Good paranormal historical suspense
MY RATING
5 stars--WOW
4 stars--would read again
3 stars--was good
2 stars--didn't enjoy
1 star--didn't finish
Should I read books before this one: no
Cliffhanger: yes
SUMMARY
Inspector Sebastian Pinsley investigates a murder at Bedlam. He's methodical, logical, a speed reader, a veteran of the Crimean War, the widower of a brutally murdered woman, and he possibly has an eidetic memory. The guard has him sign the visitors log before he's escorted to the room of Tabitha Greene. The body is still there, looks clawed. Her roommate, Elsie, mutters about shadows. Pinsley asks about the knife. None found. Elsie claims she's innocent. But the room was locked and no one had been in or out.
Kaia escapes from the orphanage. Tomorrow is her 17th birthday, and she knows the Garrows have arranged a male "benefactor" for her. She runs for a long time. Eventually she gets hungry, won't steal from food carts. She approaches a man who just bought a lot of food to ask for an apple, the man yells Thief. A constable arrests her, tells her she'll be shipped to Australia.
Pinsley attends the autopsy. The doctor agrees the killing slices look like claw marks, but not from a domestic animal. Also, the blows are downward; Elsie is too short. Tabitha tried to defend herself with her fingernails; Elsie had no scratches. Pinsley sees a mark on Tabitha: an eye (oval with a dot and lines like stylized lashes). It's not a brand, a burn, or a tattoo, it's inherent like a birthmark.
Kaia waits in the cell, fearful. When she's being led to the magistrate, she makes a break for it, they rip her sleeve off, are about to beat her when Pinsley comes in. He invites her to his office.
He'd seen the mark on her arm. Just like Tabitha's. He asks her what orphanage she's from. Do you read minds? No, then he lists his observations. She asserts her innocence, he offers to help her in exchange for her help. He asks about the mark. My birth mark? “And what if I were to tell you that earlier, I saw the same mark on the body of a dead woman?” “I don’t know anything about a dead woman.” “I believe you. And yet, I also find it improbable that the two of you would be unconnected. Tell me, what do you know of your family?” Nothing. He takes her to see the corpse.
Kaia rides in her first cab. She thinks of escaping, but is too curious about the woman with the same mark. Maybe she'll find out something about herself. She's not scared of the corpse; she's seen worse. But a sense of wrongness comes over her. They have identical marks.
Pinsley takes her back to the station. A constable puts her in the cell while Pinsley thinks in his office. Kaia is the same age as his daughter would be. He needs to find someone who knows Kaia or who recognizes the mark; he feels it's the key. He asks for Kaia to be released into his custody. His boss, Superintendent Hutton, says OK. “If Commissioner Mayne were not such a friend to you, I would simply dismiss you. As it is, I must have cause, and I suspect that this fool’s errand will give me exactly that. If not, well, one of my men will have succeeded in catching a killer.”
They go to Bedlam. He makes her agree to not run. Bedlam feels wrong like the corpse did. A man comes out. He feels even more wrong.
The doctor doesn't know if she recognized what he is, but he certainly recognized what she is. He's the one who put Tabitha in Bedlam, even though she wasn't crazy; she was a shadow-seer. "No one looking would be able to tell where the doctor stopped and the shadow began, not even him. Except a shadow-seer." Even though the murder went as hoped, the doctor worries about that girl messing things up.
EVALUATION
A lot of thinking and narration, but it's also world building (historical and paranormal) and 2 characters who've been alone for a long time. Pinsley's use of a metronome to order his thoughts is unique and insightful. And sad.
The timeline is condensed and a lot happens; the pacing is well done.
Family is a strong theme in this book. Both Kaia and Pinsley have lost theirs; Bedlam relies on family disconnection, as do thugs.
It's set in the 1850s. Autopsies are newly legal, though only of criminals or insane. The police are under duress because of the Orsini incident (not clearly explained).
I enjoyed it, especially in October, enough that I'm tempted to buy book #2 so I find out what happens.
RECOMMENDATION
Anyone who likes paranormal, historical fiction, and/or crime suspense
FAVORITE QUOTES
People are far too often invisible to one another.
Humanity cared so much about the way things appeared. They didn’t look closer.
“You have to learn before they get to you. Avoid drunkenness, opium, hatred. They all open ways for the shadows. Focus on the light.”
POSSIBLE TRIGGERS (SPOILERS)
Sex: none
Language: none
Violence: murder, report of rape, child abuse, possible sex trafficking, kidnapping, fights