This anthology was put together in 1963, featuring authors who were (mostly) alive at the time. Then-contemporary-now-dated is a peculiar vibe and it thrilled me to be holding a 60+ year old book in my hands.
The stories are organized from relative light to pretty grim. The earlier ones are more domestic and closed circle crimes and include a surprising number of the inverted type—you start out knowing who the murderer is and it's a question of why and howdunnit and whether they actually get caught.
Excellent ones The holy well / H.C. Bailey (incredibly atmospheric) Murder! / Arnold Bennett (satisfying ending) By kind permission of the murdered man / Hylton Cleaver (one of the good Inverted murders—but with a twist) Suspect unknown / Courtney Ryley Cooper (fun buildup) The specialty of the house / Stanley Ellin (dark but terrific) Phyllis Annesley's peril / R. Austin Freeman (stretches the imagination but excellent nevertheless)
Good ones The clue of the red wig / John Dickson Carr (surprise criminal but annoying protagonist) Triangle at Rhodes / Agatha Christie (how Poirot knows what's happening is a bit meh, but otherwise, great characters and a solid plot that she's repurposed many times before) No trace / Veronica Parker Johns (interesting narrator) Listen, listen! / R.E. Kendall (terrific ending) The letter / Somerset Maugham (very readable, even though the murderer is treated far too leniently) The fountain plays / Dorothy Sayers (you almost feel sorry for the murderer!) The sleeve / L.A.G. Strong (good ending)
The holy well / H.C. Bailey --3 Murder! / Arnold Bennett --3 Murder for posterity / Margot Bennett (NA)-- Aren't our police wonderful? / Christianna Brand --2 The clue of the red wig / John Dickson Carr --3 Triangle at Rhodes / Agatha Christie --2 By kind permission of the murdered man / Hylton Cleaver --3 Suspect unknown / Courtney Ryley Cooper --3 Recipe for murder / C.J. Donnel --2 *The empty house / Arthur Conan Doyle -- The specialty of the house / Stanley Ellin --2 The letters in evidence / C.S. Forester --2 *Phyllis Annesley's peril / R. Austin Freeman -- No trace / Veronica Parker Johns --3 Listen, listen! / R.E. Kendall -- *A roof in Manhattan / Hilda Lawrence (NA)-- Ten o'clock / Philip Macdonald --2 *Wilful murder / H.A. Manhood -- The letter / Somerset Maugham --4 The murder in the fishing cat / Edna St. Vincent Millay --2 He got what she wanted / Nigel Morland --1 In the dark / E. Nesbit --3 The undiscovered murderer / E. Phillips Oppenheim --2 The murders in the Rue Morgue / Edgar Allen Poe --3 Sense of humour / Damon Runyon --3 The fountain plays / Dorothy Sayers --2 The sleeve / L.A.G. Strong (NA)-- The rubber trumpet / Roy Vickers --2 Being a murderer myself / Arthur Williams --3 The boat race murder / David Winser --2 Inquest / Loel Yeo--3