Another grouchy Christmas read bites the dust! This one was a grinch alien retelling. He was green and lived alone on a mountain. He was the last of his kind and watched as the humans and their alien rescuers took over his planet. Not a lot of info is given on why the hero was the last of his kind, no virus or war or anything, it seems others like him just went away. His parents died but no reason is given. The world building in this read was very lacking but I’m attributing it to being a novella in a larger series that I have not read, so I imagine the world building was done in previous books. This book can still be enjoyed if you aren’t concerned with knowing why humans were on the planet or why Resa was the last green, winged being of his kind. It bugged me a bit but other things bugged me more so 🤷🏼♀️.
I liked Resa, the grinchy alien, I thought he was endearing and wanted to learn more about him. His observations of the alien humans doing yoga were quite funny. He was very grumpy but sweet. My big issue with this book was the moralizing. I’m finding this a lot with Christmas reads, they can’t just be stories, they have to have a message or teach a lesson, and if you know me at all you will know I hate being taught lessons in my fiction. The problem with many of these lessons is that the author is in no way equipped to judge what a good lesson is. This author basically took the stance that family and togetherness is what Christmas is about, which is true, but she didn’t consider that her setting was on a planet and with species who were not Christian and did not celebrate Christmas. Some alien reads do this well, they account for other aliens’ culture and traditions and make sure to reinforce that Christmas is a human tradition and focus on North American practices or whichever country the human or author is from. This book didn’t do that. This book was basically the FMC, Lo, preaching and pushing her Christmas traditions onto the poor green alien. Telling him his way of life was wrong. She frequently calls his feelings ‘dumb’ and at one point she beats him with branches of flowers, swearing at him the entire time because he won’t return to her village with her.
I was hoping at that point that the lessons in this story would be hers to learn. That pressuring, guilting and finally being angry and violent with someone for not believing what you believe or agreeing with your way of life was wrong. But that is not how this went down. Nope, it’s Resa who ends up seeking Lo out and apologizing to her. At the end he agrees to her way of life and abandons his own.
So I’m not going to get into the pro-colonization messages this conveys, how the humans come and save this savage from his lonely existence on the mountain. But I will end this by saying, this was not a good retelling of the Grinch Who Stole Christmas. In the original Grinch story, the real grinch actively messed with the Whos in Whoville. He tries to ruin and steal their Christmas away from them, hence the title ‘Steals Christmas’. In this book Resa just minded his own business on his mountain and Lo pushed herself on to him over and over. She sought him out and bullied him in his own cave. He asked her to leave him alone frequently and she disregarded this and trampled all over his wishes, traditions and boundaries.
Then after all this, the epilogue shows Resa and Lo years later being all happy and cozy celebrating Christmas with their family. Not one of his traditions or beliefs was incorporated into their family at the end. It was all Lo’s traditions.
So though I liked Resa, overall this book was a judgey and terrible grinch retelling. The author got the message of the original story completely wrong.