The premise of this book seemed decent enough to take a chance on, so I did (especially since I got it for free at the time). The story takes place in a sort of remote-ish village ruled by Mayor Jones (an inherited position, not a political one) who doles out fiery sermons meant to keep the village people in line with his beliefs. The village is so caught up in its "traditions" and way of life that there is no empathy or leeway for those who are born different (the Strangers who live outside the village but are still subject to its rules) or those who run into bad luck (the Unmarrieds, women who aren't married by 18 for whatever reason or Emma and her mother whose husband died years ago).
Emma and her mother Grace live on the edge of the village next to a meadow that borders the forbidden woods. People who wander into the woods (young, single women) are never seen again. At age 5, while playing the meadow, Emma sees a strange boy playing a flute in the woods. She never forgets him. Fast forward 12 years and Emma is nearing her 18th birthday when she must get married or live as an Unmarried, a woman who is so subordinate that they are treated as less than livestock. Having been raised by a single mother, Emma is not a typical young woman, which is a strike against her in this community. Her best friend is a Stranger, and her ability to think independently makes unique enough that the entire village (except Mayor Jones) actually respects her, even though they won't say so to her face. Oh, and the two eligible boys for Emma are Andrew (who is less than enthusiastic about marriage) and Samuel, a boy Emma used to play with when they were little who still harbors a crush for her...and happens to be the mayor's son. Yeah, you can see where this is heading.
But the story takes a couple twists. First, Samuel begins to woo Emma, much to the surprise of everyone in the village. Then Emma blows it by not dumping her best friend. And that boy she saw in the forest years ago, yep, he's still there, and he begins to lure Emma toward him through dreams and then in reality. To her credit, Emma resists, even though it means a lifetime of drudgery as an Unmarried. And then something happens that is the catalyst for change within Emma and, ultimately, the entire village.
This tale moves along at a good pace and reads fairly quickly. The characters are mostly believable and act in ways you would mostly expect. And the little bit of the supernatural keeps you wondering what's really going to happen next. So why just four stars? First, though things were believable, I found them to be a little bit too cookie cutter for true enjoyment. Some of the characters turned into caricatures right before me eyes, and certain plot lines were transparent. And second, I thought the ending of the book wrapped up a little too neatly too quickly. Don't get me wrong. It's the ending I wanted, but it happened so quickly that I felt caught up in a whirlwind. Not a bad one, but a whirlwind nonetheless.
In short, this is a very good book. I liked the characters and liked the plot. And the little twists that propelled the story were a great touch. And even though this falls into the YA category, it's readable for anyone. If you're looking for a book to pick up and enjoy in front of the fireplace or under a warm blanket, this is a worthy choice.