Seven books into the Dog Man series, one could hardly blame Dav Pilkey if the concept were starting to get stale, but that isn't the case. For Whom the Ball Rolls is the best Dog Man yet, a delightful mixture of humor, emotion, and profound thought. Ever since book three, A Tale of Two Kitties, the titles have been clever parodies of classic literature, featuring stories that frequently reference other works by the highlighted author; For Whom the Ball Rolls introduces kids to the stylings of Ernest Hemingway. Petey the Cat has been Dog Man's nemesis since book one, but his allegiances are shifting. This is because of Li'L Petey, the clone Petey created of himself so he could cause twice as much havoc. But Li'L Petey is a child, unjaded by the experiences that hardened Petey into a criminal. He often pleads with his "Papa" to resist doing evil, and this came to a head in the previous book, Brawl of the Wild, when Petey helped apprehend the villain and save the day. He remains in Cat Jail for past crimes, but that could change as public support sways in Petey's favor. Does he deserve a clean slate?
While Petey rallies his fellow prisoners to support a pardon for him, an old problem returns for Dog Man. His dual nature—head of a dog, body of a human—normally makes him a great cop, but he's vulnerable to certain distractions. A criminal with a rubber ball to throw can divert Dog Man from the chase, and easily escape. This aggravates the police chief, who wishes his star cop would close the gaping hole in his skills set, but Dog Man needs help to build the discipline to overcome his animal instincts. It takes Li'L Petey and his robot assistant, 80-HD, days of concentrated aversion therapy to break Dog Man's ball-chasing habit, but our hero will do whatever he has to in order to be a better law officer.
When Petey gets sprung from prison, he unknowingly leaves behind his three former cohorts—Piggy, Clunky, and Bub—with Big Jim, a cat whose good heart sharply contrasts with his criminal record. Shrunk to the size of tiny insects in Lord of the Fleas, Piggy's gang wants revenge on Petey, and the three miniaturized animals will play a role later on. For now, Petey is off to Dog Man's house to pick up Li'L Petey, a joyful reunion even if the kid is sad to leave Dog Man. Petey may be his Papa, but Dog Man is his friend and mentor, who helps ensure the young cat won't follow Petey's path into a life of crime. Petey would rather cut ties with Dog Man altogether, but he doesn't want to hurt the kid, so he arranges for him to split time between Petey's house and Dog Man's. Knowing he'll stay with his friends every weekend is a weight off Li'L Petey's mind.
Back at Cat Jail, minuscule Piggy whispers subliminal suggestions into Big Jim's ear, but controlling the cat for nefarious purposes isn't going as planned. In another section of the city, at Robo-Time Industries, Dr. Scum returns with a plan to reassert himself as a prominent criminal, but he needs a new tactic; if he goes back to his old tricks he'll just land in prison. How can he neutralize Dog Man? Meanwhile, as Li'L Petey and his Papa get to know each other, Petey talks for the first time about his own father, who left Petey as a child and never came back. Li'L Petey wonders: if he could track down his grandfather and bring him home, would Petey's bitterness toward the world dissipate? Would his villainous impulse go away? With help from 80-HD, Li'L Petey conducts a search for his grandfather, but the old cat who rings the doorbell is nothing like Li'L Petey expected. Will his return have a restorative effect on Petey, or show the younger cat once and for all that some people are just bad?
At long last, Dr. Scum discovers a weakness of Dog Man's to exploit, and tailors his latest criminal invention to do just that. His mechanized "Burgle Balls" terrorize the citizenry, stealing a fortune in jewelry and other expensive wares. Dog Man will have to battle his own canine nature to stop Dr. Scum, but he won't have to go it alone. Li'L Petey (aka Cat Kid) and 80-HD (Lightning Dude) are at his side, warriors for justice to aid the "Bark Knight". The Burgle Balls can't overcome all three, but Dr. Scum has a contingency plan: his Colossal-Bot 2000, a four-armed behemoth that could crush the city beneath its feet. Can the Bark Knight, Cat Kid, and Lightning Dude defeat this new foe? Maybe if Petey joins the fight, affirming his commitment to change his ways for the kid's sake. Whether or not Petey's father can be reformed, Petey has the choice from this day forward to set an example for Li'L Petey by opposing his own darker urges. Has he truly turned good? We'll find out as the series moves forward.
For Whom the Ball Rolls features spectacular full-color artwork. Dav Pilkey deserves some credit, but a fair amount should go to Jose Garibaldi, the colorist. He's a magician with blacks, blues, purples, and other majestic shades of the night sky. As for the story, it's packed with deeper insight than we've yet seen in a Dog Man book. Early on, we get a glimpse of the difference in Petey and Li'L Petey's dispositions as they walk home after Petey gets out of Cat Jail. The kid marvels at the sights of nature, but all Petey pays attention to is the bad parts, things that cause him stress. "Hey, Papa! Look at the cute flowers!" the kid says. "Those aren't flowers. Those are weeds!" Petey grumps back at him. "Hey, Papa! Look at the pretty river!" "That river isn't pretty—it's polluted!" Petey shouts. "Hey, Papa! Look at all of the twinkly stars!" "Hey! Watch where you're stepping!" Petey grouses. "There's mud everywhere!" Petey lost his sense of awe long ago, and with it, any joy he had. Bitterness rushed in to fill the vacuum, and now he sees everything through that murky, distorted filter. But Li'L Petey isn't just his son; he's an exact genetic duplicate of Petey, a chance to set right what went wrong in his own childhood, to shield the kid from having his sense of awe and innocence ripped away. Li'L Petey is his shot at redemption, though making the most of it won't be easy for a damaged person like Petey. And yet...he has to try.
This book draws clear distinction between feelings and action: you need more than good intentions to be a decent person. In an argument between Li'L Petey and his grandfather, the old cat claims he never felt love for Petey a day in his life. "Love isn't just something you feel," Li'L Petey tells him. "Love is something you do!" Powerful words from a perceptive youngster. You can't force yourself to feel affection for someone, but you can dutifully protect and provide for them as though you felt love. In the end, how you treat them is more important than what you felt while doing it. Things might have turned out differently had Petey's father grasped this years ago. Li'L Petey encourages Dog Man in a similar vein when he finds our hero hiding in a trash can, terrified of Dr. Scum's Burgle Balls. Li'L Petey assures Dog Man he's a "good boy," but, "that doesn't mean very much. Look around. This city is filled with good people...but none of them are doing anything! It's not enough to just be good. We gotta do good! Even if things get scary!" Being a hero requires that you stand up to evil when you're afraid, risking your safety to do good, and Dog Man's record of heroism is why we love and admire him.
The Dog Man series had been good so far, but For Whom the Ball Rolls takes it to another level. I might well rate this book the full three stars. It is a simmering brew of life in all its disappointments and glory, a visual and philosophical spectacle that can also be highly amusing, even if this isn't Dav Pilkey at his comedic best. The story comes full circle with Li'L Petey and his Papa taking a walk at night, contemplating the adventure they've just been on, the sadness and triumph. Petey isn't an affectionate type, so what he says means that much more. "You wanna know something, kid?...This world has a lot of problems...But it could never be a horrible place...because you're in it." Li'L Petey is his Papa's chance to hit rewind on his own life, a life that went terribly wrong but can still be reclaimed via the sweet miracle that is Li'L Petey. When he hugs his son, he's hugging that lonesome, disenchanted young cat Petey was years ago, before he entered a life of crime. For Whom the Ball Rolls is my favorite of Dav Pilkey's books, and if you like stories that are a mixture of funny, sweet, and thoughtful, this one might be for you. I'm glad I stuck with the Dog Man series long enough to reach this book.