I don’t often quote poetry in reviews because it doesn’t translate well, but here’s an exception, because it’s perfect:
“Imagine a girl, not yet trouble”
Hear me out. It’s preceded by a snatch of Negro spiritual—“Wade in the water [...] God’s gonna trouble the water”—and followed by the story of a young girl’s baptism. It’s the first line of Wilkinson's first lyrical poem in the collection (the very first is a prose poem, elegant in its own way, but for my money Wilkinson’s lyric, compressed sensibility is outstanding), and it pretty much immediately sold me on this collection. These six words, two bars of 3/4 time, musical in rhythm and sound, contain a world of sorrow. And I’m not just talking about that amazing line break.
We’re asked to imagine a girl before puberty, before—from the perspective of the male gaze and the mothers who force themselves into that gaze as a “protective” measure—she enters a time of such objectification that she becomes identified, to her community and herself, as sexual currency. We learn later in the collection what gauntlets of sexual harassment and violence Wilkinson survived (it’s bad!), but we get a glimpse, here, of what a young girl is before her community turns her into a siren, temptress, slut, or ice queen: a young girl. I found this line heart-breaking, and delightfully deft. The poem’s glimpse of baptism as a rite of passage initiating young girls into a man’s world is the gentlest punch in the face, and I love it so much.
And the entire collection has this delicate sensibility and light touch. It recalls a rural childhood in Kentucky and experiences that are essential to defining what it is to be a black woman in that space. “Black Body,” an eloquent prose poem (and one of the best I’ve ever read), is a powerful container for the grief, alienation, self-loathing, self-love, and compassion that exist together there, highlighting the limitlessness of fertility and creativity. Wilkinson’s movement between short-line lyrical poems and blocky prose poems is beautifully adept, and the shifts in register and form evoke both her complex inner life and the adjustments Black southerners have to make in tone and body language to live in the south.
Rural southern life is always connected to agriculture and kitchen scenes—prove me wrong. This collection touches both, but finds a home in domestic scenes at the stove, at the kitchen table, at supper. I loved “O Tobacco,” a paean to the crop that fed and clothed generations of families in the south. Effortless, trim evocation of the familiar (to me, a fellow southern Appalachian) smells and sights of barn lofts, drying tobacco, hard-packed dirt floors. But the kitchen scenes are where Wilkinson settles, watching her grandmother can, pickle, simmer, knead, chop, and fry. Her images are so crisp you smell them. These scenes stretch out on either side, as Wilkinson herself learns to cook, and learns how it feels and what it can mean to cook for your family, and as she reaches back along matrilineal lines, cooking under the watchful gaze of her grandmother and great-grandmothers, their ghosts both speaking and mute. These poems are philosophical in their treatment of enslaved ancestors (of whom she knows a few important bits and pieces), and the power she draws from their stories, but grounded in concrete movements and images.
It’s such a wide-ranging book, in style and thematic material, and it manages to really be excellent on every page. Please go buy this book (from your local indie bookstore)!