What do you think?
Rate this book
A Dubious Witch Cozy Mystery #1
Sceptique à Salem : Un épisode de meurtre
SCEPTIQUE À SALEM : UN ÉPISODE DE MEURTRE est la première histoire d’une charmante nouvelle série de cosy mystery par Fiona Grace, l’auteure à succès de Meurtre au manoir, un best-seller avec plus de 100 avis 5 étoiles (en téléchargement gratuit) !
Quand Mia Bold, 30 ans, apprend que l’entreprise pharmaceutique qui l’emploie ne s’intéresse qu’au profit, elle démissionne sur-le-champ, abandonnant une carrière de haut niveau. Pire encore, son petit ami de longue date, au lieu de la demander en mariage comme escompté, décide de rompre avec elle.
La vraie passion de Mia réside dans son podcast, consacré à démystifier l’occultisme et à mettre en lumière la vérité. Fille d’un père escroc, Mia se sent moralement responsable de la vérité et veut empêcher que les autres ne se fassent arnaquer.
Lorsque Mia reçoit à un moment décisif une invitation d’un célèbre podcast sur le surnaturel l’invitant à déménager à Salem et à rejoindre ses créateurs en tant que sceptique résidente, Mia y voit une chance de recommencer sa vie et de poursuivre sa mission.
Mais à Salem, rien ne se passe comme prévu. Quand survient une mort inattendue – pendant que Mia tente de démystifier une auberge hantée –, elle se rend compte qu’elle est peut-être dépassée par les événements. Son propre avenir étant en jeu désormais, peut-elle vraiment prouver que les sorcières et les fantômes n’existent pas ?
Envoûtant, rempli d’intrigues, de mystères, de romance, d’animaux, de bons repas et surtout de surnaturel, SCEPTIQUE À SALEM est un cosy mystery plein de rebondissements que vous chérirez tout autant que son personnage principal, et qui vous captivera (et vous fera rire) jusque tard dans la nuit.
Quand Mia Bold, 30 ans, apprend que l’entreprise pharmaceutique qui l’emploie ne s’intéresse qu’au profit, elle démissionne sur-le-champ, abandonnant une carrière de haut niveau. Pire encore, son petit ami de longue date, au lieu de la demander en mariage comme escompté, décide de rompre avec elle.
La vraie passion de Mia réside dans son podcast, consacré à démystifier l’occultisme et à mettre en lumière la vérité. Fille d’un père escroc, Mia se sent moralement responsable de la vérité et veut empêcher que les autres ne se fassent arnaquer.
Lorsque Mia reçoit à un moment décisif une invitation d’un célèbre podcast sur le surnaturel l’invitant à déménager à Salem et à rejoindre ses créateurs en tant que sceptique résidente, Mia y voit une chance de recommencer sa vie et de poursuivre sa mission.
Mais à Salem, rien ne se passe comme prévu. Quand survient une mort inattendue – pendant que Mia tente de démystifier une auberge hantée –, elle se rend compte qu’elle est peut-être dépassée par les événements. Son propre avenir étant en jeu désormais, peut-elle vraiment prouver que les sorcières et les fantômes n’existent pas ?
Envoûtant, rempli d’intrigues, de mystères, de romance, d’animaux, de bons repas et surtout de surnaturel, SCEPTIQUE À SALEM est un cosy mystery plein de rebondissements que vous chérirez tout autant que son personnage principal, et qui vous captivera (et vous fera rire) jusque tard dans la nuit.
233 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 30, 2020
593 people are currently reading
1071 people want to read
About the author
Fiona Grace
477 books725 followersDebut author Fiona Grace is author of the LACEY DOYLE COZY MYSTERY series which includes MURDER IN THE MANOR (Book #1), DEATH AND A DOG (Book #2) and CRIME IN THE CAFE (Book #3). Fiona would love to hear from you, so please visit www.fionagraceauthor.com to receive free ebooks, hear the latest news, and stay in touch.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 240 reviews
June 7, 2021
It's pretty hard to mess up a cozy, but I found this one mostly annoying. The copy editing wasn't the worst I've seen, but it was pretty bad. The writing was also not great. The first thing I learned in journalism class was show, don't tell. This author never learned that. She tells us over and over how smart Mia is and how great she is at solving mysteries. We see no evidence of this. She's rifling through a drawer belonging to one of her suspects and she comes across an item that's so obvious it might as well have CLUE written across it, and she shrugs her shoulders, tosses it aside and thinks no more of it. We're also told that Mia always speaks her mind, but again, this never happens. Her entire family of jerks, her fiance and her podcast boss treat her like a doormat and she never says anything. She mostly dodges their calls. Also this is a cozy and there's no body until about halfway through the book! That's too much exposition.
I didn't care for Mia and found myself rooting for her to be arrested and charged with the murder, but she actually somehow managed to stumble into solving the crime. Part of me is curious to see how she overcomes her stupidity in the next book, but not enough to actually read another of these.
I didn't care for Mia and found myself rooting for her to be arrested and charged with the murder, but she actually somehow managed to stumble into solving the crime. Part of me is curious to see how she overcomes her stupidity in the next book, but not enough to actually read another of these.
May 19, 2022
It was okay, enjoyable enough read but nothing I was blown away by. Something to enjoy on a weekend while relaxing. The main character did show some growth and spine when it came to finally standing up to her family and ex-fiancé so that’s a ++ in my books. The paranormal element was barely present, the murder didn’t show up until 1/2 way through the book so ehhh. Maybe lessons will be learned for the next book in the series??
September 25, 2022
This was so much fun!! I didn’t have high expectations from a random free kindle book but I started it on a whim and it hooked me in. I find the cozy mystery genre to be super cute and enjoyable and this was no less. I liked the characters, felt the atmosphere, and loved the cat and dog in this story. I thoroughly enjoyed myself and can’t wait to see how the next mystery goes!
July 2, 2022
I listened to the audio version of this book and it was charming a great way to pass the time while looking thru the windshield. Upon hearing The End I purchased book 2.
June 2, 2022
I thought this cozy mystery would be right up my alley, but it is the first book I've read that I had to keep a running list of all the things that drove me crazy. Some I think a good editor could've helped with, but what the hell do I know? I don't like to criticize anybody's labor of love, but here is what didn't work for me in the notes I jotted down while reading:
Everybody was always "marching" or "storming" off. I swear, I would've been drunk if it was a drinking game with those adjectives. Mia never tells the detective that she broke into the inn because she saw through the window that the chandelier had pinned someone down and she was trying to help. This would justify the breaking and entering, but she doesn't try to explain herself. This miscommunication and oversight would have ended the story right there and we wouldn't have drama, but it was the first of the series of reasons why this wasn't working for me. She than becomes Nancy Drew to do her own detective work vs give info to the detective and let him do his job. She is stupid enough to leave the city after the detective tells her not to leave to do this detective work. She also breaks and enters the Inn committing the same crime she went into custody for, but she is charming enough that the detective doesn't do anything about it because she found evidence. Regardless, IT IS STILL A CRIME. I listened to the audiobook which magnified my grievances. The inflection in Will's voice always sounded like was always asking a question and in pain like a whiny boy with laryngitis with his balls in a vice FOR THE ENTIRE TIME! Had I been able to download another book for the road trip, I would've stopped listening altogether. There is more, but I've already spent too much time on this and I already feel bad that I'm writing a bad review as I feel for the author
Everybody was always "marching" or "storming" off. I swear, I would've been drunk if it was a drinking game with those adjectives. Mia never tells the detective that she broke into the inn because she saw through the window that the chandelier had pinned someone down and she was trying to help. This would justify the breaking and entering, but she doesn't try to explain herself. This miscommunication and oversight would have ended the story right there and we wouldn't have drama, but it was the first of the series of reasons why this wasn't working for me. She than becomes Nancy Drew to do her own detective work vs give info to the detective and let him do his job. She is stupid enough to leave the city after the detective tells her not to leave to do this detective work. She also breaks and enters the Inn committing the same crime she went into custody for, but she is charming enough that the detective doesn't do anything about it because she found evidence. Regardless, IT IS STILL A CRIME. I listened to the audiobook which magnified my grievances. The inflection in Will's voice always sounded like was always asking a question and in pain like a whiny boy with laryngitis with his balls in a vice FOR THE ENTIRE TIME! Had I been able to download another book for the road trip, I would've stopped listening altogether. There is more, but I've already spent too much time on this and I already feel bad that I'm writing a bad review as I feel for the author
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 24, 2023
A fun, free audiobook. I like the ghost/witch/Salem vibes. The narrator kind of reads like she’s reading a bed time story to a 5 year old though.
November 5, 2020
Surprising new series by this author!
I've read a few books by Fiona Grace, from 2 of her other series. What these 3 series have in common is that the main character is a woman in her thirties. That she recently lost her boyfriend/fiance and moved to a different city. But, whereas the other 2 main characters move to another country and find a new job there, this woman gets a job offer which lands her a 5 hours drive away.
What is also different, is the atmosphere of the book. What do you expect, when you move to a witchtown? It is really interesting to read about a city everyone has heard of because of witchtrails taken place there. What is that city like, today?
The story, as always, is good. Lots of colourful characters and a cute dog and kitten to top it off.
I'm looking forward to the next book in this series!
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I've read a few books by Fiona Grace, from 2 of her other series. What these 3 series have in common is that the main character is a woman in her thirties. That she recently lost her boyfriend/fiance and moved to a different city. But, whereas the other 2 main characters move to another country and find a new job there, this woman gets a job offer which lands her a 5 hours drive away.
What is also different, is the atmosphere of the book. What do you expect, when you move to a witchtown? It is really interesting to read about a city everyone has heard of because of witchtrails taken place there. What is that city like, today?
The story, as always, is good. Lots of colourful characters and a cute dog and kitten to top it off.
I'm looking forward to the next book in this series!
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
February 1, 2021
A rather good entry into the genre. Pair a believer (Johnny) with a non-believer/debunker (Mia), add a new best friend, and a teen helper, and you have a good, if predictable, start. The story progresses along some predictable and not-so-predictable lines and ends with just a teeny sense of cliffhangers that are supposed to make you want to read the next books. For me, if the book showed up in my library or on one of the free-Kindle-books sites, I'd definitely read it, but I'm not likely to go looking for it.
Still, I enjoyed every minute of the read.
Still, I enjoyed every minute of the read.
August 9, 2024
A perfectly alright book. Really got better towards the end. The beginning was slow. It took about halfway through this book for someone to actually be murdered and the plot of the book to really begin. I also had to bump up the audiobook speed to 1.3x to get the narrator up to a normal speech cadence. They were was awkwardly slow with lots of pausing. And some of their voices were a bit cringe. Once I sped it up the book was so much easier to listen to and interesting.
Otherwise it was a good plot (when they finally got there). I love the scientific nature of the main character, and the ghost debunking plot line was super interesting and fun. Almost a Scooby-Doo vibe. Not super realistic sometimes, but generally just fun. They really painted the town of Salem, MA in a fun way. I loved the location for the story. Can’t wait to read the next books in the series!
Otherwise it was a good plot (when they finally got there). I love the scientific nature of the main character, and the ghost debunking plot line was super interesting and fun. Almost a Scooby-Doo vibe. Not super realistic sometimes, but generally just fun. They really painted the town of Salem, MA in a fun way. I loved the location for the story. Can’t wait to read the next books in the series!
March 4, 2025
Really would like to give this book a 3.5. Was a good book. Surprisingly hooked me early on. Wasn’t the greatest mystery book and the characters while likable didn’t have a lot of great depth to most of them. Could be a good start to the series though allowing future room for character development.
I listened to the audio book. Reader was good. She was energetic and enthusiastic. Started off feeling like she was used to reading books to small children but I worked in a preschool so it felt homey to me.
I listened to the audio book. Reader was good. She was energetic and enthusiastic. Started off feeling like she was used to reading books to small children but I worked in a preschool so it felt homey to me.
June 12, 2025
This wasn’t completely awful but it seemed very immature. I think I might have loved this when I was 11 years old but at this point in my life (much older than 11) I was just rolling my eyes at some of the behavior and thought processes going on. It was just plain silly. But again there were parts that I kind of liked so 3 stars it is.
October 15, 2024
The ONLY reason I would read the second book is because I’ve heard it’s better than the first. This is more like a young adult novel that could have been better constructed to be a more interesting read
April 25, 2021
An enjoyable read of a highly qualified young lady with principles. When bad things happen she turns to what she really wants to do. It ends up putting her into the middle of a murder investigation. With grace and determination she moves ahead with her life. We can see that she really has made the correct decisions for herself.
August 13, 2024
Love the mystery.
October 13, 2024
Très bon. Je vais me procurer le 2e tome c'est certain.
September 23, 2024
I love a cozy mystery so I knew I would enjoy this. Low stakes plot and super cozy, witchy ambience. I wasn’t super invested in any particular element of this story, but it was sweet and a pretty easy fall read.
3/5 🐈⬛
3/5 🐈⬛
June 17, 2021
Fantastic
A fantastic read. It kept me glued to the story the whole time. I would recommend this book and this author.
A fantastic read. It kept me glued to the story the whole time. I would recommend this book and this author.
May 26, 2021
A relationship problem, a disapproving family, a dog providing charm and the occasional plot device, a foil who isn’t who you think she or he might be, a penchant for getting into trouble, and a law enforcement officer who is more interested than she or he seemingly should be would seem to be the perfect formula for a cozy mystery series. Throw in a touch of the supernatural, albeit with the intent of debunking it, and an exotic setting (I’ve only been to Salem, Massachusetts on one occasion and despite having no interest in the occult (except as a fictional device), I found it fascinating. So, I was curious about Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Murder and the “Dubious Witch Cozy” series it was kicking off, even before I realized that it was going to be the second novel I would read this month about new media. Mia Bold, the “dubious” protagonist of the series, is a podcaster, a podcaster of a series debunking hauntings and supernatural presences. In fact, Mia Bold is a scientist, lead researcher on a team which has just unveiled a pharmacological breakthrough. Unfortunately, that breakthrough is not sufficient to keep her life stable.
Bold is a good surname for Mia because she is certainly willing to stand up for what she believes (or “disbelieves”). When the discovery to which she has committed her life is planned to be used for monetary gain rather than reducing physical pain (more “health” than pain, but you get the idea), she finds herself adrift. But even as the story begins, Mia finds herself even more adrift than she thought. Even those who are supposed to have her back seem to be pushing her in directions doomed to misery. So, she very “bold”ly and bravely plunges herself into another passion.
Of course, this is a cozy mystery. You know the protagonists in these mysteries often are relocating to a new town (usually small) in order to start a new slate, and Mia is no exception. You also know that the most common type of mystery is a murder mystery, even if it begins with what might be written off as an accident. Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Murder is no exception to these two rules. In addition, Mia finds herself faced with rivals in work and rivals in love. Also, there is a very wicked twist toward the end that leaves Fiona Grace, the creator of this property, ample room to maneuver (or not) regarding the unveiling of supernatural mysteries which may sometimes seem “Scooby Doo” solutions and, at other times, seem more sophisticated. I’m curious as to how this will come out.
Confession: In my personal life, I have always been attracted to intelligent, independent women (witness my loving and lovely wife). So, it is no wonder that I find myself drawn to protagonists like Mia Bold in this, apparently self-published, and Fiona Figg from the, also apparently self-published, novels by Kelly Oliver. They have enough creativity and courage to go with their natural intelligence that it seems plausible that they can solve the conundrums into which they are thrust. On the other hand, they have just enough vulnerability to make it interesting without dwelling upon female stereotypes of weakness and subservience that would be quite uninteresting (if not sickening).
Bold is a good surname for Mia because she is certainly willing to stand up for what she believes (or “disbelieves”). When the discovery to which she has committed her life is planned to be used for monetary gain rather than reducing physical pain (more “health” than pain, but you get the idea), she finds herself adrift. But even as the story begins, Mia finds herself even more adrift than she thought. Even those who are supposed to have her back seem to be pushing her in directions doomed to misery. So, she very “bold”ly and bravely plunges herself into another passion.
Of course, this is a cozy mystery. You know the protagonists in these mysteries often are relocating to a new town (usually small) in order to start a new slate, and Mia is no exception. You also know that the most common type of mystery is a murder mystery, even if it begins with what might be written off as an accident. Skeptic in Salem: An Episode of Murder is no exception to these two rules. In addition, Mia finds herself faced with rivals in work and rivals in love. Also, there is a very wicked twist toward the end that leaves Fiona Grace, the creator of this property, ample room to maneuver (or not) regarding the unveiling of supernatural mysteries which may sometimes seem “Scooby Doo” solutions and, at other times, seem more sophisticated. I’m curious as to how this will come out.
Confession: In my personal life, I have always been attracted to intelligent, independent women (witness my loving and lovely wife). So, it is no wonder that I find myself drawn to protagonists like Mia Bold in this, apparently self-published, and Fiona Figg from the, also apparently self-published, novels by Kelly Oliver. They have enough creativity and courage to go with their natural intelligence that it seems plausible that they can solve the conundrums into which they are thrust. On the other hand, they have just enough vulnerability to make it interesting without dwelling upon female stereotypes of weakness and subservience that would be quite uninteresting (if not sickening).
May 24, 2022
So many times authors struggle finding the balance between introducing the main character, setting, etc. and then having the murder/ investigation, which makes a book feel underwritten and lopsided. I was so grateful this wasn't the case with this story. The characters are fun and interesting and showed a fair amount of growth for a first book. I enjoyed the setting, and I thought the murder/ overall conflict was pretty interesting too.
However, I don't think certain aspects were planned out very well, like the real events of the murder itself. How did the individuals involved know that would actually kill anyone? Also, I don't think it was edited super well. For example, there were several instances I noticed where characters repeated statements a few lines after they had originally said them, like the author rewrote the conversation but didn't completely remove the old pieces. Plus there were some strange word choices and phrasing. But overall, the story was good and I'm planning to continue reading the series.
However, I don't think certain aspects were planned out very well, like the real events of the murder itself. How did the individuals involved know that would actually kill anyone? Also, I don't think it was edited super well. For example, there were several instances I noticed where characters repeated statements a few lines after they had originally said them, like the author rewrote the conversation but didn't completely remove the old pieces. Plus there were some strange word choices and phrasing. But overall, the story was good and I'm planning to continue reading the series.
August 14, 2024
2.5 stars. The plot of this cozy mystery was a bit underwhelming. Mia, as a main character, did not feel fully developed, and her actions and thoughts seemed to be guided entirely by whims of plot convince. Concerningly, this narrative struggled to consistently relay basic details about characters: Mia's sister is referred to as "half" and "step" interchangeably. Unreliable narration of such basic elements does not inspire confidence in the plotting of a mystery.
The mystery that Mia is investigating does not begin until approximately half way through the narrative; I do wonder if Mia's journey to Salem needed to be quite as drawn out as it was, since her family dynamic becomes virtually inconsequential once she moves.
The mystery that Mia is investigating does not begin until approximately half way through the narrative; I do wonder if Mia's journey to Salem needed to be quite as drawn out as it was, since her family dynamic becomes virtually inconsequential once she moves.
January 22, 2025
ugh. listened to the audio. narrator didn't help story. I wanted to like this. It was a very interesting premise. But the writing was rough. And could've maybe used an editor. lot of over-usage of the same words.
characters were never really developed. unlike most cozies where the murder starts the book that didn't happen in this one. It was about halfway through. Which then left us to needing to quickly get to the end. It's actually at this point where the book started to get better. I hung in there but only because it was one of my hoopla borrows and I only have one more for the month.
characters were never really developed. unlike most cozies where the murder starts the book that didn't happen in this one. It was about halfway through. Which then left us to needing to quickly get to the end. It's actually at this point where the book started to get better. I hung in there but only because it was one of my hoopla borrows and I only have one more for the month.
April 29, 2021
You can call me easy to please if you wish, but I really liked this story. The main characters were easy to like, the plot was simple to follow and the ending worked out quite well. I was indeed fooled by the red herring and convinced myself I knew the murderer, but of course I was wrong. I very much liked this book and highly recommend it. I look forward to the next one.
August 29, 2021
Just too many annoying features in this book. Stereotypic characters, too much detail, dumb dialogue. And my most hated thing, historical inaccuracies (books published in 1893 are not printed on vellum).
July 29, 2022
Did not finish. Disliked the characters, many situations seemed silly,plot did not hold my attention, dialogue often seemed immature. I have enjoyed many books by Fiona grace, but just couldn’t get into this one.
March 18, 2023
Cardboard cutout characters. Awful dialog. Lots of telling, not so much showing.
I probably should have DNFd it - I mostly just skimmed the last quarter of it anyway - but at least it was short and fast to read. And the story was reasonably amusing, so I wish it had been a better read.
I probably should have DNFd it - I mostly just skimmed the last quarter of it anyway - but at least it was short and fast to read. And the story was reasonably amusing, so I wish it had been a better read.
November 26, 2024
I love the premise of this book but it was actually kind of stupid. The main character did a lot of really dumb things and it was a bit over the top silly. But I do love a good mystery so there’s that. Also the audiobook narrator was extremely annoying which may be coloring my review.
February 28, 2022
Main character is written as a woman that is a Lab Technician but acts like a fifteen year old. Pass!
March 24, 2025
Rating: 3.5/5 Stars
Skeptic in Salem by Fiona Grace is a cozy mystery that follows Mia Bold, a 30-year-old who quits her high-powered pharmaceutical job after realizing the company prioritizes profit over ethics. Reeling from a breakup—her long-time boyfriend ends things instead of proposing as she’d hoped—Mia decides to pursue her true passion: her podcast, where she debunks the occult and exposes the truth, driven by a moral responsibility shaped by her con-man father’s legacy. When a famous supernatural podcast invites her to move to Salem and join as their skeptic-in-residence, Mia sees a chance to start over. But things take a dark turn when an unexpected death occurs while she’s debunking a haunted inn, forcing her to question whether witches and ghosts might be real—and whether she’s in over her head.
The book shines in many ways. The pacing is spot-on, with a well-structured timeline that keeps the tension high and the story moving forward. The central “whodunit” is delightfully complex, made even more engaging by smaller mysteries woven throughout—keeping readers guessing until the end. The characters are well-rounded, especially Mia, whose skepticism provides a grounded perspective in the spooky setting of Salem. Her interactions with non-skeptical characters are a highlight, showcasing her ability to bridge differing beliefs while staying true to her mission. Mia’s growth over the course of the story is satisfying, as she navigates her new life and confronts her own biases, making her a protagonist worth rooting for. The witchy, paranormal vibes of Salem are a perfect backdrop, adding an atmospheric charm that fans of the occult will love.
However, the book stumbles in its writing style, particularly with repetitive word choice that becomes monotonous, especially in audiobook form. The author overuses the phrase “I could feel the blood rushing to my cheeks” to describe Mia’s emotions—whether blushing or angry—followed by “in anger” or “in a blush,” with no variation like “my face flushed” or “heat crept up my neck.” This lack of descriptive diversity pulls you out of the story, making emotional moments feel formulaic. Similarly, dialogue tags are a constant frustration—every line ends with “[Character Name] said” (e.g., “Mia said,” “Johnny said”), with no variation like “Mia replied,” “Johnny muttered,” or “Mia whispered.” This repetitive structure makes the audiobook feel flat, despite the characters’ depth, and detracts from the tension a mystery needs. Dictionaries and thesauruses exist for a reason, and the author’s failure to use more descriptive language feels like a missed opportunity to elevate the writing.
Overall, Skeptic in Salem is a solid cozy mystery with a captivating plot, well-rounded characters, and a setting that brims with witchy charm. Mia’s journey as a skeptic in a paranormal world is engaging, and the complex mystery keeps you hooked. However, the repetitive word choice—both in emotional descriptions and dialogue tags—holds the book back from its full potential, especially for audiobook listeners. I’m looking forward to the next book in the series, hoping the author varies her language to match the story’s strengths. If you love witchy mysteries with a skeptical twist, this is worth a read—just be prepared for some stylistic frustrations.
Skeptic in Salem by Fiona Grace is a cozy mystery that follows Mia Bold, a 30-year-old who quits her high-powered pharmaceutical job after realizing the company prioritizes profit over ethics. Reeling from a breakup—her long-time boyfriend ends things instead of proposing as she’d hoped—Mia decides to pursue her true passion: her podcast, where she debunks the occult and exposes the truth, driven by a moral responsibility shaped by her con-man father’s legacy. When a famous supernatural podcast invites her to move to Salem and join as their skeptic-in-residence, Mia sees a chance to start over. But things take a dark turn when an unexpected death occurs while she’s debunking a haunted inn, forcing her to question whether witches and ghosts might be real—and whether she’s in over her head.
The book shines in many ways. The pacing is spot-on, with a well-structured timeline that keeps the tension high and the story moving forward. The central “whodunit” is delightfully complex, made even more engaging by smaller mysteries woven throughout—keeping readers guessing until the end. The characters are well-rounded, especially Mia, whose skepticism provides a grounded perspective in the spooky setting of Salem. Her interactions with non-skeptical characters are a highlight, showcasing her ability to bridge differing beliefs while staying true to her mission. Mia’s growth over the course of the story is satisfying, as she navigates her new life and confronts her own biases, making her a protagonist worth rooting for. The witchy, paranormal vibes of Salem are a perfect backdrop, adding an atmospheric charm that fans of the occult will love.
However, the book stumbles in its writing style, particularly with repetitive word choice that becomes monotonous, especially in audiobook form. The author overuses the phrase “I could feel the blood rushing to my cheeks” to describe Mia’s emotions—whether blushing or angry—followed by “in anger” or “in a blush,” with no variation like “my face flushed” or “heat crept up my neck.” This lack of descriptive diversity pulls you out of the story, making emotional moments feel formulaic. Similarly, dialogue tags are a constant frustration—every line ends with “[Character Name] said” (e.g., “Mia said,” “Johnny said”), with no variation like “Mia replied,” “Johnny muttered,” or “Mia whispered.” This repetitive structure makes the audiobook feel flat, despite the characters’ depth, and detracts from the tension a mystery needs. Dictionaries and thesauruses exist for a reason, and the author’s failure to use more descriptive language feels like a missed opportunity to elevate the writing.
Overall, Skeptic in Salem is a solid cozy mystery with a captivating plot, well-rounded characters, and a setting that brims with witchy charm. Mia’s journey as a skeptic in a paranormal world is engaging, and the complex mystery keeps you hooked. However, the repetitive word choice—both in emotional descriptions and dialogue tags—holds the book back from its full potential, especially for audiobook listeners. I’m looking forward to the next book in the series, hoping the author varies her language to match the story’s strengths. If you love witchy mysteries with a skeptical twist, this is worth a read—just be prepared for some stylistic frustrations.
January 23, 2025
"Scettica a Salem: Un evento delittuoso" I gialli di una dubbiosa strega - Libro 1 di Fiona Grace
Self Publishing, 2020
280 pagine
📚 Genere: Narrativa, Paranormal Romance
⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Scettica a Salem” è il romanzo d’esordio di Fiona Grace, leggerlo è stato veramente un piacere, la lettura è leggera e scorre molto velocemente ✨
È un simpatico “cozy crime” che rientra perfettamente tra i cosiddetti "libri coccola”, i libri che scelgo quando voglio passare qualche ora serena e rilassata, in relax e andare avanti con la lettura fino alla fine 😊
Mia Bold ha 30 anni, ha un bel appartamento (un loft ...dove non paga neanche l'affitto) ha un bel lavoro, è un tecnico di laboratorio presso una grande e prestigiosa società farmaceutica, è fidanzata con Mark ed è in attesa de ‘il Prossimo Passo’, in pratica è in attesa della proposta di matrimonio ❤️ poi ha una grande passione: The Vortex il suo podcast personale a tema "occulto e paranormale" 🥰
E vive con Tandy il suo amato cagnolino 🐾
Mia è felice!
Ma, a volte, il destino ha altri programmi 😱
Infatti BOOM! la vita di Mia cambia totalmente in meno di ventiquattr’ore: la mattina presto scopre che ha pochi giorni per lasciare il suo loft... poi appena arrivata a lavoro si scontra con il capo, risultato: prima di pranzo è fuori dall'azienda... e ciliegina sulla torta 🧐 la sera litiga con Mark, perché invece di supportarla per l'appartamento e il lavoro perso, come si aspettava, il caro fidanzato decide di scaricarla 😱
Un incubo!
Per "fortuna" a Mia arriva, inaspettata, la proposta da parte di una famosa trasmissione che tratta “fenomeni paranormali”.
Hanno bisogno di una persona "scettica" e con basi scientifiche come presentatrice 💪🏻
Deve solo trasferirsi a Salem, nel Massachusetts, posto celebre in tutto il mondo per la caccia alle streghe 🧙🏻
Il sogno di Mia ✨ finalmente potrà davvero provare che streghe e fantasmi non esistono!?!? 🤔
Ci riuscirà? 👻
Come sarà la vita di Mia nella città più infestata degli Stati Uniti??
Carino. Un giallo leggero, divertente e scorrevole, con un pizzico di soprannaturale e romance... c'è anche l'omicidio ma comunque rimane una lettura rilassante. Scritto bene.
Ho amato i personaggi: la scettica Mia Bold e il suo kit per la caccia ai fantasmi 😊 Sylvie il tecnico del suono, poi Johnny Astor il co-presentatore della trasmissione, ma ci sono anche i particolari abitanti di Salem, come Hazel e la sua magia bianca o l'affascinante Hugh Wolfe, proprietario del Café Noir ❤️
Tutto da leggere. Consigliato 👍🏻
Self Publishing, 2020
280 pagine
📚 Genere: Narrativa, Paranormal Romance
⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Scettica a Salem” è il romanzo d’esordio di Fiona Grace, leggerlo è stato veramente un piacere, la lettura è leggera e scorre molto velocemente ✨
È un simpatico “cozy crime” che rientra perfettamente tra i cosiddetti "libri coccola”, i libri che scelgo quando voglio passare qualche ora serena e rilassata, in relax e andare avanti con la lettura fino alla fine 😊
Mia Bold ha 30 anni, ha un bel appartamento (un loft ...dove non paga neanche l'affitto) ha un bel lavoro, è un tecnico di laboratorio presso una grande e prestigiosa società farmaceutica, è fidanzata con Mark ed è in attesa de ‘il Prossimo Passo’, in pratica è in attesa della proposta di matrimonio ❤️ poi ha una grande passione: The Vortex il suo podcast personale a tema "occulto e paranormale" 🥰
E vive con Tandy il suo amato cagnolino 🐾
Mia è felice!
Ma, a volte, il destino ha altri programmi 😱
Infatti BOOM! la vita di Mia cambia totalmente in meno di ventiquattr’ore: la mattina presto scopre che ha pochi giorni per lasciare il suo loft... poi appena arrivata a lavoro si scontra con il capo, risultato: prima di pranzo è fuori dall'azienda... e ciliegina sulla torta 🧐 la sera litiga con Mark, perché invece di supportarla per l'appartamento e il lavoro perso, come si aspettava, il caro fidanzato decide di scaricarla 😱
Un incubo!
Per "fortuna" a Mia arriva, inaspettata, la proposta da parte di una famosa trasmissione che tratta “fenomeni paranormali”.
Hanno bisogno di una persona "scettica" e con basi scientifiche come presentatrice 💪🏻
Deve solo trasferirsi a Salem, nel Massachusetts, posto celebre in tutto il mondo per la caccia alle streghe 🧙🏻
Il sogno di Mia ✨ finalmente potrà davvero provare che streghe e fantasmi non esistono!?!? 🤔
Ci riuscirà? 👻
Come sarà la vita di Mia nella città più infestata degli Stati Uniti??
Carino. Un giallo leggero, divertente e scorrevole, con un pizzico di soprannaturale e romance... c'è anche l'omicidio ma comunque rimane una lettura rilassante. Scritto bene.
Ho amato i personaggi: la scettica Mia Bold e il suo kit per la caccia ai fantasmi 😊 Sylvie il tecnico del suono, poi Johnny Astor il co-presentatore della trasmissione, ma ci sono anche i particolari abitanti di Salem, come Hazel e la sua magia bianca o l'affascinante Hugh Wolfe, proprietario del Café Noir ❤️
Tutto da leggere. Consigliato 👍🏻
May 9, 2021
Mia Bold is having a bad day. She finds out that her brother-in-law has sold the building she lives in and she has 2 weeks to find another place to live, then when talking to the owner of the pharmaceutical company she works for, she finds out what he plans on doing with the new diabetic drug they’ve been working on, and when she stands up to him, she gets fired. You’d think that would be enough for anyone, but not for Mia. While out to dinner with her fiancé, when she tells him about her day, he starts arguing with her, and they end up breaking up. The only thing left in her life besides her dog that brings her joy is her small ghost busting podcast, but then her only sponsor quits as well.
Then out of the blue, she gets a call from the podcast that her sponsor went to. They want her for their show and they’re willing to put her up in and apartment in Salem, MA of all places. After a disastrous family meal, Mia decides to take the offered deal, packs up her life and moves to the witchy town of Salem. Of course, the first place she has to stop is the house that was the muse for Nathanial Hawthorne’s The House of the Seven Gables.
Mia finds out that things are definitely strange in the town of Salem. From the number of supposed ghosts, to the number of witches, there’s a lot to be seen and there’s a lot to do. Digging right in to her new job, she’s ready to prove that the ghost haunting the tavern aren’t real, or are they? But that’s not all. When the owner is murdered, Mia is the top suspect. Not only did she find him, her fingers are the only ones on the door, and she did break a window in the back to gain access, but when an edited episode of the show is sent to the detective in charge of the case, Mia couldn’t look more guilty. Will she be able to prove her innocence and find out who the killer really is before she’s arrested and charged with the murder?
This was a really good story. I was immediately drawn in and empathized with Mia. I was drawn in because of the authors descriptions of the area, I could picture everything, and I love when that happens. I couldn’t put the book down and devoured it in one sitting. What a great start, and I can’t wait to read the next book!!
Then out of the blue, she gets a call from the podcast that her sponsor went to. They want her for their show and they’re willing to put her up in and apartment in Salem, MA of all places. After a disastrous family meal, Mia decides to take the offered deal, packs up her life and moves to the witchy town of Salem. Of course, the first place she has to stop is the house that was the muse for Nathanial Hawthorne’s The House of the Seven Gables.
Mia finds out that things are definitely strange in the town of Salem. From the number of supposed ghosts, to the number of witches, there’s a lot to be seen and there’s a lot to do. Digging right in to her new job, she’s ready to prove that the ghost haunting the tavern aren’t real, or are they? But that’s not all. When the owner is murdered, Mia is the top suspect. Not only did she find him, her fingers are the only ones on the door, and she did break a window in the back to gain access, but when an edited episode of the show is sent to the detective in charge of the case, Mia couldn’t look more guilty. Will she be able to prove her innocence and find out who the killer really is before she’s arrested and charged with the murder?
This was a really good story. I was immediately drawn in and empathized with Mia. I was drawn in because of the authors descriptions of the area, I could picture everything, and I love when that happens. I couldn’t put the book down and devoured it in one sitting. What a great start, and I can’t wait to read the next book!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 240 reviews