What do you think?
Rate this book
Gaslight Mystery #23
Murder on Pleasant Avenue
When midwife Sarah and detective Frank Malloy’s friend and new partner Gino Donatelli is accused of murder, he and Sarah must catch the real killer to keep him alive, in this enthralling, new novel in the USA Today bestselling Gaslight Mystery series. . . .
A young woman is missing in the upper Manhattan neighborhood called Italian Harlem, and everyone knows whoʼs responsible—the Black Hand, a notorious group known for terrorizing their own community with violence and kidnappings. Gino and Frank set out to learn more about the disreputable gang and soon find a a saloon-owning gangster named Nunzio Esposito.
Gino hates that a fellow immigrant would stoop so low and decides to confront his wayward countryman. But he quickly discovers the man can’t be reasoned with—because he’s been murdered. The police have only one Gino Donatelli.
Frank and Sarah know Gino is no killer, but someone has pulled out all the stops to make it look like he is guilty. They also must now face the Black Hand, who are honor-bound to avenge the death of one of their own.
With evidence mounting against their friend and a group of bad guys out for blood, Sarah and Frank race to unravel a treacherous plot before Gino’s time runs out. . . .
A young woman is missing in the upper Manhattan neighborhood called Italian Harlem, and everyone knows whoʼs responsible—the Black Hand, a notorious group known for terrorizing their own community with violence and kidnappings. Gino and Frank set out to learn more about the disreputable gang and soon find a a saloon-owning gangster named Nunzio Esposito.
Gino hates that a fellow immigrant would stoop so low and decides to confront his wayward countryman. But he quickly discovers the man can’t be reasoned with—because he’s been murdered. The police have only one Gino Donatelli.
Frank and Sarah know Gino is no killer, but someone has pulled out all the stops to make it look like he is guilty. They also must now face the Black Hand, who are honor-bound to avenge the death of one of their own.
With evidence mounting against their friend and a group of bad guys out for blood, Sarah and Frank race to unravel a treacherous plot before Gino’s time runs out. . . .
336 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published April 28, 2020
466 people are currently reading
4087 people want to read
About the author
Victoria Thompson
83 books2,448 followersVictoria Thompson was a beloved authoress of 'standard mystery' novels.
This middle of the road tone is not violent like a 'thriller' but unsanitized (NOT light like a 'cozy mystery'), is unflinchingly adult, serious, and dark.
Humour, romance, family, and compassion balance out the crime part of dear Victoria's unforgettable mysteries.
This middle of the road tone is not violent like a 'thriller' but unsanitized (NOT light like a 'cozy mystery'), is unflinchingly adult, serious, and dark.
Humour, romance, family, and compassion balance out the crime part of dear Victoria's unforgettable mysteries.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 307 reviews
May 22, 2020
Murder on Pleasant Avenue by Victoria Thompson is a 2020 Berkley publication.
A nail- biting historical mystery and adventure!!
Over the past couple of months, I have been fortunate to have several of my favorite mystery authors publish a new novel. I have found it quite comforting to touch base with familiar characters and landscapes, so the timing of this latest release couldn't have been better.
In this 23rd installment of the Gaslight series, we get to know Gino Donatelli a little better- although not under the best of circumstances. Gino’s sister-in-law asks for help concerning a settlement house resident who appears to have gone missing, the main concern being the possibility the young woman may have been kidnapped by ‘The Black Hand’- a gang operating in Little Italy- East Harlem.
As Frank and Gino begin their investigation, it becomes clear they need help from Sarah and Maeve while dealing with sensitive situations. But, in a horrible turn of events, Gino becomes a murder suspect, which lands him in jail. Not only that, he could be in grave danger. Can Frank find the real murderer before it’s too late?
Victoria Thompson always provides the most interesting history in her books. Seriously, every novel is like a mini history lesson- and it is always fascinating! This story is no exception. I always find myself Googling something, curious to learn more. This installment shines a light on the 'Black Hand' gang, of which I knew practically nothing.
As to the mystery, there are some tense moments of suspense, as the behavior of some of the characters becomes curiously erratic. It was an absorbing and puzzling situation. Naturally, I worried about Gino, who can be a bit stubborn.
On a lighter note, I found myself grinning with delight over some key developments between the recurring characters and I'm betting fans of this series will be just as pleased as I am!
Overall, I am impressed with how Thompson continues to keep this series fresh. Great characters, interesting history, and compelling mysteries- what’s not to love?
A nail- biting historical mystery and adventure!!
Over the past couple of months, I have been fortunate to have several of my favorite mystery authors publish a new novel. I have found it quite comforting to touch base with familiar characters and landscapes, so the timing of this latest release couldn't have been better.
In this 23rd installment of the Gaslight series, we get to know Gino Donatelli a little better- although not under the best of circumstances. Gino’s sister-in-law asks for help concerning a settlement house resident who appears to have gone missing, the main concern being the possibility the young woman may have been kidnapped by ‘The Black Hand’- a gang operating in Little Italy- East Harlem.
As Frank and Gino begin their investigation, it becomes clear they need help from Sarah and Maeve while dealing with sensitive situations. But, in a horrible turn of events, Gino becomes a murder suspect, which lands him in jail. Not only that, he could be in grave danger. Can Frank find the real murderer before it’s too late?
Victoria Thompson always provides the most interesting history in her books. Seriously, every novel is like a mini history lesson- and it is always fascinating! This story is no exception. I always find myself Googling something, curious to learn more. This installment shines a light on the 'Black Hand' gang, of which I knew practically nothing.
As to the mystery, there are some tense moments of suspense, as the behavior of some of the characters becomes curiously erratic. It was an absorbing and puzzling situation. Naturally, I worried about Gino, who can be a bit stubborn.
On a lighter note, I found myself grinning with delight over some key developments between the recurring characters and I'm betting fans of this series will be just as pleased as I am!
Overall, I am impressed with how Thompson continues to keep this series fresh. Great characters, interesting history, and compelling mysteries- what’s not to love?
May 6, 2020
I really enjoyed another visit with Frank, Sarah and the family. It was another nice little history lesson too about New York in those days. I guarantee I learn at least one new and fascinating fact in every one of these books and usually more than one.
In this latest book Gino is in the wrong place at the wrong time and is accused of murder. This involves the whole family in working towards clearing his name and finding the real culprit. Apparently fans of the series have been nagging the author to move the almost romance between Maeve and Gino into something more and things do seem to be blossoming!
I do not get the feeling that Victoria Thompson has exhausted this series yet so I will look forward to another book in a year (no pressure). However I also just discovered she has another series out there which I am going to start very soon!
In this latest book Gino is in the wrong place at the wrong time and is accused of murder. This involves the whole family in working towards clearing his name and finding the real culprit. Apparently fans of the series have been nagging the author to move the almost romance between Maeve and Gino into something more and things do seem to be blossoming!
I do not get the feeling that Victoria Thompson has exhausted this series yet so I will look forward to another book in a year (no pressure). However I also just discovered she has another series out there which I am going to start very soon!
May 2, 2020
Private investigators Frank Malloy and Gino Donatelli get a case that’s very close to home. Gino’s sister-in-law Teo asks for help in finding a missing volunteer worker who is a resident at the settlement house in Italian East Harlem. They fear she’s been kidnapped by Nunzio Esposito and his gang who’s operating under the Black Hand. As they get into the investigation, Gino finds himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and is accused of murdering the crime boss. The entire team, including Sarah Malloy and Maeve Smith, must use all of their resources to clear his name, not only to avoid prison but retaliation from the Black Hand.
It was great being back in this series and even more interesting to get to know Gino’s family and his world. I wasn’t aware that at the beginning of the 20th century East Harlem was considered to be part of Little Italy, nor had I heard of settlement houses that served as a central community volunteer resource. The notion was fascinating and operated similarly to what we see today as the YMCA/YWCA but with volunteers in residence. The mystery involving the missing volunteer wasn’t tough to solve but the underlying motives weren’t as clear so that kept me engaged. And, I learned more about the Black Hand and how they really operated.
I enjoyed this story as much for the historical elements as the characters and mystery. Since Gino is at the forefront, so is his relationship with Maeve, which took a giant leap forward. It was wonderful getting to know his family and especially his brothers. Solving the murder was interesting and led to lots of intriguing situations, culminating in an exciting but bizarre climax. I continue to enjoy this series and look forward to what’s next for these characters I’ve come to care about.
Posted on Blue Mood Café
(Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.)
It was great being back in this series and even more interesting to get to know Gino’s family and his world. I wasn’t aware that at the beginning of the 20th century East Harlem was considered to be part of Little Italy, nor had I heard of settlement houses that served as a central community volunteer resource. The notion was fascinating and operated similarly to what we see today as the YMCA/YWCA but with volunteers in residence. The mystery involving the missing volunteer wasn’t tough to solve but the underlying motives weren’t as clear so that kept me engaged. And, I learned more about the Black Hand and how they really operated.
I enjoyed this story as much for the historical elements as the characters and mystery. Since Gino is at the forefront, so is his relationship with Maeve, which took a giant leap forward. It was wonderful getting to know his family and especially his brothers. Solving the murder was interesting and led to lots of intriguing situations, culminating in an exciting but bizarre climax. I continue to enjoy this series and look forward to what’s next for these characters I’ve come to care about.
Posted on Blue Mood Café
(Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.)
February 15, 2021
... and we have here Gino's book! I mean where Gino is a suspect! I'm wondering who's next? Mr. Decker? LOL
And that's not all!!!
And with this one I end my binge-reading of this series and now I have to wait for the next one...
And that's not all!!!
And with this one I end my binge-reading of this series and now I have to wait for the next one...
February 24, 2020
As a long time devotee to this series and author, I am saddened to say that this probably my least favorite installment. I will, however, still recommend this series to anyone and everyone who will listen to me forever and ever.
ARC from publisher.
ARC from publisher.
August 9, 2020
3 - 1/2*
A light historical murder mystery set in New York City 1899.
Quick easy read with laudable characters and enough suspects to keep you guessing.
This is not highfalutin literature it’s just something entertaining for a lazy weekend.
This is #23 in a series and while it can be read as a stand-alone it would be much more enjoyable if the reader was familiar with the characters from the previous books.
A light historical murder mystery set in New York City 1899.
Quick easy read with laudable characters and enough suspects to keep you guessing.
This is not highfalutin literature it’s just something entertaining for a lazy weekend.
This is #23 in a series and while it can be read as a stand-alone it would be much more enjoyable if the reader was familiar with the characters from the previous books.
July 12, 2020
A victim is found, brutally murdered and the police are certain they've caught the killer. Their only suspect: Gino Donatelli.
Frank and Sarah know Gino is innocent but the police have a one-track mind. Once Frank struck it rich and left their ranks taking Gino with him, there has been a simmering resentment in the department. And now, someone has pulled out all the stops to make it look like Gino is the only one who could have committed the crime.
With the clock ticking and evidence mounting against their friend, Sarah and Frank will try to unravel a treacherous plot before Gino is sent up the river for good.
It's hard to believe I've read 23 books in this series. This one was ok, but not one of my favorites. As usual with this series, the mystery was pretty easy to solve. My usual complaint about Frank and Sarah being too dumbed down apply here, but they weren't as clueless as they've been in the past. Also, as usual, there is a nice bit of New York City history added into the story. This time around it's the Black Hand gang in Little Italy. There were also interesting tidbits about Theodore Roosevelt being nominated for vice president, and electric lighting being installed in Frank and Sarah's house that I thought added a nice historical touch to the book.
One thing I especially liked was how Maeve was frustrated at being sidelined as a secretary for the detective agency, but at one point takes things into her own hands with the investigation. I always like when Maeve gets involved. I also really enjoyed the part where she meets Gino's family. That was priceless.
After reading 23 books I do feel like something exciting needs to happen to breathe new life into the series. Despite there being one development that I've been waiting several books for, this book still felt a little run of the mill.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
Frank and Sarah know Gino is innocent but the police have a one-track mind. Once Frank struck it rich and left their ranks taking Gino with him, there has been a simmering resentment in the department. And now, someone has pulled out all the stops to make it look like Gino is the only one who could have committed the crime.
With the clock ticking and evidence mounting against their friend, Sarah and Frank will try to unravel a treacherous plot before Gino is sent up the river for good.
It's hard to believe I've read 23 books in this series. This one was ok, but not one of my favorites. As usual with this series, the mystery was pretty easy to solve. My usual complaint about Frank and Sarah being too dumbed down apply here, but they weren't as clueless as they've been in the past. Also, as usual, there is a nice bit of New York City history added into the story. This time around it's the Black Hand gang in Little Italy. There were also interesting tidbits about Theodore Roosevelt being nominated for vice president, and electric lighting being installed in Frank and Sarah's house that I thought added a nice historical touch to the book.
One thing I especially liked was how Maeve was frustrated at being sidelined as a secretary for the detective agency, but at one point takes things into her own hands with the investigation. I always like when Maeve gets involved. I also really enjoyed the part where she meets Gino's family. That was priceless.
After reading 23 books I do feel like something exciting needs to happen to breathe new life into the series. Despite there being one development that I've been waiting several books for, this book still felt a little run of the mill.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
April 16, 2020
All the moving parts fit together so perfectly in this latest installment of the Gaslight Mystery. The mystery begins with the suspected kidnapping of a volunteer at an East Harlem tenement. Casting a shadow over this event is the Black Hand. Thompson sheds light on the inner workings of that infamous group while furthering the development of the characters we have come to love. It is so much fun to watch Maeve and Gino contributing to the investigation. As usual Sarah uses her Decker name to gain a welcome in hoity toity parlors. Frank is his street smart self. Mrs. Malloy shines as a foil for the rest of the family. Even Mrs. Ellsworth makes an appearance, although she is not sprinkled in as much as in other books. In addition, solid historical clues give us a strong sense of place. Really well done and I look forward to #24.
Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
October 13, 2022
When Gino’s sister-in-law shows up at the detective agency Frank Malloy now owns, she is looking for help. One of the volunteers at the settlement house where she volunteers in her neighborhood of Italian Harlem has been kidnapped by the Black Hand. Soon Sarah has joined her husband, Frank, and Gino is trying to figure out what has happened. But just as they think they’ve gotten a handle on what is happening, a murder happens and Gino is the only suspect. Can they clear him before the Black Hand decides to take revenge on him?
It was a pleasure to jump back to 1900 once again and visit these characters. The action unfolds quickly. While I figured a few things out before the characters, I didn’t have the entire picture put together until they did. I did feel the final chapter felt forced into the book, but that was a minor complaint. I love spending time with these characters. We don’t see all the supporting players, but I was happy with some of the advances we saw for the core characters. I also enjoyed the seeds planted for some upcoming historical events. I’m so glad I’ve spent the time reading this series. Anyone who enjoys a good historical mystery will enjoy it as well.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
It was a pleasure to jump back to 1900 once again and visit these characters. The action unfolds quickly. While I figured a few things out before the characters, I didn’t have the entire picture put together until they did. I did feel the final chapter felt forced into the book, but that was a minor complaint. I love spending time with these characters. We don’t see all the supporting players, but I was happy with some of the advances we saw for the core characters. I also enjoyed the seeds planted for some upcoming historical events. I’m so glad I’ve spent the time reading this series. Anyone who enjoys a good historical mystery will enjoy it as well.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
March 2, 2023
Gino is begged by his sister in law Teo, to look into a kidnapping case suspected of being another incident of the Black Hand, who hold sway in the Italian community. This investigation leads to Gino’s arrest for murder. Sarah and Frank Malloy are quick to investigate because the police seem to only have the one suspect, Gino. But then, the police do carry a grudge since Gino left the police force to work with Frank. Sarah and Frank are convinced something is not right and Gino is the easy out for police. Can they find the real murderer? They have their suspects but another murder throws their theories into disarray.
This is not my first book by this author and featuring Sarah and Frank. The other one was book 1 in the Gaslight series. Things have moved on a lot as this is book 23 in the series. Good to catch up with Sarah and Frank again. It was fine to read this without having read the books in between these two. I still enjoyed it. It it kept me turning the pages, even though I was pretty sure I had the murderer pegged fairly early. But it’s always good to be proved right.
An entertaining read that delves easily into the history of the Italian community in New York and the influence of The Black Hand, which I first encountered in the TV show. Murdoch Mysteries. The relationship between midwife Sarah and Frank works well and there is another romance happening amid the murders and a lot about family loyalty.
Well worth reading, even if like me, you haven’t read all the others in the series.
This is not my first book by this author and featuring Sarah and Frank. The other one was book 1 in the Gaslight series. Things have moved on a lot as this is book 23 in the series. Good to catch up with Sarah and Frank again. It was fine to read this without having read the books in between these two. I still enjoyed it. It it kept me turning the pages, even though I was pretty sure I had the murderer pegged fairly early. But it’s always good to be proved right.
An entertaining read that delves easily into the history of the Italian community in New York and the influence of The Black Hand, which I first encountered in the TV show. Murdoch Mysteries. The relationship between midwife Sarah and Frank works well and there is another romance happening amid the murders and a lot about family loyalty.
Well worth reading, even if like me, you haven’t read all the others in the series.
March 31, 2022
What is a fairly standard installment in this mystery takes a completely turn in the last chapter and I LOVED it.
The main story is about the Black Hand (a loose collection of gangs in Italian American neighborhoods) kidnapping women and children. Gino is so upset that Italians are perpetrating crimes on other Italians that he goes to confront a leader of one of the groups, but he's been set up to take the fall for the man's murder. There's a second murder, kidnappings, and attempted murder thrown in Frank, Sarah, Gino, and Maeve try to clear Gino.
At one point, Maeve has to go to Gino's family home to tell them he's been arrested and she meets his parents and a brother. The scene is hilarious, as they clearly think she and Gino are a couple.
The last chapter of the book happens after the main story has resolved. No spoilers here, but Maeve and a small army of Gino's family members and neighbors band together to confront the Black Hand. Maeve and Gino's relationship progresses just a big as a result and it's so satisfying to see Maeve acknowledge her feelings. It's almost as if a new phase of the series is starting because of this last chapter.
The main story is about the Black Hand (a loose collection of gangs in Italian American neighborhoods) kidnapping women and children. Gino is so upset that Italians are perpetrating crimes on other Italians that he goes to confront a leader of one of the groups, but he's been set up to take the fall for the man's murder. There's a second murder, kidnappings, and attempted murder thrown in Frank, Sarah, Gino, and Maeve try to clear Gino.
At one point, Maeve has to go to Gino's family home to tell them he's been arrested and she meets his parents and a brother. The scene is hilarious, as they clearly think she and Gino are a couple.
The last chapter of the book happens after the main story has resolved. No spoilers here, but Maeve and a small army of Gino's family members and neighbors band together to confront the Black Hand. Maeve and Gino's relationship progresses just a big as a result and it's so satisfying to see Maeve acknowledge her feelings. It's almost as if a new phase of the series is starting because of this last chapter.
May 15, 2020
People in Harlem's Little Italy are being kidnapped by a group called the Black Hand and ransomed back to their families. Private Detectives Frank Malloy and Gino Donatelli are hired to quietly find Miss Jane Harding who was kidnapped off the streets. Their investigation eventually leads them to a dead body where Gino is arrested for the murder. It's up to Frank, along with Sarah and Maeve, to prove Gino didn't kill anyone by finding the real killer.
I was so happy to get the latest book in the Gaslight Mystery series. It's nice to be back with Frank and Sarah, solving mysteries where the police either ignore the crime or arrest the first possible suspect. In this one women and children are being kidnapped and ransomed. Frank and Gino work to get the latest victim back before her disappearance becomes general knowledge and ruins her reputation. I liked the mystery even though I guessed the killer early in the book. And I loved the end of the story where Maeve gets the spotlight. My rating: 4.5 Stars.
I was so happy to get the latest book in the Gaslight Mystery series. It's nice to be back with Frank and Sarah, solving mysteries where the police either ignore the crime or arrest the first possible suspect. In this one women and children are being kidnapped and ransomed. Frank and Gino work to get the latest victim back before her disappearance becomes general knowledge and ruins her reputation. I liked the mystery even though I guessed the killer early in the book. And I loved the end of the story where Maeve gets the spotlight. My rating: 4.5 Stars.
September 7, 2020
Another fine outing from the author.
Once again, the reader learns about a different New York City neighborhood at the beginning of the 20th century. In this book we are exploring the Italian immigrant community. It was fun to spend time with Gino Donatelli's family; with several members playing a major part in the story.
I found the mystery to be fairly easy to solve (for once!), but that didn't lessen my enjoyment of the book. It was nice to see young Maeve shine (to say more would be spoiler-y!).
I enjoy my yearly visits with Frank and Sarah, their family and friends. I look forward to catching up with them next year.
Once again, the reader learns about a different New York City neighborhood at the beginning of the 20th century. In this book we are exploring the Italian immigrant community. It was fun to spend time with Gino Donatelli's family; with several members playing a major part in the story.
I found the mystery to be fairly easy to solve (for once!), but that didn't lessen my enjoyment of the book. It was nice to see young Maeve shine (to say more would be spoiler-y!).
I enjoy my yearly visits with Frank and Sarah, their family and friends. I look forward to catching up with them next year.
July 15, 2020
No mystery as it is very obvious of the killer's identity. Pace was slow and I felt there's little history added to the story compared to previous books. Wish the whole book was as good as its last two chapters.
November 27, 2023
Doing some catch up in the Gaslight Murder Mysteries…reading the last four this month. A new one is due out soon. I can hardly wait – reviews to follow (eventually).
Murder on Pleasant Avenue
Murder on Wall Street
Murder on Madison Square
Murder on Bedford Street
For me, all the books in the series are solid 4-4.5 Stars
Murder on Pleasant Avenue
Murder on Wall Street
Murder on Madison Square
Murder on Bedford Street
For me, all the books in the series are solid 4-4.5 Stars
May 31, 2020
Another great installment of the Gaslight Mystery Series. A great sleuthing team with Frank and Sarah and the amazing New York setting and Italian Harlem too. I think it is amazing that the location is always a big part of the narrative. This is my first book in this series and I enjoyed this a lot and worked for me even though this is book #23. The pacing and characterization is spot on and I immediately became invested with Frank and Sarah and will be ordering the rest of the Gaslight Mystery Series. I enjoyed the writing and loved that I can spend an afternoon reading this book for a great escape read.
May 1, 2020
Murder on Pleasant Avenue by Victoria Thompson is the twenty-third installment in the Gaslight Mystery series. I haven’t read any of the other books in the series, but this was a great introduction for me.
Sarah and Frank Malloy find themselves embroiled in another sticky situation. Gino Donatelli, Frank’s business partner and friend, has been arrested for murder. The Malloy’s are determined to prove his innocence and keep him safe in the process. The events leading to Gino’s arrest get more mysterious by the minute.
Murder on Pleasant Avenue is well-written. The characters are vibrant and believable with complete backstories. The plot is engaging with a good mystery and enough twists to hold the reader’s attention throughout. Humor is injected making the story even more entertaining. Ms. Thompson has done thorough research and gives an accurate accounting of the time period. I rate this novel 5 out of 5 stars. Readers of historical fiction will find this story to be captivating.
My thanks to Berkeley Publishing Group and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book. However, the opinions expressed in this review are 100% mine and mine alone.
Sarah and Frank Malloy find themselves embroiled in another sticky situation. Gino Donatelli, Frank’s business partner and friend, has been arrested for murder. The Malloy’s are determined to prove his innocence and keep him safe in the process. The events leading to Gino’s arrest get more mysterious by the minute.
Murder on Pleasant Avenue is well-written. The characters are vibrant and believable with complete backstories. The plot is engaging with a good mystery and enough twists to hold the reader’s attention throughout. Humor is injected making the story even more entertaining. Ms. Thompson has done thorough research and gives an accurate accounting of the time period. I rate this novel 5 out of 5 stars. Readers of historical fiction will find this story to be captivating.
My thanks to Berkeley Publishing Group and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book. However, the opinions expressed in this review are 100% mine and mine alone.
October 9, 2020
3.5 stars - I’ve read every book in this cozy series, and it’s had its ups and downs. The first several books had a much more gritty feel, as Sarah entered the tenements in the poorest areas of New York City to tend to pregnant women. Frank Malloy was a tough detective; both had lost their spouses in tragic ways, and they worked together reluctantly to solve murders, usually among the poorest immigrants. Occasionally, Sarah’s upper crust knickerbocker roots came in handy, as she infiltrated the high society she was born into to help Irish working-class Malloy find a killer.
Sometimes, the series has entered low points, where the entries were rather blah – not necessarily bad, just kind of boring - repetitious, the mystery not exactly complex, the bad guy pretty obvious. For me, one of the low points of the series was when Thompson seemed unsure what to do with the growing attraction between Frank and Sarah. They were both adults who’d lost their spouses, but they were separated by a yawning social gulf, so a casual affair seemed impossible. So, they spent a lot of time, and several books, sitting around her kitchen table drinking coffee, discussing their latest cases, and not much happened. The whole “will they, won’t they” thing dragged out way too long.
Thompson seems to be trying to avoid that with this book, which she admits in the afterward was an attempt to resolve the situation with Maeve, Sarah’s longtime nanny, and Gino Donatelli. She says fans wanted a resolution for the two young friends/lovers, and this book was the result.
Thompson, the descendent of Italian American immigrants, clearly enjoys researching New York City’s immigrant past. In this case, the notorious Black Hand is kidnapping women and children in the Italian community, and using fear to extort ransoms and protection money. Frank Malloy is asked to investigate when a young lady volunteer at the local Settlement House is kidnapped - her reputation would be in shreds if word got out, so Malloy is asked to find her. The local Italian immigrants fear the police, and won’t go to them for help. The young woman reappears, but won’t discuss what’s happened to her. Soon, her supposed kidnapper, a local crime boss, is found murdered. Frank’s young detective partner, Gino Donatelli, is arrested for the murder, and Frank has to find the true killer to clear Gino’s name.
This was one of those cases where the killer seemed so obvious, and Frank, Sarah and company just floundered around, not wanting to think the worst - although it seemed so obvious what had happened. It was an interesting look at the Italian immigrant community of the time however, and a chance to get to know Gino Donatelli’s family a little bit better, and for Maeve to really shine! I look forward to the next book in this long series, as it’s always fun to check in with these characters, and to see what Thompson does with them.
Sometimes, the series has entered low points, where the entries were rather blah – not necessarily bad, just kind of boring - repetitious, the mystery not exactly complex, the bad guy pretty obvious. For me, one of the low points of the series was when Thompson seemed unsure what to do with the growing attraction between Frank and Sarah. They were both adults who’d lost their spouses, but they were separated by a yawning social gulf, so a casual affair seemed impossible. So, they spent a lot of time, and several books, sitting around her kitchen table drinking coffee, discussing their latest cases, and not much happened. The whole “will they, won’t they” thing dragged out way too long.
Thompson seems to be trying to avoid that with this book, which she admits in the afterward was an attempt to resolve the situation with Maeve, Sarah’s longtime nanny, and Gino Donatelli. She says fans wanted a resolution for the two young friends/lovers, and this book was the result.
Thompson, the descendent of Italian American immigrants, clearly enjoys researching New York City’s immigrant past. In this case, the notorious Black Hand is kidnapping women and children in the Italian community, and using fear to extort ransoms and protection money. Frank Malloy is asked to investigate when a young lady volunteer at the local Settlement House is kidnapped - her reputation would be in shreds if word got out, so Malloy is asked to find her. The local Italian immigrants fear the police, and won’t go to them for help. The young woman reappears, but won’t discuss what’s happened to her. Soon, her supposed kidnapper, a local crime boss, is found murdered. Frank’s young detective partner, Gino Donatelli, is arrested for the murder, and Frank has to find the true killer to clear Gino’s name.
This was one of those cases where the killer seemed so obvious, and Frank, Sarah and company just floundered around, not wanting to think the worst - although it seemed so obvious what had happened. It was an interesting look at the Italian immigrant community of the time however, and a chance to get to know Gino Donatelli’s family a little bit better, and for Maeve to really shine! I look forward to the next book in this long series, as it’s always fun to check in with these characters, and to see what Thompson does with them.
April 21, 2020
This review was originally posted on Books of My Heart
Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
I have been loving this Gaslight Mystery series. I started on audio but switched to ebook when the narrator changed after the first 8 or so books. They are so addictive, I read 9 books in one week! Then I was determined to catch up for the new release, Murder on Pleasant Avenue. There may be some spoilers for earlier books in this review. I do recommend reading in order, because I always do, but also the personal lives of the characters progresses throughout the series. I especially love Brian and always wanted to know more about how he was doing.
I will say I enjoyed the building relationship between Frank and Sarah in earlier books. They each developed their bright, young assistants, Maeve and Gino. I think Maeve is particularly sharp. I enjoyed the mystery handled by all the secondary characters, but primarily Gino and Maeve while they were on their honeymoon. I don't like them being quite as much of the story as they are though. Gino seemed less experienced, then he seemed more seasoned after volunteering in Cuba, but now he is back to more mediocre efforts.
I enjoyed this mystery and learning more about the settlement houses in New York City. The settlement house concept was great but implemented at various levels of competence, like anything. Sarah certainly created a wonderful place with her maternity hospital. I suspected the culprits quite early this time.
I wish there was more Frank and Sarah and a bit less Gino and Maeve. At least, I wish there were more of their discussions and personal time without the other two. The mentions of the rest of the family, meals and Mrs. Ellsworth are simplistic, barely more than a mention now. Mother Malloy does sometimes have a bright observation to contribute.
I got tired of Maeve's sort of whiny attitude at office work and her jumping into dangerous investigating on her own. At the end, however, Maeve comes through playing an integral part in solving the loose ends once the case is solved. Her quick mind and fearless action saved the day.
I'll be thrilled to read more in this series. I love the characters and the historic setting. I enjoy the author's note ending each book with details about the authenticity of historical aspects.
Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
I have been loving this Gaslight Mystery series. I started on audio but switched to ebook when the narrator changed after the first 8 or so books. They are so addictive, I read 9 books in one week! Then I was determined to catch up for the new release, Murder on Pleasant Avenue. There may be some spoilers for earlier books in this review. I do recommend reading in order, because I always do, but also the personal lives of the characters progresses throughout the series. I especially love Brian and always wanted to know more about how he was doing.
I will say I enjoyed the building relationship between Frank and Sarah in earlier books. They each developed their bright, young assistants, Maeve and Gino. I think Maeve is particularly sharp. I enjoyed the mystery handled by all the secondary characters, but primarily Gino and Maeve while they were on their honeymoon. I don't like them being quite as much of the story as they are though. Gino seemed less experienced, then he seemed more seasoned after volunteering in Cuba, but now he is back to more mediocre efforts.
I enjoyed this mystery and learning more about the settlement houses in New York City. The settlement house concept was great but implemented at various levels of competence, like anything. Sarah certainly created a wonderful place with her maternity hospital. I suspected the culprits quite early this time.
I wish there was more Frank and Sarah and a bit less Gino and Maeve. At least, I wish there were more of their discussions and personal time without the other two. The mentions of the rest of the family, meals and Mrs. Ellsworth are simplistic, barely more than a mention now. Mother Malloy does sometimes have a bright observation to contribute.
I got tired of Maeve's sort of whiny attitude at office work and her jumping into dangerous investigating on her own. At the end, however, Maeve comes through playing an integral part in solving the loose ends once the case is solved. Her quick mind and fearless action saved the day.
I'll be thrilled to read more in this series. I love the characters and the historic setting. I enjoy the author's note ending each book with details about the authenticity of historical aspects.
September 14, 2020
Well I'm officially caught up on this series. I'm hoping my declining interest in the series is more because I've read too many back to back, but that seems doubtful given I've binged read several series and loved them. This was lost the magic though. Maybe it should've ended on a high note with the wedding, or even just after they all moved into their new house. I miss Mrs. Ellsworth and her superstitions, Sarah and Frank chatting about their case over coffee, I miss Gino and Maeve being secondary characters. Now that Frank and Sarah are married they have to try and cram another romance at us and while some might find it cute, it's not. Frank and Sarah had major obstacles to overcome before they became a couple, there are no real barriers to Gino and Maeve and it feels like a stretch to make them, like something to fill a few pages in. In this book once again another member of the team is implicated in a murder. This time it's Gino, who's investigating a woman missing from Italian Harlem. It involves the Black Hand and their powerful leader. Again not much excitement. I feel like this series needs to end, or a revamp like the Maisie Dobbs series did come back in a year or two, or have someone go away on a trip for a while to shake things up. But for now I'll stick with it and hope it improves, the mystery part isn't the greatest, but the moments with the families and close friends do make up for it, a bit.
December 31, 2020
This was one of a favorite installment of the Gaslight Mystery series (#23). We join Frank, Sarah, Maeve, and Gino in solving the case of a kidnapping that led to a murder; and by coincidence Gino is accused of the murder.
This plays up the key four characters and we see a development of Maeve and Gino's relationship. We meet several more members of Gino's family.
Twists and turns kept me turning the page to see when they were going to finally realize who the killer was.
Thanks to Goodreads, Berkley, and Victoria Thompson for the ARC unedited proof. These opinions are my own and not compensated.
This plays up the key four characters and we see a development of Maeve and Gino's relationship. We meet several more members of Gino's family.
Twists and turns kept me turning the page to see when they were going to finally realize who the killer was.
Thanks to Goodreads, Berkley, and Victoria Thompson for the ARC unedited proof. These opinions are my own and not compensated.
May 4, 2022
I found this to be the most enjoyable installment of this series in quite some time. I listen to these on audio and generally don't care much about the mysteries, but instead enjoy the characters. However, I was very interested in this particular murder and was quite proud of myself for having guessed the murderer early on.
June 19, 2020
Sadly, I have to lower the rating from what I gave the books earlier in this series. I truly wish that the author would return to the better character development of Sarah's family, that she used in the earlier books in the series. The struggles involved in raising a deaf child in that era, as well as the dynamics between she and her mother-in-law and her parents, gave a nice depth to the characters that has been missing for many of the books. Gino and Maeve are now being more developed, but their characters and story lines also remain easy-breezy. The stories have become somewhat "slick", and not as intriguing as they once were because the characters have become more shallow.
As a side note - I also always wondered why Malloy would not be bothered to learn sign language, to be able to communicate with his own son. It seems out of character for him, since he is otherwise a progressive thinker about his child's education and capabilities.
As a side note - I also always wondered why Malloy would not be bothered to learn sign language, to be able to communicate with his own son. It seems out of character for him, since he is otherwise a progressive thinker about his child's education and capabilities.
May 6, 2020
The fact that it takes until the ~70% mark for the characters to figure out something that's been made extremely obvious to me as the reader makes this book one of the more poorly written of the series. The killer was obvious. I don't think it was intentional telegraphing on the author's part, but it was pretty obvious who was lying and even why. There's not even that many potential suspects! I solved it way before them, and it made it really difficult to enjoy the story with no suspense.
May 5, 2020
I really enjoy this series. The characters are so likeable and interesting. It has been fun watching them grow! I look foward to each mystery and trying to solve the puzzle before the end....of course with the plot twist and turns...I never do! Fun read!
June 17, 2020
Miss the budding of Sarah and Frank’s relationship
Read
August 21, 2020When a young woman is kidnapped from the area known as Italian Harlem, Frank Malloy and his assistant Gino Donatelli are called to investigate. In order to get more details from the voluntary group where the young woman was working, Maeve also joins in on the investigation and goes undercover.
It becomes evident that the Black Hand, an organized crime group, has been terrorizing the residents and when Gino Donatelli gets more involved and tries to look into matters on his own, he suddenly finds himself at the scene of a murder and he’s becomes the prime suspect.
Sarah, Malloy’s wife, also becomes involved in the investigation as she tries to learn more about the young woman and other women who have been kidnapped. Of course as Sarah digs into the background story she finds out the young woman may also be hiding other secrets.
This is the 23rd installment in the Gaslight Mystery series and as I’ve been saying about these latest entries, I feel like the witty banter we saw between Sarah and Frank at the start of this series is gone. Also, some of my favorite characters are almost non-existent. I realize that this book is so Gino and Maeve have their moment in the spotlight but it’s a shame that some of the other characters felt like an afterthought. Unfortunately a bit of a disappointment.
It becomes evident that the Black Hand, an organized crime group, has been terrorizing the residents and when Gino Donatelli gets more involved and tries to look into matters on his own, he suddenly finds himself at the scene of a murder and he’s becomes the prime suspect.
Sarah, Malloy’s wife, also becomes involved in the investigation as she tries to learn more about the young woman and other women who have been kidnapped. Of course as Sarah digs into the background story she finds out the young woman may also be hiding other secrets.
This is the 23rd installment in the Gaslight Mystery series and as I’ve been saying about these latest entries, I feel like the witty banter we saw between Sarah and Frank at the start of this series is gone. Also, some of my favorite characters are almost non-existent. I realize that this book is so Gino and Maeve have their moment in the spotlight but it’s a shame that some of the other characters felt like an afterthought. Unfortunately a bit of a disappointment.
September 19, 2020
I really like a good mystery with some history thrown in, as well as a little romance. This series is set in early 20th century New York City. In the series, Mauve has been a midwife, as well as a wife and mother. Frank was a NYC detective, and now has his own detective agency with his partner, Gino. I like the way the series has evolved, adding new characters and bringing some from earlier books back into the picture. This is book number 23 in the series, and may easily be the best one yet! Ms Thompson has a way of presenting her characters that makes them feel like a part of your own life. She also does a very good job of describing the areas where the action is taking place. Don’t miss this book, and, better yet, the entire series. I am pleased to see that number 24 in the series is planned.
May 29, 2022
The mystery plot here was fairly standard and I figured it out very early on, but the standout here is, as always, the main cast of characters and this one was particularly strong on that front. I loved spending time with Gino's family and getting to know them a little more. Really loved every interaction Maeve had with his family, and then everything in the final chapter was great.
One note I had here was it's really clear how much research Thompson puts into these books. I recognized the name of Our Lady of Mount Carmel immediately, although I didn't know about the festival. I may have to check it out in August. I also really love the cover of this one. I know this isn't a holiday story, but the cover art really evokes those streetlight fixtures they put up over the holidays. It maybe isn't a great match for this non-holiday story, but I like it a lot all the same.
One note I had here was it's really clear how much research Thompson puts into these books. I recognized the name of Our Lady of Mount Carmel immediately, although I didn't know about the festival. I may have to check it out in August. I also really love the cover of this one. I know this isn't a holiday story, but the cover art really evokes those streetlight fixtures they put up over the holidays. It maybe isn't a great match for this non-holiday story, but I like it a lot all the same.
June 10, 2021
This series is so nostalgic for me. Every year a new book is released. During the summer my Grandma and I had a tradition of purchasing the new book and then one of us would read it first before handing it off to the other to read. Since her passing last summer, this is the first book in the series where I won’t be able to give it to her and I just know she would have loved it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 307 reviews