they are neither. Edmund begins an investigation but is swiftly removed from the case (if a natural death embellished with a dagger actually constitutes a case) and side-lined, ridiculed. Clearly the Pullman’s have enormous influence within this kleptocracy. Edmund, and an unlikely (indeed random) assistant, must try to resolve if there is a murder; if so who is the murderer; what illegal activities surround the Pullman’s apparent control of the local powers-that-be? And what connection, if any, is there with his childhood?
The quality of the writing, the skilful use of metaphor, the sense of place, the depth of the characterisation, the intricacy of the plot, combine to produce a singular work. This book is way above five stars.
I would like to thank NetGalley, the publishers and the author for providing me with a draft proof copy for the purpose of this review.
January 13, 2022
Marcia Pullman was preparing for her book group when she felt a headache coming on and decided to lie down. When Janet, a member of the group, arrives she finds Marcia in her bed with a letter opener protruding from her chest. The coroner determined that she was dead of natural causes before being stabbed, but why stab a corpse? Chief Inspector Edmund Dube takes the call reporting the death and arrives to investigate. Dube was influenced to become a policeman from the images of investigators in novels and movies, but he is soft spoken and overlooked by everyone at his station. Marcia’s husband has connections with the police and Dube is soon warned off. Determined to find answers, he continues to investigate on his own. The story builds slowly as Dube questions Janet, Marcia’s husband, her maid Dorcas, Craig Martin, a man who recently threatened her, and her neighbor Roland. Each time he reaches out to them he learns more of their connections and history with Marcia and realizes that she had a hold over each of them and they all hated her.
Set in a primarily white suburb in Zimbabwe, this is a contemporary mystery that deals with the faltering economy and racial relations in a post-colonial society. Byrony Rheam builds her story slowly until the final third of the book, which moves rapidly to the conclusion. In a Poirot-like confrontation, Dube gathers his suspects together and reveals their secrets and his conclusions with a truly surprising twist. All Come to Dust is a lengthy mystery that is beautifully written and well worth the time that it takes to follow Chief Inspector Dube’s quest for the truth. I would like to thank NetGalley and Parthian Books for providing this book for my review.
Set in a primarily white suburb in Zimbabwe, this is a contemporary mystery that deals with the faltering economy and racial relations in a post-colonial society. Byrony Rheam builds her story slowly until the final third of the book, which moves rapidly to the conclusion. In a Poirot-like confrontation, Dube gathers his suspects together and reveals their secrets and his conclusions with a truly surprising twist. All Come to Dust is a lengthy mystery that is beautifully written and well worth the time that it takes to follow Chief Inspector Dube’s quest for the truth. I would like to thank NetGalley and Parthian Books for providing this book for my review.
January 16, 2022
Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is conscientious and honest, and would seem to be just the man to investigate the strange death of Marcia Pullman, but the Chief Inspector has his own secrets.
The book starts with Marcia′s point of view. She is getting ready for the monthly book club, and her thoughts give us a little insight into her character before she goes to lie down before the meeting. When we next see her, she is dead and stabbed through the chest.
The Chief Inspector is the one called to investigate, but resources are short and he has to cadge a lift from Martin Craig, a white man who has just been accused of speeding. And at the scene of the crime the maid seems to recognise Martin. Marcia′s husband does not seem to be too bothered by her death, and it seems higher forces in the police force also feel it should be dealt with as quickly as possible.
More characters are introduced and they all seem to have connections with and reasons to dislike Marcia. The way they all seem to interconnect with each other seems unlikely until you realise that the white community in Rhodesia and post-independence Zimbabwe would have come across each other in the same clubs and organisations.
Dube keeps plugging away, and we learn more about the lives of all involved, which for me was the most fascinating part of the book since it gave an insight into some aspects of 21st century Zimbabwe. More people die and the sadness of many people′s lives is uncovered, but it does finish on a small note of hope. This book is not the usual procedural, but is an engrossing read all the same.
I had a copy of this book early through Netgalley
The book starts with Marcia′s point of view. She is getting ready for the monthly book club, and her thoughts give us a little insight into her character before she goes to lie down before the meeting. When we next see her, she is dead and stabbed through the chest.
The Chief Inspector is the one called to investigate, but resources are short and he has to cadge a lift from Martin Craig, a white man who has just been accused of speeding. And at the scene of the crime the maid seems to recognise Martin. Marcia′s husband does not seem to be too bothered by her death, and it seems higher forces in the police force also feel it should be dealt with as quickly as possible.
More characters are introduced and they all seem to have connections with and reasons to dislike Marcia. The way they all seem to interconnect with each other seems unlikely until you realise that the white community in Rhodesia and post-independence Zimbabwe would have come across each other in the same clubs and organisations.
Dube keeps plugging away, and we learn more about the lives of all involved, which for me was the most fascinating part of the book since it gave an insight into some aspects of 21st century Zimbabwe. More people die and the sadness of many people′s lives is uncovered, but it does finish on a small note of hope. This book is not the usual procedural, but is an engrossing read all the same.
I had a copy of this book early through Netgalley
October 20, 2023
Title: "All Come to Dust" by Bryony Rheam - A Gripping Tale of Resilience and Redemption
Rating: ★★★★☆
Having delved into an advanced reader copy of "All Come to Dust" by Bryony Rheam, I was pleasantly surprised by the depth and complexity of the narrative. Rheam weaves a compelling story that revolves around family, secrets, and the enduring power of love.
The novel follows the lives of the Richardson family, primarily focusing on Zoe, a spirited and resilient young woman. The story explores her tumultuous journey as she grapples with past tragedies and seeks to unravel the mysteries surrounding her family's history. Rheam's writing is both evocative and emotionally charged, drawing readers into the atmospheric world she has created. The characters are multi-dimensional, with their intricate relationships and personal growth serving as the driving force behind the narrative. "All Come to Dust" beautifully examines themes of forgiveness, redemption, and the enduring bonds of love, making it a poignant and thought-provoking read.
I am sincerely grateful to NetGalley and the publisher for granting me the opportunity to explore this advanced reader copy. "All Come to Dust" is a four-star novel that delivers a rich and immersive story, full of compelling characters and a deep exploration of human nature. It is a testament to Bryony Rheam's storytelling prowess and her ability to craft a narrative that leaves a lasting impact on readers.
Rating: ★★★★☆
Having delved into an advanced reader copy of "All Come to Dust" by Bryony Rheam, I was pleasantly surprised by the depth and complexity of the narrative. Rheam weaves a compelling story that revolves around family, secrets, and the enduring power of love.
The novel follows the lives of the Richardson family, primarily focusing on Zoe, a spirited and resilient young woman. The story explores her tumultuous journey as she grapples with past tragedies and seeks to unravel the mysteries surrounding her family's history. Rheam's writing is both evocative and emotionally charged, drawing readers into the atmospheric world she has created. The characters are multi-dimensional, with their intricate relationships and personal growth serving as the driving force behind the narrative. "All Come to Dust" beautifully examines themes of forgiveness, redemption, and the enduring bonds of love, making it a poignant and thought-provoking read.
I am sincerely grateful to NetGalley and the publisher for granting me the opportunity to explore this advanced reader copy. "All Come to Dust" is a four-star novel that delivers a rich and immersive story, full of compelling characters and a deep exploration of human nature. It is a testament to Bryony Rheam's storytelling prowess and her ability to craft a narrative that leaves a lasting impact on readers.
September 5, 2021
I received an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This book originally fascinated me as something I've never read before - I've never read Zimbabwean literature, and I was really excited to check it out. And what I found just wasn't really for me.
I found the pace meandering, and too slow for me. There was a deliberate point to the pacing, which definitely worked plot-wise, but it just didn't suit me very well. I also found I could not relate to a single character, which made it difficult for me to really get into the book.
I stuck around for the plot - I really needed to know how the mystery ended. And within that mystery was a whole web of subterfuge, deceit, devastation, and just downright irreconcilable inhumanity. It was definitely way, way more than I ever bargained for.
Overall, if the pace had been faster, I think I would have really liked this book. But as it stands, I just didn't. It was not for me, but I definitely understand the appeal. As such, I will keep this review short and sweet - the overall unraveling of the mystery made finishing the book well worth it, but I would most likely not have read it had I known how slow the pace was.
This book originally fascinated me as something I've never read before - I've never read Zimbabwean literature, and I was really excited to check it out. And what I found just wasn't really for me.
I found the pace meandering, and too slow for me. There was a deliberate point to the pacing, which definitely worked plot-wise, but it just didn't suit me very well. I also found I could not relate to a single character, which made it difficult for me to really get into the book.
I stuck around for the plot - I really needed to know how the mystery ended. And within that mystery was a whole web of subterfuge, deceit, devastation, and just downright irreconcilable inhumanity. It was definitely way, way more than I ever bargained for.
Overall, if the pace had been faster, I think I would have really liked this book. But as it stands, I just didn't. It was not for me, but I definitely understand the appeal. As such, I will keep this review short and sweet - the overall unraveling of the mystery made finishing the book well worth it, but I would most likely not have read it had I known how slow the pace was.
October 18, 2021
I tried so hard to enjoy this one more than I did. It really had such a great premise behind it and the writing was really good but my heart just wasn’t quite in it.
I love a good murder mystery, especially a good detective story and this one had all the marks of an Agatha Christie or Hercule Poirot style whodunit. Unfortunately for me it was just a little too bumbling and confusing.
It seemed way too long, as if the end would never arrive, but I desperately wanted to know what happened because I was actually invested in the characters. I think that’s where my frustration lay. Because it seemed too long it was often a chore to get there.
Set in Zimbabwe, the author expertly wove in issues surrounding racism and colonialism with stories past and present intertwining as it all came together. It’s a really slow burn style read, which I am absolutely a fan of, just again, because this was such a hefty book, it just took too long to reach the conclusion for me.
A great idea and premise for a story, just could have done a bit more tweaking and editing and my rating would absolutely have been higher.
A huge thank you to Parthian Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this one.
I love a good murder mystery, especially a good detective story and this one had all the marks of an Agatha Christie or Hercule Poirot style whodunit. Unfortunately for me it was just a little too bumbling and confusing.
It seemed way too long, as if the end would never arrive, but I desperately wanted to know what happened because I was actually invested in the characters. I think that’s where my frustration lay. Because it seemed too long it was often a chore to get there.
Set in Zimbabwe, the author expertly wove in issues surrounding racism and colonialism with stories past and present intertwining as it all came together. It’s a really slow burn style read, which I am absolutely a fan of, just again, because this was such a hefty book, it just took too long to reach the conclusion for me.
A great idea and premise for a story, just could have done a bit more tweaking and editing and my rating would absolutely have been higher.
A huge thank you to Parthian Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this one.
February 17, 2022
3.5 Stars Rounded up.
A murder that may not be a murder but is probably still a murder in a village in Zimbabwe.
This had a fabulous start and I was in it with all the book club characters who all seemed to have reasons to kill the book club host!
Then the middle of the story took me a while to get through. I had the initial feelings of a cozy mystery, but it became much more serious with all sorts of issues ranging from decolonization, racism, classism, human trafficking, adoption, and ageism. I felt like the murder mystery was more of a tool with which the author wanted to delve into her view of Zimbabwean life, as complicated and messy as it may be. It did take me a bit to work out the various perspectives.
The ending took all the backstories and details and seemed to work it all together very well. I enjoyed the Poirot-esque homage and reveals at the end.
Ultimately, I did enjoy this story. It became heavier than I had expected and dealt with some issues I am still processing. If you are looking for a mystery with what I would almost describe as a character study of Zimbabwe, grab this book which will be out March 4, 2022!
Thank you to NetGalley and Parthian Books for the opportunity to read this digital ARC.
A murder that may not be a murder but is probably still a murder in a village in Zimbabwe.
This had a fabulous start and I was in it with all the book club characters who all seemed to have reasons to kill the book club host!
Then the middle of the story took me a while to get through. I had the initial feelings of a cozy mystery, but it became much more serious with all sorts of issues ranging from decolonization, racism, classism, human trafficking, adoption, and ageism. I felt like the murder mystery was more of a tool with which the author wanted to delve into her view of Zimbabwean life, as complicated and messy as it may be. It did take me a bit to work out the various perspectives.
The ending took all the backstories and details and seemed to work it all together very well. I enjoyed the Poirot-esque homage and reveals at the end.
Ultimately, I did enjoy this story. It became heavier than I had expected and dealt with some issues I am still processing. If you are looking for a mystery with what I would almost describe as a character study of Zimbabwe, grab this book which will be out March 4, 2022!
Thank you to NetGalley and Parthian Books for the opportunity to read this digital ARC.
October 12, 2021
I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This is the first story from a Zimbabwean perspective I've read, and I quite enjoyed it. It was a really interesting read with a lot of character development. A murder that may not actually be a murder is a great premise for a story. I also loved that it was one policeman determined to get to the bottom, no matter how many times he's told to leave it be. It added to the suspense and trying to work out just who was behind it all.
I felt as though the beginning was a little slow, and the pace picked up about halfway through. I have to say, I never figured it out until things were revealed, so it was well written. The last third was probably my favourite part as things started to unravel more and more.
I like that it was told with both past and present perspectives and how there were so many connections I didn't pick up on.
All in all, a well written story with a strong character focus.
This is the first story from a Zimbabwean perspective I've read, and I quite enjoyed it. It was a really interesting read with a lot of character development. A murder that may not actually be a murder is a great premise for a story. I also loved that it was one policeman determined to get to the bottom, no matter how many times he's told to leave it be. It added to the suspense and trying to work out just who was behind it all.
I felt as though the beginning was a little slow, and the pace picked up about halfway through. I have to say, I never figured it out until things were revealed, so it was well written. The last third was probably my favourite part as things started to unravel more and more.
I like that it was told with both past and present perspectives and how there were so many connections I didn't pick up on.
All in all, a well written story with a strong character focus.
July 18, 2021
I wanted to like this book, I did. I actively seek out books that offer perspectives that are new to me, and a story set in Zimbabwe that gives insight into the issues of colonialism, the realities of white and black populations even in suburban areas, the fight to reclaim one's standing in society - all of it sounds like it should make for an excellent read. But this is a character driven murder plot without enticing characters, a truly slow start, and at this point still full of typos. A spelling error on page 1 isn't the most auspicious start, and unfortunately nothing works to improve that opinion even several chapters in. This was a DNF for me, though I think I would be willing to try again after it's gone through another round of edits, because the concepts are very much there are very much intriguing. Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read.
July 28, 2021
I have mixed feelings about this book. I thought it was beautifully written and very descriptive, however I thought it touched on a number of characters’ pasts too much to be a true mystery. I enjoyed reading about each character however I found it made the crime in the book take a back seat to the character development. Being as descriptive as it is, it took me a long time to finish this book. The last third of the book seemed more rushed than the previous 2/3 and the end I felt came to an abrupt end where I’m still left wondering a few things.
Overall I enjoyed reading the novel, however it wasn’t a quick paced mystery novel that I am used to so I had to adjust my expectations while reading.
Overall I enjoyed reading the novel, however it wasn’t a quick paced mystery novel that I am used to so I had to adjust my expectations while reading.
February 22, 2022
I received a gifted copy of ‘All Come to Dust’ by Bryony Rheam in return for my honest review.
This book is set in Zimbabwe, in the town of Bulawayo and follows Chief Inspector Edmund Dube.
One day he is called to the house where a woman has been found dead, the only reason for suspicion is a letter opener sticking out of her chest.
Edmund is told to leave the case alone, but he is determined to find out the reasons behind the death.
With many local residents not opening up, he struggles to find the truth.
Was the woman’s death a murder? What other secrets will Edmund uncover throughout his investigation?
This book is more than just a mystery, it explores the changes in the country and the poverty of its occupants. It also points out the inequalities and prejudices that are still present.
I really felt for Edmund as no one seemed to be taking him seriously, even though his intelligence is great, and he discovers many secrets and corruptions in his local area.
I did find it a bit hard to get into as it was a little slow and to be honest, I found it going over my head a little bit. However, it is a brilliantly written story and one that many will enjoy, it was just not for me.
Overall, a brilliantly written mystery which delves into the changes in Zimbabwe.
This book is set in Zimbabwe, in the town of Bulawayo and follows Chief Inspector Edmund Dube.
One day he is called to the house where a woman has been found dead, the only reason for suspicion is a letter opener sticking out of her chest.
Edmund is told to leave the case alone, but he is determined to find out the reasons behind the death.
With many local residents not opening up, he struggles to find the truth.
Was the woman’s death a murder? What other secrets will Edmund uncover throughout his investigation?
This book is more than just a mystery, it explores the changes in the country and the poverty of its occupants. It also points out the inequalities and prejudices that are still present.
I really felt for Edmund as no one seemed to be taking him seriously, even though his intelligence is great, and he discovers many secrets and corruptions in his local area.
I did find it a bit hard to get into as it was a little slow and to be honest, I found it going over my head a little bit. However, it is a brilliantly written story and one that many will enjoy, it was just not for me.
Overall, a brilliantly written mystery which delves into the changes in Zimbabwe.
January 20, 2022
An old fashioned mystery with an old fashioned detective, Edmund Dube, this novel was a very pleasant read. It is reminiscent of The No 1 ladies detective agency, though more edgy and is set in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe. The sense of place is wonderful and the reader gets an insight into modern day Zimbabwe and the struggles since hyper inflation. The characters are well drawn, though the author takes her time. The story twists and turns and nothing is quite what it seems. Overall it’s a relaxing and enjoyable read.
Thanks to Netgalley, Parthian Books and Bryony Rheam for the ARC.
Thanks to Netgalley, Parthian Books and Bryony Rheam for the ARC.
January 26, 2022
All Come to Dust by Bryony Rheam
This book is set in Zimbabwe. Edmund Dude is a police officer that does not have much respect from his peers but he is determined to find out what really happened to Marcia Pullman. Marcia Pullman was found dead in her bed but even though it looks like she was stabbed everyone else is saying she died before the stabbing of natural causes. Edmund still wants to know who did it.
I found this book to be very slow and long.
I would like to thank Net Galley and Parthian Books for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
This book is set in Zimbabwe. Edmund Dude is a police officer that does not have much respect from his peers but he is determined to find out what really happened to Marcia Pullman. Marcia Pullman was found dead in her bed but even though it looks like she was stabbed everyone else is saying she died before the stabbing of natural causes. Edmund still wants to know who did it.
I found this book to be very slow and long.
I would like to thank Net Galley and Parthian Books for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
October 30, 2021
All Come To Dust is a long book, with lots of descriptions and has a great premise, but it didn't kept me hooked.
This was my first time reading a book from Zimbabwe and I really enjoyed the descriptions of the scenary, the mystery and the writing in general.
It may not have kept me hooked, but it was definitely an interesting experience. I recommend!
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This was my first time reading a book from Zimbabwe and I really enjoyed the descriptions of the scenary, the mystery and the writing in general.
It may not have kept me hooked, but it was definitely an interesting experience. I recommend!
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 21, 2022
When Marcia Pullman is found dead, Chief Inspector Dube goes to investigate, however soon the victim's husband and even the rest of the police want him off the case. This is a VERY slow burn that goes for 500 pages, but I did enjoy the detail of the investigation and it kept me hooked, you never know what's going to happen next. Set in Zimbabwe, it touches corruption and racial themes.
#NetGalley
#NetGalley
August 16, 2021
Bulawayo's chief inspector, Edmund Dube, doesn't care if he has to dirty his hands while investigating a book club socializer's mysterious death.
Read full review here 👇
https://priyankapatrabookgallery.blog...
Also, thank you Parthian Books and NetGalley for the digital arc of this book.
Read full review here 👇
https://priyankapatrabookgallery.blog...
Also, thank you Parthian Books and NetGalley for the digital arc of this book.
March 12, 2022
At first glance, this seems to be a straightforward murder mystery set in Zimbabwe. Rich white woman Marcia Pullman is found dead on her bed, stabbed in the chest before her book club evening event. Chief Inspector Edmund Dube is first on the scene and is determined to solve the mystery.
But both Marcia and Edmund turn out to be complex characters and what seems on the surface to be happening is completely different underneath. An interesting and thought provoking read.
Thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for providing a review copy in exchange for honest feedback.
But both Marcia and Edmund turn out to be complex characters and what seems on the surface to be happening is completely different underneath. An interesting and thought provoking read.
Thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for providing a review copy in exchange for honest feedback.
October 2, 2021
This was a deeply character driven murder mystery with some intriguing insights into life in post-colonial Zimbabwe. There were some twists and turns that were exciting, but this is a slow-paced novel to be certain. Worth the read in the end if only for Rheam’s prose.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 35 reviews