What do you think?
Rate this book
Perfectly Preventable Deaths #2
Precious Catastrophe
The utterly compelling and darkly magical sequel to award-winning author Deirdre Sullivan's PERFECTLY PREVENTABLE DEATHS
Look. Madeline. You've lost your soul. You've lost your freedom. You've lost a bit of your sister. What else could go wrong?
Catlin and Madeline are extraordinary sisters, living extraordinary lives - in a place that seems entirely ordinary, but which in fact seethes with secrets, both sacred and sinister. Ballyfran is a village where, for centuries, people who are not quite human have gathered. Catlin has already fallen foul of one such creature - a dark, vicious predator who almost killed her - and only Madeline giving up a part of her own soul was able to bring Catlin back from the brink of death.
Now, the girls are making their strange new lives: Catlin, haunted by what happened to her, is isolated and bereft; Madeline is learning ancient magics under the tutelage of local wise woman Mamó. Learning that magic isn't mindfulness and hats. It's work - hard work. And Madeline knows she has to keep watch. On her sister. On the things that happen. Notice things before they start to happen. And before long, they do ...
Look. Madeline. You've lost your soul. You've lost your freedom. You've lost a bit of your sister. What else could go wrong?
Catlin and Madeline are extraordinary sisters, living extraordinary lives - in a place that seems entirely ordinary, but which in fact seethes with secrets, both sacred and sinister. Ballyfran is a village where, for centuries, people who are not quite human have gathered. Catlin has already fallen foul of one such creature - a dark, vicious predator who almost killed her - and only Madeline giving up a part of her own soul was able to bring Catlin back from the brink of death.
Now, the girls are making their strange new lives: Catlin, haunted by what happened to her, is isolated and bereft; Madeline is learning ancient magics under the tutelage of local wise woman Mamó. Learning that magic isn't mindfulness and hats. It's work - hard work. And Madeline knows she has to keep watch. On her sister. On the things that happen. Notice things before they start to happen. And before long, they do ...
418 pages, Paperback
First published September 30, 2021
13 people are currently reading
880 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews
January 14, 2022
3.5 stars
Maddy and Caitlin are still in Ballyfran after moving there to live with their new stepdad. In Perfectly Preventable Deaths, the twins got to know their new town, its strange inhabitants and while Maddy began to realise she possessed skills of witchcraft, Caitlin became distracted by a new, dangerous relationships. In Precious Catastrophes, the reader follows the twins as they deal with the fall out of the previous book and all the traumas that entails.
I very much enjoyed this. I listened to this on audiobook narrated by Alison McKenna and she was absolutely fantastic. Her tone of voice for Caitlin in particular was so spot on, the characters really jumped to life for me.
The exploration of trauma and a trauma victim in this book is done so well and in a way that I can only describe as being incredibly Irish. The way Caitlin is still able to be utterly herself -sarcastic, dry, witty and sensual - while inwardly dealing with the mess that Lon made of her and using the incident to her advantage in ways that are genuinely funny, is just all written really well. Caitlin turns to prayer and the church in a way she hasn't done before - and I actually surprised myself, by really loving the local priest. His kindness and support of Caitlin in a difficult time was lovely to read, as was his frankness about aspects of religion and priesthood. I really appreciated as well seeing some of the effects of Caitlin's trauma come to her when she attempts to 'move on' with Eddie, a perfectly nice boy who would never hurt her. But that doesn't mean Caitlin's mind and body are unable to forget what had happened to her and the moments she freezes and panics in situations is very understandable and realistic. Also cheers for Caitlin explaining to Eddie that she doesn't feel up to things and him respecting that.
Caitlin's POV, which we didn't have in the first book, brought a lot to the story as a whole. Maddy is a lot more of a busy character in this now she has 'sold her soul' and begun her training with Mamo. Which means she doesn't always get some of the exciting scenes but I actually very much enjoyed having Caitlin and her humour in the driver's seat, as it was balanced out well by Maddy's shyness.
I did find myself wondering when the story was going to end in the last part of the book - mostly because there had been the pivotal activity with Our Lady of Ballyfran, Lon, and Brian and I still had 4 hours of audiobook and I couldn't understand why. It did feel a bit dragged out from the caves to the actual end of the book.
Still enjoyed this a lot. Deirdre Sullivan is able to write Irish witchy-ness and supernatural so, so well and she also really brings to life a great teenager which I have seen so many authors fail at.
Maddy and Caitlin are still in Ballyfran after moving there to live with their new stepdad. In Perfectly Preventable Deaths, the twins got to know their new town, its strange inhabitants and while Maddy began to realise she possessed skills of witchcraft, Caitlin became distracted by a new, dangerous relationships. In Precious Catastrophes, the reader follows the twins as they deal with the fall out of the previous book and all the traumas that entails.
I very much enjoyed this. I listened to this on audiobook narrated by Alison McKenna and she was absolutely fantastic. Her tone of voice for Caitlin in particular was so spot on, the characters really jumped to life for me.
The exploration of trauma and a trauma victim in this book is done so well and in a way that I can only describe as being incredibly Irish. The way Caitlin is still able to be utterly herself -sarcastic, dry, witty and sensual - while inwardly dealing with the mess that Lon made of her and using the incident to her advantage in ways that are genuinely funny, is just all written really well. Caitlin turns to prayer and the church in a way she hasn't done before - and I actually surprised myself, by really loving the local priest. His kindness and support of Caitlin in a difficult time was lovely to read, as was his frankness about aspects of religion and priesthood. I really appreciated as well seeing some of the effects of Caitlin's trauma come to her when she attempts to 'move on' with Eddie, a perfectly nice boy who would never hurt her. But that doesn't mean Caitlin's mind and body are unable to forget what had happened to her and the moments she freezes and panics in situations is very understandable and realistic. Also cheers for Caitlin explaining to Eddie that she doesn't feel up to things and him respecting that.
Caitlin's POV, which we didn't have in the first book, brought a lot to the story as a whole. Maddy is a lot more of a busy character in this now she has 'sold her soul' and begun her training with Mamo. Which means she doesn't always get some of the exciting scenes but I actually very much enjoyed having Caitlin and her humour in the driver's seat, as it was balanced out well by Maddy's shyness.
I did find myself wondering when the story was going to end in the last part of the book - mostly because there had been the pivotal activity with Our Lady of Ballyfran, Lon, and Brian and I still had 4 hours of audiobook and I couldn't understand why. It did feel a bit dragged out from the caves to the actual end of the book.
Still enjoyed this a lot. Deirdre Sullivan is able to write Irish witchy-ness and supernatural so, so well and she also really brings to life a great teenager which I have seen so many authors fail at.
December 27, 2021
The enthrallingly dark and unsettlingly creepy sequel to Perfectly Preventable Deaths is just as immersive,humorously macabre and richly atmospheric as the first—a chilling page-turner I practically devoured it was soo good.
It’s starts up shortly after the events of the previous book. Madeline having made a deal with Mamó (her soul and seven years of servitude) to save her sister, is now under the wise woman’s tutelage and learning ancient magic she never thought possible. Her twin, Catlin is still haunted by what happened and feels more isolated than ever.
But strange things are still happening and Madeline knows she has to keep watch. On her sister. On the things that happen. To notice them before they happen—long,long before…
Once again Deirdre Sullivan serves us with another richly compelling and utterly addictive book that I literally couldn’t get enough of; it’s told from the POVs of both Madeline and Catlin instead of just Madeline which I felt added more depth to the narrative.
I still absolutely loved Madeline who’s willingness to sacrifice everything for the ones she loved deeply endearing. I still felt that, although Catlin suffered a great deal of trauma and sympathised with her greatly, as a character she’s still wasn’t as likeable as her twin but she has the best humour (even if it’s a little dark) and I enjoyed getting to see more from her POV.
Though I must admit the sensitive way Sullivan depicts Catlin’s emotional development was incredible and felt organic for someone suffering trauma. It’s some of the most emotionally evocative writing I’ve read in a while and it’s simply phenomenal.
Mamó was also one of the characters I wanted to explore more about as she was such a mystery in book 1 and seemed a rather feared and misunderstood figure. We don’t get too much backstory for her but what we do learn really makes me like her more than I thought I would.
We also delve more into the secrets of Ballyfrann, and even shed a little more light on the towns’ inhabitants (including Brian.) However with soo many strange occurrences and generations of secrets we’re left with just as many questions as answers which has me hoping there’s going to be a book three.
If you love your fiction magical, atmospheric and with a hint of the macabre then this is definitely the book for you. Though there is quite a bit of gore so consider yourself warned.
And thanks to Hot Key Books and NetGalley for the e-arc.
It’s starts up shortly after the events of the previous book. Madeline having made a deal with Mamó (her soul and seven years of servitude) to save her sister, is now under the wise woman’s tutelage and learning ancient magic she never thought possible. Her twin, Catlin is still haunted by what happened and feels more isolated than ever.
But strange things are still happening and Madeline knows she has to keep watch. On her sister. On the things that happen. To notice them before they happen—long,long before…
Once again Deirdre Sullivan serves us with another richly compelling and utterly addictive book that I literally couldn’t get enough of; it’s told from the POVs of both Madeline and Catlin instead of just Madeline which I felt added more depth to the narrative.
I still absolutely loved Madeline who’s willingness to sacrifice everything for the ones she loved deeply endearing. I still felt that, although Catlin suffered a great deal of trauma and sympathised with her greatly, as a character she’s still wasn’t as likeable as her twin but she has the best humour (even if it’s a little dark) and I enjoyed getting to see more from her POV.
Though I must admit the sensitive way Sullivan depicts Catlin’s emotional development was incredible and felt organic for someone suffering trauma. It’s some of the most emotionally evocative writing I’ve read in a while and it’s simply phenomenal.
Mamó was also one of the characters I wanted to explore more about as she was such a mystery in book 1 and seemed a rather feared and misunderstood figure. We don’t get too much backstory for her but what we do learn really makes me like her more than I thought I would.
We also delve more into the secrets of Ballyfrann, and even shed a little more light on the towns’ inhabitants (including Brian.) However with soo many strange occurrences and generations of secrets we’re left with just as many questions as answers which has me hoping there’s going to be a book three.
If you love your fiction magical, atmospheric and with a hint of the macabre then this is definitely the book for you. Though there is quite a bit of gore so consider yourself warned.
And thanks to Hot Key Books and NetGalley for the e-arc.
November 28, 2023
Really well done continuation of the story. This time you get the perspective of both sisters. I love that each book ends so that the story is finished but has room to expand. Personally I would love to see a part three of this world.
September 19, 2021
I received this eProof for free from Hot Key Books via NetGalley for the purposes of providing an honest review.
Trigger and content warnings:
When I heard that Precious Catastrophe by Deirdre Sullivan, sequel to Perfectly Preventable Deaths, was being published this year, it immediately became my most anticipated book of 2021. There was no waiting around with this book; as soon as I had it in my hands, I immediately started reading, and I'm thrilled to say it was more epic than I was expecting!
After Lon attacked and killed Catlin in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, and Maddy made a bargain with Mamó to save her life, both are dealing with the consequences. Maddy now lives with Mamó, constantly working and constantly learning, rarely seeing her family or having any time for herself, and Mamó is just as grumpy and taciturn as ever. But it's all worth it, because Catlin is alive. Catlin is struggling with what she's experienced, and with Maddy hardly ever around, turns to her faith and spirituality for solace. But when they discover their father's ashes have been exhumed from his grave, and that bones of one of the previous girls killed by Lon have been scattered again, they realise they're not as safe as they thought. Something has awoken. Evil is still haunting Ballyfrann.
Precious Catastrophe is told from both Maddy and Catlin's perspectives, as opposed to just Maddy's in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, but the focus is mainly on Catlin. She's still dealing with the trauma and betrayal of what Lon did to her. What I absolutely loved about Catlin's struggle is how real it is; this story may be fantasy, and she may have been torn apart by a monster, but her trauma response is authentic, and very relatable. When she was was killed, she was having sex with Lon that she consented to, but it quickly changed from consensual sex to Lon tearing into her flesh with his teeth, It might not be what we normally think of, but it's sexual assault, and Catlin's trauma response is that of a sexual assault survivor. She was once very confident, and loved the attention of boys, but now things are hard. She's still Catlin; she's still wise-cracking, and kind of self-centered, and that confidence still seems to be there. But she's having nightmares, has anxiety, and when Eddie Collins takes an interest in her, things are different from Catlin when things get physical. When it looks like things might go even a little further than just kissing, Catlin freezes in fear. Eddie even simply brushing his hand over her ribs in a similar to Lon is enough to take her right back. Eddie is a nice guy, though, who knows what has she's been through and is completely up for going at her pace, which makes things easier for Catlin. But the trauma is real, and it isn't something she can exactly go to a therapist with - that her ex-boyfriend is a monster who tried to kill her with his teeth.
So she turns to her spirituality. The Virgin Mary has always resonated to Catlin, and she's always kept a shrine of statues and prayer cards, and she turns to Mary now, both at her own shrine and at the local church, where she spends the majority of her time now. Catlin's spirituality like the other half of the coin to Maddy's witchcraft. It was fascinating to see Catlin's spirituality from her own perspective, because in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, we got it from Maddy's; how unfair she thought it that their mum was ok with Catlin's faith and spirituality, but Maddy's intuitive and instinctive knowledge of what plants and other household items were needed to protect her family was strange and unacceptable. It felt a lot less about religion, and more about ritual and turning inward, and a respect and a reverence that is separate to that within religion. It's a spirituality that is familiar to me. Despite being an atheist, Catlin's spirituality really resonated with me, and the ritual of it all bringing her peace is something I completely understood. But things start to change when a statue in the church that Catlin is particularly drawn to, Our Lady of Ballyfrann, starts performing miracles for Catlin. Mary has heard her prayers, has made contact, and is now going to help Catlin never feel afraid again.
There is a constant and pervasive feeling of dread as you read Precious Catastrophe. The writing is atmospheric and creepy, and I was constantly on edge. You just know there's something sinister happening, even if you don't know what. It's the feeling of knowing someone is watching you, they're behind you, and they're creeping up to you, but you can't turn around, so you're just waiting and waiting for them to reach you. You're constantly on the precipice of terror; it's encompassing and inescapable, and bloody brilliant! I had so many theories about what was going on, and while they were almost half right, I was never spot on. The direction the story took at a number of points surprised me, and my horror just grew and grew. The twists and revelations were mind blowing, and the climax, oh my god! Sitting on the edge of my seat, completely horrified, and incredibly tense, with no idea how Catlin and Maddy would get out of things this time! It was just incredible! It's all kind of freaky and disturbing and sinister, and I bloody loved it! Honestly, I love Precious Catastrophe more than Perfectly Preventable Deaths, and I thought that was pretty much perfect.
And I'm excited! Because while the story of Precious Catastrophe is all wrapped up and has a conclusion, there are little bits and pieces that make me think there's going to be a third book. There are still questions around the world Ballyfrann exists in we don't have the answers to yet, questions around the past, and a few tiny loose ends - or rather possibilities that could be explored. There are definite hints of more to come. And I'm thrilled because I am in no way ready to say goodbye to Maddy and Catlin, and this petrifying world! I bloody adored Precious Catastrophe, and I need you all to buy it to make sure we definitely get that third book. Seriously, I cannot recommend this terrifying series enough!
Trigger and content warnings:
When I heard that Precious Catastrophe by Deirdre Sullivan, sequel to Perfectly Preventable Deaths, was being published this year, it immediately became my most anticipated book of 2021. There was no waiting around with this book; as soon as I had it in my hands, I immediately started reading, and I'm thrilled to say it was more epic than I was expecting!
After Lon attacked and killed Catlin in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, and Maddy made a bargain with Mamó to save her life, both are dealing with the consequences. Maddy now lives with Mamó, constantly working and constantly learning, rarely seeing her family or having any time for herself, and Mamó is just as grumpy and taciturn as ever. But it's all worth it, because Catlin is alive. Catlin is struggling with what she's experienced, and with Maddy hardly ever around, turns to her faith and spirituality for solace. But when they discover their father's ashes have been exhumed from his grave, and that bones of one of the previous girls killed by Lon have been scattered again, they realise they're not as safe as they thought. Something has awoken. Evil is still haunting Ballyfrann.
Precious Catastrophe is told from both Maddy and Catlin's perspectives, as opposed to just Maddy's in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, but the focus is mainly on Catlin. She's still dealing with the trauma and betrayal of what Lon did to her. What I absolutely loved about Catlin's struggle is how real it is; this story may be fantasy, and she may have been torn apart by a monster, but her trauma response is authentic, and very relatable. When she was was killed, she was having sex with Lon that she consented to, but it quickly changed from consensual sex to Lon tearing into her flesh with his teeth, It might not be what we normally think of, but it's sexual assault, and Catlin's trauma response is that of a sexual assault survivor. She was once very confident, and loved the attention of boys, but now things are hard. She's still Catlin; she's still wise-cracking, and kind of self-centered, and that confidence still seems to be there. But she's having nightmares, has anxiety, and when Eddie Collins takes an interest in her, things are different from Catlin when things get physical. When it looks like things might go even a little further than just kissing, Catlin freezes in fear. Eddie even simply brushing his hand over her ribs in a similar to Lon is enough to take her right back. Eddie is a nice guy, though, who knows what has she's been through and is completely up for going at her pace, which makes things easier for Catlin. But the trauma is real, and it isn't something she can exactly go to a therapist with - that her ex-boyfriend is a monster who tried to kill her with his teeth.
So she turns to her spirituality. The Virgin Mary has always resonated to Catlin, and she's always kept a shrine of statues and prayer cards, and she turns to Mary now, both at her own shrine and at the local church, where she spends the majority of her time now. Catlin's spirituality like the other half of the coin to Maddy's witchcraft. It was fascinating to see Catlin's spirituality from her own perspective, because in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, we got it from Maddy's; how unfair she thought it that their mum was ok with Catlin's faith and spirituality, but Maddy's intuitive and instinctive knowledge of what plants and other household items were needed to protect her family was strange and unacceptable. It felt a lot less about religion, and more about ritual and turning inward, and a respect and a reverence that is separate to that within religion. It's a spirituality that is familiar to me. Despite being an atheist, Catlin's spirituality really resonated with me, and the ritual of it all bringing her peace is something I completely understood. But things start to change when a statue in the church that Catlin is particularly drawn to, Our Lady of Ballyfrann, starts performing miracles for Catlin. Mary has heard her prayers, has made contact, and is now going to help Catlin never feel afraid again.
There is a constant and pervasive feeling of dread as you read Precious Catastrophe. The writing is atmospheric and creepy, and I was constantly on edge. You just know there's something sinister happening, even if you don't know what. It's the feeling of knowing someone is watching you, they're behind you, and they're creeping up to you, but you can't turn around, so you're just waiting and waiting for them to reach you. You're constantly on the precipice of terror; it's encompassing and inescapable, and bloody brilliant! I had so many theories about what was going on, and while they were almost half right, I was never spot on. The direction the story took at a number of points surprised me, and my horror just grew and grew. The twists and revelations were mind blowing, and the climax, oh my god! Sitting on the edge of my seat, completely horrified, and incredibly tense, with no idea how Catlin and Maddy would get out of things this time! It was just incredible! It's all kind of freaky and disturbing and sinister, and I bloody loved it! Honestly, I love Precious Catastrophe more than Perfectly Preventable Deaths, and I thought that was pretty much perfect.
And I'm excited! Because while the story of Precious Catastrophe is all wrapped up and has a conclusion, there are little bits and pieces that make me think there's going to be a third book. There are still questions around the world Ballyfrann exists in we don't have the answers to yet, questions around the past, and a few tiny loose ends - or rather possibilities that could be explored. There are definite hints of more to come. And I'm thrilled because I am in no way ready to say goodbye to Maddy and Catlin, and this petrifying world! I bloody adored Precious Catastrophe, and I need you all to buy it to make sure we definitely get that third book. Seriously, I cannot recommend this terrifying series enough!
November 12, 2025
God, I love this series so much!
I had no idea where this book was going to go after the ending of Perfectly Preventable Deaths but it surpassed any expectations I had. I feel like it's really rare for a sequel to be as good as the first but Deirdre absolutely nailed this one!
I loved that we got Caitlin's POV in this book, it added so much depth to her character. It definitely made me like her more.
This book really was everything I hoped for and I'm crossing my fingers that there will be a 3rd because the ending definitely implied that there might be one. I'm not ready to let go of Ballyfran and the Hayes family (Mamo included!) yet!
I had no idea where this book was going to go after the ending of Perfectly Preventable Deaths but it surpassed any expectations I had. I feel like it's really rare for a sequel to be as good as the first but Deirdre absolutely nailed this one!
I loved that we got Caitlin's POV in this book, it added so much depth to her character. It definitely made me like her more.
This book really was everything I hoped for and I'm crossing my fingers that there will be a 3rd because the ending definitely implied that there might be one. I'm not ready to let go of Ballyfran and the Hayes family (Mamo included!) yet!
November 6, 2021
4.5 rounded up.
I liked PPD when I first read it, but nothing aside from the lovely writing really stuck with me. This one felt like a big improvement - I think the duel POV helped me connect with both girls more. I also enjoyed the exploration of religion and the Catholic Church. The only reason I knocked half a star off was the last quarter dragged a bit.
I liked PPD when I first read it, but nothing aside from the lovely writing really stuck with me. This one felt like a big improvement - I think the duel POV helped me connect with both girls more. I also enjoyed the exploration of religion and the Catholic Church. The only reason I knocked half a star off was the last quarter dragged a bit.
November 28, 2021
Teen witchy shenanigans, often laugh out loud dialogue, sisterhood.
Great craic. Read it.
Great craic. Read it.
September 29, 2021
I still dislike Oonagh
December 31, 2021
Now, THIS is what I wanted Perfectly Preventable Deaths to be!
From the start, this book just flowed. Completely sinking its teeth in, twisting its dark, depraved world around you relentlessly until the very last word. Almost as if it was possessing you.
The delicious and vile imagery seeps into the pages, as you begin to truly discover the hidden darkness and creatures that lurk in this unassuming Irish town. Deirdre Sullivan's writing is beautifully eerie, invoking powerful emotions awakening your senses as if you can feel, taste, and smell it yourself.
Unlike Perfectly Preventable Deaths, this is told from both Madeline & Catlin's POV. Which gives a better insight into the girls.
And allows us, the reader, to follow them down very different paths. Madeline as she begins her new life with Mamó learning that being a witch isn't broomsticks, black cats, and cauldrons. And Catlin as she struggles to come to terms with what happened to her. Turning to the power of religion and prayer to guide her. With a greater understanding that Ballyfrann is bursting with secrets, will Madeline's new abilities help prevent the darkness from being unearthed or will evil beyond their imaginations be reborn?
There is so much in this book that I love I knew from the first chapter that it would be 5 stars. Book 1 was a great introduction, but this was superb! I'm sure there are still some unanswered questions, but right now, I'm so glad I did carry on with this series and you never know, they may even be a 3rd? Who knows? Well, Deirdre obviously lol but you know what I mean
Thank you so much, NetGalley & Bonnier Books UK/Hot Key Books for the ARC ebook in return for an honest review.
From the start, this book just flowed. Completely sinking its teeth in, twisting its dark, depraved world around you relentlessly until the very last word. Almost as if it was possessing you.
The delicious and vile imagery seeps into the pages, as you begin to truly discover the hidden darkness and creatures that lurk in this unassuming Irish town. Deirdre Sullivan's writing is beautifully eerie, invoking powerful emotions awakening your senses as if you can feel, taste, and smell it yourself.
Unlike Perfectly Preventable Deaths, this is told from both Madeline & Catlin's POV. Which gives a better insight into the girls.
And allows us, the reader, to follow them down very different paths. Madeline as she begins her new life with Mamó learning that being a witch isn't broomsticks, black cats, and cauldrons. And Catlin as she struggles to come to terms with what happened to her. Turning to the power of religion and prayer to guide her. With a greater understanding that Ballyfrann is bursting with secrets, will Madeline's new abilities help prevent the darkness from being unearthed or will evil beyond their imaginations be reborn?
There is so much in this book that I love I knew from the first chapter that it would be 5 stars. Book 1 was a great introduction, but this was superb! I'm sure there are still some unanswered questions, but right now, I'm so glad I did carry on with this series and you never know, they may even be a 3rd? Who knows? Well, Deirdre obviously lol but you know what I mean
Thank you so much, NetGalley & Bonnier Books UK/Hot Key Books for the ARC ebook in return for an honest review.
October 26, 2021
Precious Catastrophe quickly drew me in with its witty humour, loveable characters and spookiness.
Ugh, Deidre just has this incredible way with storytelling, of making the whole thing fun, imbuing all of both these books with the wonderful personalities of Maddy and Catlin. It was their narration that really brought the story to life, full with their wit, sarcasm and teenage annoyance. Them being teenagers, too, was perfectly done. They were just childish enough to come across as very real, without being naive or annoying. I’m the same age as them, I think?, and can confirm we would be besties IRL, which means Deidre has created some really 3D, amazing characters.
As well as this wit in the writing, the prose is just gorgeous. Precious Catastrophe is set in a small town in Ireland, where the supernatural lurks, and Deidre perfectly captures the spookiness of the castle, the witchcraft and the haunted Irish hills, as well as the odd neatness of small towns!
It’s been a good while since I read Perfectly Preventable Deaths, but I remembered enough of the plot to fully love this one, I think. I believe the first book was written as a standalone, so some of the reveals in this book had to be explained a bit more than if they’d had foreshadowing in the first one, but that’s another thing I think Deidre did well - the reveals still hit very hard, and I think this book was probably better than the first one. It was just awesome to see both sides of Catlin and Maddy’s sisterhood, which really does sit at the centre of these books. I absolutely love that, and their bond is just SO amazing, aah. I love the way they learn to lean on each other in Precious Catastrophe, as well as to accept their differences.
And I love that Maddy is a lesbian OBVIOUSLY, that’s why I read these books! It’s relatively casual and takes a back seat to the rest of the plot, but in a good way. Like, she’s a lesbian, she likes a girl, but the story isn’t really about that. I love gay people !!!!!
4.5 stars :)
Ugh, Deidre just has this incredible way with storytelling, of making the whole thing fun, imbuing all of both these books with the wonderful personalities of Maddy and Catlin. It was their narration that really brought the story to life, full with their wit, sarcasm and teenage annoyance. Them being teenagers, too, was perfectly done. They were just childish enough to come across as very real, without being naive or annoying. I’m the same age as them, I think?, and can confirm we would be besties IRL, which means Deidre has created some really 3D, amazing characters.
As well as this wit in the writing, the prose is just gorgeous. Precious Catastrophe is set in a small town in Ireland, where the supernatural lurks, and Deidre perfectly captures the spookiness of the castle, the witchcraft and the haunted Irish hills, as well as the odd neatness of small towns!
It’s been a good while since I read Perfectly Preventable Deaths, but I remembered enough of the plot to fully love this one, I think. I believe the first book was written as a standalone, so some of the reveals in this book had to be explained a bit more than if they’d had foreshadowing in the first one, but that’s another thing I think Deidre did well - the reveals still hit very hard, and I think this book was probably better than the first one. It was just awesome to see both sides of Catlin and Maddy’s sisterhood, which really does sit at the centre of these books. I absolutely love that, and their bond is just SO amazing, aah. I love the way they learn to lean on each other in Precious Catastrophe, as well as to accept their differences.
And I love that Maddy is a lesbian OBVIOUSLY, that’s why I read these books! It’s relatively casual and takes a back seat to the rest of the plot, but in a good way. Like, she’s a lesbian, she likes a girl, but the story isn’t really about that. I love gay people !!!!!
4.5 stars :)
March 15, 2024
It's been a while since I got the first book in this series in my Book Box Club (I still miss Book Box Club...). It's also been a while since I got a copy of the sequel. However, this week I had some extra reading time due to not having to travel to the office, so it was the perfect moment to pick up some books I wanted to read for some time but never got to. I was afraid I wouldn't really remember much of the first book, but luckily that fear turned out to be unfounded.
Although the book starts where the previous book ended and although what happens in the previous book is playing a huge role in what's going on now, it also feels like this book is an entirely new story. And every time we did need a few reminders, the author did an amazing job giving them to us without it sounding forced or weird. It therefore didn't take long before all the horrifying details of the first book came back to me.
In a way this book is less bloody and less gory compared to the first book, but I wouldn't say it's less scary. Because once more our favorite twins are facing danger and once more they will have to be creative and will have to be willing to embrace their magic to survive. On top of that they're stumbling upon quite a few secrets changing their entire lives. I don't wanna give too much away, but we already knew something was up with Brian, right?
I also loved loved loved the magic of praying in this book and the role the local priest played in this story. Quite often religion, faith and priests play a negative role in books (and we all understand where that comes from), so it was kind of refreshing to see a priest portrayed in a more positive light. Especially because he really seemed to be a nice and good guy, understanding what this town and its people need and want from him.
I don't think this is the last book in the series. So, I will certainly keep an eye out for more!
Although the book starts where the previous book ended and although what happens in the previous book is playing a huge role in what's going on now, it also feels like this book is an entirely new story. And every time we did need a few reminders, the author did an amazing job giving them to us without it sounding forced or weird. It therefore didn't take long before all the horrifying details of the first book came back to me.
In a way this book is less bloody and less gory compared to the first book, but I wouldn't say it's less scary. Because once more our favorite twins are facing danger and once more they will have to be creative and will have to be willing to embrace their magic to survive. On top of that they're stumbling upon quite a few secrets changing their entire lives. I don't wanna give too much away, but we already knew something was up with Brian, right?
I also loved loved loved the magic of praying in this book and the role the local priest played in this story. Quite often religion, faith and priests play a negative role in books (and we all understand where that comes from), so it was kind of refreshing to see a priest portrayed in a more positive light. Especially because he really seemed to be a nice and good guy, understanding what this town and its people need and want from him.
I don't think this is the last book in the series. So, I will certainly keep an eye out for more!
November 12, 2023
This book. As always I was trying to find out if I wasn't being critique-y enough before giving a star rating. The only thing that gave me pause was the way everyone interacts after the big dramatic middle to 3rd quarter section. Ita very Gilmore Girls banter without the references even with the v problematic Brian. But tbf it is a uniquely Irish way of dealing with trauma to dark comedy the pain away. I do this with my bestie. And the bond between the twins is one of the strongest and most well rounded things in this book, they're very different voices in the chapters they pov buy the connection is always there. The banter is top notch too and I love a good banter with lots of Irish punch and slang. I think the cheeriness, real or self protective, and probably too merciful solutions,are also doing what fiction often fails to do to morally good characters; stop them from becoming more like the monsters they face. However, this system has lots of rules and consequences ,who anyone who knows me will know I adore! And the magic system is just gorgeous! Irish myth and herbs and sarcasm abound in it and a new type of uniquely Irish magic I won't spoil for those who haven't read this...another one of my interests is in there in a new and interesting way. Kind of like the dualities of St Brigid if you'd like a clue. Finally I love the other characters and how they feel v real. Mam is really like sn Irish mam. And while she's less of a bitch witch Mamo is still cutting and class. I also love how real they get the Irish mammy attempt to understand and support gay children. Its a tiny detail in the story that does it justice without overdoing it, much like Sheila's overenthusiasm while awkward support.
October 17, 2024
I loved this series and I truly hope there will be more in the future. Of course, you should rather end at a good time, than just continue writing just because there is material but I believe that Sullivan would only make good of more.
There is potential.
I love that we got both point of views, well three to be clear - now I question, was it maybe really Bridget at the beginning in Catlin's dreams? And the evil goddess just took over at some point, having made her way in through an already open door?
I hope we see more, so we can also see if Bridget is really okay with being the watcher of Brian.
Brian... an interesting guy, I can't even be mad at him? He is ABSOLUTELY in the wrong, with everything but to me he seems really lost. REALLY lost. That doesn't excuse anything but makes it impossible for me to be mad at him. Even though he killed their father - or at least knew who did and was present.
The cannibalism to get more powerful... is something.
Lon being the son of OLOB is also something, something that when it happened was SO plausible but I would have never thought of it and was so shocked. Him being - hopefully I mean he was stabbed to death before and still lived - gone for good, is what we all need. No one needs more of Lon or his psycho mother. (Also the incest???)
I loved it all, it was mysterious and good and scary but also light, I loved them all - well, if they could be loved. And again, I do wish and hope for more.
Catlin and Maddy being able to be witch sisters, doing it all together, deserves a story. A happy story.
Well, I am biased, of course I want more.
Also I want to see how powerful they can get. Also what will happen to Mamó? Like I hope she will be fine and so... we NEED more.
There is potential.
I love that we got both point of views, well three to be clear - now I question, was it maybe really Bridget at the beginning in Catlin's dreams? And the evil goddess just took over at some point, having made her way in through an already open door?
I hope we see more, so we can also see if Bridget is really okay with being the watcher of Brian.
Brian... an interesting guy, I can't even be mad at him? He is ABSOLUTELY in the wrong, with everything but to me he seems really lost. REALLY lost. That doesn't excuse anything but makes it impossible for me to be mad at him. Even though he killed their father - or at least knew who did and was present.
The cannibalism to get more powerful... is something.
Lon being the son of OLOB is also something, something that when it happened was SO plausible but I would have never thought of it and was so shocked. Him being - hopefully I mean he was stabbed to death before and still lived - gone for good, is what we all need. No one needs more of Lon or his psycho mother. (Also the incest???)
I loved it all, it was mysterious and good and scary but also light, I loved them all - well, if they could be loved. And again, I do wish and hope for more.
Catlin and Maddy being able to be witch sisters, doing it all together, deserves a story. A happy story.
Well, I am biased, of course I want more.
Also I want to see how powerful they can get. Also what will happen to Mamó? Like I hope she will be fine and so... we NEED more.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 12, 2021
A captivating sequel to Perfectly Preventable Deaths, this is a tightly-paced and dramatic story, full of horror and tension, which makes for a wonderful spooky read. When we left twins Madeline and Catlin, Madeline had become apprentice to the witch Mamó, to repay her for bringing back Catlin from death. The story picks up shortly after these events: Catlin is coping with her past relationship with murderer Lon, and finds solace in prayer. Though she's been brought up as a Catholic, this kind of devotion is new, and Madeline worries about her, especially when she begins sleepwalking. The forces acting against the sisters become more and more intense in this instalment, while Sullivan balances the horror and dread with great insight into the teenage frame of mind, as well as lots of witty banter, cutting-edge references, and chances for love and lust. Unlike many YA novels, this story never went in the directions I expected, and I loved how vividly drawn the central characters are. Like much Irish fiction today, particularly YA novels, this book looks at the influence of the Catholic church, and tries to grapple with the legacy of abuse and death, and Sullivan does so in a particularly subtle way. An excellent sequel that builds on the mystery and atmosphere established in Perfectly Preventable Deaths, and leaves room for more.
October 8, 2024
Audiobook- ehhhh. It was okay. It wasn’t as good as the first book, basically being its mirror but featuring the alternate twins perspective, and I didn’t love the pregnancy stuff, but I rarely do.
Again, it didn’t have any surprises- everything was laid out for you so the stuff happens in slow motion whilst you wait for it.
I did still like the audio though, this actress was great, and the vibes were very on theme for October! 👻
Again, it didn’t have any surprises- everything was laid out for you so the stuff happens in slow motion whilst you wait for it.
I did still like the audio though, this actress was great, and the vibes were very on theme for October! 👻
October 18, 2021
A modern witchy duology with lots of gothic vibes. I devoured both of these books in two days. They were both dark, chilling atmospheric reads. I loved the dynamics between the sisters and the humour, I was fully invested in their story. These books are so beautifully written and completely captivating. If you enjoy dark witchy reads, I highly recommend picking these up.
May 24, 2022
4.5 stars.
The story continues with one twin recovering from trauma and the other embracing her witchy side. Love Mamó and Caitlin 😊
I love how Irish this is, specially the way the narrator does the voices and also how they go on .😅
Dark at times but light notes too.
Recommend this to all!
Hoping there's a sequel too!
The story continues with one twin recovering from trauma and the other embracing her witchy side. Love Mamó and Caitlin 😊
I love how Irish this is, specially the way the narrator does the voices and also how they go on .😅
Dark at times but light notes too.
Recommend this to all!
Hoping there's a sequel too!
September 3, 2022
3.5/5 This was sooo much more enjoyable than the first book in the collection! The story was better paced, characters were more interesting, plot had more depth... overall just a much better book imo!
November 16, 2021
Loved it just as much as book 1.
September 30, 2022
3.5/5
Not as strong as the first one to me, but a great edition to the series and a very fun story.
Not as strong as the first one to me, but a great edition to the series and a very fun story.
December 28, 2021
I absolutely adore this follow up from perfectly preventable deaths. This series has my heart and soul. I love the sisterly bond and the thickened plot, and everything about it. I didn’t know what to expect going into the second book, but it blew me away and was everything I wanted and more.
October 12, 2021
I so enjoyed re-visiting Ballyfran and all its mysteries in Precious Catastrophe. I loved getting to see the world and especially the magic progressing. Unravelling a few more of its secrets.
Of course, Mamo is back in all her wise and grumpy glory.
It was a nice surprise too to have Catlin's POV which I didn't know going in. Getting to see that sisterly bond and also the bond that formed from all they've survived.
I wish I had Deirdre Sullivan's talent with words to properly express how much I love this story, and to be able to talk eloquently enough about the themes and impact that they leave.
Alas, I will have to struggle on in 'fan girl word vomit'.
Deirdre Sullivan's writing has always read to me like a mix of the magical and the visceral raw things in life. It was no different here. So many quotes I wanted to underline. When she wrote about a town that eats girls, that takes and takes things from them. And how very easy they are to break. Or at least on the surface. A girl is made of sterner things underneath. And I absolutely loved how she portrayed that.
I don't mean to say that there was any glorification of trauma or anything. But I found it hugely inspiring how she wrote about finding strength through pain and suffering because that's just what you have no choice to do sometimes.
I also don't want to make this sound like a depressing book at all! The amount of sarcastic humour and banter between the twins and about the possible demon cat, Button, had me smiling and giggling to myself like something possessed.
Too soon, Catlin? Sorry.
The spell work and explanations of magic in this world never fail to give me the spine tingles in the best way. The mix of herbal magic practice and the author's own spin on things is a dark delight to read.
I feel like the feminine and sisterly bond is almost extended to the reader here. Some sisters you grow up with and some you forge if not through blood, then through life and shared experience. And there's a power in that bond.
There are so many things I want to say and to say better but then I'd end up just talking about every second sentence that I had to underline and admire.
So in short... read it.. And welcome to Ballyfran..Beal Ifran...Hell mouth, and be careful what you open the door to.
Of course, Mamo is back in all her wise and grumpy glory.
It was a nice surprise too to have Catlin's POV which I didn't know going in. Getting to see that sisterly bond and also the bond that formed from all they've survived.
I wish I had Deirdre Sullivan's talent with words to properly express how much I love this story, and to be able to talk eloquently enough about the themes and impact that they leave.
Alas, I will have to struggle on in 'fan girl word vomit'.
Deirdre Sullivan's writing has always read to me like a mix of the magical and the visceral raw things in life. It was no different here. So many quotes I wanted to underline. When she wrote about a town that eats girls, that takes and takes things from them. And how very easy they are to break. Or at least on the surface. A girl is made of sterner things underneath. And I absolutely loved how she portrayed that.
I don't mean to say that there was any glorification of trauma or anything. But I found it hugely inspiring how she wrote about finding strength through pain and suffering because that's just what you have no choice to do sometimes.
I also don't want to make this sound like a depressing book at all! The amount of sarcastic humour and banter between the twins and about the possible demon cat, Button, had me smiling and giggling to myself like something possessed.
Too soon, Catlin? Sorry.
The spell work and explanations of magic in this world never fail to give me the spine tingles in the best way. The mix of herbal magic practice and the author's own spin on things is a dark delight to read.
I feel like the feminine and sisterly bond is almost extended to the reader here. Some sisters you grow up with and some you forge if not through blood, then through life and shared experience. And there's a power in that bond.
There are so many things I want to say and to say better but then I'd end up just talking about every second sentence that I had to underline and admire.
So in short... read it.. And welcome to Ballyfran..Beal Ifran...Hell mouth, and be careful what you open the door to.
November 3, 2024
Having loved the first book “Perfectly Preventable Deaths”, I was expecting mystery, a really dark atmosphere and magic and it lacked.
.
It was so hard to go through this one. Nothing was making me feel hooked and suddenly I thought every character was boring.
.
It was so hard to go through this one. Nothing was making me feel hooked and suddenly I thought every character was boring.
August 22, 2022
Perfectly Preventable Deaths is one of my absolute favourite YA novel, so I was very excited to hear there was a sequel coming out.
Precious Catastrophe picks up right where book one ends, and it is pretty necessary to read the first one first. One reason I was thrilled at news of a sequel is that book one left quite a few open questions. What happened to Catlin and Maddy's dad? Did Brian have a part to play in everything that happened? We saw two figures at one point and it was never clear exactly who they were.
Precious Catastrophe goes a long way towards answering these questions. Not every mystery is cleared up, and I'm really hoping for a third book, but I definitely finished this one with fewer unresolved queries and doubts.
After the events of book one, Catlin is recovering from her abuse and murder at the hands of Lon, while Maddy is working for Mamo, learning how to be a witch. The point of view switches between the two sisters, as we see how they cope with their changes of circumstance and their changing relationship with each other. The growing tension between the twins, no longer living together, really drives a lot of the tension in the book. I felt like things would be so much simpler for them if they just worked together, though of course that wouldn't make for such an exciting book.
Like with Perfectly Preventable Deaths, one of the key elements of Precious Catastrophe is the tension between Catholicism and Pagan beliefs. This feels so particular to Ireland that it's hard to imagine the book being set anywhere else, but in a remote, cut-off Galway village it has found the perfect setting. It's not just the tension though, these aren't necessarily competing beliefs facing off against each other, the parish priest against the witch. The true beauty and magic of this is found in where these belief systems intertwine, flow into each other, feed off each other. It's in the worshipping of ancient bog statues in the church, in saying prayers and not really knowing who is answering them, in their shared blood rituals and offerings. I absolutely loved how well this was handled, and it gave the book such a deep and mysterious darkness.
I loved how well it picked up elements of book one, without retracing old ground, telling a new and powerful story with a mixture of new and familiar parts. I loved the queer elements, and how sensitively they were handled, and I loved the little hints at the wider mysteries of this village. There's clearly so much more there to explore, and I really hope Deirdre Sullivan does that.
Powerful, dark, haunting and mysterious. Precious Catastrophe is YA horror at its finest.
Precious Catastrophe picks up right where book one ends, and it is pretty necessary to read the first one first. One reason I was thrilled at news of a sequel is that book one left quite a few open questions. What happened to Catlin and Maddy's dad? Did Brian have a part to play in everything that happened? We saw two figures at one point and it was never clear exactly who they were.
Precious Catastrophe goes a long way towards answering these questions. Not every mystery is cleared up, and I'm really hoping for a third book, but I definitely finished this one with fewer unresolved queries and doubts.
After the events of book one, Catlin is recovering from her abuse and murder at the hands of Lon, while Maddy is working for Mamo, learning how to be a witch. The point of view switches between the two sisters, as we see how they cope with their changes of circumstance and their changing relationship with each other. The growing tension between the twins, no longer living together, really drives a lot of the tension in the book. I felt like things would be so much simpler for them if they just worked together, though of course that wouldn't make for such an exciting book.
Like with Perfectly Preventable Deaths, one of the key elements of Precious Catastrophe is the tension between Catholicism and Pagan beliefs. This feels so particular to Ireland that it's hard to imagine the book being set anywhere else, but in a remote, cut-off Galway village it has found the perfect setting. It's not just the tension though, these aren't necessarily competing beliefs facing off against each other, the parish priest against the witch. The true beauty and magic of this is found in where these belief systems intertwine, flow into each other, feed off each other. It's in the worshipping of ancient bog statues in the church, in saying prayers and not really knowing who is answering them, in their shared blood rituals and offerings. I absolutely loved how well this was handled, and it gave the book such a deep and mysterious darkness.
I loved how well it picked up elements of book one, without retracing old ground, telling a new and powerful story with a mixture of new and familiar parts. I loved the queer elements, and how sensitively they were handled, and I loved the little hints at the wider mysteries of this village. There's clearly so much more there to explore, and I really hope Deirdre Sullivan does that.
Powerful, dark, haunting and mysterious. Precious Catastrophe is YA horror at its finest.
April 7, 2025
4.5 stars
I was so happy when i realized this was a series, i loved the first book and couldn’t let the characters go just yet. This was great too!
Okay so Maddy finally gets Oona at the end (yay!)
They kill Lon off completely, which, FINALLY, because i was sick of hearing about him and then having to deal with him all over again, that whole battle scene felt so drawn out i was honestly kinda getting bored unfortunately, but it was still epic nonetheless.
God how i love Mámo, i’ve read a review of the previous book that said that she was a villain and i was so confused because she clearly isn’t. She’s just a witch that doesn’t take shit from no one. I love her so much i wish i had my own Mámo.
Catlin irritated me to death, genuinely why doesn’t that girl just stay the fuck away from like everything and everyone for a bit, she always ends up getting herself nearly killed and gets mad at Maddy when her sister ends up being right as always…. I love her but god!
Brian was such a disappointment, i was genuinely sticking up for him the whole time until the very end. The fact that he killed their dad did it for me because what the fuck. Him BLENDING Lon into his smoothies was genuinely horrifying and funny at the same time because Lon kinda deserved that didn’t he?
Button owns my entire soul and i genuinely was sick when in the previous book Maddy tried to kill him, i honestly don’t think i would ever be able to hurt a kitten no matter what, even for my sister. I’m glad he’s slowly forgiving her and a huge thank you ti the author for letting us know he’s alive and well because until i heard about him i couldn’t focus on anything else that happened and how Catlin was saved since i just wanted to know they didn’t leave a hurt kitten roaming free in the forest.
There are a few remaining questions i have and i’m not sure whether we are getting another book, which i am sad about because i genuinely do adore this series.
When will Mámo be back in her body again? What will happen with Brian and stuff? Are the girls completely safe? Are they gonna get normal education?
Great book, the only reason it’s not 5 stars is because it felt like it dragged a little, which is okay, i still loved it.
I was so happy when i realized this was a series, i loved the first book and couldn’t let the characters go just yet. This was great too!
Okay so Maddy finally gets Oona at the end (yay!)
They kill Lon off completely, which, FINALLY, because i was sick of hearing about him and then having to deal with him all over again, that whole battle scene felt so drawn out i was honestly kinda getting bored unfortunately, but it was still epic nonetheless.
God how i love Mámo, i’ve read a review of the previous book that said that she was a villain and i was so confused because she clearly isn’t. She’s just a witch that doesn’t take shit from no one. I love her so much i wish i had my own Mámo.
Catlin irritated me to death, genuinely why doesn’t that girl just stay the fuck away from like everything and everyone for a bit, she always ends up getting herself nearly killed and gets mad at Maddy when her sister ends up being right as always…. I love her but god!
Brian was such a disappointment, i was genuinely sticking up for him the whole time until the very end. The fact that he killed their dad did it for me because what the fuck. Him BLENDING Lon into his smoothies was genuinely horrifying and funny at the same time because Lon kinda deserved that didn’t he?
Button owns my entire soul and i genuinely was sick when in the previous book Maddy tried to kill him, i honestly don’t think i would ever be able to hurt a kitten no matter what, even for my sister. I’m glad he’s slowly forgiving her and a huge thank you ti the author for letting us know he’s alive and well because until i heard about him i couldn’t focus on anything else that happened and how Catlin was saved since i just wanted to know they didn’t leave a hurt kitten roaming free in the forest.
There are a few remaining questions i have and i’m not sure whether we are getting another book, which i am sad about because i genuinely do adore this series.
When will Mámo be back in her body again? What will happen with Brian and stuff? Are the girls completely safe? Are they gonna get normal education?
Great book, the only reason it’s not 5 stars is because it felt like it dragged a little, which is okay, i still loved it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 20, 2021
This review is going to have me taking in a Cork accent, like.
What a ride. Like, I keep saying it about Deirdre's books, but they are SO. BEAUTIFUL.
I've actually had fairly scary nightmares over the two nights I've been re/reading this series, but the beauty is undeniable. So is the love. I LOOOOOOVE how ordinary and true the girls are in the story, how the family is there for each other through it all. I even loved learning all the herb lore.
Mamó is also one of the clearest, sharpest characters I've ever read about. If I haven't seen a picture/movie poster, sometimes characters can be fuzzy for me. But Mamó .... Like, even her wrinkles are sharp and consistent. I assume it's the magic.
A note also about the YA *issues* and themes in this story: they are there, but for once, they flow as part of the story. They are real and organic. They're not like certain bigass series that just BASH YOU OVER THE HEAD WITH HOW DIVERSE THEY ARE, LOOK AT MY KEYWORDS AND HASHTAGS AND FANSERVICE. If there are more Ballyfrann books, I want them, but if there aren't, can we please please please have an Oona or a Collinses spin-off?!?!
A beautiful, beautiful story. Perfect for this time of year, for this place on earth and for those little shivers up your spine.
What a ride. Like, I keep saying it about Deirdre's books, but they are SO. BEAUTIFUL.
I've actually had fairly scary nightmares over the two nights I've been re/reading this series, but the beauty is undeniable. So is the love. I LOOOOOOVE how ordinary and true the girls are in the story, how the family is there for each other through it all. I even loved learning all the herb lore.
Mamó is also one of the clearest, sharpest characters I've ever read about. If I haven't seen a picture/movie poster, sometimes characters can be fuzzy for me. But Mamó .... Like, even her wrinkles are sharp and consistent. I assume it's the magic.
A note also about the YA *issues* and themes in this story: they are there, but for once, they flow as part of the story. They are real and organic. They're not like certain bigass series that just BASH YOU OVER THE HEAD WITH HOW DIVERSE THEY ARE, LOOK AT MY KEYWORDS AND HASHTAGS AND FANSERVICE. If there are more Ballyfrann books, I want them, but if there aren't, can we please please please have an Oona or a Collinses spin-off?!?!
A beautiful, beautiful story. Perfect for this time of year, for this place on earth and for those little shivers up your spine.
November 1, 2021
I was so excited to receive and read this review copy as I was absolutely OBSESSED with the first of the series, Perfectly Preventable Deaths. Don't make the same mistake I did though, and make sure to reread the first if you're in need of a refresher! I had forgotten a lot of loose ends and plot points but not only that, I had forgotten the general tone of the novel - humorous and gory and magical.
There were times when I felt a bit jolted by the tone of the novel, especially when it came to the big villain reveal and everyone's reaction to it. I also thought the action got a bit confusing and difficult to visualize with the switching narrators. Hopefully this is tightened in the final print copy.
Unlike the first novel, Precious Catastrophe alternates perspectives between those of Madeline and Catlin. This was such a refreshing change, as the two twins are polar opposites. Sitting into each other's voices helped pace the novel while also keeping the reader intrigued - who is really right and what is really the truth?
A very interesting and mesmerisingly written novel as always from Deirdre Sullivan. While I didn't love this one as much as the first, which I hold very dear to my heart, I still want more Ballyfrann in my life. I wonder will there be a third???
There were times when I felt a bit jolted by the tone of the novel, especially when it came to the big villain reveal and everyone's reaction to it. I also thought the action got a bit confusing and difficult to visualize with the switching narrators. Hopefully this is tightened in the final print copy.
Unlike the first novel, Precious Catastrophe alternates perspectives between those of Madeline and Catlin. This was such a refreshing change, as the two twins are polar opposites. Sitting into each other's voices helped pace the novel while also keeping the reader intrigued - who is really right and what is really the truth?
A very interesting and mesmerisingly written novel as always from Deirdre Sullivan. While I didn't love this one as much as the first, which I hold very dear to my heart, I still want more Ballyfrann in my life. I wonder will there be a third???
October 8, 2021
I have to say it again...no one, absolutely no one writes magical, ominous YA like Deirdre Sullivan. The lyrical, soothing prose powerfully expresses the hearts and minds of the protagonists is a way the makes the reader part of the thoughts, emotions and actions, as you melt into the eerie landscape and strange people. It is inescapable. The bond of sisterhood, the fault lines that have appeared between them given recent events, the sheer horror of previous circumstances and the constant longing and desire for reparation; for finding that closeness again is palpable; as is the determination to find their own footing. The magic; the witchcraft in this book is complex, woven naturally into life and demands that there be sacrifice, but also responsibility, respect. Your fate, and the fate of those around is profoundly effected by your actions. No simple wand-waving here. The demand is that the authority and burden must be owned. The darkness of the tale is broken by typical teenage banter and action, giving a welcome relief and enters the storyline with pitch-perfect placement; with just the right timing at just the right moment. But the stuff of nightmares is never too far behind. And it comes from some the most surprising places. In returning to the gothic, fictional Ballyfrann to be pulled into those paths and tunnels in and around brought all the eerie pleasure and fright back again. The power and possibilities of magic workings highlight the deep, intimate soul within the pages. Once again,I was lost in this book...and no doubt will be again. Expressive, bone-chilling, exquisite, revealing, compelling....utterly beautiful. (And also perfect reading for the spooky season!) Can we go again please, Deirdre?
September 27, 2022
Die gelungene Fortsetzung zu »Perfectly Preventable Deaths«, in der Maddy ihre Ausbildung als Hexe beginnt und Catlin erneut Opfer einer mysteriösen Macht aus Ballyfran wird. Anders als in Band eins wird hier abwechselnd aus der Sicht beider Schwestern geschildert, was sich erneut mega flüssig und süchtig machend liest. Außerdem lernt man Catlin dadurch noch besser kennen, was ein zusätzlicher Pluspunkt ist. Generell sind die Charaktere aber weiterhin sympathisch und interessant und auch die Lovestory bekommt im Hintergrund ihren Platz. Aber auch vom Plot her hat sich einiges verbessert; es kommt definitiv mehr Spannung auf als im ersten Band und der Schleier um die Geheimnisse der Kleinstadt, sowie um den Tod des Vaters der Zwillinge lüftet sich immer mehr. Zwar wird es dann im letzten Drittel wieder ruhiger, aber ich hoffe sehr auf noch eine Fortsetzung, damit das Potenzial der Reihe noch voll ausgeschöpft werden kann. Insgesamt also lohnt sich das Buch definitiv, wenn man Band eins mochte, und hat sich dazu noch gesteigert.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews