a good tale with a plucky heroine
It’s a good story, if you don’t need too much realism in your tales.
Not every story needs to be realistic, and this one is a fun adventure, though it did have me face-palming a few times.
What I liked:
- The MC is likable: spunky and sweet, vulnerable and determined. The other characters are varied and fairly interesting, including the magical, talking animals. Effort is made to make them multilayered and three-dimensional. Although the villain is a bit of a caricature, the back story does depict a believable path to darkness.
- The world is intriguing, although incredibly small. (Conveniently, it only takes a few hours’ travel to get anywhere.) The details at the beginning paint a homey picture of a delightful cottage and a warm, close-knit family. Other parts of the world are also portrayed with vivid imagery. I’d like to see more of it.
- The premise with the power of the Earth-Treaders and the missing stones is excellent, and mostly well done. The end was satisfying, both from a fantasy-adventure standpoint and a romantic one.
- The multiple romantic tensions are cute. There’s definitely some love-at-first-sight dynamics that don’t make a lot of sense—but then love often doesn’t. And hardship is what proves love, and that element is there, which is what saves the romance from being pure fluff. And I love that I could hand this to a 10yo daughter and let her just enjoy the wholesome ride.
- The adventure is mostly fast-paced, with one event leading quickly to another—some dire, some more fun.
- Moo is a cutie. I’d like to have him as a friend.
What I had trouble with:
- There are a lot of coincidences, conveniences and contrivances in the action. The MC just stumbles on the very people or objects she needs to find. She goes long periods of time without seeming to notice hunger. But as I said, not every story needs to feel realistic. This one feels a lot like one of those fairy-tales where the fairy godmother shows up at just the right time. The result is a good tale… but not one that will change me.
- The main love interest is not the sharpest tool in the shed. We literally start his involvement in the story with his overlooking multiple clues—and realizing later what a dolt he is. I like him. I appreciate the personal demons he wrestles with and his determination to find atonement. He’s honorable. But he’s a fairy-tale knight, not necessarily one I’d like to meet in real life.
- The talking animals thing is great, but the execution of it had some bumps. The cat is perceived, by those who can’t understand what he says, to meow a lot. But if his communications with the MC are so vocal, that leaves a number of times when quiet conversation between them ought to be awkward, but isn’t. (He does whisper at times. But still.) The part where the owls are so erudite they have to speak in ornate, complex phrases was I think meant to be entertaining, but it fell flat for me. (What little horse speech there is was really nicely done though.)
- The writing was sometimes a little too ornate, or did odd things grammatically. Not a show-stopper, but I prefer the words become invisible, pulling me into a story and letting me lose myself in it, rather than sounding in my head as I read.
- I liked the characters, but I didn’t love them. I enjoyed reading about them, but I’m not sad to part with them. I could tell the author saw them, and was trying to portray them, as multifaceted and deep, but I didn’t really feel the magic. That’s probably the main reason I give this 4 stars instead of 5.
- The romance is cute, and I’m glad for them that they get their happy ending, but I’m not really feeling my heart pounding along with them.
I guess my takeaway is that this was more of a “tell me a tale” kind of book—and tales can be highly interesting—than “drop me in the story and make me feel every second of it.”
All in all, it’s a recommendable tale, with a plucky heroine who overcomes her own self-obstacles to save the day, with much-needed help from some worthy friends along the way!