Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Death in Venice: And Other Stories

Rate this book
The Nobel Prize-winning author's masterful novella of eros and obsession, presented alongside other short works of lyrical beauty and psychological depth.

In Thomas Mann's immortal novella A Death in Venice, renowned author Gustave Aschenbach faces both middle age and a severe case of writer's block. He resolves to go on holiday in search of inspiration, only to find himself awestruck by the classical beauty of a fourteen-year-old boy. Submitting to his obsession with the youth, Gustave slowly loses himself, his dignity, and finally his life.

This volume includes six short works by Mann, including "Little Herr Friedmann," "Gladius Dei," Tristan," and "Tonio Kroger," among others.

76 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 1, 1928

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Thomas Mann

2,351 books5,740 followers
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

See also:
Serbian: Tomas Man

Thomas Mann was a German novelist, short story writer, social critic, philanthropist, essayist, and Nobel Prize laureate in 1929, known for his series of highly symbolic and ironic epic novels and novellas, noted for their insight into the psychology of the artist and the intellectual. His analysis and critique of the European and German soul used modernized German and Biblical stories, as well as the ideas of Goethe, Nietzsche, and Schopenhauer. His older brother was the radical writer Heinrich Mann, and three of his six children, Erika Mann, Klaus Mann and Golo Mann, also became important German writers. When Hitler came to power in 1933, Mann fled to Switzerland. When World War II broke out in 1939, he emigrated to the United States, from where he returned to Switzerland in 1952. Thomas Mann is one of the best-known exponents of the so-called Exilliteratur.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
898 (24%)
4 stars
1,456 (40%)
3 stars
946 (26%)
2 stars
242 (6%)
1 star
79 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 379 reviews
Profile Image for William2.
897 reviews4,283 followers
March 25, 2011
Read "Death in Venice." Love and Death. No wonder Woody Allen referenced the story in Annie Hall. Aschenbach, a writer in his fifties, an artist raised by the Kaiser to the aristocracy, sees the boy-god Tadzio on a beach in Venice and promptly loses his reason. It's a very human story. Who hasn't lost their head over someone? The references to Plato's Symposium are spot on. The prose might be a little dense for some. I enjoyed it but found it excruciating, so affecting is its theme. In that sense it reminded me of Knut Hamsun's Pan, another tale of love run amok. Though at least in Pan there's consummation. In Death in Venice the lovers never exchange a word, only glances. Anyway, this is what fiction can do. By the way, this is the preferred translation according to The Oxford Guide to Literature in English Translation, ed. Peter France. I'd like to hear from anyone who's read Joachim Neugroschel's version and the original German.
Profile Image for Mark.
510 reviews111 followers
January 24, 2024
I read Colm Tóibín’s The Magician last year and was honestly mesmerised by the historical fictional narrative of the life of German Nobel Laureate, Thomas Mann. I knew at the end of that reading that I had to get my hands on Mann’s books, to understand more of him and to hear him through his books many of which appeared to be some sort of processing of Mann’s life and person. Death in Venice seemed a good starting point - a novella of sorts, set within an anthology of other short stories.

I find Mann’s writing intoxicating. There’s something about it that draws me in. Each of the stories in this collection is a masterpiece, reflecting something of Mann in each one. I appreciated the 59 page introduction to the collection by translator David Luke to which I turned at the the end of each story to read expanded notes to help me process and understand what I’d just read.

There is something urgent about each of these stories. It’s not a stressful urgent, but almost some sort of anticipatory urgency, as Mann’s emotions express in their fullness almost like the words are going to burst from the page.

Death in Venice as the culminating story is astounding. Clearly Mann gives some kind of insight into his own being as main character Gustav von Aschenbach, ageing writer, who descends into some kind of vortex of all possessing emotion, rendering him impotent to any other action other than imaginatively obsessing over 14 year old Tadzio, a young boy holidaying with members of his family at the same location in Venice. What transpires is honestly bewitching as Mann is unable to function except by following Tadzio as “feelings he had had long ago, early and precious dolours of the heart, which had died out in his life’s austere service and were now, so strangely transformed, returning to him - he recognised them with a confused and astonished smile.” p270. Eventually, there is nothing else but Tadzio, no other reason for living, no other imagining, ultimately leading to an inevitable outcome.

In some ways all the novellas in this anthology pointed to Death in Venice, each a building block to understanding the Mann. Tonio Kröger, the story immediately preceding Death in Venice is yet another expression of Mann and I found myself identifying and resonating so much with it…. “And occasionally he would reflect: “But why am I peculiar, why do I fight against everything, why am I in the masters’ bad books and a stranger among the other boys?” I get the impression that Thomas Mann deeply harboured so much inside himself. I get that.

I could write so much more about each of these stories. They move me and will stay with me. 5 stars no doubt.
Profile Image for Matthew Ted.
1,136 reviews1,110 followers
February 16, 2021
[14th book of 2021. Artist for this review is German painter Emil Nolde.]

Firstly, here are my story updates copied from my currently-reading to display my first impressions. One date is changed, however, as I mistyped it.

"Little Herr Friedemann" [1897] is a German Florentino of sorts. Despite being a story of just 30 pages, it is quite a saddening one. Mann's writing, like most German-speaking writers, is hypnotic without being overstated. There is something wonderfully simple and profound about it, as one can find in Kafka, Rilke, Sebald, Hesse...

"The Joker" [1897] starts well, continues well, and ends slightly less than well, but overall a good story. It is, really, the psychology of the artist (which Mann is famous for), or the dream of the artist. Then, and now, there are expectations in society which make it hard for young people to chase creative endeavours--we look like Jokers, like a child standing proudly and declaring: I want to be an astronaut.

description
"Sechs Herren" (Detail)—1921

"The Road to the Churchyard" [1900] is a fairly bland story. No doubt there is something under the surface with the old man screaming at the boy on the bicycle, whom is renamed Life itself... But in the end there wasn't enough to make it worthwhile or thought-provoking. Weakest story yet.

"Gladius Dei" [1902] is an odd story, comprised of almost one single incident. Worth reading for the explosive tirade about art and its duty near the end of the story, the verbal and narrative climax of the piece. This David Luke translation is quite lovely to read, as I've heard before.

"Tristan" [1903] is excellent, pure delight. It gives me great hope for The Magic Mountain, which I plan to read this year, as it is set in a sanatorium as this is. Again, some wonderful comments on art... The nature of creation and love. I could read pages and pages of Mann's opinions on art and the universe.

"Tonio Kröger" [1903] is fairly brilliant too. At times the narrative felt a little too loose at times, but it is forgiven for how much time it ambitiously covers. Lovely writing, lovely thoughts... Lovely, heartfelt ending.

"Death in Venice" [1912] is a story I feel like I am not old enough to appreciate yet, or perhaps not wise enough. There is something elusively powerful about it, but not so much that I can consciously feel it from the page; I am aware of something hidden between its lines, but cannot access it so far.

description
"Autumn Evening"—1924

As for overarching ideas in Mann's stories, or even novellas, as some of them are in here (I believe "Tristan", "Tonio Kröger" and "Death in Venice" are all regarded as novellas). a lot of them appear across several. Mann is known for his gift as portraying the "psychology of the artist"; this is something I am interested in myself. Many of his characters believe they are part of art, that they are destined to create good art... Or, as Kröger himself puts it:
'Literature isn't a profession at all, I'll have you know—it's a curse. And when do we first discover that this curse has come upon us? At a terribly early age. An age when by rights one should be living at peace and harmony with God and the world. You begin to feel that you are a marked man, mysteriously different from other people, from ordinary normal folk; a gulf of irony, of scepticism, of antagonism, of awareness, of sensibility, is fixed between you and your fellow men—it gets deeper and deeper, it isolates you from them, and in the end all communication with them becomes impossible.'

As for the collection though, "Tristan" is perhaps my favourite. Maybe one day I'll read "Death in Venice" again and join the masses of people who laud it as Mann's masterpiece... But today is not that day.
Profile Image for Steven Godin.
2,809 reviews3,693 followers
September 12, 2018

Thomas Mann is rightly one of those figures who still looms large over literature. 'Death in Venice' is regarded as one of his best works, forming an appropriate ending to this collection, but many of the other stories in this volume are also excellent, and if anything, even match the qualities of Venice. Almost everything included here is worthy of any thoughtful reader's mind. Many of the stories in this collection form variations on a similar theme: that of young men who waste away their lives, only to come to their senses all too late. Naturally, this makes it a rather melancholic read at times, but this is what Mann generally does so well - the death of youth. Which, is a fascinating theme to read about. Although some may feel that the stories seem like templates for novels, this is certainly not the case. Regardless of length, Mann's real skill is his gift for relating the high emotions of his characters in a short space of time, and he pulls it off with eaze, even when they are not obvious to those around them. Because of this, the reader has to approach them with empathy; although Mann's writing is not as formally inventive as some of his contemporaries, perhaps the difficulty of his work lies in its emotional nuances. Fortunately, he shares the empathy of the reader in bringing his characters to life.

Other than Venice my other favourites were - 'The Will for Happiness', 'Harsh Hour', and 'Tonio Kroger'. Some weren't as strong as others, hense the four stars.
Profile Image for Daniela.
193 reviews90 followers
September 21, 2021
I have a complicated relationship with Thomas Mann. I read the Buddenbrooks a few years ago, and while I stood a bit in awe of the fact that Mann wrote it at the tender age of 25, I couldn’t help but think, wait, this is it? The Buddenbrooks is an often retold tale of family decline, which had been done better before Mann and better after him. Formalistically, the Buddenbrooks was excellent. Some scenes were pitch-perfect. Yet something was missing. Verve, perhaps, or feeling. Did Mann care about his characters at all?

I began this collection of short stories and novellas with the same feeling. The first few stories, Herr Little Friedmann, the Joker, and Tristan are all good, but I couldn’t think them very good. I couldn’t think them excellent. Something was still missing. I reminded myself that Mann was still fairly young when he wrote them. Herr Little Friedmann is even a bit amateurish. Tristan, which apparently Mann intended as a satire, fails entirely in its purpose because Mann only manages humour every 200 pages. He is a writer born for tragedy. The feeling that Mann didn't really care prevailed. The stories feel like an exercise in aesthetics. Mann is testing his own abilities as a writer and he is not involved emotionally in any of it. 

This changes radically with Tonio Kruger. Because Tonio is so clearly Mann's Alter Ego - the son of a strict, hard working German father and an eccentric, uncomfortably exotic Southern European Mother - the story feels personal for the first time. Something more than his talents is on the line. Mann is examining himself and as it turns out, he excels at it. Kruger is a coming of age story about a boy who feels misplaced and misunderstood, doomed to experience life from the window panes.  There's an irony there too, for Tonio/Mann is aware of all the things he can't have and rejects everything he has or could have. Mann's self-awareness is tantalizing: he admits to himself and his readers that his angst is a product of his narrow bourgeois upbringing, but he can't free himself from the same shackles he tries to satirize. 

Death in Venice is another monster altogether. So well written that to stress this point seems almost trite. No longer is he young Tonio Kruger. Now Mann is old Gustav Aschenbach, a successful writer whose life is a wasteland of emotions. He travels to Venice in search of Beauty and rest and finds Beauty and Inquietation, which is just another word for love. By going to Venice Gustav finds everything he's been searching for. Even a plague ridden Venice seems a paradise from which no one can escape. Perhaps to ease our conscience, it would be more comfortable to see Tadzio as an Angel of Death, a harbinger of Gustav's imminent destruction, or simply an abstract personification of beauty. But to do so would be to ignore how deeply Gustav fell in love. Gustav pictures himself in turns as a father, a teacher, a mentor and a lover to this 14 year boy - and this is disturbing. But the paradox lies precisely in the fact that this grotesque love is written with all the truth of passionate love: a love which elevates and degrades at the same time. Perhaps no one understood this better than Visconti, who gave us Aschenbach sliding down a wall, laughing and crying at the same time after chasing Tadzio through all of Venice. That scene is a faithful representation of the agony of love, the power it exerts over us, how it distorts our will and makes us hostage to feeling. Aschenbach puts it himself perfectly: he doesn't want to leave Venice because he doesn't want to return to himself. A return to reason would mean the abandonment of love, and that cannot be borne because love, even when painful, grotesque and one might say in this case profoundly disturbing, is pleasurable. 

Perhaps that's what it is. Perhaps Death is the only possible solution, because even without a plague and disease, how could Aschenbach return to himself? He'd be doomed, like a ghost, to wander the Earth, unable to let go of the exhilaration of passion.
Profile Image for robin friedman.
2,017 reviews448 followers
October 15, 2019
Mann's Death In Venice And More

Thomas Mann's masterful short novel "Death in Venice" (1912) tells the story of a distinguished German writer, Gustav Aschenbach, who, at the age of 53 while on holiday in Venice, develops a passion for a 14-year old boy named Tadzio. Mann's story sets the demands and powers of eros, human sexuality, in the form of Aschenbach's feelings for Tadzio, against the life, of intellect, discipline, artistic creation, and order which Aschenbach had, before his fateful passion, attempted to realize in his life. Mann's story is highly organized and beautifully controlled, meeting the artistic and intellectual demands of his protagonist, Aschenbach. Yet the story exudes passion and eroticism, in Aschebach's homosexual attraction for a young adolescent, the dank gondolas of Venice, the fetid epidemic that plagues the city, and the atmosphere of death and destruction that Mann captures in his work. The story is full of allusions to Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, to Plato's Phaedrus and Symposium and, I think, to the Bacchae of Euripides. Mann's story offers a disturbing picture of the claims of sexuality and eroticism, particularly on the life of the mind, and of the consequences of their repression.

I had the opportunity to reread "Death in Venice" in a book group, and my understanding of the work was enhanced by our discussion. It also benefitted from this excellent collection of seven of Mann's early short stories in a volume edited by David Luke. The six other stories in the volume were written earlier than "Death in Venice" and show a unity of theme with this great work. Each of the stories juxtaposes the life of the artist, the outsider trying to observe and understand, with the claims of passion. The artists involved, the passions, and the results differ among the stories, but the underlying theme remains the same.

"Tonio Kroger" (1903), an extended short story, shows an aspiring writer infatuated in his youth with a school friend and, subsequently, with the girl his friend marries. He years to be part of what he deems "the bright children of life, the happy, the charming, and the ordinary" while recognizing that this is not to be for him. "Tonio Kroger" was Mann's own favorite among his works and it presents the theme of "Death in Venice" -- intellect and passion in a different way and light.

The extended story "Tristan" (1903) also is based upon a conflict over a young woman, set in a sanitorium, between a dandified writer and her business-like matter-of-fact husband. Mann's love for Wagner and for music are also at the center of this story.

The remaining four stories also develop the theme of passion as a disturbing force in what appears to be a settled life. I particularly enjoyed the short opening work, "Little Herr Friedemann" (1897) in which a young man who becomes hunchbacked and reserved as a result of an accident in infancy is humiliated and rejected when he feels the stirrings of passion in the person of a beautiful 24 year old married woman.

In delving into the force eroticism exerts on human life, Mann's stories explore a theme which resonates deeply with me and with many readers. This book, with Luke's translation and introduction, is an excellent way of getting to know Mann's stories.

Robin Friedman
Profile Image for E. G..
1,184 reviews803 followers
December 5, 2013
Introduction

--Little Herr Friedemann
--The Joker
--The Road to the Churchyard
--Gladius Dei
--Tristan
--Tonio Kröger
--Death in Venice
Profile Image for Nathan "N.R." Gaddis.
1,342 reviews1,769 followers
Read
November 23, 2014
a brief chronology ::

19xx, May :: purchased Bantam Death in Venice and Other Stories by Thomas Mann.

19xx, June :: read “Death in Venice” in class along with two things from Dubliners, Mrs Dalloway, something from Sartre, something from Robbe-Grillet, and a few other things. Pretty cool.

19xx, May(?) :: saw the Orlando film. Still have not read the novel.

20xx, Sept :: read “Little Herr Friedemann”, “The Joke”, “The Road to the Churchyard”, “Gladius Dei”, “Tristan,” and “Tonio Kröger” in the hops field at midnight. Thought they were pretty fantastic.

20xx, ?? :: read Magic Mountain. Very happy to have done so.

20xx, today :: finally reread “Death in Venice” several years later.

20?? (future) :: watch some filmic translation of “Death in Venice”.

20?? (still the future) :: more Mann ; either Joseph or the one about the composer. Or Buddenbrooks (auf Deutsch?)
Profile Image for Alexandra .
936 reviews385 followers
May 20, 2017
Jetzt gleich mal ein Fazit: Thomas Mann und seine Kurzgeschichten sind meiner Meinung nach total überbewertet. Die Germanisten unter Euch mögen mich hinrichten, aber dieses nutzlose verkrampfte geistige Gehirnwichsen ergibt einfach keinen Sinn. Eines muss man dem Autor lassen: Er kann Schachtelsätze, aber das ist auch schon alles. Ausführliche Details ob dieses Trauerspiels in den Einzelbeurteilungen.


1. Tod in Venedig 2,5 Sterne
Der Beginn ist ein unnötiges verkrampftes nichtssagendes Geschwurbel über Kunst (genaue Beschreibung der Schwurbelei bei Tristan). Als sich der Hauptprotagonist Aschenbach nach Venedig aufmacht, wird die Geschichte zwar mit pädophilen homosexuellen Zügen behaftet aber recht erträglich.

2. Tristan 2,5 Sterne
Auch hier läßt es sich der Autor nicht nehmen, über Musik zu schwurbeln. Der Mann'sche Stil, um es Euch zu beschreiben, ist so wie bei den Leutchen, die zwar selber keine Künstler sind, sich aber bei den sehr progressiven Kulturfestivals in der Foldertextbeschreibung einen auf pseudo-intellektuell abonanieren, indem sie versuchen, präpotent mit der Sprache die Kunst nachzustellen, ohne natürlich auch wirklich mit der Sprache umgehen zu können. Eine Aneinanderreihung von wertlosen Fremdwörtern, Wortschöpfungen und Metaphern, die einfach keinen Sinn ergeben, nicht wissend, dass man manche Kunst einfach erleben und nur die Rahmenbedingungen wie Stil Hintergrund etc. beschreiben sollte. Nachdem man die Beschreibung des Theaterstücks, Musikstücks... gelesen hat, hat man gar keine Ahnung was einen erwartet oder was die Scheisse soll.
Nachdem man sich als Leser durch dieses unsägliche nutzlose Elaborat durchgewühlt hat, kommt wieder etwas Plot und Figurenentwicklung und die Geschichte wird recht erträglich.

3. Die vertauschten Köpfe 0-1 Stern (0 kann man ja in Goodreads gar nicht geben weil dies nicht beurteilt bedeutet)
Das ist wirklich der Gipfel an schlechter Literatur. Auf 100 Seiten nur 1 Szene, die es wert ist, erzählt zu werden. Die vertauschten Köpfe sind wieder mal nutzloses Geschwafel in Form eines indischen Märchens über eine Dreicksgeschichte zwischen zwei Freunden und einer Frau, da tun sich literarische Abgründe auf, die man sich gar ned vorstellen möchte - dagegen ist Tod in Venedig ein mittelmäßiger Lercherlschas ;-).
Meine Empfehlung im Originalton an die Protagonisten, die es verdient haben, alle zu sterben, aber ihre Entleibung einfach zu langsam durchgezogen und mich dadurch leider mit ihrem nutzlosen Dasein viel zu lange gequält haben. "Ja bringts Euch alle um, denn Ihr seids sogar zum ordentlichen hinterlistigen Ehebruch zu deppat und brauchts a Kopftausch Ausrede und extrem viel hirnloses Gelaber als Rechtfertigung für Eurer dreieckiges Swingerabenteuer :D unpackbar."

4. Gladus Dei 3,5 Sterne
Ok diese Story ist durchaus gelungen, aber in Anbetracht der Tatsache, dass dies eine Kurz-Kurzgeschichte von 10 Seiten ist, wäre diese schwerlich auch noch so zu vergeigen, wie die anderen.

5. Schwere Stunde 3 Sterne
Der Hauptprotagonist quält sich bei der Erstellung von literarischer Kunst in einem Schreibprozess einen ab. Nicht schlecht aber eben auch nur 10 Seiten. Eine Geschichte dieses Umfanges können auch Deutschmaturanten in einer Schularbeit.

6. Das Gesetz 3,5 Sterne
Das war die erste Geschichte, die mir im Ansatz ganz gut gefallen hat. Das Gesetz ist die Story von Moses: eine Perlenkette atemberaubender Inkompetenzen - gut angelehnt an die alten Überlieferungen aber aus anderer Sicht erzählt.

Fazit: Wenn ich alles zusammenzähle, kommen 2,5 Sterne raus. Weil es aber der Thomas Mann ist, kriegt er ob seines Namens einen Promibonus, und ich runde sehr gnädig auf.

Ach ja so wie Thomas Mann ständig in seinen Geschichten herumlaviert, möchte ich meine Gefühle bezüglich dieser Lektüre mit dem Zitat von Christian Tramitz aus dem Schuh des Manitu ausdrücken: "Ich bin mit der Gesamtsituation unzufrieden. [...] ständiges sinnloses herumschleichen und dauernd am Marterpfahl."
Profile Image for Holly Allen.
9 reviews3 followers
January 25, 2021

A beautiful collection of short stories and an eye-opening introduction to Thomas Mann.

These stories conjured such a deep sadness in me that I can feel the words linger at the pit of my stomach. An assembling of protagonists who are unconsciously invisible. Usually an aging man feeling an overwhelming pull towards a beautiful, oblivious character. The protagonist is an outsider who is desperate to find a way in but instead is met with ridicule and degradation. I think the story I’m referring to most here is ‘Little Herr Friedmann’ which I’m certain will haunt me forever, much like the poem ‘Prufrock’ by T.S Eliot which stirs that same uncomfortable feeling.
Profile Image for Reyer.
564 reviews60 followers
September 25, 2023
Nederlands (English below)

De bundel De dood in Venetië en andere verhalen bestaat uit vier korte verhalen van de hand van Thomas Mann (1875-1955). Ik was vooral nieuwsgierig naar Manns beroemde novelle uit 1912 over de oudere schrijver Gustav von Aschenbach die zijn ogen niet kan afhouden van de jonge Tadzio en daardoor de door cholera geplaagde stad niet tijdig verlaat. Afgezien van zijn verlengde verblijf en een grotere zorg voor zijn uiterlijk krijgt de verliefdheid van Von Aschenbach geen gestalte: het is Mann te doen om de overwegingen die daarachter schuilgaan. Meer dan een onbeantwoorde liefde – die ook te zien kan zijn als verlangen naar de jeugd – is De dood in Venetië naar mijn idee daarom een verkenning van de betekenis van kunst en schoonheid.

De verwisselde hoofden uit 1940 sluit op dit thema aan. Voortbouwend op een Indisch verhaal schrijft Mann over Sita, die haar man Shridaman en hun vriend Nanda op een dag onthoofd aantreft. Wanneer zij dankzij een goddelijke inmenging de kans krijgt hen weer tot leven te wekken, vergist ze zich in de hoofden, waarna de vraag rijst wie nu haar echtgenoot is: de persoon met het lichaam of met het hoofd van Shridaman? Aanvankelijk leek de Indische context me wat ongepast voor Mann, die zich het verhaal echter toe-eigent door er een ‘ideeënnovelle’ van te maken in de stijl van een klassieke mythe. Zo onnatuurlijk plechtig als de dialogen tussen de vrienden zijn, zo interessant zijn hun opvattingen over schoonheid.

Schijnbaar immers doet het schone in het geheel geen beroep op ons geweten en noopt ons niet in te gaan op de ziel, zoals het beeld van de bedelaar, juist doordat het ellende uitstraalt, nog altijd wel doet. En toch worden wij ook tegenover de verschijning van het schone schuldig wanneer wij ons alleen maar verlustigen in de aanblik ervan zonder naar het Zijn te vragen, en bijzonder diep, dunkt mij, geraken wij bij het schone in de schuld als wij het wel zien, maar het ons niet ziet.


De novelle Tristan (1903) over het sanatorium Einfried deed me – afgezien van de associatie met De toverberg – weinig, waarschijnlijk omdat ik de klassieke verwijzingen niet herkende. De belangstelling van de teruggetrokken schrijver Detlev Spinell voor mevrouw Klöterjahn en zijn brief aan diens echtgenoot doen wat gekunsteld en aanstellerig aan. Van De wet (1944) over het leven van Mozes, die zijn volk uit Egypte leidt en zich vervolgens moet bewijzen als profeet heb ik daarentegen veel geleerd. Het deed me eraan herinneren dat ik het Oude Testament eens integraal zou moeten lezen.

Mann is een schrijver die stevig uitweidt en op het eerste gezicht niet altijd duidelijk is, maar de lezer veel teruggeeft. Ook zijn korte verhalen intrigeren en leiden tot stof voor discussie.

English

Thomas Mann is as much a novelist as he is an essayist. His short stories Death in Venice and The Transposed Heads are packed with interesting ideas about art and beauty, which are well worth reading. Mann’s sense of context and setting is another aspect to enjoy. Some stories do require some background knowledge however.
Profile Image for Blair.
2,120 reviews6,123 followers
April 6, 2014
I did this a bit of a disservice by reading the first two stories in October last year, and then not picking it up again until January - my intention was to spread the stories out over a couple of months, in the hope that this would make me savour and appreciate them more, but... it didn't really work out. Though a couple of characters grated, and the repetition of themes dulled their impact slightly by the end, I loved these stories, with 'Little Herr Friedemann', 'The Joker', and 'Death in Venice' itself standing out as favourites.
Profile Image for Els Lens.
436 reviews26 followers
July 8, 2022
(Ik las 2 van de 4 verhalen: Tristan en De dood in Venetië)
Tristan.
Dit verhaal deed mij heel erg denken aan De Toverberg.
Hier heet het sanatorium ‘Einfried’ en niet ‘Berghof’.
Er zijn, net als in de Toverberg twee dokters, die erg verschillend zijn van karakter en van opvatting.
Er is de ‘femme fatale’, hier mevrouw Klöterjahn, in De Toverberg mevrouw Chauchat.
Er is de schrijver Detlev Spinell, die nog wereldvreemder is dan Hans Castorp.
Mijnheer Klöterjahn deed me denken aan mijnheer Peperkorn, een zeer extravert persoon, levensgenieter, nogal zelfingenomen en met beide voeten op de grond. Geen dromer zoals Spinell.
Bijzonder knappe karaktertekeningen.

De dood in Venetië

Ik had de film gezien tot op het moment dat de mooie jongen verschijnt.
Nu heb ik, eindelijk, het boek gelezen.
Eerst las ik het veel te snel, om te weten hoe het verhaal verder ging, hoewel de titel natuurlijk al verklapt dat er iemand dood gaat. Wie gaat er dood? Aschenbach?, de jongen?, de hele stad?

Ik had het gevoel dat ik het veel te snel had gelezen, dus las ik het meteen opnieuw, en met veel meer aandacht.
Als je het heel traag leest, dan pas ontdek je dat dit een echt meesterwerk is. Er zit zo veel in, buiten het simpele verhaal dat je op het eerste gezicht ziet.
Er is al veel over geschreven. Is het homo-erotisch of gaat het eerder om het verlangen naar schoonheid en naar jeugdigheid?
Aschenbach is geen ouwe geilaard. Hij is gewoon een man, een vijftiger, die verliefd wordt op een uitzonderlijk mooie jongen, en die spijt heeft van de vervlogen jaren, waarin hij altijd zo’n keurige burger was en alles deed zoals het hoorde in zijn (hogere) klasse.
Gaat het eigenlijk, in een diepere laag, over het verval van het oude Europa?
Citaat:
“… keek hij uit over het op dit middaguur niet erg drukke strand en over de zee waar geen zon op scheen en waar de vloed lage, langgerekte golven met een kalme regelmaat naar de oever zond.
Voor de eenzaam-zwijgende is wat hij ziet en wat hem wedervaart tegelijk onscherper en indringender dan voor hem die in gezelschap is; zijn gedachten zijn zwaarwichtiger, vreemder en nooit zonder een zweem van treurigheid.”

Profile Image for Nigeyb.
1,612 reviews456 followers
June 21, 2013
Death In Venice was published in 1912 and is the tale of Gustav von Aschenbach, a famous and successful ageing author, who goes on holiday to Venice, and falls in love with a 14 year-old boy. I only read Death in Venice, and not the other short stories in "Death in Venice and Other Stories".

Death In Venice is one of those stories that, for the average reader, needs some explanation from an informed commentator. It's a brief, albeit dense, tale and (thanks to Wikipedia) I can confidently report that the novella is rife with allusions from antiquity forward, especially to Greek antiquity and to German works (literary, art-historical, musical, and visual - from the 18th century onwards).

Prior to heading off to Venice, Gustav von Aschenbach's life is very disciplined and work-orientated. Once in Venice, Aschenbach slowly changes and eventually starts to experience passionate feelings for Tadzio, a 14 year-old Polish boy staying with his family at the same hotel. It's unclear what has prompted these feelings in Aschenbach. Is it a reaction to the constraints of Aschenbach's life prior to Venice? Is he simply just moved by Tadzio's youth and beauty?

According to Wikipedia, Mann's original intention was to write about "passion as confusion and degradation", after having been fascinated by the true story of Goethe's love for 18-year-old Baroness Ulrike von Levetzow, which had led Goethe to write his Marienbad Elegy. The May 1911 death of composer Gustav Mahler in Vienna and Mann's real life interest in a Polish boy during a holiday in Venice were additional experiences occupying his thoughts. He used the story to illuminate certain convictions about the relationship between life and mind, with Aschenbach representing the intellectual. Mann was also influenced by Sigmund Freud and his views on dreams, as well as by philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche who had visited Venice several times.

To what extent is Aschenbach's decline a punishment and does it reinforce the social order? Some cultures would accept Aschenbach's feelings, therefore to what extent might they be considered "natural"? Thomas Mann poses various questions in this story without appearing to come to any definitive conclusions, except that Achenbach's passion, and his illness, appear to be linked and this is presumably the cause of the death in Venice.

It's well written and, whilst dense, easy to follow. Thomas Mann evokes the faded grandeur and decay of Venice, and achieves an increasingly ominous tone as the story progresses. The tale is slight though and the book's preoccupations are too esoteric for my tastes. I doubt I'll bother reading it again though and was expecting to enjoy it more than I did.
Profile Image for Jessica (thebluestocking).
1,041 reviews20 followers
May 27, 2008
Knocking another one down for the novella challenge, I finished Death in Venice this evening. I’m not sure what exactly I was expecting when I choose this story, but it certainly wasn’t the tale of a respected older writer gentleman who falls in love with a fourteen year-old demigod boy and eventually dies of cholera because of it. Nope. That’s not what I expected at all.

Gustav von Aschenbach sees a strange red-headed man in Munich and suddenly decides to go on vacation. Before retiring to his summer house, he stops in Venice, a city he has visited often. The red-headed man makes numberous appearances throughout the story as a man on the ship, a gondolier, and a street musician. Aschenbach arrives at the hotel and sees Tadzio, a young polish boy, “[p]ale and elegantly reserved, with ringlets of honey-colored hair, a straight sloping nose, a lovely mouth and an expression of divinely belseed solemnity, his face called to mind Greek sculputres of the best period.” Aschenback falls in love with the boy and begins to follow him around Venice. Meanwhile, Venice is suffering from the plague. Aschenback knows this but keeps the secret along with the government officials of Venice. Becoming further and further debased, Aschenback falls ill with the cholera and dies.

I did enjoy the progression of the story, though there, at times, seemed to be a number of digressions that slowed down the plot. However, the story is packed with metaphors and literary allusions to Greek mythology and other arresting techniques. For example, the health of the city of Venice declines at the same rate as does the mental health of our hero. Also, our hero’s greatest written achievement is a short story entitled “A True Wretch.” I think you can guess by this point who turns out to be that True Wretch. The best part about the story is that a second reading would reveal a number of insights that I missed the first time.

Here are a few of my favorite passages:

“But he discovered in the end that his thoughts and inspirations were like the intimations of a dream, which always seem inspired at the time but prove utterly shallow and useless to the waking mind.”

“His nerves lapped up the tooting and jangling, the vulgar pining melodies, for passion criples taste, solemnly following the lure of pleasures that sobriety would either laugh at or reject altogether.”

“Ultimately, we are only as old as we feel in our hearts and minds.”
Profile Image for ❀ Tina ❀.
848 reviews184 followers
June 26, 2021
Der Tod in Venedig: 5 Sterne
Tristan: 4,5 Sterne
Die vertauschten Köpfe: 2 Sterne
Gladius Dei: 2,5 Sterne
Schwere Stunde: 3 Sterne
Das Gesetz 3 Sterne

Insgesamt also 3,3 Sterne
Ich runde einfach mal auf 3,5 Sterne auf ;)
Profile Image for Realini Ionescu.
4,744 reviews49 followers
September 11, 2025
Death by Thomas Mann

Der Todd



This is a short meditation on…death.

Since I am starting to get old, I am interested on the subject, even if at the same time I avoid even the Animal< National Geographic or whatever channel shows images of Der Todd.

With time, we need to come to terms with the finity of our lives and consider the final exit, even if not in the way the hero of this tale does.

In a few ways, the main character of this saga reminds me of the man from another of Mann’s short stories- Disillusionment.

Both personages are worried that death can have something

- Bourgeois and banal about it

My first reaction is- how can you think such a thing; there is nothing banal about the end of your whole journey.

We never get a name for this character, so I will call him the Hero.

His mindset is that:

- Something unusual and strange must happen all around, on that big, serious and enigmatic day-

- On October 12th

I have read elsewhere about this fixed date that some people have in mind, regarding their own, or more often others ‘death.

Somerset Maugham comes to mind with a story, even if there may be more than a couple of them, where someone dies at a fixed moment, so to say.

There is a man who has disappointed a woman native of Burma, or another place in South East Asia, and she takes her revenge by…killing her departed lover from the distance.

In Der Todd, there is another mechanism at work, perhaps just as strange and sensational-

- The hero seems to call Death to himself

With the proper mindset, plenty of things can and will happen.

The Pygmalion Effect is a well documented example of the situations where people who believe strongly in others being able to do things, make these Other people do them.

If you are interested, you can google for these experiments and find all about the phenomenon in question.

Der Todd may work as one confirmation, since the Hero does attract Death, even if not onto himself and I will not mention who falls prey to this folly.

If we condition ourselves for an event or a goal, we create the premises and conditions for it to come true.

Positive and optimistic people with challenging and meaningful goals are much more likely to achieve them and live happy, longer and healthier lives in the process.

Negative, pessimistic individuals on the other hand create the setting for unfortunate outcomes, not just for themselves, but for those around them.

Experiments have proved that even those who share a room with a negative soul are more exposed to catching a disease, not just family members.

Negativity is catching and so is optimism.

Der Todd shows in a literary way what can happen when someone is asking for it.

It being disaster.
Profile Image for Elena Sala.
498 reviews94 followers
November 19, 2019
This selection of stories includes texts from Thomas Mann's literary beginnings to the sublime "Death in Venice" (1912). Mann used material from his own life and family background in most of his early fiction, including BUDDENBROOKS. Either Lübeck, his native town, or Munich, his city of adoption, is the location in nearly all cases. There are also recurring motifs: the old patrician family home and its garden, the theme of the isolated "outsider" and the capacity of passion, or any infatuation to destroy dignity.

Probably one the most important stories of this collection is Tonio Kröger, a work Mann often referred to as his favorite. This story focuses on the relationship between the artist and society, another recurring subject in his oeuvre. The other text worth mentioning is "Death in Venice ", a landmark achievement of European modernism. This novella is a potentially sordid tale of sexual obsession transformed into symbol and myth. Lust, disease, artistic creativity and death are linked, as a derivation of the nineteenth century pessimist philosophy of Schopenhauer and Nietzsche. The subject is as controversial as Nabokov's LOLITA. The story is about a middle aged man whose object of desire is a fourteen year old boy. As the story is about homosexuality, stalking and pedophilia: it is likely that the use of classical myths could serve, among other things, to camouflage a very disturbing and scandalous topic. "Death in Venice" is a must read; the rest of the stories are quite good, but if you have read BUDDENBROOKS you might find them repetitive.
Profile Image for Rita (the_bookthiefgirl).
380 reviews83 followers
November 6, 2021
Little Herr Friedman(1897)- 4⭐️

The Joker (1897)-4⭐️

The road to the Churchyard (1900)-3⭐️

Gladius Dei (1902) -3⭐️

Tristan (1903)-4.5⭐️

Tonio Kröger(1903)- 4⭐️

Death in Venice (1912)-4.5⭐️

Profile Image for Herman.
214 reviews43 followers
October 8, 2022
***1/2
***** voor De dood in Venetië
De andere verhalen konden me niet zo bekoren.
Profile Image for Richard.
179 reviews
March 5, 2017
A troublingly sympathetic look at pederasty in the context of creativity. Nicely written.
Profile Image for Filip.
71 reviews15 followers
May 22, 2017
1) Tristan (p.7 - p.53): *** 1/2
2) De dood in Venetië (p.55 - p.138): **** 1/2
3) De verwisselde hoofden (p.139 - p.235): ****
4) De wet (p.237 - p.307): ***
Profile Image for Alissia.
98 reviews
April 30, 2021
Meine Favoriten sind "Gladius Dei und Die vertauschten Knöpfe".
Profile Image for Knivdelsbo.
362 reviews
February 16, 2023
Technically a reread but there were some stories I hadn't read before. I'll overlook 'Tristan' as I don't think that deserves a five, but the rest...damn.
Profile Image for Jovana.
102 reviews15 followers
December 7, 2024
Ne znam da li dajem pet zvezdica knjizi ili sebi što sam je konačno završila.
Profile Image for Sanne.
145 reviews3 followers
October 16, 2026
It feels odd to read descriptions of Mann as a cold-hearted writer. I think he had too much heart and tried to smother it, believing that at some point he would fail to keep it contained, and that it would eventually burst out of him, to everyone’s detriment.

Whether this has something to do with Mann’s self-professed repressed “homosexual tendencies,” whether it was written in a time of great political turbulence and uncertainty, or whether Mann believed that art and love were fundamentally at odds with each other, I’m not sure, but there’s so much urgency and pain in these stories. As a fairly sensitive adult myself, who would probably cry if someone washed my hair, I find the repeated tale of a malformed man who buries himself in literature to suppress his longing for connection, only for his life to fall apart the moment he experiences a semblance of intimacy, almost a bit too personal. The introduction by David Luke (which may be one of the best introductions I’ve read to any work of fiction) calls these short stories confessions. As though they were all silent pleas for help, written down instead of spoken aloud. But it’s all wrapped up in the detached intellectual irony that is so typical of Mann. Like the mind is unwilling to surrender control of the situation to the emotion.

“I tell you I am often sick to death of being a portrayer of humanity and having no share in human experience.”
69 reviews3 followers
October 8, 2025
Thomas Mann funkar bra på nynorsk også! Eg trur den første novella var min personlege favoritt, Tonio eit-eller-anna.

Skal tru om Mesteren og Margarita var inspirert av den siste...

Eg har diverre ikkje klokare ord å bidra med i denne omgang, men bra greier!

[Side note: Me er alle samde om at Mann var kjempehomo, sant?]
Profile Image for Kyle.
319 reviews171 followers
February 6, 2022
The Joker and Death In Venice were my favorites, but all of these selections are important in understanding Mann's style and subject matter. Would recommend!
Profile Image for Falk.
53 reviews47 followers
June 4, 2015
Thomas Mann's novels are far better than his short stories. Period. This collection spans the years of 1896 to 1912 and I found them to be of uneven quality. The one I liked best was Tonio Kröger, which was also Mann's own favorite among his works. It has a much tighter and leaner structure than its more famous counterpart Death in Venice. Though the latter is more evocative and also has more depth, the story took forever to even get started. The same goes for Gladius Dei (an alternative title for it could be 'Savonarola goes to Munich') – it's like Mann can’t help himself going overboard in descriptions of the most uninteresting kind. It must have been more entertaining for himself than for the reader, who isn't given the slightest hint about why these descriptions should carry any import until an eternity of pages later - if at all. Surprisingly, I found myself almost siding with the Münchner Savonarola, here called Hieronymus, against the disagreeable bourgeois art-dealer who is his nemesis in this story – though I don’t share his passion for the Madonna, or more to the point: in contrast to Hieronymus, I rather like her undressed. Tristan is another story built upon the Liebestod-theme, like Tonio Kröger, though here it might even amount to murder – or maybe suicide – anyway, it’s death by Wagner, no less! (Ingenius "murder weapon" by the way.)
The Joker is a story in the "superfluous man"-genre, but as only Mann could have written it - while Little Herr Friedemann is transported out of of his orderly existence by a sudden passion, somewhat reminiscent of Death in Venice but written much earlier. Finally, The Road to the Churchyard is one of the shortest of these stories, and it's as short as it is absurdly comical. Here the main character, Lobgott Piepsam, more or less self-destructs on his way to the cemetery to visit the grave of his late wife. Not exactly a comical setup, you say? But then you probably haven’t yet been introduced to Piepsam. – There is quite a lot of self-destruction in several of these stories, so this comical interlude (another was Gladius Dei) was a relief.
I read these stories while traveling back and forth to work, and a good measure of how much I like a book is whether I continue reading it at home; with this book that happened only with a couple of these stories and it has taken me several months to finish reading it. It is possible that this could be due to the translation, but I'm not particularly tempted to give them a try in German. All in all: fascinating at times, boring at others. I’m actually quite relieved to have made it all the way through this book, though I'm nevertheless glad I did.



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 379 reviews