Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Supernatural Submission #1

Submitting to My Neighbor the Witch

Rate this book
Elena Cortez loves Halloween. So when her new sexy neighbor Cassia invites her to a Halloween party, she’s super-stoked! Only problem: Elena thinks Cassia might be a witch. Like a real witch. Who’s using her magic to make Elena have the most epic orgasms of her life!

Will Elena be able to discover the truth about Cassia? Will she let herself become the ultimate witch slut? And will she let Cassia put her wand wherever she wants?

Find out in this fun, Halloween-themed erotica!

A Lesbian Supernatural Erotica with a Latina protagonist and featuring lesbian sex, lesbian bondage and submission, magical orgasms, squirting, and supernatural BDSM!

1 pages, Audible Audio

Published January 14, 2021

41 people are currently reading
68 people want to read

About the author

Riley Rose

80 books75 followers
Riley Rose writes comedic sci-fi, fantasy, urban fantasy, and erotica.

Riley has published over sixty books, penning both original works as well as fun parodies of Star Wars, Star Trek, Knight Rider, G.I. Joe, and Tomb Raider.

Riley’s goal is to write fun characters who have zany adventures that make readers smile.

Riley has also hosted panels at comic cons and book festivals across North America and is generally geeking out with gargoyles when not writing.

Find out more at RileyRoseErotica.com and RileyRoseErotica.substack.com.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
45 (42%)
4 stars
30 (28%)
3 stars
22 (20%)
2 stars
4 (3%)
1 star
6 (5%)
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews
Profile Image for LeeBookie.
278 reviews5 followers
April 25, 2021
Riley Rose wrote the perfect book for anyone that loves quirky erotica AND is a big fan of all things Halloween. I enjoyed it so much. I listened to this an audiobook narrated by Nikki Monroe who is just awesome. I also need to add that Nikki Monroe sure knows how to narrate happy lady sounds. (So good). In this story, Elena is very attracted to her mysterious neighbor Cassia. As you might have guessed from the title, the mysterious neighbor is in fact a witch! Cassia’s witchy gifts cause very intense feelings to surface within Elena and watching their relationship build is an incredibly sexy good time.
Profile Image for Lorraine Rusnack.
1,126 reviews33 followers
April 25, 2021
A Halloween fantasy come true with a sexy witch. I had fun listening to this audiobook. I like that Elena and Cassia plan to be together and not just for the physical part. Riley’s stories are fun and stimulating 😊
564 reviews5 followers
July 27, 2023
interesting and very hot!

Well I guess there is a first time for everything! This sultry slut story is very hot and quite amusing. I haven’t read anything along these lines before. If you are into ultra hot erotica reading you might enjoy this read. I think I did, it might just take a few more reads like it for me to decide.
Profile Image for Siddie.
539 reviews9 followers
January 4, 2024
Elena is a teacher, and she gets a new neighbour Cassia, who she finds immensely attractive. This is their very sexy story, full of intense magical sex. Flying dildos, invisible ropes and virtual magical hands make this so much fun!
The main thing I can say about this, apart from the extreme sex, is that there is also lots of love between these two, unlike many books in this style. We can see that even though Cass is in charge, she cares a lot for Elena, and doesn’t do anything without asking.
This is a fun short book, worth reading for a change of pace from heavier novels.
Profile Image for Lauren.
151 reviews5 followers
September 9, 2022
I never thought I would hear the phrase “sexual TNT” in a book. The sex and descriptions were cringy and the word “sauce” will never be the same again.
Profile Image for Maria.
11 reviews
March 3, 2022
Very hot quirky erotica. Exactly what you expect from Riley Rose, and her stories never disappoint.
Profile Image for T.J. Dallas.
Author 16 books339 followers
March 4, 2022
I do love Riley Rose's short stories! Lots of sex, often hilarious, and they always make me smile. I look forward to the next one on my list!
Profile Image for Jd.
640 reviews3 followers
August 3, 2023
Quite imaginative. There was actually some substance to this erotic novella...don't judge people by stereotypes. Nice HEA.
Profile Image for Kaitlyn.
240 reviews101 followers
November 1, 2022
I recieved a free copy of the audio version from the author and she was really sweet so I wanted to enjoy this, but it was only okay for me, unfortunately.  While the concept/plot had potential and it was certainly very steamy, two things in particular brought it down for me...

First was the narration. It didn't really fit for me, and accentuated the issues that I had with the writing style.  This is very much a personal opinion and I'm quite picky about my narrators, so others may well enjoy it more than I did - I had a tough time not cringing at the moaning parts.

The second was the writing style which I found was just too juvenile for my taste.  I don't read a lot of erotica, but when I do, I tend to lean toward more tasteful and eloquent writing styles.  The thing that was most detrimental was the excessive simple adjectives (ex: "super sexy body", "crazy hard nipples") that made it sound like it was written in the words of a teenage boy.  There was definitely some potential there if the writing was tightened up.  Again, that's very much a matter of personal taste - I'm not one for things like "sauce" and "cumming like a fire hose" in my lesbian erotica, but if that's your thing, you'll love this.

I would recommend it for those who are into very smutty, light-hearted, and sweet (i.e. HEA) erotica.
50 reviews1 follower
November 14, 2022
Funny erotica at its best. Started laughing from the beginning all the way through the end. Instead of love at first sight this is love with first spell. Good narration especially with the erotic sounds when combined.
I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Missi Martin (Stockwell).
1,122 reviews33 followers
January 28, 2024
I am over 50 years old and boy did I blush while reading Submitting to my Neighbor the Witch by Riley Rose. This is the first book in the Supernatural Submission Series and I can only imagine what will be in future books ... Rose does not leave anything to the readers imagination !!

Submitting to my Neighbor the Witch is about SEX ... plain and simple !! But there is a storyline in it unlike the few porn movies I watched years and years ago. 

Main character Elena is decorating for her favorite holiday Halloween when her new neighbor comes over to help her before she falls off of a ladder. Little does Elena know that Cassia is a witch and will soon place Elena under her spell .... sex spell.

Submitting to my Neighbor the Witch is actually a silly read and having a sex witch living next door may not be a bad thing .... but for someone my age, it may not be because I am happily married and do not think I could keep up even when magic is involved. This is the first time that I have read a book like this and the main reason I did is because I met the author at a local book festival and I try to do what I can to help local talent.

If you like Halloween, witches, spells, sex and magic, I highly recommend reading this short story. What do you have to lose ?
Profile Image for Chantal Van den berg.
5 reviews4 followers
November 2, 2022
The holiday may have just come and gone but those who want to indulge some more can get their sexy fill with Submitting to my neighbor the witch by Riley Rose. Or as the character Cassia would say “You can never have too much Halloween.”

Be sure to know what you are getting into when you start this short story. Just like Sexy outfits and Halloween have been uttered in the same breathe often. So have Riley Rose and hot quirky erotica. Not necessarily everybody’s bag of candy.

Don’t expect to get multilayered characters or Virginia Woolf dialogues. Riley Rose’s stories are meant to be taken as some lighthearted, naughty fun. If you can poke and prode through a few cringy wordchoices (personal prefference) you can still have a fun read or listen.

But if you do sit down for this one you’ll get a sexy witch who knows how to magic her way around a woman’s body and her horny little neighbor who is more than willing to take it all in return.

For those of you getting it on audiobook it’s Narrated by Nikki Monroe who definitely brought enthusiasm and fun to the reading table for those hotter scenes. Be sure to plug in those headsets before starting this one. ;-)
679 reviews5 followers
November 3, 2024
Pure glorious F/F smut. Sex everywhere with only enough plot to hold things together.

Elena is a very hot schoolteacher. Her new next-door neighbor is a hot witch. And, yeah, Elena finds out that "witch" is literally true. With a VERY magic wand. And Elana gets tied up magically and spanked and fucked all over the place.

There was so much juicy (extra juicy and with more liquid on the side) girl cum that I really hoped the characters took a few minutes to hydrate.

I gave it 5 stars simply for over-the-top absurd erotic energy. The characters are delightful. The sex was all sorts of fun. And, really, there is not much else to say. Was this great literature? Nope. Just a lot of fun as a F/F sex romp.

I look forward to reading the next installment.
Profile Image for Stan Hutchings.
1,319 reviews20 followers
March 17, 2025
Elena has an erotic, naughty, submissive roleplay school adventure with punishments staged by Cassia. They are joined by Kaia and Jules and go on an enjoyable, erotic road trip to a cabin in the woods for lots of domme-sub activity and sexy board games. They meet an erotic, horny ghost and satisfy her needs and she reciprocates.
Also available as Book 5 in "Submitting to My Supernatural Girlfriends Books 4 – 6 "
98 reviews2 followers
September 24, 2023
I finished the story last night and I'm looking forward to it appearing in GoodReads so I can write a review. I liked to story and look forward to the 4 (now 5) friends continued adventures.
As a former College Instructor, I really liked the "Naughty Schoolgirl" scene at the start of the story. I never had anything like that happen in one of my classes!!!
1 review
November 16, 2022
This is quite a short but very good erotic story of a witch, maybe, seducing a neighbour into having the time of her lifeon Halloween.
It's well written and narrated and I will be listening to the audio book again.
230 reviews3 followers
October 5, 2023
Good read

I really enjoyed reading this book, it was very Sexy and funny. I really enjoyed this new author, waiting to read more books 📚 😀
Profile Image for MH.
354 reviews8 followers
August 9, 2023
Book Status Observation









[ePub, GoodReads no longer allows users to add books to the database, disfavoring all non-Kindle ePubs]
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.