4.25/5 stars
Willow is enjoying college life with Reid and her BFF Zoey, one day while they are out they run into Reid’s coach, Theodore and his date Tiffany. When Theo looks up and sees Willow, he is instantly in love. He knows that she is what has been missing in his life. He’s stuck on this date, one he was tricked into going on by his mom. When he tries to get Reid and the girls to join him, Tiffany whispers to Willow they are interrupting her date, Willow being from an affluent family knows the equally affluent Tiffany, so she says they are leaving. Neither can stop thinking about the other and they find out they live in the same building. They try to stay away from each other but Theo catches her in the elevator one day and kisses her. When the doors open Zoey sees them in a passionate embrace. I loved the banter between Willow, Zoey, and Reid, they are such good friends and have Willow’s back. She’s worried he’s dating and he’s worried she will start dating, he confesses it’s nothing with Tiffany and tells her to stay away from guys. I loved her nickname for him, Bear. The elevator becomes their meeting/kissing spot, they time their arrival and departures to spend time in elevator together everyday. At the next game Tiffany arrives and sits with his parents, unfortunately the seats are right above Willow and Zoey’s seat. They chit chat and after the game Willow can’t even acknowledge Her Bear so she leaves. He finds her later leaving a frat party and carries her off. He takes her to his apartment where they are about to have sex but since she’s a virgin he waits and just satisfies her orally. They continue meeting secretly and Tiffany continues to pursue Theo. The girls use Willow’s dad’s private jet to attend an away game, Willow surprises Theo and they have their first time together. After Theo leaves for the stadium Tiffany’s shows up, she asks if it’s Theo’s room, Willow pretend that it’s her room, but she wonders how she knew which room was Theo’s. They spend every night together and when the team goes to the championship, the girls go too. Willow suspects she is pregnant but before she can take the test, Tiffany shows up and tells her she is pregnant with Theo’s baby and if Willow doesn’t break up with him and give her money she will release photos she secretly took of Theo and Willow. She takes Willow’s phone and texts Theo that they are over. Theo doesn’t believe it, but is blindsided when a reporter asks about his pregnant fiancé Tiffany. He denies she’s his fiancé and that he is the father of her baby. Tired of all the secrecy and wanting Willow to know he’s hers, after the team wins he goes into the stand and kisses her then proposes. This pushes Tiffany over the edge, she comes to their hotel room with a gun. Luckily Reid tackles her before she shoots anyone. Epilogue many years later with Theo coaching still and two boys and twins on the way.
This would have definitely been a 5 star read ifTheo had maned up and handled the Tiffany thing. She caused so much angst for Willow.