No Transfer

by Stephen Walton

"For those who don't make the grade at Modern University, there's the Self-Discipline Lesson. Everyone learns from it... Some stop learning after it."From the cover.Set in a utopian university where top students and bottom students are periodically entered into a random drawing. At seemingly random intervals, one top students is selected to behead one bottom student as part of the Self-Discipline Lesson.

Genres: Horror, Fiction, Novels

Hardcover

First published January 1, 1967

Reviews

[Daniel Myatt · Rating 4 out of 5]

Modern University is a place where you get the opportunity to shine, excel, and become a grown-up! But don't let your grades drop or turn your attention from your studies. Otherwise, you might find yourself victim to the self-discipline plan....

A clever and dark spin on the age-old academia tale! One that very much reminded me of a Shirley Jackson story - dark things happen in everyday places.

[Bill · Rating 4 out of 5]

I am reading this book almost by accident. Someone recently posted a brief synopsis of the book to a listserv to which I subscribe, asking the list if anyone could figure out what the title of the book was (because a library patron remembered having read it and wanted to re-read or reference it...).
Someone from the list quickly nailed the title, and I ordered it from the library.
Suffice it to say, I've been pleasantly surprised. In fact, the matter-of-factness with which the author treats the "Self-Discipline Lesson" is, perhaps, the most horrific aspect of the entire scenario. Startling. Mind-boggling. Alarming. And very, very cool.
It's almost impossible not to loathe the main character, Gary Fort, at some point in the novel. Later, it becomes equally impossible not to feel for the kid.

[Michael Brown · Rating 4 out of 5]

Say what you like about this thing - assuming you ever come across it. I caught it by accident and my copy looked like something left in a plastic bag behind a condemned laundrette. Lucky me, as it turns out. I expected a few hours effortlessly killed but instead I got a marvellously paced piece of work with a mule's kick I did not see coming at all. Seriously, this is one of those hidden gems that you really wish would appear just a little bit more often.

[Lenny Husen · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is one of the most disturbing books I've ever read, and I've never forgotten it. Cannot recommend it too highly to anyone in university in a competitive major. Belongs on the shelf next to "Five Point Someone."

[Jesse · Rating 3 out of 5]

Feels like a very mid-60s take, complete with focus on how technocracy destroys individuality, on Clark Kerr's multiversity, featuring a highly selective college, apparently entirely housed in one skyscraper (except I guess for the football stadium and some grounds; no word on whether there's a basketball team, though it would not have registered satirically in 1965), where you graduate...or else. The author's afterword notes that it works quite well as an allegory for the elitism of the draft system as of 1965, wherein good grades could keep you out of Vietnam. It's also clearly a parody/dystopian version of the classic campus novels and of the Updike/Cheever suburban-realist school, with This Side of Paradise getting namechecked and the characters all decorating their rooms in up-to-date modern art, listening to jazz, and drinking constantly. (There's also much detailing of multicourse meals at restaurants, complete with five or six rounds of drinks.) And, I suppose, we could read this as a Marcusean repressive-toleration parable in which the students are free to drink, smoke, party, and couple up in their single-occupancy rooms from the moment they set foot on, or in, campus. In a larger sense, it feels very much like the hidden ancestor of the 2010s spate of YA dystopias, with their elaborate rituals and hierarchies and sense of decay--the difference here being that the dystopia is sparklingly clean and efficient. Given the general run of period novels where, to not spoil things, let's just say that rebels find/learn/are (re)pressed into the suit and tie of conformity, I guess I didn't find this as shocking as it felt when it came out.
Bonus points for contributing to the weird-Michigan-State tradition; those same tunnels where James Dallas Egbert went missing in 1979 while supposedly LARPing D&D make an appearance here toward the climax.

[Cam Fleishman · Rating 4 out of 5]

I read this book in 1968. My friends, Peggy & Sue, insisted I read it. I thought it was really different,
than anything I had read, at that time. The ending disturbed this naive kid from New Jersey.
I was impressed the author was a college sophomore. I remembered his first name was Stephen,
but, all these years, I was mistaken thinking his last name was King.
This brought back many great memories.
Thank you for this intense book, Mr. Walton. 🤗👏

[Garry · Rating 4 out of 5]

So unusual. Now 2022. The reliance on smoking. Druggies of old. Interesting storyline.

[Joanne · Rating 1 out of 5]

I read this book in the 70s and am now reading it via interlibrary loan. (I live in Alaska and the book came from North Dakota!) Just starting re-reading it. It will be interesting to see how I feel about it 40 years later. Will report back when I finish.

Now that I have finished this book, I can't believe I remember it being a great read. It was not. The story line was pretty thin and the ending was silly. Now I know...

[Melisende · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is one of those books you forever remember long after you forget who wrote it. I liked it at the time but as yet have had a chance to revisit.