This episode is a fabulous surprise in the series! I enjoyed every page of it, from the traditions of a Cabot Cove Christmas to the thrill of vicariously holding and reading historical documents from the late 18th century. Jessica is planning the best Christmas this year, as her home is finally ready for her to move back to. For the first time in years, she will be able to celebrate with Grady, the nephew she and her late husband Frank raised, and his family.
Jessica is at the favorite local diner, Mara’s, with Dr. Seth Hazlitt and Sheriff Mort Metzger, when her contractor calls. They are beginning to replace her septic system; the final step in her home rebuild. They found human remains in the trench, so the three head for her back yard.
While discussing what is in the trench, a trio from the tabloid TV show, Stalker, arrive. Tad, the star, wants to do a series on what he has dubbed the “murder capital of the country”. He has some unusual ideas as to what the cause of the murders are, one of them even being that Jessica is behind the murders because, after all, she is a mystery writer. Mort sends them away, refusing to allow them to film a new police investigation.
The state police confirm Seth’s estimate. One skeleton belongs to a man who died in late 1700’s, and the other, a young woman, who died 10 to 16 months ago. Both had been murdered. The other find in the trench that Mort kept in Cabot Cove might shed some light on the older remains. There was a wood chest from the colonial period, according to its craftsmanship and hardware. Inside are many journals and documents that they think are the founding documents of Cabot Cove that went missing many, many years ago. They could not have been buried that long as they are too well-preserved. And one of the skeletons has soil on it that was not from the trench. They would have only been there for a couple days, if that long. Someone alive now, presumably in Cabot Cove, has put them in the trench since excavation began, but why?
Tad, of Stalker, has a few secrets of his own, including ones kept from his producer and photographer. He is there to get an even bigger story than he will tell them, but never revealed what it is before he was murdered in his hotel room. When his real identity is learned, there is something more going on behind the scenes than anyone could have guessed.
The characters are so delightful and engaging! Jessica, Mort, and Seth would be an interesting group to sit down at Mara’s with for coffee and a slice of pie. Add Harry, her favorite PI, in town to join her for Christmas and mystery, and I would be happy to join this group just to see them work out a case. If anyone could find the who, the whodunit, and why in this mystery, it is this crew! The ending brought surprises that I could not have guessed. Don’t let this being the 52nd in the series put you off from reading it, as there is sufficient backstory to make these old friends come to life. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys well-written cozy mysteries with excellent characters, a Christmas setting, and a baffling mystery!
From a thankful heart: I received a complimentary copy of this novel, and this is my honest review.