I have been reading Robert B. Parker’s Jesse Stone series since its beginning. Jesse is the Chief of Police in the small town of Paradise, outside of Boston. Jesse’s background includes a once promising baseball prospect until suffering a career ending injury. He became a dedicated police officer in the Los Angeles Police department who developed a drinking problem that cost him his job.
Jesse’s role as Police Chief in Paradise has been his second chance at making life work, which has been full of work related challenges as well as personal ones. When Parker passed away the series continued with Michael Brandman writing three books followed by Reed Farrel Coleman authoring six. Under Coleman’s creative influence Jesse went through an incredibly personal journey of trial, heartbreak, and growth. His last three books – “The Hangman’s Sonnet”, “Colorblind”, and “The Bitterest Pill” – were especially memorable, and their strong arcs were Jesse’s Stone’s best writing in my opinion.
Last year, Mike Lupica, who has done a surprisingly good job of resurrecting Parker’s Sunny Randall series, was given creative control of Jesse Stone, the city of Paradise, Molly, Suit, and all the rest of the characters. It was a tough transition for because Coleman set an incredibly high bar and Lupica had his work cut out for him. Unfortunately, for me, I felt like his first Jesse Stone outing – “Fool’s Paradise” had some problems, especially with Jesse’s character and behaviors. It drove me crazy how many times he used the F word for the first time ever. Fortunately, Lupica’s second outing is an improved step in the right direction.
“Stone’s Throw” starts off with two dilemmas for Stone. The first is work related. A piece of Paradise land is bringing a lot of attention from two powerful businessmen, one from Boston and one from Las Vegas, both with mob relationships and gangster backgrounds. Both have placed undisclosed bids to buy the land from a longtime Paradise family and are awaiting the Town’s leadership council to vote their approval for the sale and development of a new casino resort. While the two adversaries are promising to improve Paradise’s economy post-COVID, there is a ground level resistance from the younger citizens trying to save their environment, and tempers are flaring. To make matters worse, the mayor who was passionately against the development, has been found dead, with his body left lying in a shallow grave on the very property causing the fight.
The second dilemma for Stone is personal. His on and off girlfriend, Sunny Randall has left to work a job for an old friend in California. Unfortunately, her feelings for her ex-husband have come up again, causing her to take a break from Jesse. Somehow, this separation feels more serious and lasting, so Jesse is not only fighting his feelings for her, he is dealing with his constant battle to return to drinking.
As Jesse investigates what is supposed to appear as suicide, but he is sure is murder, he finds himself going up against a new mayor who refuses to support anything less than a completion of the land deal. Jesse’s job could be at risk if he doesn’t let things go, which we know is not his style. Then, a blast from a past appears in the form of an old adversary, Wilson Cromartie, better known as “Crow” arrives in town. Years ago, Crow was a part of a team that went on a crime spree, blowing up the Stiles Island bride bridge and robbing several rich families. Most of the team was either killed or arrested, all except for Crow, who escaped on a speedboat with what was thought to be millions of dollars. 10 years following that (when the statue of limitations had run out) he returned to Paradise tracking down a runaway girl. He ended up working with Jesse to save her and disappeared again. However, not before spending some personal quality with Jesse’s deputy Molly Crane.
Now Jesse finds himself in the middle of two unwanted situations – the fight between two sworn enemies willing to kill in order to bring a casino to Paradise and the tension between Crow and Molly. If one doesn’t kill, the other one will…
I must say that Lupica improved a lot in his second Jesse Stone novel. There were a couple of things to improve on, but most of it was good. He did a pretty good job of capturing the qualities of small town of Paradise, Massachusetts. The characters were authentic and interesting, and contributed to the unfolding mystery being told. He’s displaying a better understanding of Jesse’s character (less swearing and emotional use of the F word which is not his style). I also enjoyed Molly’s expanded role, her family situations described, and individual chapters devoted to her activities. I thought that worked for the most part, not only for plotting purposes, but it also served to expand the character base around Jesse Stone. Maybe Suit can be explored further in future books.
Lupica’s plot of the town fighting over a potential casino and economic development is not new. But Lupica did a pretty good job of developing the storyline (much better than his previous Stone novel), and made it more interesting by including other well known Parker characters like Rita Fiore (one of my personal favorites). Adding in the return of Crow to provide tension with Molly and create conflicting partnership with Jesse ala Hawk and Spenser was a well delivered strong touch. I also enjoyed Lupica’s nostalgic mentioning of people and places from prior novels. I noticed that some readers liked that habit and others didn’t care for it. For me, I didn’t mind. I found those references rather nostalgic.
And I must add, without giving away any spoilers, I thoroughly the last chapter and how Jesse ended up resolving his personal issues. For me, it was the perfect ending to the book and an opening of future opportunities for development.
I mentioned in my review of Lupica’s first Jesse Stone novel that I was going to be patient, hoping that he would work on some things and get them right… Well, I am going to give credit where credit is due, and he say this was an improvement. An enjoyable one that has me looking forward with interest again for Jesse’s next outing. Lupica’s making me feel optimistic again… Thank you, Mike.