What do you think?
Rate this book
9th Street Women: Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell and Helen Frankenthaler: Five Painters and the Movement That Changed Modern Art
Detailed stories about the art, lives, loves, friendships, partnerships, struggles, sacrifices and successes of women artists , including those who exhibited in the famous 9th Street Annual Painting and Sculpture Show in 1951-1957. The book includes stories about the different times that confronted artists while they were studying and training - such as World War II, poverty, alcoholism, personal conflicts and lack of support from the art world. As Expressionism gained more status, the role of women become more appreciated, even if some of them were less known than others. Some of these artists are still shown in major galleries and museums.
945 pages, audiobook and kindle
First published September 25, 2018
About the author
Mary Gabriel
25 books160 followersMary Gabriel was educated in the United States and France, and worked in Washington and London as a Reuters editor for nearly two decades. She is the author of two previous biographies: Notorious Victoria: The Life of Victoria Woodhull, Uncensored, and The Art of Acquiring: A Portrait of Etta and Claribel Cone. She lives in Italy.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 521 reviews
December 2, 2018
”All artists succumb to self-doubt; it is the handmaiden of creation. For a woman, however, whether in Virginia Woolf’s early twentieth-century England or Joan Mitchell’s 1950’s New York, that doubt would have been the result of forces both creative and social. Of the latter, Woolf wrote,
’The indifference of the world which Keats and Flaubert and other men of genius have found so hard to bear was in her case not indifference but hostility. The world did not say to her as it said to them, Write if you choose; it makes no difference to me. The world said with a guffaw, Write? What’s the good of your writing?’
Many decades later, Joan would put her own salty spin on the same sentiment.
’How did I feel, like how? I felt, you know, when I was discouraged I wondered if really women couldn’t paint, the way all the men said they couldn’t paint. But then at other times I said, ‘Fuck them’, you know.’
Joan Mitchell in studio.
Mary Gabriel has written a biography of five amazingly talented women: Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell, and Helen Frankenthaler. However, his book is so much more than just the lives of these women. The influence of world events on people, especially creative people, can not be separated from the accomplishments of those who painted, wrote, and composed, who were attempting to make sense of these events with their brushstrokes, words, and music.
Picasso is debatably the most famous and most influential painter of all time. His painting of Guernica is without question one of the most important paintings of all time. He brought painting forward to a different place, and in my mind, the Abstract Expressionist painters spent their lives chasing after Picasso. In the process, they broke every rule, destroyed every boundary, and remade art in their image.
We call a male artist a painter without even thinking about it. We still call female artist ‘women painters.’ By the end of this book, the five women will convince you that women deserve to be called painters without designation of their sex.
Trojan Gates by Helen Frankenthaler. I love this painting!
Now the men are here, as well. In fact, two of the five women married the two most famous men of the New York Abstract Expressionist movement. Lee Krasner married Jackson Pollock and spent the rest of his life trying to keep the man alive. She always felt like she had a ”comet by the tail.” Pollock blew everything up in the art world, but in the process he destroyed his own life and adversely affected the lives of those who cared about him. Helen Frankenthaler summed up his influence on other painters. ”Soaking it all in, Helen realized something she had not understood when merely viewing Jackson’s work on a gallery wall. Pollock didn’t paint with his hands or wrists or even his arms, he painted with his whole body. Helen saw the potential for her own work in his method. She, too, wanted to engage her entire person in her paintings, not merely the delicate extreminites that held a brush. She did not want to paint on a canvas, she wanted to paint in it.”
Elaine married Willem (Bill) de Kooning, and as much as Lee struggled to find her artistic place with Pollock, Elaine had similar struggles with her relationship with de Kooning. Their marriage was beset with infidelity, artistic jealousy, and poverty. Most of the painters struggled to feed and shelter themselves and frequently had to find jobs that took them away from their canvases. Elaine wrote art reviews for magazines to allow Bill the freedom to keep searching for his voice, his expression in the strokes of his brush. Her writing helped define the Abstract Expressionist movement. ”’Whenever Hollywood does a movie on artists they don’t know how to deal with what drives an artist,’ Elaine said. ‘They always think an artist works toward fame. They can’t imagine the thrill of the actual work, it doesn’t occur to them. That, they feel is just on the side, and fame is the aim. Whereas it’s exactly the opposite. {Work} is the aim, and fame is a byproduct.’”
Elaine de Kooning went through a period when she was painting men, a reverse of the concept of women as muses. Why can’t men be muses as well? I absolutely love her portraits and would have loved to have seen how she would have painting me.
Gabriel covers the evolution of this art movement from the late 1920s to the early 1960s. Prohibition, the swinging 1930s, the emergence of Jazz, WW2 when the intellectuals of Europe were forced out of their countries to find a home in New York, and McCarthyism all had influence on the minds and actions of the artists. Amongst so much turmoil, is it any wonder that art needed to find new ways to express the torment?
”The world about us would be desolate except for the world within us.”
-----Wallace Stevens
Grace Hartigan’s Persian Jacket. Awesome!
Grace Hartigan was in love with the poet Frank O’Hara, and he with her. ”If a homosexual and a heterosexual could be in love, it was falling in love.” His poems influenced her art, but I felt that her painting may have influenced his poetry even more. Those who chose to love Grace or Frank had to understand that their relationship with the artist or poet was never going to eclipse what Grace and Frank felt for one another. I found their relationship exceedingly intriguing because so much of the definition of a relationship is defined by having sex. They were closer than siblings. Closer than lovers. They were frequently confused by the boundaries of their odd relationship and tempted to consummate it in the normal fashion, but the fear of destroying the precious, fragile bonds of what they had together always kept them from provoking fate.
Jackson Pollock was the first celebrity artist of the movement. Lee Krasner worked tirelessly to promote his art. She wasn’t just doing it for Pollock. She knew that women abstract expressionists had no chance to ever be recognized if the men were not recognized first. She put aside her own art for long periods of time to champion Pollock. Her other, on going concern with the “comet” was keeping him alive. His epic drinking was a constant threat to his health and his legacy. She was successful at least in preserving his legacy, but I can’t help wondering if the cost to her art was too large a price to pay.
Lee Krasner, Untitled 1948. The more I look into this painting it becomes a maze for my mind.
I read this book every morning with a hot cup of Earl Grey, steaming in my hand. It was such an inspirational way to start the day by reading about the trials and tribulations of these five women as they forged a place for themselves in a profession that deigned to recognize the importance of their work. They persevered because they had no choice. The same fire that drove Pollock and de Kooning to create their masterpieces was an eternal flame in their bellies as well. They painted until the final veil descended.
Mary Gabriel was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for her book Love and Capital, and I wouldn’t be surprised if she finds herself back on that list with this book. I knew the names of these five women before starting to read this book, but their work was unknown to me. If I have seen their art, it was without truly seeing it. With all these new reference points and now knowing their place in history, I can look upon their art with eyes properly focused to see beyond just color and composition, but with reverence for how that piece of art was created and the battle it took for that artwork to even be hung on the wall of any museum.
This is without a doubt the most influential and enjoyable read of the year for me.
I want to thank Little, Brown, and Company for sending me a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit http://www.jeffreykeeten.com
I also have a Facebook blogger page at: https://www.facebook.com/JeffreyKeeten
’The indifference of the world which Keats and Flaubert and other men of genius have found so hard to bear was in her case not indifference but hostility. The world did not say to her as it said to them, Write if you choose; it makes no difference to me. The world said with a guffaw, Write? What’s the good of your writing?’
Many decades later, Joan would put her own salty spin on the same sentiment.
’How did I feel, like how? I felt, you know, when I was discouraged I wondered if really women couldn’t paint, the way all the men said they couldn’t paint. But then at other times I said, ‘Fuck them’, you know.’
Joan Mitchell in studio.
Mary Gabriel has written a biography of five amazingly talented women: Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell, and Helen Frankenthaler. However, his book is so much more than just the lives of these women. The influence of world events on people, especially creative people, can not be separated from the accomplishments of those who painted, wrote, and composed, who were attempting to make sense of these events with their brushstrokes, words, and music.
Picasso is debatably the most famous and most influential painter of all time. His painting of Guernica is without question one of the most important paintings of all time. He brought painting forward to a different place, and in my mind, the Abstract Expressionist painters spent their lives chasing after Picasso. In the process, they broke every rule, destroyed every boundary, and remade art in their image.
We call a male artist a painter without even thinking about it. We still call female artist ‘women painters.’ By the end of this book, the five women will convince you that women deserve to be called painters without designation of their sex.
Trojan Gates by Helen Frankenthaler. I love this painting!
Now the men are here, as well. In fact, two of the five women married the two most famous men of the New York Abstract Expressionist movement. Lee Krasner married Jackson Pollock and spent the rest of his life trying to keep the man alive. She always felt like she had a ”comet by the tail.” Pollock blew everything up in the art world, but in the process he destroyed his own life and adversely affected the lives of those who cared about him. Helen Frankenthaler summed up his influence on other painters. ”Soaking it all in, Helen realized something she had not understood when merely viewing Jackson’s work on a gallery wall. Pollock didn’t paint with his hands or wrists or even his arms, he painted with his whole body. Helen saw the potential for her own work in his method. She, too, wanted to engage her entire person in her paintings, not merely the delicate extreminites that held a brush. She did not want to paint on a canvas, she wanted to paint in it.”
Elaine married Willem (Bill) de Kooning, and as much as Lee struggled to find her artistic place with Pollock, Elaine had similar struggles with her relationship with de Kooning. Their marriage was beset with infidelity, artistic jealousy, and poverty. Most of the painters struggled to feed and shelter themselves and frequently had to find jobs that took them away from their canvases. Elaine wrote art reviews for magazines to allow Bill the freedom to keep searching for his voice, his expression in the strokes of his brush. Her writing helped define the Abstract Expressionist movement. ”’Whenever Hollywood does a movie on artists they don’t know how to deal with what drives an artist,’ Elaine said. ‘They always think an artist works toward fame. They can’t imagine the thrill of the actual work, it doesn’t occur to them. That, they feel is just on the side, and fame is the aim. Whereas it’s exactly the opposite. {Work} is the aim, and fame is a byproduct.’”
Elaine de Kooning went through a period when she was painting men, a reverse of the concept of women as muses. Why can’t men be muses as well? I absolutely love her portraits and would have loved to have seen how she would have painting me.
Gabriel covers the evolution of this art movement from the late 1920s to the early 1960s. Prohibition, the swinging 1930s, the emergence of Jazz, WW2 when the intellectuals of Europe were forced out of their countries to find a home in New York, and McCarthyism all had influence on the minds and actions of the artists. Amongst so much turmoil, is it any wonder that art needed to find new ways to express the torment?
”The world about us would be desolate except for the world within us.”
-----Wallace Stevens
Grace Hartigan’s Persian Jacket. Awesome!
Grace Hartigan was in love with the poet Frank O’Hara, and he with her. ”If a homosexual and a heterosexual could be in love, it was falling in love.” His poems influenced her art, but I felt that her painting may have influenced his poetry even more. Those who chose to love Grace or Frank had to understand that their relationship with the artist or poet was never going to eclipse what Grace and Frank felt for one another. I found their relationship exceedingly intriguing because so much of the definition of a relationship is defined by having sex. They were closer than siblings. Closer than lovers. They were frequently confused by the boundaries of their odd relationship and tempted to consummate it in the normal fashion, but the fear of destroying the precious, fragile bonds of what they had together always kept them from provoking fate.
Jackson Pollock was the first celebrity artist of the movement. Lee Krasner worked tirelessly to promote his art. She wasn’t just doing it for Pollock. She knew that women abstract expressionists had no chance to ever be recognized if the men were not recognized first. She put aside her own art for long periods of time to champion Pollock. Her other, on going concern with the “comet” was keeping him alive. His epic drinking was a constant threat to his health and his legacy. She was successful at least in preserving his legacy, but I can’t help wondering if the cost to her art was too large a price to pay.
Lee Krasner, Untitled 1948. The more I look into this painting it becomes a maze for my mind.
I read this book every morning with a hot cup of Earl Grey, steaming in my hand. It was such an inspirational way to start the day by reading about the trials and tribulations of these five women as they forged a place for themselves in a profession that deigned to recognize the importance of their work. They persevered because they had no choice. The same fire that drove Pollock and de Kooning to create their masterpieces was an eternal flame in their bellies as well. They painted until the final veil descended.
Mary Gabriel was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for her book Love and Capital, and I wouldn’t be surprised if she finds herself back on that list with this book. I knew the names of these five women before starting to read this book, but their work was unknown to me. If I have seen their art, it was without truly seeing it. With all these new reference points and now knowing their place in history, I can look upon their art with eyes properly focused to see beyond just color and composition, but with reverence for how that piece of art was created and the battle it took for that artwork to even be hung on the wall of any museum.
This is without a doubt the most influential and enjoyable read of the year for me.
I want to thank Little, Brown, and Company for sending me a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit http://www.jeffreykeeten.com
I also have a Facebook blogger page at: https://www.facebook.com/JeffreyKeeten
July 30, 2018
More than just a fabulous five-way biography of five extraordinary artists, this is also the biography of a place and time and an art movement, a way of life, and a community. Mary Gabriel has fleshed out the story of the artists of the New York School, centering on their heyday during the 40s and 50s, but giving the necessary background material of their Depression-era development.
If this sounds dry and academic, it’s not. The world of the Ninth Street Women and their colleagues, friends and lovers was vibrant, dangerous, and exciting, and this book gives us the closest thing possible to a first-hand view. Mary Gabriel is sensitive to the fact that they did not live in a vacuum, but very much within a diverse and tumultuous community, one composed of complicated and ever-evolving men and women. Living amongst each other in a kind of near-incestuous intimacy, everyone within that community influenced and was influenced by each other. Yet despite their invaluable and interwoven contributions to American Art, the primary subjects of this book were virtually written out of history - mostly by virtue of being ignored and not written into Art History in the immediate decades after their flourishing - as a result mainly of systemic sexism, but perhaps also jealousy and pique on the part of at least one prominent ex-lover art critic.
Thanks to painstaking scholarship and the dedicated preservation of primary materials - interviews and letters and conversations by and with family and friends - Mary Gabriel has brilliantly succeeded, not just in piecing together the necessary and extraordinary lives of Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell and Helen Frankenthaler. She has reset them in their proper context within the turbulent and fertile development and flowering of the Abstract Expressionist movement and the New York School, and she has restored them to their proper place in the firmament of American Art History.
If this sounds dry and academic, it’s not. The world of the Ninth Street Women and their colleagues, friends and lovers was vibrant, dangerous, and exciting, and this book gives us the closest thing possible to a first-hand view. Mary Gabriel is sensitive to the fact that they did not live in a vacuum, but very much within a diverse and tumultuous community, one composed of complicated and ever-evolving men and women. Living amongst each other in a kind of near-incestuous intimacy, everyone within that community influenced and was influenced by each other. Yet despite their invaluable and interwoven contributions to American Art, the primary subjects of this book were virtually written out of history - mostly by virtue of being ignored and not written into Art History in the immediate decades after their flourishing - as a result mainly of systemic sexism, but perhaps also jealousy and pique on the part of at least one prominent ex-lover art critic.
Thanks to painstaking scholarship and the dedicated preservation of primary materials - interviews and letters and conversations by and with family and friends - Mary Gabriel has brilliantly succeeded, not just in piecing together the necessary and extraordinary lives of Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell and Helen Frankenthaler. She has reset them in their proper context within the turbulent and fertile development and flowering of the Abstract Expressionist movement and the New York School, and she has restored them to their proper place in the firmament of American Art History.
October 15, 2019
This book chronicles the wildest and strongest years of these five amazing and history-changing women - as they challenge what it means to be an artist.
"Lee had charted an alternate course in a world that told her a woman's duty was to submit to her family."
Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell and Helen Frankenthaler all lived through a time where women were expected to sit down and shut up...but they were not going to take that.
While I'm a bit far-removed from the art world, I did enjoy reading this one.
"Siren, saint, creative tempest, athlete, intellect, she could seemingly do anything better than anyone."
This had an incredibly thorough and in-depth look at these women's lives and how their art developed. It didn't shy away from the difficult or depressing moments and it highlighted their achievements with infectious glee.
If you are looking at the complete history of these women, this book is likely the one for you! Clocking in at 700+ pages of content (with a few sections of pictures), this book truly is a labor of love (heck, the sources alone took 100+ pages).
With thanks to Little, Brown and Co. and Mary Gabriel for sending me a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
YouTube | Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | Snapchat @miranda_reads
December 20, 2018
NetGalley ARC.
I think I've been dreaming of this book since college.
As a former Art History Major, I feel like I have to defend Abstract Expressionism, one of my favorite periods. While the paintings of Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Mitchell and Frankenthaler, as well as their male compatriots, may seem simple, they are deceptively complex. No, you could not have painted this Jackson Pollock, and even if you could, you didn't, he did.
While the book focuses on these amazing female artists, it is a great depiction of the emergence of America as the leader in contemporary art. The New Deal saw an increase in government sponsored art projects, mostly murals and then later, war propaganda. These projects allowed artists to make a living from their art. In addition, many famous artists and art dealers were forced to flee from Europe at the beginning of the Nazi Occupation. All of these influences converged to create a flourishing art world in NYC.
While this world was more egalitarian than the old European world, women were often shunted to the side. This book goes into why the talented artists Lee Krasner and Elaine de Kooning largely gave up their careers to help their more famous husbands. It was interesting to learn that Krasner's career burned very bright before meeting Pollock, and she was considered the more well known artist at the beginning of the relationship.
While this is a very long book, Mary Gabriel keeps it interesting, peppering the narrative with quotes from the subject's contemporaries. This is a subject that really deserves the in-depth look that Gabriel achieves.
I think I've been dreaming of this book since college.
As a former Art History Major, I feel like I have to defend Abstract Expressionism, one of my favorite periods. While the paintings of Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Mitchell and Frankenthaler, as well as their male compatriots, may seem simple, they are deceptively complex. No, you could not have painted this Jackson Pollock, and even if you could, you didn't, he did.
While the book focuses on these amazing female artists, it is a great depiction of the emergence of America as the leader in contemporary art. The New Deal saw an increase in government sponsored art projects, mostly murals and then later, war propaganda. These projects allowed artists to make a living from their art. In addition, many famous artists and art dealers were forced to flee from Europe at the beginning of the Nazi Occupation. All of these influences converged to create a flourishing art world in NYC.
While this world was more egalitarian than the old European world, women were often shunted to the side. This book goes into why the talented artists Lee Krasner and Elaine de Kooning largely gave up their careers to help their more famous husbands. It was interesting to learn that Krasner's career burned very bright before meeting Pollock, and she was considered the more well known artist at the beginning of the relationship.
While this is a very long book, Mary Gabriel keeps it interesting, peppering the narrative with quotes from the subject's contemporaries. This is a subject that really deserves the in-depth look that Gabriel achieves.
April 6, 2019
DNF. I read up to chapter 26 (of 42) and then skipped ahead to the epilogue. I picked this up from a podcast rec and did not expect it to be 950(!) pages long. I've noticed the absence of female artists in discussions about art and art history, so a part of me really wanted this book to succeed. Unfortunately, I found it unnecessarily detailed (perhaps a little unrealistically so, for a second-hand biography) and the connections tenuous.
I think this book would have been better served just focusing on Lee Krasner. While the cover details the "five" painters the book follows, I don't think I was introduced to Helen Frankenthaler until about chapter 20 or so? It became hard at that point to engage with these new artists being introduced when I've essentially only been following Krasner (and Elaine de Kooning, to a lesser extent) for 300 pages. I genuinely forgot this book was about five women! This was mainly a structuring issue. Another confusing structural point was following Krasner through her early years, the war, then the post-war art scene, only to have to do it all again for Kooning and the others. It would have made more sense to keep the book entirely chronological and introduce the different artists earlier. -- But, again, the issue is the lives of these women don't entirely overlap. Krasner was about 20 years older than the others, and their times of death ranged from the 1980s to the 2010s. Perhaps a stronger structure would have focused just on the period when all were active at the same time (i.e. disregard the earlier and later time frames). But I have this feeling the author, Mary Gabriel, did a lot of research on the lives of these artists and then felt too close to her subject matter to edit down her research into a clear and compelling narrative. Gabriel worked hard for her knowledge and it felt like she treated her research too preciously to disregard anything. While I understand the feeling, it doesn't always make for great writing.
You know what? This feels like someone's PhD thesis turned into a book rather than something that was designed with a wider audience in mind as a first priority. The writing is readable and I think it is important to learn about these artists, but ultimately this book could have been edited down significantly and it suffers from structural issues.
I think this book would have been better served just focusing on Lee Krasner. While the cover details the "five" painters the book follows, I don't think I was introduced to Helen Frankenthaler until about chapter 20 or so? It became hard at that point to engage with these new artists being introduced when I've essentially only been following Krasner (and Elaine de Kooning, to a lesser extent) for 300 pages. I genuinely forgot this book was about five women! This was mainly a structuring issue. Another confusing structural point was following Krasner through her early years, the war, then the post-war art scene, only to have to do it all again for Kooning and the others. It would have made more sense to keep the book entirely chronological and introduce the different artists earlier. -- But, again, the issue is the lives of these women don't entirely overlap. Krasner was about 20 years older than the others, and their times of death ranged from the 1980s to the 2010s. Perhaps a stronger structure would have focused just on the period when all were active at the same time (i.e. disregard the earlier and later time frames). But I have this feeling the author, Mary Gabriel, did a lot of research on the lives of these artists and then felt too close to her subject matter to edit down her research into a clear and compelling narrative. Gabriel worked hard for her knowledge and it felt like she treated her research too preciously to disregard anything. While I understand the feeling, it doesn't always make for great writing.
You know what? This feels like someone's PhD thesis turned into a book rather than something that was designed with a wider audience in mind as a first priority. The writing is readable and I think it is important to learn about these artists, but ultimately this book could have been edited down significantly and it suffers from structural issues.
July 8, 2019
This book either needed a different name or very heavy editing. Calling it a book about five women is a joke. Half of the book is about Jackson Pollack and his circle of influence on the art community. I understand he was largely responsible for these women's art direction but to include a full biography of his life was unnecessary. This book completely encompasses the art movement of abstract expressionism, but doesn't stop there; it also includes many writers lives as well. It's not a bad book just poorly named and a little over zealous in content. It would have been much better to narrow the subject matter down. Mentioning a person as involved in someones life doesnt mean you need to include every known detail about that person. Overall I felt much of what I read in this book, while interesting, could have been cut out.
January 7, 2023
Fascinating--full of information, about art, artists, the context of the times in which these artists worked, biography: so full and dense, in fact, that it took me a very long time to finish this but I never lost interest.
May 4, 2020
This is more of a social history of abstract expressionism with 5 female artists as touch points than an art historical or critical work. There's sort of a curious selection of detail from skipping over John Cage and Merce Cunningham's relationship (they were ... friends) and pages about peripheral characters or incidents (Dylan Thomas' death and funeral at the White Horse tavern.) I wonder if the original intent of the book was to share the anecdotes that dot the pages told as if the author knew 'Morty Feldman' and 'Bob Rauschenberg'. There's little to no detail about what inspired the artists or affected their work (Joan Mitchell being raped visiting a psychiatric hospital is almost a foot note.) I had to put the book down for periods as I grew more irritated with the author's ending chapters with cliffhangers (And Bill's behavior was bringing Elaine to make a change...) that never resolves (Elaine would be revisited near to the end of the chapter and no mention of the change or stasis.)
I think the book would have been better if it had focused on each author as a section with a longer introductory section placing them in context. And with fewer remarks about their beauty, figures, and breasts (or lack there of when it came to Krasner.)
I think the book would have been better if it had focused on each author as a section with a longer introductory section placing them in context. And with fewer remarks about their beauty, figures, and breasts (or lack there of when it came to Krasner.)
April 24, 2022
I loved this group biography so much. The five artists are fascinating and the way Gabriel weaves their stories together is masterful. I particularly relished the discussion of how each woman broke through to paint in new ways.
September 11, 2018
Gabriel expertly merges historical context with artistic knowledge, making for an easy read, albeit a long one. It is a length that the reader doesn’t notice much, because they are having so much fun. Why worry about the length of a chapter when you’re following along the adventures of Grace Hartigan and Frank O’Hara? Gabriel creates a vision of these women that is stunning, and not always flattering. These are imperfect women and dedicated artists, all at once. Each chapter is a portrait of an artist and a women, existing all at once and sometimes in contradiction. Each woman's story is their own, and leaves a distinct understanding of the artist in its’ wake. In considering Elaine de Kooning:
“Elaine believed in freedom. Freedom of gesture, risk in everything she touched. She showed me that abandon long practiced becomes skill.”
For lovers of abstract art, both in the beginning of their art appreciation or experts of the movement. The journeys of Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Helen Frankenthaler, Joan Mitchell, and Grace Hartigan provide a fresh lens with which to experience abstract expressionism in the fifties and sixties.
Review copy provided by Little, Brown and Company in exchange for an honest review.
“Elaine believed in freedom. Freedom of gesture, risk in everything she touched. She showed me that abandon long practiced becomes skill.”
For lovers of abstract art, both in the beginning of their art appreciation or experts of the movement. The journeys of Lee Krasner, Elaine de Kooning, Helen Frankenthaler, Joan Mitchell, and Grace Hartigan provide a fresh lens with which to experience abstract expressionism in the fifties and sixties.
Review copy provided by Little, Brown and Company in exchange for an honest review.
January 23, 2019
This was the best art history / biography I’ve ever read. The book gives a great overall view of the development of abstract expressionism in the 1940s-50s with a focus on 5 courageous and talented women painters who helped define the genre. Two of them — Lee Krasner and Elaine DeKoonig — married famous men —Jackson Pollock and Bill DeKoonig. Despite their talents they were often regarded as secondary to their spouses. In fact they definitely helped the husbands overcome a lot of issues — Lee kept Pollock sober for years. But these two women along with Joan Mitchell, Grace Harriman and Helen Frankenthaler were fantastic artists. Both Hartigan and Frankenthaler were early successes getting solo shows and being included in shows with the men.
The author Mary Gabriel does a fabulous job weaving these individual stories and describing the New York scene where they interacted with other artists, like Larry Rivers, Robert Motherwell, Hans Hoffman and writers like Frank o’Hara, Kenneth Koch, Clement Greenberg, gallery and museum directors — Alfred Barr, Betty Parsons, Eleanor Miller and so many more.
The book is long —722 pages—but riveting. I didn’t want to put it down except when I traveled outside the country for 10 days, it was as too heavy to carry. As soon as I returned, I was back into the world of the ‘40s and ‘50s — the artistic scene is the East Village, their studios and the bars at the Five Spot and Cedar Bar where the artists meet to talk l about their work. There are multiple relationships many often dysfunctional but deeply human. Most are very poor but all share the passion, the drive, the compulsion to paint; they can’t not paint.
These four women — my heroes — were courageous; they bucked the cultural norms and followed their instincts and changed the face of art forever.
Best book I’ve read in years.
The author Mary Gabriel does a fabulous job weaving these individual stories and describing the New York scene where they interacted with other artists, like Larry Rivers, Robert Motherwell, Hans Hoffman and writers like Frank o’Hara, Kenneth Koch, Clement Greenberg, gallery and museum directors — Alfred Barr, Betty Parsons, Eleanor Miller and so many more.
The book is long —722 pages—but riveting. I didn’t want to put it down except when I traveled outside the country for 10 days, it was as too heavy to carry. As soon as I returned, I was back into the world of the ‘40s and ‘50s — the artistic scene is the East Village, their studios and the bars at the Five Spot and Cedar Bar where the artists meet to talk l about their work. There are multiple relationships many often dysfunctional but deeply human. Most are very poor but all share the passion, the drive, the compulsion to paint; they can’t not paint.
These four women — my heroes — were courageous; they bucked the cultural norms and followed their instincts and changed the face of art forever.
Best book I’ve read in years.
January 17, 2020
Clocking in at 722 pages, I feel like I’ve just done the literary equivalent of running a marathon. Or at least weightlifting! I was really excited for this, excited to learn more about these modern women painters who were largely erased from the discussion of American art and are now making it back in. And there was a lot here to absorb. Lots of sources. Transcripts and tapes of interviews with the artists before their passing. Insights from surviving family and friends. Letters, articles, books. It’s almost overwhelming.
The book frequently feels very gossipy - a lot of ink is spilled over lovers and husbands and drunken behaviour—the presentation of “the scene”—and all presented with a sort of romantic bohemian patina that just felt a bit odd to me, lacking as it was in any critical exploration. There is a bit too much of the “genius excuses all” kind of thinking on display with multiple stories of partner and spousal abuse sort of matter-of-factly shrugged off. The work is the work, but Pollock and de Kooning were assholes.
I didn’t come for this drama. I came for the art history. I felt a bit let down by the lack of politics (small and large P) here. There wasn’t a lot of analysis in this text. It seems mostly dismissive of the pretty substantial class difference between Mitchell and Frankenthaler and Krasner, de Kooning and Hartigan. And not being an expert on abstract expressionism, was it really as apolitical as all this? All this flouting of convention and tradition didn’t track?
All that said, I’m still intrigued by Lee, Elaine, Grace, Joan and Helen. I wish there had been a few more images of their works included. But hopefully I can track some down on my next visit to NYC.
The book frequently feels very gossipy - a lot of ink is spilled over lovers and husbands and drunken behaviour—the presentation of “the scene”—and all presented with a sort of romantic bohemian patina that just felt a bit odd to me, lacking as it was in any critical exploration. There is a bit too much of the “genius excuses all” kind of thinking on display with multiple stories of partner and spousal abuse sort of matter-of-factly shrugged off. The work is the work, but Pollock and de Kooning were assholes.
I didn’t come for this drama. I came for the art history. I felt a bit let down by the lack of politics (small and large P) here. There wasn’t a lot of analysis in this text. It seems mostly dismissive of the pretty substantial class difference between Mitchell and Frankenthaler and Krasner, de Kooning and Hartigan. And not being an expert on abstract expressionism, was it really as apolitical as all this? All this flouting of convention and tradition didn’t track?
All that said, I’m still intrigued by Lee, Elaine, Grace, Joan and Helen. I wish there had been a few more images of their works included. But hopefully I can track some down on my next visit to NYC.
March 22, 2020
Wow wow wow! A thrilling, illuminating, and fascinating romp through the NYC art world from 1928-1959. This is a BIG book with broad scope; kudos to Gabriel for maintaining momentum throughout. I practically devoured the epilogue.
Before reading the book, I knew some info about Helen Frankenthaler -- but almost nothing about Lee, Elaine, Grace, and Joan. Now I am going to dive into each of their oeuvres! Not to mention the other male and female painters and poets surrounding them. What a time it was...
Before reading the book, I knew some info about Helen Frankenthaler -- but almost nothing about Lee, Elaine, Grace, and Joan. Now I am going to dive into each of their oeuvres! Not to mention the other male and female painters and poets surrounding them. What a time it was...
February 17, 2019
Fabulous!
This book is dense with vivid details, and expertly crafted weaving through each of the woman artist’s life and the lives of the people influential in the art world . This is one of those books I wish I have time to review if I didn’t have an intense day job. I hope it wins some sort of an award or recognition.
Memorable and going in my favorites.
This book is dense with vivid details, and expertly crafted weaving through each of the woman artist’s life and the lives of the people influential in the art world . This is one of those books I wish I have time to review if I didn’t have an intense day job. I hope it wins some sort of an award or recognition.
Memorable and going in my favorites.
September 12, 2019
I did enjoy this, but I found the structure of each woman’s story (versus telling the story chronologically and how each woman fit in) too repetitive and wordy. There was also a lot more about the men (and I realize they played an integral role) than I was expecting.
February 27, 2019
Incredibly vivid and thorough portrait of the New York School, New York, Abstract Impressionism, painting, painters, art, artists. Everything, really. Bloody great.
March 21, 2022
This book is genuinely brilliant, it’s going to be on my favorites of the year for sure.
June 1, 2021
A number of years ago, I saw an art exhibit focused on New York Abstract Expressionists. I'd heard of Jackson Pollock, sure, but the work of Lee Krasner, his wife, wasn't familiar to me at all and really struck me. Since then, I've been curious to learn more about her and about Abstract Expressionism in general. It took me a while, but I've now made my way to and through Mary Gabriel's exploration of the intertwined lives of five women at the forefront of Abstract Expressionism over a 30 year period. It's a huge book - over 700 pages without footnotes- exhaustive and sometimes exhausting in its level of detail, but also a rewarding and immersive read. I came away with a real sense of these immensely talented and challenging women and their milieu.
I loved the variety and commitment of Gabriel's subjects. Lee Krasner and Elaine de Kooning struggled with being defined by their famous spouses (the Artist and Wife exhibit both were featured in at one point didn't help, ugh). Krasner continued to create art throughout her marriage, which in itself is remarkable, because being married to Pollock sounds like a full-time and pretty lousy job. De Kooning carved out her own life as an artist and art critic and had a myriad of affairs, but remained a 'team' with Willem de Kooning, at least until he had a child with another woman. Grace Hartigan from New Jersey married at 19, had a baby, and left it all behind to move to New York and be a painter - Gabriel describes her as without a 'guilt chip,' pretty remarkable for a woman at any time let alone in the 1940s and 1950s. Joan Mitchell was insecure, sharp-tongued and had a messy and I would think sometimes traumatic personal life. Helen Frankenthaler's relationship with an older art critic may have opened some doors for her, but, breathtakingly, he engineered her out of the acknowledged history of the Color Field school of painting despite her pioneering role. Throughout, Gabriel gives the reader a detailed sense of the sometimes claustrophobic interrelationships among the artists, male and female, of the New York School, as well as the writers, musicians, and hang-out spots of their world. The destructive impact of alcohol is striking, as is the way that the growth of market forces in the art world pushed women out. 4.5.
I loved the variety and commitment of Gabriel's subjects. Lee Krasner and Elaine de Kooning struggled with being defined by their famous spouses (the Artist and Wife exhibit both were featured in at one point didn't help, ugh). Krasner continued to create art throughout her marriage, which in itself is remarkable, because being married to Pollock sounds like a full-time and pretty lousy job. De Kooning carved out her own life as an artist and art critic and had a myriad of affairs, but remained a 'team' with Willem de Kooning, at least until he had a child with another woman. Grace Hartigan from New Jersey married at 19, had a baby, and left it all behind to move to New York and be a painter - Gabriel describes her as without a 'guilt chip,' pretty remarkable for a woman at any time let alone in the 1940s and 1950s. Joan Mitchell was insecure, sharp-tongued and had a messy and I would think sometimes traumatic personal life. Helen Frankenthaler's relationship with an older art critic may have opened some doors for her, but, breathtakingly, he engineered her out of the acknowledged history of the Color Field school of painting despite her pioneering role. Throughout, Gabriel gives the reader a detailed sense of the sometimes claustrophobic interrelationships among the artists, male and female, of the New York School, as well as the writers, musicians, and hang-out spots of their world. The destructive impact of alcohol is striking, as is the way that the growth of market forces in the art world pushed women out. 4.5.
December 31, 2023
At what point can we talk about women artists without mentioning their husbands? You certainly won’t find these women highlighted in relation to their husband’s work. Lee Krasner was an incredible artist in her own right and the only reason Jackson Pollock need be mentioned along side her is in the context that was her reality : He was an abusive drunk that obstructed her success. Same for Elaine de Kooning.
The book overall was not great and desperately needed editing.
The book overall was not great and desperately needed editing.
October 10, 2019
Loved this book--rich in detail about so many artists and writers whose work I've followed for years
& all of it taking place in neighborhoods I've visited or lived in. Fantastic research and so well written, definitely an award winner!
& all of it taking place in neighborhoods I've visited or lived in. Fantastic research and so well written, definitely an award winner!
February 7, 2022
This book is my bible.
May 27, 2024
I was an art history major and I always said that my favorite part of art history was learning art through history and history through art, especially that of the 19th and 20th centuries. I always felt so connected to the changing social and historical situations and felt very attached to the artists!
"Ninth Street Women" is the longest book I have read to date. Spanning three decades in its chief focus on the American Abstract Expressionist movement, the narrative focuses on the lives of five women artists: Lee Krasner, Elaine de Koonig, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell, and Helen Frankenthaler. I had vaguely heard of some of these artists. My mom, who is quite learned and cultured in the way so many boomer Jewish women are, had not heard of any of them.
I hope this book can serve as a corrective to the Erasure of women in the stories we tell about Modern art in the United States. While far too much of these women's hours were filled with finding non abusive partners, or keeping their husband sober, in this book we learn about the enormous art contributions of these women.
From the interwar period when Paris still reigned culturally, through WWII, McCarthyism, changing tastes, we see how these women not only adapted to change, but also were the change themselves. They influenced each other, took care of each other, competed with each other, all with a very lushly illustrated backdrop of New York City, another character, who you also see changing over time.
Highly recommended, but you need to be aware of the length of the book. Almost 1000 pages and almost 40 hours, this book is an entire universe. But after you finish, you feel as though you have been at the Cedar Bar and the Club, at the Tibor de Nagy and MoMA, in Paris and on Long Island. You'll have seen Presidents rise and fall, programs come and go, attitudes change. It's very much worth it!
"Ninth Street Women" is the longest book I have read to date. Spanning three decades in its chief focus on the American Abstract Expressionist movement, the narrative focuses on the lives of five women artists: Lee Krasner, Elaine de Koonig, Grace Hartigan, Joan Mitchell, and Helen Frankenthaler. I had vaguely heard of some of these artists. My mom, who is quite learned and cultured in the way so many boomer Jewish women are, had not heard of any of them.
I hope this book can serve as a corrective to the Erasure of women in the stories we tell about Modern art in the United States. While far too much of these women's hours were filled with finding non abusive partners, or keeping their husband sober, in this book we learn about the enormous art contributions of these women.
From the interwar period when Paris still reigned culturally, through WWII, McCarthyism, changing tastes, we see how these women not only adapted to change, but also were the change themselves. They influenced each other, took care of each other, competed with each other, all with a very lushly illustrated backdrop of New York City, another character, who you also see changing over time.
Highly recommended, but you need to be aware of the length of the book. Almost 1000 pages and almost 40 hours, this book is an entire universe. But after you finish, you feel as though you have been at the Cedar Bar and the Club, at the Tibor de Nagy and MoMA, in Paris and on Long Island. You'll have seen Presidents rise and fall, programs come and go, attitudes change. It's very much worth it!
November 27, 2025
A truly incredible survey of these artists’ lives, choices, & work. I saw Mary Gabriel speak last year at the Art Students’ League & was so struck by her commitment to research & reporting rather than cherry-picking history to create a narrative that might satisfy today’s readers. She colors in the gray areas with such care, and I felt these brilliant women’s lives bloom before my eyes while reading.
I wish Lee Krasner was alive today so that we could talk over coffee. I look at her “How Blue is Blue” everyday on my Lock Screen - makes me feel close to her and all the creators who precede us, who gave so much to their craft
I wish Lee Krasner was alive today so that we could talk over coffee. I look at her “How Blue is Blue” everyday on my Lock Screen - makes me feel close to her and all the creators who precede us, who gave so much to their craft
November 21, 2023
A masterfully written, endlessly intoxicating book. Don't be intimidated by it's 926 pages. I couldn't put it down and didn't want it to end. It was such a treat to be immersed in this world, like a Mount Olympus of Mid 20th Century Art. Wow!
February 4, 2022
Wow, what an exhilarating ride! using the intertwined lives of five extraordinary artists, Gabriel manages to present a history of The American Century, Ground Zero: Manhattan, from the late 1930's through the early 1960's, all in a tidy 730 or so pages. This is essential reading. And I'm going to have to find a clothbound copy, because over the past month I have managed to pretty much destroy my paperback.
July 18, 2021
Extremely readable, bordering on gossipy, this is a great overview of the New York School and the American art scene in the 40s-60s, focused on five women painters who were central and important to the movement but often left out of the dominant popular art history narrative.
February 8, 2024
What an undeniable achievement of research by Mary Gabriel. I feel like I just took an 8 week course in American abstract expressionism but also I feel like I just had the most rowdy and insightful all-night conversation with an old friend about people we used to know. Read this if you want to feel entirely inspired about possibility in revolutionary art.
September 3, 2026
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
September 7, 2022
For me, this was a seminal book. I am changed. I view art differently. I feel motivated to engage more with art, with artists, with the art world. I am at once fascinated and appalled. I want to know more about the artists discussed in the book and artists who are breaking new ground today. I’m going to pay more attention to controversies and disruptions around art. View art as social, cultural, political barometer: what’s going on, really? Who or what’s feeling threatened?
Loved the book! A wild ride in so many levels and a total inspiration.
Loved the book! A wild ride in so many levels and a total inspiration.
Did Not Finish
August 25, 2026Yeah, I can't do it. It's good but so non-linear, which the author is very open about from the beginning so, I respect it, but I can't hang. I'm also only 40% in and the repetition of the narrative is just too much.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 521 reviews