I thought Mina and Scott were adorable. I also thought the tension between Mina's desire to make partner in her law firm and her desire to stay in Grosberg, Germany for The Icicle Cafe were good. My problem had to deal with the setting itself and what consistently pulled me out of the story.
Before I go into my critique about the setting, I want to issue some caveats. First, I have never lived in Germany and I do not know what the feel of Germany is. Second, I have a smidge of knowledge about German culture from taking German in college. Third, I did read the letter Denise N. Wheatley had in the beginning of my copy. With that said, let's get into the critique.
In her letter, Denise N. Wheatley mentions this book was inspired by her Dad's experience in Germany when he was stationed there in the military. She also mentioned how by the time she finished this book she felt she was an expert in patent law and German cooking. With those details, I feel I should be transported to a small town in Germany, but I did not get that feel. If I missed the part about Munich International Airport and the references about being in Germany then I would think Mina was still in America.
There were no German phrases used by any of the townspeople, the potential partner, or Mina and Scott. Now writing in a different language can be tricky, especially if you do not speak it, but the phrase "Speaking German, Mina said..." or something along those lines. I am not saying people in Germany do not speak English, but if they are talking with a fellow German-speaker you would think you would hear German more often. You would think the same would occur in the made-up town of Germany. Now if this was based on the author's Dad's military experiences then that would make sense that English would have been spoken more often, but the made-up town of Grosberg was supposed to be a small town and there seems to be no American base near the town. To me, this would mean it would be weird to have the entire town speaking English. Now it could be that everybody is speaking German, but we are just seeing English For example, in graphic novels, there would be these brackets that would have English in them, but the brackets are signifying another language.
Besides the language, there did not seem to be a culture separate from what a number of Americans experience. Sure, there was mentions of bratwurst and schnitzel, but I think a number of Americans have heard of those terms. There are other foods that maybe some Americans have not heard of like quark cheese. There was also mentioned of football, which I taken to mean American football. I have to look this up, but American football is played in Germany even though soccer is still king (American Football International. 2019. "Germany is shifting their attention to American football"). There was also the mentioned of cheerleaders, which I was like "What?!" There are cheerleaders, but according to a 2003 New York Times article it was practically nonexistent 10 years ago (Hong, Euny Y. 2003. Teaching Germany to Grin and Bear Cheerleading). Now I am not an expert in German surnames or first names, but there did not seem to be a lot of those either.
The biggest detail that pulled me out of the story was mentioned of gingerbread houses. It was mentioned that nobody in town knows how to make gingerbread houses and they put up pitiful brown houses (page 81). That shocked me! Gingerbread houses originated in Germany (Avey, Tori. 2013. "The History of Gingerbread." PBS). This is a small town in Germany there should be at least one person who knows how to make gingerbread houses! In the downtown region of my town, a German Christmas market was set-up and one of the local high school's German club was there with some gingerbread creations, including their winning gingerbread house!
All of these details made me feel we were not in Germany. I feel if a book is going to take place in different country then those details should be there. If they are not there then they should be an explanation from the author saying why some readers may not get the feel of being in a different country. Based on Denise N. Wheatley's initial letter, I would think her research would have shown, but unless it was super subtle I feel like it did not show. There was also no acknowledgements page at least in my copy, which would have been a good indicator on the research as well. I wished there was more of an explanation about the setting from the author.
Verdict: The love story, the career tension, and the cafe drama were all good, but the setting was lacking for me.