Torn between 3 stars and 4.
I listened to the audio book and enjoyed it. I'm glad Mary Portas narrated it herself as she did so with vigour. I was entertained by the book, and enjoyed learning about her career journey.
However. While she condemned Sheryl Sandberg's 'Lean In' for only advising women to navigate the patriarchal business system, and not dismantling the system itself, Portas' book seemed to share a similar tone with Sandberg's.
Both are smart, plucky business women, driven by their careers, who learn as they grow their families the importance of balancing work and motherhood.
Both womens' success can be attested to a combination of 'right-place, right-time', hard work, good sponsors/mentors, and so on. I'm happy they have both have had successful careers and I'm sure inspired many other women with their success.
However, I don't really feel any less confused about my own career. I don't think either book enlightens the world of women in work in the ways they *think* they do.
I think I'd have preferred this book if it had kept its focus on Portas' own life and learnings, and had spent less time giving out universal advice to all women. Because from my understanding, luck seems the biggest factor in success, then hard work and determination and all the rest of it.
But luck determines whether you're born in a prosperous city with more career inspiration, whether you have an inspiring network of good peers/teachers/role models around you at a time when you can be receptive to their advice, whether you stumble into a career that compliments your personality and stretches you without leading to burnout. Luck, then privilege. And Portas does recognise her luck and privilege now and then, but I don't think gives either one adequate weighting.
If you're looking to emulate Portas' career journey then this is a good quick introduction on how to maybe do that. But I don't think the advice tracks across to women working in small organisations, waitresses, nurses, doctors, public sector roles, etc etc. It's a book written to advise herself and people like her. Which is fair enough.
Maybe this genre of book just isn't for me.