What do you think?
Rate this book
House of El #1
House of El: Book One: The Shadow Threat (House of El
A brand-new vision of one of comics most famous tragedies-the first of a trilogy of young adult graphic novels by New York Times bestselling writer Claudia Gray and illustrator Eric Zawadzki!
Explore Krypton like never before: through the eyes of two teenagers on opposite sides of the same extinction-level event. Zahn is one of Krypton’s elites: wealthy, privileged, a future leader. Sera is one of Krypton’s soldiers: strong, dedicated, fearless. Their rule-bound society has ordained that their paths should never cross. But groundquakes are shaking the planet’s surface. Rebellious uprisings are shaking the populace. Krypton’s top scientists, Jor-El and Lara, conduct a secret experiment that is meant to reform their planet from the cellular level up.
Zahn and Sera must join forces to investigate the hidden dangers truly threatening Krypton. In the process, they form a bond that will endure past the end of the world...
Explore Krypton like never before: through the eyes of two teenagers on opposite sides of the same extinction-level event. Zahn is one of Krypton’s elites: wealthy, privileged, a future leader. Sera is one of Krypton’s soldiers: strong, dedicated, fearless. Their rule-bound society has ordained that their paths should never cross. But groundquakes are shaking the planet’s surface. Rebellious uprisings are shaking the populace. Krypton’s top scientists, Jor-El and Lara, conduct a secret experiment that is meant to reform their planet from the cellular level up.
Zahn and Sera must join forces to investigate the hidden dangers truly threatening Krypton. In the process, they form a bond that will endure past the end of the world...
197 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 5, 2021
14 people are currently reading
2337 people want to read
About the author
Claudia Gray
79 books14.2k followersClaudia Gray is not my real name. I didn't choose a pseudonym because my real name is unpleasant (it isn't), because I'd always dreamed of calling myself this (I haven't) or even because I'm hiding from the remnants of that international diamond-smuggling cartel I smashed in 2003 (Interpol has taken care of them). In short, I took a pseudonym for no real reason whatsoever. Sometimes this is actually the best reason to do things.
I live in New Orleans. So far, in life, I've been a disc jockey, a lawyer, a journalist and an extremely bad waitress, just to name a few. I especially like to spend time traveling, hiking, reading and listening to music. More than anything else, I enjoy writing.
I live in New Orleans. So far, in life, I've been a disc jockey, a lawyer, a journalist and an extremely bad waitress, just to name a few. I especially like to spend time traveling, hiking, reading and listening to music. More than anything else, I enjoy writing.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 164 reviews
January 5, 2021
THE SHADOW THREAT is the first volume in a planned trilogy of YA graphic novels from DC Comics called House of El, penned by highly-acclaimed author Claudia Gray and illustrated by Eric Zawadzki. The story begins before the destruction of Krypton but already there are tremors and groundquakes being felt across the planet. A select group of citizens are demanding answers as to the causes of the instability, feeling as if the tribunes at the head of the government may be covering something up.
Suspicions grow even more when the leaders of Krypton order other planets in the system to be terraformed immediately, most so hurriedly that they trigger violent eruptions and the spawning of creatures beyond imagination. Throughout it all the tribunes continue to tell the populace that absolutely nothing is wrong and that Krypton is too perfect a society to worry about any potential disasters occurring.
I haven't read many graphic novels in recent years but THE SHADOW THREAT was one of the best and had me fixated the entire time. The story totally captivated me and it effectively encapsulated the struggle between the upper caste and the general population and soldiers. It shows how corruption can eat away at the system from the inside and how that same corruption can lead to the suppression of information that is vital to a free functioning society.
Yet there was also an undercurrent of hope as the few who choose to resist are determined to uncover what they believe the government is hiding from them. There was also a nice forbidden romance aspect that personalized the characters and elevated them from mere cookie cutter status to something much deeper. Another pretty cool moment is when General Zod makes a brief appearance. Let's just say he is portrayed quite differently from the accused criminal who is banished from Krypton years later. It was interesting to get a little more backstory on this somewhat enigmatic character.
I'd be remiss if I didn't mention the stunning artwork in this graphic novel by the extremely talented Eric Zawadzki. He captures the mood and tension in the story brilliantly with amazing deftness and it really made the story so much more enriching as a result. Kudos for his ability to perfectly depict the plot visually and to render it so vividly with his magnificent illustrations.
In the end I was totally sucked into THE SHADOW THREAT and found myself devouring it pretty quickly. This was a fantastic opening volume in the House of El graphic novel trilogy that bodes well for the entries to come. I can't wait to check out the next two to see how this incredible story plays out. I mean, I kind of know how it plays out based on the history, but it is fascinating to get a better perspective on exactly what could have taken place before the tragedy of what eventually befell the doomed planet of Krypton. I simply loved the ride and this has gotten me back on reading graphic novels again, it was that good!
Suspicions grow even more when the leaders of Krypton order other planets in the system to be terraformed immediately, most so hurriedly that they trigger violent eruptions and the spawning of creatures beyond imagination. Throughout it all the tribunes continue to tell the populace that absolutely nothing is wrong and that Krypton is too perfect a society to worry about any potential disasters occurring.
I haven't read many graphic novels in recent years but THE SHADOW THREAT was one of the best and had me fixated the entire time. The story totally captivated me and it effectively encapsulated the struggle between the upper caste and the general population and soldiers. It shows how corruption can eat away at the system from the inside and how that same corruption can lead to the suppression of information that is vital to a free functioning society.
Yet there was also an undercurrent of hope as the few who choose to resist are determined to uncover what they believe the government is hiding from them. There was also a nice forbidden romance aspect that personalized the characters and elevated them from mere cookie cutter status to something much deeper. Another pretty cool moment is when General Zod makes a brief appearance. Let's just say he is portrayed quite differently from the accused criminal who is banished from Krypton years later. It was interesting to get a little more backstory on this somewhat enigmatic character.
I'd be remiss if I didn't mention the stunning artwork in this graphic novel by the extremely talented Eric Zawadzki. He captures the mood and tension in the story brilliantly with amazing deftness and it really made the story so much more enriching as a result. Kudos for his ability to perfectly depict the plot visually and to render it so vividly with his magnificent illustrations.
In the end I was totally sucked into THE SHADOW THREAT and found myself devouring it pretty quickly. This was a fantastic opening volume in the House of El graphic novel trilogy that bodes well for the entries to come. I can't wait to check out the next two to see how this incredible story plays out. I mean, I kind of know how it plays out based on the history, but it is fascinating to get a better perspective on exactly what could have taken place before the tragedy of what eventually befell the doomed planet of Krypton. I simply loved the ride and this has gotten me back on reading graphic novels again, it was that good!
January 10, 2021
I loved reading this graphic novel, and this particular book is the first in this planned trilogy, which really sets up the story introducing the wonderful characters as we meet Zahn and Sera as Krypton is threatened. The illustration was phenomenal and really added to the description storyline. Fabulous comics I enjoyed!
September 28, 2023
I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher (DC Comics) for promotional purposes.
Going into this book, I didn’t know what to expect. I didn’t know much about Krypton, other than the fact it is Superman’s birthplace. But once I started reading it, I was very intrigued!
I’ve read many of DC’s graphic novels for young adults, and this one leans more on the action packed side (some other titles in the line are more slower paced and introspective). This book is full of adventure and there is never a dull moment.
I found the setting of Krypton to be so interesting. It was a utopia where things weren’t actually perfect.
I also liked the two main characters, Sera and Zahn. They are from 2 different castes (Sera is a solider and Zahn is an elite future leader), but team up due to their doubts about Krypton. They were both so well developed and had an equal amount of storyline.
The artwork worked very well for the story. The colors were vivid and really brought the word to life. The action scenes were also nicely drawn.
Since this is the first book in a trilogy, it does end in a cliffhanger that makes you want to read the next one ASAP.
Overall, if you’re looking for an exciting and action filled graphic novel, read this one!
Going into this book, I didn’t know what to expect. I didn’t know much about Krypton, other than the fact it is Superman’s birthplace. But once I started reading it, I was very intrigued!
I’ve read many of DC’s graphic novels for young adults, and this one leans more on the action packed side (some other titles in the line are more slower paced and introspective). This book is full of adventure and there is never a dull moment.
I found the setting of Krypton to be so interesting. It was a utopia where things weren’t actually perfect.
I also liked the two main characters, Sera and Zahn. They are from 2 different castes (Sera is a solider and Zahn is an elite future leader), but team up due to their doubts about Krypton. They were both so well developed and had an equal amount of storyline.
The artwork worked very well for the story. The colors were vivid and really brought the word to life. The action scenes were also nicely drawn.
Since this is the first book in a trilogy, it does end in a cliffhanger that makes you want to read the next one ASAP.
Overall, if you’re looking for an exciting and action filled graphic novel, read this one!
January 13, 2021
Originally published on The Nerd Daily | Review by David Allen
The House of El Book One: The Shadow Threat is the first in a new trilogy of graphic novels. It is clearly a part of the effort to draw in new, younger readers. Written by prolific young adult author Claudia Gray, with art by Eric Zawadzki, the book attempts to put a new twist on the story of the demise of the planet Krypton.
Gray is best known for her Evernight series and her work as a Star Wars novelist. With The House of El, she has to face a pretty substantial challenge. Is it possible to present the last days of the planet Krypton, Superman’s home world, in a new way after so many writers have put their own spin on its story? To her credit, the answer is a resounding “yes”.
Read the FULL REVIEW on The Nerd Daily
The House of El Book One: The Shadow Threat is the first in a new trilogy of graphic novels. It is clearly a part of the effort to draw in new, younger readers. Written by prolific young adult author Claudia Gray, with art by Eric Zawadzki, the book attempts to put a new twist on the story of the demise of the planet Krypton.
Gray is best known for her Evernight series and her work as a Star Wars novelist. With The House of El, she has to face a pretty substantial challenge. Is it possible to present the last days of the planet Krypton, Superman’s home world, in a new way after so many writers have put their own spin on its story? To her credit, the answer is a resounding “yes”.
Read the FULL REVIEW on The Nerd Daily
February 3, 2021
This first of three planned parts serves to introduce the protagonists (Zahn-Re and Sera-Ur), the important side characters (Lara and Jor-El, Zod, etc.) and the stakes (the viability of Krypton and survival of the Kryptonian species and civilization, wouldn’t ya know).
DC seems to have hit kind of a groove with this style of YA graphic novel with talented writers like Gray and stylized art that conveys more narrative than detail. I will certainly check out the second volume when it’s released later this year.
DC seems to have hit kind of a groove with this style of YA graphic novel with talented writers like Gray and stylized art that conveys more narrative than detail. I will certainly check out the second volume when it’s released later this year.
March 29, 2021
I can still remember hearing a character on Lois & Clark saying, "Lord Kal-El, from the house of El." Back in the day, I had a field day with that quotation; I adapted it into an insult, which shows you where my mind was back then. Thankfully, I've matured quite a bit since those days.
As for the book itself: Even though the ending is obvious from the get-go--everyone knows what happens to the planet Krypton!--this is still an interesting history of the infamous doomed home of Superman.
As for the book itself: Even though the ending is obvious from the get-go--everyone knows what happens to the planet Krypton!--this is still an interesting history of the infamous doomed home of Superman.
August 3, 2021
I don't read Graphics that often, but I couldn't pass up on buying this one way back before it's release. I put in a pre-order and the rest was history. Written by Claudia Gray, set on Krypton before it's destroyed and a interesting synopsis... Count me in!
And I wasn't dissapointed, now that I finally got around to actually read it!
I liked the detailed graphics by Eric Zawadzki; it all matched the story written by Gray very well.
There's a solid story line build up towards the end and I'm excited to see how the story continues.
So the next installment will definitely be bought as a pre-order when the time comes.
This was a fun, fast paced read and if you're into graphics, DC Comics and especially interested in reading a story set on Krypton, I definitely recommend this. You'll be meeting new characters but some already know ones will make appaearances as well, so that was great!
And I wasn't dissapointed, now that I finally got around to actually read it!
I liked the detailed graphics by Eric Zawadzki; it all matched the story written by Gray very well.
There's a solid story line build up towards the end and I'm excited to see how the story continues.
So the next installment will definitely be bought as a pre-order when the time comes.
This was a fun, fast paced read and if you're into graphics, DC Comics and especially interested in reading a story set on Krypton, I definitely recommend this. You'll be meeting new characters but some already know ones will make appaearances as well, so that was great!
November 20, 2020
I received a copy of The Shadow Threat in exchange for a fair and honest review.
The Shadow Threat (House of El #1) is the tale of Krypton, before everything went so horribly wrong. Written by Claudia Gray (the detail that caught my attention to begin with) and illustrated by Eric Zawadski, this is a fascinating tale that shows a darker side of Krypton.
Zahn is one of the elites on Krypton. He was born into wealth, power, and privilege, and only recently has he realized just how much farther ahead that has brought him in life. How many times it has saved his life, or changed it for the better. Perhaps that is the reason why he's intent to join a rebellion.
Sera was born and bred to be one of Krypton's soldiers – literally. It's her job to protect the people, and to take on all of the risky missions specifically designed for the soldiers. She's one of the best at her job, despite all of the constraints.
You'd think that these two would never meet, but you'd be wrong. Their paths are about to collide in the events of The Shadow Threat, as both struggle to come to terms with all of the signs they've been seeing.
I'm going to be honest with you here, I really wasn't sure what to expect from The Shadow Threat. While I do read a lot of comics, I'm arguably the weakest when it comes to Superman knowledge. That being said, I just knew that I had to give it a try when I saw Claudia Gray's name on the project.
I'm actually pretty happy that I took a chance and gave it a go. Though I'm certain my experience will be drastically different from somebody who knows everything about Superman and his home planet.
The art style felt almost Atlantean at times, yet it actually worked quite nicely for Krypton and all of the advancements it has available. I adored the color palette, and for the most part, liked the character designs as well.
The differing plots revolving around Zahn and Sera were fascinating. Both had such strong personalities, and plenty of reason to be questioning the status quo (even if it is truly the last thing they wanted to be doing).
It raised a lot of questions along the way, and I for one am actually really looking forward to seeing what happens in the next installment of the series. That may be my lack of knowledge speaking there, I'm not certain. I'm not worried though, as it will be a fun read regardless.
Check out more reviews over at Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks
The Shadow Threat (House of El #1) is the tale of Krypton, before everything went so horribly wrong. Written by Claudia Gray (the detail that caught my attention to begin with) and illustrated by Eric Zawadski, this is a fascinating tale that shows a darker side of Krypton.
Zahn is one of the elites on Krypton. He was born into wealth, power, and privilege, and only recently has he realized just how much farther ahead that has brought him in life. How many times it has saved his life, or changed it for the better. Perhaps that is the reason why he's intent to join a rebellion.
Sera was born and bred to be one of Krypton's soldiers – literally. It's her job to protect the people, and to take on all of the risky missions specifically designed for the soldiers. She's one of the best at her job, despite all of the constraints.
You'd think that these two would never meet, but you'd be wrong. Their paths are about to collide in the events of The Shadow Threat, as both struggle to come to terms with all of the signs they've been seeing.
I'm going to be honest with you here, I really wasn't sure what to expect from The Shadow Threat. While I do read a lot of comics, I'm arguably the weakest when it comes to Superman knowledge. That being said, I just knew that I had to give it a try when I saw Claudia Gray's name on the project.
I'm actually pretty happy that I took a chance and gave it a go. Though I'm certain my experience will be drastically different from somebody who knows everything about Superman and his home planet.
The art style felt almost Atlantean at times, yet it actually worked quite nicely for Krypton and all of the advancements it has available. I adored the color palette, and for the most part, liked the character designs as well.
The differing plots revolving around Zahn and Sera were fascinating. Both had such strong personalities, and plenty of reason to be questioning the status quo (even if it is truly the last thing they wanted to be doing).
It raised a lot of questions along the way, and I for one am actually really looking forward to seeing what happens in the next installment of the series. That may be my lack of knowledge speaking there, I'm not certain. I'm not worried though, as it will be a fun read regardless.
Check out more reviews over at Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks
December 13, 2020
Before Superman, there was Krypton, and Krypton, before it exploded, has quite a backstory, and House of El is delving into that.
Each person is genetically engineered to be the perfect thing that they are supposed to be. If you are to be a soldier, you are the perfect one. but what if you weren't genetically engineered. That is the mystery at the heart of this, the first in what it is assumed to be a series of stories told before Superman was even born.
This first volume, only begins to touch on what makes a perfect, anything. If you are born into a house, does that make you what it is? Are all the genetics in place, and what happens with the things are removed.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.
Each person is genetically engineered to be the perfect thing that they are supposed to be. If you are to be a soldier, you are the perfect one. but what if you weren't genetically engineered. That is the mystery at the heart of this, the first in what it is assumed to be a series of stories told before Superman was even born.
This first volume, only begins to touch on what makes a perfect, anything. If you are born into a house, does that make you what it is? Are all the genetics in place, and what happens with the things are removed.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.
June 16, 2025
A good start for the trilogy. I think that for book one, the title is maybe a little misleading, but I’m sure it will become a more fitting title in future books given the role the Els play here and famously in DC canon. It’s got two interesting perspectives, that of a young person each from the society’s highest and lowest class coming to the same realization: that something is seriously wrong with their planet. Something that those in charge are trying to keep secret from the public. It helps that nearly everyone on Krypton has been genetically designed to be ignorant to developments like this— either so that they are too affluent to care or too selfless (to the point that they are literally programmed not to value their own lives) to be alarmed. Despite the genetic engineering, the two protagonists realize something is wrong anyway, and are inspired to take action to change it. I think Zahn-Re ends up coming off more likable than Sera-Ur in this one, but I bet that’s only because she’s programmed not to have an individual personality for most of the book. I’m optimistic my thoughts on her will change as the series goes on.
February 20, 2021
An interesting start to this story. It's fascinating for me to see Krypton and how it's supposedly perfect world was actually pretty horrible and messed up. This definitely gets across the difference between the castes and highlights the dangers of genetic engineering.
January 11, 2021
Claudia Gray is the queen of taking IP and turning it into gold (she also seems to live in a world without time because HOW DOES SHE DO IT ALL?!). To say I was excited for House of El: The Shadow Threat is an understatement. I’ve always been curious about the time before Superman came to Earth and this trilogy starter was out of this world!
This page turner kept my fully in the story, with action, worldbuilding, and captivating art. The book establishes this universe’s unique take on the House of El and establishes itself as part of Superman but not reliant on him.
The Shadow Threat takes on not only the clear political instability as Krypton gets to a boiling point but also the challenges of genetic engineering. Classism reigns in the world of those with and without modifications, mirroring the issues we would inevitably have with such an endeavor.
I too would like to know the truth about Krypton. A solid start to this series – I can’t wait to see what comes next!
TY DC Comics for sending me a copy of House of El: The Shadow Threat!
This page turner kept my fully in the story, with action, worldbuilding, and captivating art. The book establishes this universe’s unique take on the House of El and establishes itself as part of Superman but not reliant on him.
The Shadow Threat takes on not only the clear political instability as Krypton gets to a boiling point but also the challenges of genetic engineering. Classism reigns in the world of those with and without modifications, mirroring the issues we would inevitably have with such an endeavor.
I too would like to know the truth about Krypton. A solid start to this series – I can’t wait to see what comes next!
TY DC Comics for sending me a copy of House of El: The Shadow Threat!
October 6, 2021
This is certainly a "book one", feeling like the first part of a larger story that isn't as satisfying as an individual release. We know the general story of Krypton, how it's super advanced but doomed to die, and this series sets out to show its final days. The hypocrisy of its leaders who attempt to ignore the signs of catastrophe closely mirrors our real world's approach to climate change, albeit Krypton can get away with blaming parts of it on eugenics. I have hope for where this series ends up, and how the characters progress from here on, but it felt like they were only just getting to the interesting parts when the book ended.
November 13, 2020
This book is set on krypton from the superman mythology but it really doesn’t have anything to do with superheroes other than the backstory of superman. The main theme is about genetic predisposition and genetic engineering with regards to social caste and philosophy. It wasn’t very captivating with the main characters but the story was new and interesting and some ways. By definition they were very one-sided. The art was fine. There isn’t much conclusion in book one so you need to read book two.
January 6, 2021
El problema con The Shadow Threat es que quiere abarcar mucho pero no logra absolutamente nada. Tarda más de 100 páginas en mostrarte el perfil de los personajes, el cual, siendo honesto, es sumamente plano.
Como una novela no relacionada con el universo DC podría haber funcionado, pero teniendo otros trabajos como Krypton y considerando todo lo que se ha hablado de ese planeta y su sociedad, esta novela se queda muy corta.
Como una novela no relacionada con el universo DC podría haber funcionado, pero teniendo otros trabajos como Krypton y considerando todo lo que se ha hablado de ese planeta y su sociedad, esta novela se queda muy corta.
December 31, 2020
House of El: The Shadow Threat covers quite a different perspective when it conveys a story of Krypton unlike one we've heard of before. Set before Superman and the explosion that destroyed Krypton, House of El holds a secret even the people of Krypton wouldn't be able to understand.
The Shadow Threat covers a series of events in Krypton about the genetic engineering that keeps their planet...perfect. Dedicated soldiers raised only understanding their sacrifice and high elites who only want power. Yet both are becoming blind to their failing planet and the dangers that reside within the core of it all. While the reader has a transversal perspective of both Sera and Zahn's personalities, they are quick to assume that one won't be able to survive without the other and both of them need each other's skills in an attempt to save the future of Krypton's people. When Sera undergoes an experimental treatment from none other than Lara herself...she quickly understands that the omitted emotions her genetics have never touched before are just what is needed to best serve Krypton.
Krypton is full of a society that is based on specific genetic engineering that is geared fulfill the roles of their society perfectly. Yet, not even those skilled to defend the city can save it. By lacking vital elements of humanity, Krypton will fail and fall. Unless Sera and Zahn can help save them. What once felt like a simple and perfect planet is quickly shattered by the reality of their government.
As we know from past DC Young Reader graphic novels, they advance a new perspective on the origin stories for a younger audience. Each illustration was mesmerizing, colorful, and great transition for visual concept. Action scenes were played out without gore and grueling details, yet still relevant to the sacrifice. Some characters are familiar within typical Superman research which will help transition the story later on.
This story starts out rather slow in regard to the reader understanding the mission. While I am told that this is at least a 3 book series, it leaves some details to be gained in the next installments. House of El: The Shadow Threat is a page-turning, sit and binge read that will suck the reader right to the planet of Krypton.
You won't need to be a fan of Superman to enjoy these new characters from the Krypton planet. Sera and Zahn are more than ready to steal the audience and make their own way into the DC Universe.
The Shadow Threat covers a series of events in Krypton about the genetic engineering that keeps their planet...perfect. Dedicated soldiers raised only understanding their sacrifice and high elites who only want power. Yet both are becoming blind to their failing planet and the dangers that reside within the core of it all. While the reader has a transversal perspective of both Sera and Zahn's personalities, they are quick to assume that one won't be able to survive without the other and both of them need each other's skills in an attempt to save the future of Krypton's people. When Sera undergoes an experimental treatment from none other than Lara herself...she quickly understands that the omitted emotions her genetics have never touched before are just what is needed to best serve Krypton.
Krypton is full of a society that is based on specific genetic engineering that is geared fulfill the roles of their society perfectly. Yet, not even those skilled to defend the city can save it. By lacking vital elements of humanity, Krypton will fail and fall. Unless Sera and Zahn can help save them. What once felt like a simple and perfect planet is quickly shattered by the reality of their government.
As we know from past DC Young Reader graphic novels, they advance a new perspective on the origin stories for a younger audience. Each illustration was mesmerizing, colorful, and great transition for visual concept. Action scenes were played out without gore and grueling details, yet still relevant to the sacrifice. Some characters are familiar within typical Superman research which will help transition the story later on.
This story starts out rather slow in regard to the reader understanding the mission. While I am told that this is at least a 3 book series, it leaves some details to be gained in the next installments. House of El: The Shadow Threat is a page-turning, sit and binge read that will suck the reader right to the planet of Krypton.
You won't need to be a fan of Superman to enjoy these new characters from the Krypton planet. Sera and Zahn are more than ready to steal the audience and make their own way into the DC Universe.
December 19, 2020
Thank you, DC comics, for sending me a free copy! All the opinions are my own.
I really loved reading this graphic novel!
Set on Krypton, the story follows two characters, very different from one other. Zahn is a Re, from and élite classs, while Sera is a Ur, a soldier. Both of them are programmed to be and act in a certain way. Their paths shouldn't cross, but slowly they start to question the truth about their government, about the groundquakes and the lies they are told. Between uprisings, esperiments and rebellion, in a society bound by caste, rules and lies, they will have to find a way to uncover the truth and save everyone.
The story is captivating and really interesting, dealing with themes like government lies, caste system, deaths and sacrifices. The artwork is amazing, the characters are well written and crafted and I can't wait to read what will happen next.
I really loved reading this graphic novel!
Set on Krypton, the story follows two characters, very different from one other. Zahn is a Re, from and élite classs, while Sera is a Ur, a soldier. Both of them are programmed to be and act in a certain way. Their paths shouldn't cross, but slowly they start to question the truth about their government, about the groundquakes and the lies they are told. Between uprisings, esperiments and rebellion, in a society bound by caste, rules and lies, they will have to find a way to uncover the truth and save everyone.
The story is captivating and really interesting, dealing with themes like government lies, caste system, deaths and sacrifices. The artwork is amazing, the characters are well written and crafted and I can't wait to read what will happen next.
January 4, 2021
First of, DC sent this book to me for free so I could review it. Thank you so much for that!
Even if you don’t know anything about the origin of Superman, you will still be able to follow the story. The images already tell you a lot and are really amazing. So it really isn’t hard to follow at all.
The problem with a lot of comics or graphic novels is that you miss an amount of depth. There is only so much you can tell by using images and actual conversations between people. That was a bit of the problem here as well. You do get to know all the important characters, but only on the surface. There are some hints and remarks about things that happened in the past between some of them. But it still keeps you guessing a lot. And that is a shame.
What I did like, that when you do know more about Krypton and the origin of Superman, you get to see some things you recognize. And I think the writer took the already existing characters and gave them a really nice spin. In combination with the amazing graphics, you finally get a real feel for Krypton. And it makes it easier to place some later things about Superman in perspective.
It was an enjoyable read. And if you like the Supermand story, or just sci-fi in general, I think this can be a nice graphic novel for you. It reads away easy, even without reading you can still follow a lot of the story because of the graphics. And it really keeps you guessing what will happen next and wanting to read the next book.
World building: 3/5
Characters: 3,5/5
Storyline 3,5/5
Even if you don’t know anything about the origin of Superman, you will still be able to follow the story. The images already tell you a lot and are really amazing. So it really isn’t hard to follow at all.
The problem with a lot of comics or graphic novels is that you miss an amount of depth. There is only so much you can tell by using images and actual conversations between people. That was a bit of the problem here as well. You do get to know all the important characters, but only on the surface. There are some hints and remarks about things that happened in the past between some of them. But it still keeps you guessing a lot. And that is a shame.
What I did like, that when you do know more about Krypton and the origin of Superman, you get to see some things you recognize. And I think the writer took the already existing characters and gave them a really nice spin. In combination with the amazing graphics, you finally get a real feel for Krypton. And it makes it easier to place some later things about Superman in perspective.
It was an enjoyable read. And if you like the Supermand story, or just sci-fi in general, I think this can be a nice graphic novel for you. It reads away easy, even without reading you can still follow a lot of the story because of the graphics. And it really keeps you guessing what will happen next and wanting to read the next book.
World building: 3/5
Characters: 3,5/5
Storyline 3,5/5
January 12, 2021
3.5/5
Fun introduction to a new arm of Superman lore. I love how well Gray writes stories for characters "in the background" of other more popular/known ones!
Check out my full review at Forever Young Adult.
Fun introduction to a new arm of Superman lore. I love how well Gray writes stories for characters "in the background" of other more popular/known ones!
Check out my full review at Forever Young Adult.
April 8, 2023
This was an enjoyable graphic novel. I am invested in the story and will continue reading.
Read
April 18, 2024Really great art, but only found the writing fine. The YA crowd would eat this right up, made me wish it was a little more steamy honestly
June 12, 2025
The story isn't finished. Even if it's a series, it should give the reader a payoff. But nope. It doesn't. Also, the story isn't that compelling. Therefore, I don't feel inclined to search for and buy the second book.
January 31, 2021
I did not care for the story and hated the artwork. I liked the cover.
February 3, 2021
Listen to Around Comics Ep. 359 to find out my thought on this book.
www.aroundcomics.com
www.aroundcomics.com
December 2, 2021
Ther's a lot of politics involved it really lays the groundwork for how krypton operates. I didn't know that everyone was genetically modified for their jobs. It ended on a cliffhanger so I'm ready for book 2.
4.5
4.5
June 21, 2022
Read more graphic novel reviews at www.graphiclibrary.org.
House of El is a story of Kryptonians before Superman is even born. There is an impending doom of the planet that the Tribunes refuse to admit is real, but citizens are starting to act out and investigate what's happening. A group of dissenters recruits Zohn, of the House of Re, who is part of the upper caste and destined to become one of Krypton's future leaders. Zohn knows that the earthquakes are getting worse and could be a sign that the planet is near to collapse. Elsewhere, Zohn's cousin, Lara, wife of Jor-El, is experimenting with rewriting the genetic code of Kryptonians in order to introduce missing elements left out from generations of genetic manipulation. Their chosen subject is Sera, an Ur, a lower caste, genetically engineered soldier bred to be completely loyal to Krypton. Urs are modified to live life without fear, without questioning orders, and without regard to their own lives. Lara hopes to create a better soldier with some semblance of self-preservation, believing that these omitted traits are essential for Kryptonians to fully serve their society.
The pre-collapse of Krypton is an interesting time in Superman's lore, as many people often question how an advanced civilization didn't realize their own planet was doomed. This series has started to explain what happened, and I appreciate the direction Gray is taking in her rendition of Krypton. There are some familiar characters: General Zod, who is Sera’s commanding officer, and Jor-El and wife Lara, Superman's parents. There isn't a ton of prerequisite knowledge needed to jump into this title, so this is a perfect place for new fans to get into Superman stories. There is one heck of a cliffhanger here, the frustration of which is compounded by a volume two release date of 2022.
Zawadzki's illustrations beautifully depict the futuristic society of Krypton. Most of the world is set in a light blue with decadent gold accents. The places frequented by the lower caste are anchored in browns and darker, dingy colors. Action sequences are fluid and easy to follow.
There are some action sequences with explosions, earthquakes that destroy buildings, and gunfire fighting, but no gore is seen on the page. This title would easily find a home on middle school and high school shelves.
Sara's Rating: 9/10
Suitability Level: Grades 7-10
This review was made possible with a digital reader copy from the publisher.
House of El is a story of Kryptonians before Superman is even born. There is an impending doom of the planet that the Tribunes refuse to admit is real, but citizens are starting to act out and investigate what's happening. A group of dissenters recruits Zohn, of the House of Re, who is part of the upper caste and destined to become one of Krypton's future leaders. Zohn knows that the earthquakes are getting worse and could be a sign that the planet is near to collapse. Elsewhere, Zohn's cousin, Lara, wife of Jor-El, is experimenting with rewriting the genetic code of Kryptonians in order to introduce missing elements left out from generations of genetic manipulation. Their chosen subject is Sera, an Ur, a lower caste, genetically engineered soldier bred to be completely loyal to Krypton. Urs are modified to live life without fear, without questioning orders, and without regard to their own lives. Lara hopes to create a better soldier with some semblance of self-preservation, believing that these omitted traits are essential for Kryptonians to fully serve their society.
The pre-collapse of Krypton is an interesting time in Superman's lore, as many people often question how an advanced civilization didn't realize their own planet was doomed. This series has started to explain what happened, and I appreciate the direction Gray is taking in her rendition of Krypton. There are some familiar characters: General Zod, who is Sera’s commanding officer, and Jor-El and wife Lara, Superman's parents. There isn't a ton of prerequisite knowledge needed to jump into this title, so this is a perfect place for new fans to get into Superman stories. There is one heck of a cliffhanger here, the frustration of which is compounded by a volume two release date of 2022.
Zawadzki's illustrations beautifully depict the futuristic society of Krypton. Most of the world is set in a light blue with decadent gold accents. The places frequented by the lower caste are anchored in browns and darker, dingy colors. Action sequences are fluid and easy to follow.
There are some action sequences with explosions, earthquakes that destroy buildings, and gunfire fighting, but no gore is seen on the page. This title would easily find a home on middle school and high school shelves.
Sara's Rating: 9/10
Suitability Level: Grades 7-10
This review was made possible with a digital reader copy from the publisher.
January 9, 2021
I had early access to this thanks to NetGalley and I was excited to dig in. As a fan of this author as well as non-traditional Superman stories, I had high hopes. Ultimately I was let down by the art as well as the inevitability of Krypton's fate. It's hard to get invested in characters with such a threat looming and this didn't give me enough to latch on to. I don't think this is a series I'll follow.
We discussed this further on a special episode of Comic Book Coffee Break: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EhTj...
We discussed this further on a special episode of Comic Book Coffee Break: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EhTj...
January 14, 2022
House of El: The Shadow Threat is the first book in a series that focuses on Krypton before its disastrous fate. In this story, Krypton is experiencing groundquakes that are wrecking the city but the city officials are not acknowledging the severity of the situation. The lower classes are getting hit with the brunt of the damage while the privileged classes are able to ignore the issues from there higher zones.
The story follows teens Sera, a warrior/soldier, and Zhan one of the elite family members on their journeys figuring out what is happening from their point of views. Sera is set to terraform planets that are un-terraform-able, and that makes her slightly suspicious of the tribunes (city officials) but she like other Kryptonians has been genetically enhanced for her 'soldier' persona and will continue to follow orders. Zahn is an elite, but feels different from the rest. He is able to see the issues with Krypton and is working to be a part of the rebellion and assist in any way that he can.
This was a fun read, it was interesting to see Krypton before Superman, and before it goes away. I also like that we follow two new characters and learn more about what is going wrong with Krypton. I liked Sera and Zhan and how they are both so different but are willing to come together to learn about the groundquakes and their severity.
The overall plot focuses on Sera and Zhan and also the impending doom of Krypton, but we also learn that every person is genetically engineered to be what they are supposed to be. So Sera is engineered to be a soldier, while Zahn is engineered to be an elite member of society. Both are questioning their engineering, Sera because the House of El wants to change her and Zahn because he acts and feels so different from the others.
I am excited to see what happens next with these characters and the planet and how they attempt to handle it (I mean I know that the ending is not ideal, so I am also sad that I know the inevitable outcome). If you are looking for a new take on the Krypton lore and the before Superman timeline - this is a great add to your list.
The story follows teens Sera, a warrior/soldier, and Zhan one of the elite family members on their journeys figuring out what is happening from their point of views. Sera is set to terraform planets that are un-terraform-able, and that makes her slightly suspicious of the tribunes (city officials) but she like other Kryptonians has been genetically enhanced for her 'soldier' persona and will continue to follow orders. Zahn is an elite, but feels different from the rest. He is able to see the issues with Krypton and is working to be a part of the rebellion and assist in any way that he can.
This was a fun read, it was interesting to see Krypton before Superman, and before it goes away. I also like that we follow two new characters and learn more about what is going wrong with Krypton. I liked Sera and Zhan and how they are both so different but are willing to come together to learn about the groundquakes and their severity.
The overall plot focuses on Sera and Zhan and also the impending doom of Krypton, but we also learn that every person is genetically engineered to be what they are supposed to be. So Sera is engineered to be a soldier, while Zahn is engineered to be an elite member of society. Both are questioning their engineering, Sera because the House of El wants to change her and Zahn because he acts and feels so different from the others.
I am excited to see what happens next with these characters and the planet and how they attempt to handle it (I mean I know that the ending is not ideal, so I am also sad that I know the inevitable outcome). If you are looking for a new take on the Krypton lore and the before Superman timeline - this is a great add to your list.
February 2, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed my introduction to Krypton, and although I am not very well versed in Superman lore, I was able to jump right into this graphic novel. Grey spends enough time with each character to give them the appreciation the reader needs to really care about them. It’s important to point out that The Shadow Threat is Book One in a trilogy, which increased my interest. I like the idea of a longer story that I can really sink my teeth into. There are times reading graphic novels that I feel rushed through a story. At 150-200 pages, I can rip through one in a couple hours and sometimes I too quickly forget the story.
The only part of the book I couldn’t fully get behind is the artwork. I was hoping for a more modern look, yet I found a strong connection the style of the Silver Age of comic books. (I am no expert at all. This is only a gut reaction from reading my father’s old stack of DCs.) I did like the color palette and how it ties into the caste system. Golds and greens for the upper class and greys and browns for the lowly soldiers.
Overall, this is a mixed review, but one where the positives outweigh the negatives. This is a very good title for YA readers and a series that I would recommend for any of my students who are superhero fans.
For my full review: https://paulspicks.blog/2021/02/01/ho...
For all my reviews: https://paulspicks.blog
The only part of the book I couldn’t fully get behind is the artwork. I was hoping for a more modern look, yet I found a strong connection the style of the Silver Age of comic books. (I am no expert at all. This is only a gut reaction from reading my father’s old stack of DCs.) I did like the color palette and how it ties into the caste system. Golds and greens for the upper class and greys and browns for the lowly soldiers.
Overall, this is a mixed review, but one where the positives outweigh the negatives. This is a very good title for YA readers and a series that I would recommend for any of my students who are superhero fans.
For my full review: https://paulspicks.blog/2021/02/01/ho...
For all my reviews: https://paulspicks.blog
October 30, 2021
Grabbed this mostly because of the author's name - Claudia Gray has never steered me wrong - not realizing it was a Krypton book.
Not that I have anything against Krypton. Mostly I'm ambivalent. So it took me a couple of tries to get into it once I realized, "Oh, hey, Supes-verse".
Sera-Lir is a soldier of Krypton though most of what she and her squad do is head out to other planets to try and terraform them. Only the terraforming isn't working and she and her squad can kind of see there's something wrong happening back home...but they're soldiers and literally genetically engineered not to care, just to do what they're ordered to do.
Zahn is one of the elite but he realizes something strange is happening and the Tribune is turning a blind eye to it. Joining with a political group of mostly lower-caste citizens, he's trying to help wake everyone on Krypton up before it's too late.
Zahn and Sera have some sort of odd relationship prior to the story - is he quietly stalking her? Did they have a one-night thing? - but due to their caste ranks, "nothing can come of it".
At least, not until both of them realize there's something really scary going on in Krypton and the higher-ups don't seem to care at all.
If you know Superman canon at all, you can guess what's gonna happen.
Not that I have anything against Krypton. Mostly I'm ambivalent. So it took me a couple of tries to get into it once I realized, "Oh, hey, Supes-verse".
Sera-Lir is a soldier of Krypton though most of what she and her squad do is head out to other planets to try and terraform them. Only the terraforming isn't working and she and her squad can kind of see there's something wrong happening back home...but they're soldiers and literally genetically engineered not to care, just to do what they're ordered to do.
Zahn is one of the elite but he realizes something strange is happening and the Tribune is turning a blind eye to it. Joining with a political group of mostly lower-caste citizens, he's trying to help wake everyone on Krypton up before it's too late.
Zahn and Sera have some sort of odd relationship prior to the story - is he quietly stalking her? Did they have a one-night thing? - but due to their caste ranks, "nothing can come of it".
At least, not until both of them realize there's something really scary going on in Krypton and the higher-ups don't seem to care at all.
If you know Superman canon at all, you can guess what's gonna happen.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 164 reviews