James Dahle’s The White Coat Investor’s Guide for Students emphasizes the importance of financial planning, frugality, and protecting yourself via disability and life insurance, giving good tips and advice on which insurance policies to purchase. Dahle also covers appropriate debt-to-income ratios, eliminating student loans, and investing to become financially independent.
You will find financial freedom, and with that freedom will come a confidence that comes from the knowledge that you do not work for money, money works for you. Money is no longer your master, and you can then afford to take the personal and professional risks in life that will maximize your happiness.
I prefer to think of this concept as a "debt-to-income ratio" (DTI), a term frequently used in lending. For our purposes today, it is simply the ratio of your total student loans upon completing your training to your expected income upon completing your training. At 1X, medical or dental school is an excellent investment. With careful financial management (which we will discuss later in the book), you can pay off that debt within two years of completing your training and then enjoy that high income the rest of your career. At 2X, the investment was not nearly as good. However, it is probably still an acceptable ratio. With careful financial management, this debt can be cleared within five years of the completion of training. At 3X, things start breaking down.
When you are paying for school with debt, by definition you are living above your means. Each month you sink further and further into debt. Minimizing how far you go into debt is key to your finances. After you select a school to attend, the main way you can do this is by spending as little as possible.
It is psychologically much easier to increase your standard of living than to decrease it. This tendency we all have to grow into our income is called lifestyle inflation or the hedonic treadmill. Despite spending more, we do not permanently increase our happiness. It also turns out that many small increases in spending actually bring more happiness than one large increase in spending. If you live frugally as a student, the modest upgrades in lifestyle in residency will feel like splurges and bring on more enjoyment.
Living on $50,000 a year while earning $300,000 a year is not pleasant, requires discipline, and is going to be harder than you think. Do not extend that time period any longer than you have to.
Too many Americans, including doctors, buy insurance to protect against financial loss that would not actually be a financial catastrophe (consider how many people buy Applecare® for their iPhone). Meanwhile, they do not bother purchasing term life or disability insurance and carry only the state required minimum liability insurance. So make sure you protect against those financial catastrophes that can be insured against by purchasing personal (umbrella) and professional (malpractice) liability policies, homeowner's or renter's insurance, disability insurance, term life insurance if you have dependents, and health insurance.
As you prepare to enter your career, be aware of the existence of burnout and its prevalence among doctors. Maintain the relationships, habits, and outside interests that will allow you to overcome burnout. Increase your personal resilience whenever possible. Eliminating financial concerns from your life will reduce the likelihood of burnout, and facilitate solutions when it occurs.
Ownership will never be right for all dentists, but I want to reassure you that just having a high student loan burden should not be a reason to avoid owning a practice. In fact, I would argue that the higher your student loans, the more you need to own your job. You simply need a higher income to pay them off.
Lots of people mistakenly think that "renting is throwing money away." That is absolutely not true. Renting is exchanging money for a place to live. You exchange money for food to eat and entertainment to watch all the time, but do not view that as throwing money away. Paying for housing is no different.
While smart decisions about purchasing, maintaining. and upgrading can help, the primary factor that determines whether you make money on such a short-term home purchase is completely out of your control: appreciation. The home simply has to appreciate enough to overcome the substantial costs of buying and selling. It typically will not do so during a three to four-year stint in school or residency. On average you will lose money.
Admittedly doctors generally buy more expensive houses than the typical American, but a doctor who becomes financially independent certainly does not have half their net worth tied up in their house. The house more likely makes up < 20% of their net worth, and usually less than 10%. If you become successful, the value of your house will not be a major part of your financial life.
Paying off a student loan with a 6-10% interest rate immediately eliminates the interest that you would be paying on that loan-which basically provides you a guaranteed after-tax return of 6-10% on that "investment." This should be very attractive given that for years the best rate of return you have been able to find on a guaranteed investment has been in the 1-2% range. There is essentially no justification for carrying that level of debt in order to invest money elsewhere.
The only time you lose with a variable interest rate loan is when rates go up a lot and do so early in the loan term. By taking out a fixed-rate loan, you are essentially buying an insurance policy against rates going up. Like any insurance policy, there is a cost. So if you can afford to run interest rate risk, then do so. Calculate out the worst-case scenario on a variable rate loan. If you can afford it, take it. The risk will probably not show up. If you cannot afford to take that risk, then you will have to insure against it with a fixed rate loan.
The second risk that lending companies take on is term risk. The longer you take to pay off your loans, the longer it will be before they can lend that money out to someone else (hopefully at a higher rate). Plus, a longer loan term increases the chance that you will default on the loan. Thus, if you are willing to commit to pay the debt off over a shorter time period, the lender is willing to offer you a lower interest rate.
I tell attending physicians and practicing dentists that they really need to be saving about 20% of their gross income for retirement in order to preserve their pre-retirement standard of living. Realize that getting that "savings rate" up to 20% will need to be a major financial priority as you move into your career.
A workaround that many doctors use is called a Backdoor Roth IRA, which consists of contributing to a traditional IRA (no deduction) and then converting it to a Roth IRA later (at no tax cost). However, this indirect Roth IRA contribution process is subject to a pro-rata rule that requires you to roll traditional and SEP IRAs into a 401(k) or similar plan.
A practicing dentist or physician has the potential to earn $200,000-$500,000 per year for the next 30-40 years. This represents a sum of $6-20 million. Converting this potential income and wealth into actual income and wealth is the greatest financial task of your life. However, there are risks that could show up in your life that would prevent you from being able to accomplish this task. One of the most common of these risks is an extended or even permanent disability. Insurance companies estimate that as many as one in seven doctors will be disabled at some point during her career. While many imagine this will occur in a sudden traumatic accident, medical illness is actually a more common cause of disability that prevents a doctor from working.
Most doctors do not have the skills or education to generate anywhere near their former income doing anything besides the practice of medicine or dentistry. They invested 10-15 years in their education and training to develop their specialized knowledge base and skill set. Not insuring this ability against such a prevalent risk with such serious consequences is simply foolish.
Since disability insurance is frequently used, it tends to carry fairly expensive premiums. Typically, a solid policy will cost you 2-6% of the benefit. So if you purchase a policy with a $10,000 per month benefit, expect to pay $200-$600 per month. This will be a major budget line item for you during your career, so try to get over the sticker shock quickly.
Good policies are own occupation, specialty-specific policies. This means that they will pay you the promised benefit in the event that you cannot perform the essential duties of your specialty, even if you could do something else.
There are six companies currently selling true own-occupation policies to doctors including Principal, The Standard, Guardian, Ameritas, Mass Mutual, and Ohio National.
Every purchaser should buy a partial/residual disability rider. This provides a partial benefit to you in the event of partial disability or during the recovery from a complete disability. Resident purchasers will also want to buy two other riders, The first is a cost of living rider. This rider increases the benefit each year with inflation beginning with the year after you are disabled. The second rider is a future purchase option rider. This allows you to buy a larger policy when your income goes up without a medical questionnaire or exam.
Nevertheless, disability is common enough among physicians that you should carry a policy from the time you leave school until the time you reach financial independence.
Get a $1-$5 million, 30-year level term policy in place as soon as possible. The jump in price from year 30 to year 31 is usually pretty dramatic, however, so it is best to make sure you buy a policy with a long enough term that you are certain you will be financially independent by the time the term is up. Once you have a nest egg sufficient to support your loved ones in the event of your death, you have no need for life insurance and can safely cancel the policy and save the premium.
If a company does not pay out any dividends, the investor will pay no taxes on its earnings until selling the shares. In fact, if the investor dies before selling them, those earnings will not be subject to income tax at all due to the step-up in basis. That means that when the investor's heirs go to sell their inherited investment, the IRS considers them to have bought it at the price on the day of the investor's death, and they only have to pay capital gains taxes on the difference between the value on the day they sell and the value on the day the investor died.
The smaller the company, the riskier the investment tends to be. Sometimes that additional return "premium" shows up and sometimes it does not, but on average over decades, smaller stocks have had higher returns than larger stocks.
In fact, over the decades, the data has been pretty clear that value stocks outperform growth stocks over the long run. However, just like with large and small-cap stocks, it might take a very long time for you to receive that "premium."
.
There are some rules of thumb out there, perhaps the most common being to make sure you get 0.20% in extra yield for every year of extra duration, but those rules can break down at very high or very low interest rates. Since current yield is generally the best predictor of future returns with bonds, you want to make sure you are being paid to take on additional risk. Yield curves can flatten (meaning a invert (meaning a short-term bond has a higher yield than a long-term bond). long-term bond does not have a higher yield than a short-term bond) or even These events have some correlation with economic and stock downturns
For a high earner, that safe harbor is either paying 100% of taxes due (within $1,000) or at least 110% of what was due on last year's tax return. Thus an easy way for a self-employed doctor to calculate their quarterly estimated tax payments is to multiply their tax bill from the year before by 110% and then divide by four. Note that that figure has absolutely nothing to do with your income from this year or your tax bill for this year.
In addition to income taxes, your employer will also deduct payroll (or FICA) taxes from your paychecks. The two main payroll taxes are Social Security and Medicare tax. If you are an employee, your employer will pay half of that amount. If you are self-employed, you will be responsible for both halves, but will be able to deduct the employer half.
Investment income can also be taxed at a lower rate. If you have held an investment for at least a year before selling it for a gain, it qualifies for the lower long-term capital gains tax rates, which range from 0-20%, much lower than the 10-37% brackets used for ordinary income.
The upfront tax deduction inherent in a tax-deferred account is very useful for doctors, who are usually in one of the highest tax brackets during their peak earnings years. Typically, they are allowed to save tax on the contributed amount entirely at their marginal tax rate. In retirement, they can use the withdrawals to fill the brackets. It would not be unusual for a doctor to save money at 35% and then pay taxes on that money decades later at a rate of 15%.
While a health savings account is designed to used ideally to pay for health care, it can be used for any purpose you like. However, if you use it for something other than health care before age 65, you will have to pay a 20% penalty (and taxes) on the withdrawal. That is a bad idea. However, after age 65, it functions very similarly to any other tax-deferred account in that you only have to pay taxes on the withdrawal. In this way, it functions as a "stealth IRA." Another unique aspect of HSAs is that under current law you do not have to withdraw money from the account in the same year you spend it on health care. You can actually save your receipts for years, allowing the investments in the account to continue to grow before withdrawing money in an amount equal to the receipts tax and penalty-free.
Our next worthwhile calculation is your retirement savings rate. I think this is worth calculating once per year throughout your working career.This is simply how much money you saved for retirement divided by how much money you earned (again, "Total Income" from your tax return). Be sure to include contributions to retirement accounts, including any employer match, in both the numerator and denominator of the equation. If you will save 20% of your gross income for retirement throughout your career, you will be able to maintain your standard of living during retirement.
If you can charge 1% or more of the purchase price of a property as monthly rent, it is likely to "pencil out" as a good, cash-flowing rental property.