(Zero spoiler review) 3.5/5
First off, Marvel, as always, suck at choosing omnibus covers. If that wasn't enough initial disappointment, when I realised that Dale Keown wasn't on art, it broke me a little. Spoiler alert, but that won't be the only time this book breaks me. But as soon as we got going, all those wistful longings for Dale Keown became naught but a distant memory, for Gary Frank, along with Cam Smith on inks, made for a more than worthy replacement. Quite how you can replace Dale Keown with someone(s) at least just as good shows how strong comics were back in the day, but this book was back to looking a million bucks, and Peter David's writing, if anything, was even stronger here. Sure, the annuals and such were various shades of who gives a shit, but they were never the point. But alas, the higher the climb, the harder the fall, and once Marlo and Rick disappear from the story and Gary and Cam leave the book, within a handful of issues we go from on of the most exquisitely drawn, inked and coloured books ever made, to introducing the sterile, digitised slop that is blended colours. The transition couldn't have been more jarring, awful or unwelcome. I would be like dropping your supermodel girlfriend off at restaurant with her friends, and when you pick her up an few hours later, she's turned into a hideous blimp. I cannot, and I cannot stress this strongly enough, cannot describe the sheer maudlin sense of grief and loss I felt at having something so magnificent descend into something so heartbreakingly disappointing within a handful of issues. Liam Sharp is a really good artist, but the colours tarnish this in a way that even smearing the pages with faeces couldn't contend with. If you want to know when comics truly started dying, its when the colours began to change, and it was a very sad death indeed.
I couldn't finish the book, and it has reduced my will to crack open volume 4 to sub zero levels of interest. If I didn't already own it, you can bet your ass I wouldn't be buying it. 3.5/5
OmniBen.