**Many thanks to NetGalley, Random House-Ballantine, and Jennifer E. Smith for a gifted copy of this book!! Now available as of 3.1!!**
"One good thing about music, when it hits you, you feel no pain"- Bob Marley
Greta James has been proving this adage since her teenage years. Starting as many guitarists do, in tiny coffee shops and school talent shows, she is now A Name in the music biz. Her climb to semi-stardom, however, is interrupted when tragedy arrives at her doorstep: her mother has unexpectedly passed away. Greta made the decision not to leave her gig, but is wracked with guilt and dealing with the fall out of her first (and biggest) fan's passing. After losing it mid-song in front of a live audience, Greta feels the pressure to keep her career on an uphill trajectory while trying to heal emotionally. As if this weren't enough, brother Asher encourages her to accompany their father Conrad on a week long Alaskan cruise...one that he was SUPPOSED to take with Greta's mother to celebrate their anniversary. And of course there's the tiny fact that Conrad has never approved of Greta's 'unstable' career in the first place...
Once aboard, Conrad and Greta are forced to spend a LOT of time together, with friends and neighbors as their only occasional buffer...until Greta meets Your Stereotypical History Professor and Ultra-Cute Nerd Ben Wilder, who is obsessed with Jack London's Call of the Wild and has boarded the ship to deal with some emotional trauma of his own. Will Greta make it through the week in one piece? What does she have to learn from Ben...and will the ice, the snow, and the ever-widening chasm between her and Conrad hold fast...or like an ice floe, split off for good?
I've been wanting to dive into Jennifer Smith's work for a while, which up until this point has been in the YA world. I'm not sure how I'd feel about her YA work...but I have a pretty good feeling after reading this book, that I would ABSOLUTELY love it! The writing in this book is reminiscent of YA in certain respects, with fairly quick chapters, a reasonable page count, and characters you can grasp fairly quickly. In many respects, this COULD have been changed and pared down to fit a teenage audience...but I am SO grateful Smith didn't do that. The relationships in this one are so better realized as fully fledged adult relationships, with poignant reflections on careers, relationships, and most importantly, parent-child dynamics. The strife between Conrad and Greta was palpable, relatable, and beautifully crafted. It was hard to read at times, but gripping all along. Smith's choice to give the novel a bit of balance with the blossoming relationship between Greta and Ben was wise: it kept the novel from feeling TOO tragic, heavy, and dark.
Music is of course the through line for Greta, but she is far from the cliched rock star, and the layers of her personality slowly unfurl over the course of the narrative. I also appreciate that Smith didn't tack ANY sort of a groan inducing 'too-good-to-be-true' ending on this tale. It didn't need it, and would have done the character of Greta a great disservice. Grief doesn't get boxed away and tied up neatly just because a certain amount of time has passed, or a certain event has happened. It is simply to be managed, worked through, and used to create something better and more beautiful in the world. Greta does all of this and more. This is a tragic, lovely, and moving story that will have you reflecting on your own family, music, love, and so many other essential facets of life.
Molly Brown might be the first Unsinkable woman---but Greta James is by far the most unshakable AND unbreakable!
4 stars
Now available in paperback!