I was excited to read a World War II historical fiction that was centered on another region, specifically Ukraine. I always want to learn more history through the journey of the fictional characters. Unfortunately, this book mostly missed the mark for me. I did not get the flavor of Ukraine and there is very little about the history of the occupation or of the Red Army or the battles during World War II. Ukraine was devastated by World War II and the Soviet retreat ahead of the Nazi occupation and very little of that is explored beyond the destruction in Kiev (Kyiv), which was substantial. Absent that, I would expect more about the people, if not the battles. In that way, too, the book falls flat. Lacking either a sense of place or a better exploration of the history, the story could be any location during any war.
The set ups of the character arcs for the two main female characters, only somewhat touch on the experiences of the people in Ukraine. Lisa is rescued by the Partisans while being transported from Ukraine to work for the Nazi war machine in Germany. So we see a little bit of fear experienced by the residents and the way their world was ripped apart. Irina is living with her husband, Maxim's, parents while he is fighting with the Partisans. Through her we see a resident struggling for food, struggling against Nazi occupation, and living in fear for her husband's life. There are also side characters who are portrayed as those who would betray others for their own survival, but again, they are thinly portrayed and are placeholders. None of it is explored as fully as I would hope.
Overall I think Irina's story is better developed, but not by much. Irina is subjected to some poor treatment by her mother in law as the not being "good enough" for her precious son. It did not feel original, it felt stereotypical. We have snapshots of the challenges she faces both trying to help others in her community, being a parent of a small child while living with in-laws, fears for her husband. Those fears felt real, but often Irina feels very young, all of her emotions are in her head instead of her actions or her storyline.
Lisa, who is a main character of Kortchik's book Sisters of War (which I have not read it is not clear in the blurb that it is an attached story), is incredibly young and immature and undeveloped, in my opinion. She has a hero worshipping-like obsession with Maxim, who was one of the Partisans who rescued her. She becomes one of the Partisans, as she has nowhere else to go. Her obsession with Maxim felt like a high school crush, immature and based on absolutely nothing, and completely not shared by Maxim, who loves his wife Irina. The only points of what felt like true emotional growth were with her thinking of the family she was no longer in contact with, and her reactions after the battles she was involved in. Especially at that point, when she has to kill someone, that was the one point where I thought the character had some emotional depth and growth. That's not enough to carry the rest of the story.
Maxim exists as the point of contact between Lisa and Irina. His own struggles with how to fight for Ukraine, how to protect his young family and his parents, all could have been explored more. He has real challenges to face, and his decisions are handled in a very expected manner without any discussion of how he came to heartbreaking decisions. His character is not developed at all, his actions simply happen to move the plot or connect the female characters.
When I read the author's note on some source material, I can see she had fantastic research and inspiration. However, those individuals simply don't come through in this book. I was left still wanting to know more about the real people and the real difficulties during the war, and I still want to know about Ukraine. This was my feeling while I was reading, I kept wanting more, more, more, and I simply never got it. An opportunity lost.
I read an e-ARC provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.