Late 14th Century Wales. Trouble is brewing, but isn't it always?
The Bishop of Draychester is missing a very expensive barrel of Gascony wine. A gift for the new king, stolen from the port of Tenby in the English stronghold of South Pembrokeshire. It's a dangerous place to be asking the wrong sort of questions. The town is awash with ill feeling and intrigue, the result of a bitter feud between the merchants. Who better to send to investigate than Will Blackburne, newly appointed bishop's official?
In the north of Wales, the Welsh are starting to rise up against their English overlords. For an old mercenary like the outlawed Sir Roger Mudstone, it’s an opportunity too good to be missed. His murderous reputation has earned him the offer of a pardon. The king wants to extract his revenge on the Welsh, and someone has to do the dirty work...
M J Westerbone was born in the small industrial mill town of Radcliffe in the old county of Lancashire in the North West of England. From an early age he had a keen interest in history fueled by the fact there were the remains of a ruined medieval manor house (Radcliffe Tower) virtually on his doorstep. Deciding a career in archaeology or as a historian in all likelihood wouldn't pay the bills he focused on IT. He has been the director of an IT and Telecoms business for many years whilst continuing his passion for history by writing historical novels. He is married and lives with his wife in Lancashire.
I'm a fan of medieval crime and mystery and there are things to like about this series - the Bishop, Scrivener and the trio of bishop's men, Will, Bernard and Osbert, for example are interesting and entertaining. The settings seem convincing to me and I've enjoyed the overall stories of the first two books.
But, and it's a big but, I just cannot take Sir Roger Mudstone. He's so unpleasant that I nearly gave up on the first book after a couple of chapters. I stuck with it, and thought it worth trying the second to see if some other, more nuanced villain replace him. But no, sadly he is back. So far he's not shown a single redeeming feature.
So, with a certain amount of reluctance, I'm abandoning this series (there are so many more out there to try). I wondered whether they were inspired by Howard of Warwick's Chronicles of Brother Hermitage, which I found ingenious and vastly entertaining. So I think I'll re-read the ones of those I have and catch up with all the rest.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Once again the Bishops motley crew find themselves dispatched to solve a mystery. It quickly becomes a murder, followed by a mad dash into hostile territory (Wales) in pursuit of the culprits before they can claim sanctuary. Of course, the wild card rogue, Sir Roger Mudstone, is in Wales recking havoc under the King’s banner. Will the Draychester men outwit the murderers & manage not to fall prey to Sir Roger? That is anyone’s guess!
Barely acceptable. Language is NOT medieval. More than several places where characters are using current colloquial phrases that just don't fit. Add to that the ending was really hokey....left a lot of unanswered questions and then led you into the next book. Less than high end writing. Unimpressed.
Great second book following on Sir roger still a great villain When I read a book I try to picture in my mind the person described and when I see sir roger in my head I'm reminded of the sheriff in robin hood prince of theives