Emma Cross is devastated when her "Uncle" Cornelius Vanderbilt II dies and shocked when he leaves her a generous bequest and one for her formerly wayward half-brother. The whole family is bereaved and mourns in their own way but Neily, eldest son, was estranged from his father for many years and all but disinherited. He's grieving the lost opportunities to make up with his father, or so Emma believes anyway. When Neily decides to attend Anglophile James Van Alen's lavish Elizabethan fancy dress party at his cottage, Wakehurst, Neily's wife Grace worries he'll do something reckless and begs Emma to come along as a steadying influence. The party is entertaining, with the host speaking like Shakespeare, an archery contest which Emma wins, a jester and even a joust. Unfortunately, it seems to include a gate crasher. Emma spies her cousin arguing with an unfamiliar man who looks out of place. After breaking up the fight, Emma wanders off to avoid the joust, not wanting to see the horses hurt. She overhears an argument between socialite Imogene Schuyler and her fiancé, Jerome Herrington. After the angry couple part, Emma wanders off again. She's drawn to the howling of Mr. Van Alen's Mastiffs, a sound Emma has come to recognize from her own dog as a warning. She's horrified to stumble across the dead body of Imogene's father, Judge Clayton Schuyler, shot to death with an arrow. When the police arrive, Emma is horrified to discover her friend and longtime detective Jesse Whyte has been reassigned and instead, the arrogant Detective Gifford Myers, new in town, is handed the assignment. It seems the police chief has had it with Emma's "interference" with solving crimes and warns her to STAY OUT of police business. Well, Emma can't let that happen. This new detective has no understanding of Newport and Newporters. It's up to her to save Jesse's job and see justice done.
I was REALLY looking forward to this book. I recognized Wakehurst from the cover and I know I've at least been by it but I think also inside. I just love all the local color packed into this series. I got a little sidetracked from my reading to look up some of the people and places mentioned. I was dying to see Mr. Van Alen's Wakehurst and not the Wakehurst of today, part of Salve Regina University. I discovered Grace and Neily's home, Beaulieu, sold recently so there are loads of photos online. I know the Berwinds "monstrosity" is The Elms and my parents went there in early 2020. Of course I've been to The Breakers and I know of Castle Hill, a swanky inn (rooms start at $435 per night in off season and peak at $1245 PER NIGHT) and restaurant. It's always fun time traveling to Gilded Age Newport. I picked up on a cameo by one of Alyssa Maxwell's husband's ancestors again. That shows how deeply embedded her love for Newport is. That love shine through the pages of the novel and it's where the writing excels. Alyssa Maxwell seamlessly creates a world where fictional characters associate with real people and you can't tell the difference. She even creates backstories and chooses summer residences for her fictional characters to make them all that more realistic. I absolutely loved that!
The mystery didn't really grab me that much. There was too much backstory about Cornelius Vanderbilt and his family drama that was entirely unnecessary to the plot. It just puts Emma in the right place at the right time and helps her discover something important about her ethics. It's repetitive in spots when Emma shares her story but she even repeats information already mentioned. As much as I adore all the historical detail, a lot of it is unnecessary. There's a lot of labor history in the story and I think I heard something about that incident. I really, really hated the sexist jerk policeman plot. In the first book, yes that always makes sense but now? After all this time? I'm not interested. I always liked seeing the contrast between the new monied elite of New York vs. old Newporters and how Jesse and Emma's knowledge of their home gives them a unique perspective. There is a secondary plot for Jesse and that's when the book picked up for me.
didn't always like Emma's investigating. She does something unethical and gets caught by someone she shouldn't cross. It's one thing to use the servants to listen to gossip for you and another to do what she does. This is the second time she's crossed the line for me but she learned her lesson about confronting a suspect at the Newport Reading Room so hopefully she learned another lesson here. I never, ever figured out who the murderer was, not even when Emma confronted that person. For most of the book I was certain Emma was chasing red herrings and I knew who the murderer was from the beginning. Naturally I was wrong.
I do appreciate Emma's sense of ethics. I would feel the same way. I was surprised she was so compassionate towards Mr. Gould! Save the horse, let the man fend for himself or not. Nanny would admonish Emma if she did so and Emma is much sweeter and kinder than I am. I was surprised by the romantic developments in this story. Derrick has finally manned up and realized his parents are nasty and manipulative. Mrs. Andrews is an absolutely nasty B**** and has no reason to be rude to Emma even when Emma's behavior was inexcusable. I foresee further complications though after the surprising conclusion.
Emma's closest friends are advisors are Nanny and Katie. Her old nanny still treats Emma as a girl and has lots of advice. She knows Emma better than anyone else and knows what's in Emma's heart . Katie may be a servant and a newer friend, but her sweet and forgiving nature seems to inspire Emma. Katie has a lot of profound insights from her past and both these ladies help guide Emma to a better future. Ethan, the society reporter, has become a friend as well. He likes and respects Emma and of course she passed on the plum job to him. Emma's boss, Mr. Sheppard, is great. Her treats her like any other reporter and that means he respects her.
Another friend is Grace, her cousin Neily's wife. Grace is lovely and kind but can't deal with her angsty husband on her own. I know there's not a happy ending for these two but I so wish there was. I think Neily is acting like a spoiled brat and his inheritance is plenty plus he has skills to get a job. Emma comes to realize something else may be bothering him. When it's revealed what he's really upset about, I felt it was out of character for a Vanderbilt or any of the Society people of that era.
A lot of time is spent explaining who Judge Schuyler was (Hamilfans, he's some distant relative of Angelica, Eliza and Peggy from the Philadelphia Main Line branch of the family). He was an exemplary man and truly remarkable. His recent ruling in favor of railroad unionists surprised me - and everyone else. I would have expected he would side with the robber barons. This ruling may have made him a VERY unpopular man but would one of the 400 Club members murder one of their own? Would they stoop so low as to murder in the first place? Perhaps that's who the mysterious man arguing with Neily is, a hitman. Judge Schuyler didn't act as benevolently towards his daughter, Imogene. He has arranged a marriage for her, to a Jerome Harrington, a young man of a prominent banking fortune who has struck out on his own for reasons unknown. He's a good catch on paper but what Emma overhears makes me think he really is not a good person. He was nasty to Imogene and it's better she knows that now. Her father can't REALLY FORCE her into an unwanted marriage. That's not legal. He can cut off her money, keep her shut up at home but in 1899 as Emma has discovered, a woman can be independent and live her own life if she's brave enough (and poor enough) to try it.
Mr. Van Alen is charmingly eccentric. An even bigger Anglophile than any Anglophile I've ever met, he's built an exact replica of an English estate complete with Elizabethan garden. I like how he speaks like a Shakespeare character but outside of the party, that makes little sense and gets a bit annoying. The party actually sounds like fun and one I would attend if invited. He's kind and well meaning. His manners are all they should be and more. How shocking and upsetting for a murder to occur on his property during his party!
Imogene Schuyler is one of those mean girl types. She can't be outshone by anyone and doesn't like to lose. She's very nasty and mean to Emma in a snide way. Who is her plain friend in the brown dress and spectacles? I wouldn't expect a mean girl to be friends with a bluestocking. Her mother is even nastier. I wouldn't be surprised if she killed her husband. I think she's totally the type.
Detective Gifford Myers is an @$$. He's an arrogant jerk on a power trip. He has no idea how to deal with people and is probably the type to bow to the elite and let them control him. He's the anti-Jesse. I wouldn't be surprised if he bungles the investigation on purpose because one of the 400 Club murdered the judge.
Mr. Oberlin, a tailor, is upset because his shop was broken into. Nothing was stolen except for one custom made gentleman's suit! He seems like a nice man and whoever did that was thoughtless and didn't care whether a working man lost money because of the robbery. Jesse and Emma are on the case as Emma believes she saw the suit of clothing on the mystery man arguing with Neily. I'm not so certain. While Mr. Oberlin seems nice, it's suspicious neither he or any of the neighbors saw or heard the break-in. Is this case even connected with the murder? I think it's a red herring.
Burt Covey, the actor hired to play the jester, is not such a jovial fellow in real life. That is, unless he's running from the murderer because he saw something he shouldn't have. He's kind of snippy and rude and uncooperative. I don't like him much and I don't think he's hiding from the murderer. His colleague, Clarice O'Shea, the party's Titania, is more forthcoming. She seems nice and honest but she's an actress and I'm uncertain she's telling the truth. What she says about her relationship with Jerome and what Emma overheard don't match up.
Eliza Denholm, the daughter of an English Earl and Dollar Princess, now divorced, is a young bluestocking who attended the Elizabethan fete. She may have valuable answers to Emma's questions but she gets a little defensive and snippy. It's too bad Emma didn't know how to handle her because I think Eliza could become a protégée of Emma's and a good friend. Her defense of her friend may be admirable but not if she's hiding something. Alexander Aggasiz seems like a nice man and very philanthropic. He's a scientist raising funds for the Harvard Museum of Comparative Zoology. Unfortunately, his money comes from mining and Emma believes that may put his life in danger. I hope not because he made many worthy contributions to science and he seems to respect Emma and not dismiss her as a society reporter. Felix Matthison, an avid photographer, also seems like a kind man but has ties to mining. Could that be the common denominator?
Ernest Kemp claims to be a tourist with an interest in early American architecture. Who is he really and why is he in Newport? He doesn't seem very cooperative which means he has something to hide. What is his connection to the murder? Is he the man Emma saw with Neily or is she mistaken?
While this wasn't my favorite of the series, I still look forward to more Gilded Newport stories to come.