Policing China: Street-Level Cops in the Shadow of Protest

Studies of the Weatherhead East Asian Institute, Columbia University

by Suzanne E. Scoggins

In Policing China, Suzanne E. Scoggins delves into the paradox of China's self-projection of a strong security state while having a weak police bureaucracy. Assessing the problems of resources, enforcement, and oversight that beset the police, outside of cracking down on political protests, Scoggins finds that the central government and the Ministry of Public Security have prioritized stability maintenance (weiwen) to the detriment of nearly every aspect of policing. The result, she argues, is a hollowed out and ineffective police force that struggles to deal with everyday crime.

Using interviews with police officers up and down the hierarchy, as well as station data, news reports, and social media postings, Scoggins probes the challenges faced by ground-level officers and their superiors at the Ministry of Public Security as they attempt to do their jobs in the face of funding limitations, reform challenges, and structural issues. Policing China concludes that despite the social control exerted by China's powerful bureaucracies, security failures at the street level have undermined Chinese citizens' trust in the legitimacy of the police and the capabilities of the state.

Genres: China

198 pages, Hardcover

Published June 15, 2021

Reviews

[WiseB]

Informative book to learn about policing issues in China. Apart from overworked, underpaid, and poorly trained police force, there are the conflicting controls from the ministry and other government entities versus local government's ground level police work ... due to the emphasis in dissident control and stability maintenance with coercive response to protests of the government, which ends up focusing on political policing at the expense of everyday policing of crimes.

[Alex]

2.5 - a necessary and important initial investigation into street-level policing in China...but unnecessarily repetitive and a bit tough to follow.

[Rose]

Some important findings but sooooo redundant.

[Pinda Wang]

The irksome repetitiveness and appalling naïveté...