A reworking of a classic story that focuses on the plight of two sisters after the untimely death of their father and protector, Cerise DeLand manages to maintain the integrity of the original novel as she expands and brings us a far more steamy version of the original.
No, Austen didn’t have the story wrong for her time: her characters of Elinor and Marianne Dashwood are completely of their time, yet surprisingly created with traits that are ‘less favorable’ for the era in which they live. Highly intelligent, imaginative and resourceful, these young ladies dream of being swept off their feet by a man who will both provide for them, and love them as they are. DeLand takes these flirtations into the realm of the scandalous as these two women, in their own way, explore their more sensual and sexual sides.
Elinor is the eldest, far more flamboyant and outspoken in her real life, her fantasies all surround the quiet and respectful Edward. She longs to experience some of the heart-flutteringly sensations that Marianne is on about in her relationship with John Willoughby, yet Edward remains, true to the time, unstintingly reserved.
Marianne is a bit more flighty, and takes to the unabashed flirtations and advances from Willoughby as a duck would to water. Tired of her sister’s extolling the virtues of a man she sees as solid and boring, Marianne is not interested in the quiet and constant interest from Colonel Brandon, but is she destined for heartbreak or ruin with her profligate ways?
There is difficulty in comparing the two stories, without taking from the obvious talent and cleverness of DeLand’s writing and plotting. In what would have been shamefully scandalous behavior from either of these women in their own time, the cleverness of the character’s curiosity and openness in their discussions, and the readily apparent enjoyment in the steamier scenes brings a solidity to these characters that keeps this version separate from, yet wholly informed by the original.
Diehard fans of the original Austen, my second favorite by that author, will not find great lapses in character, in fact, this retelling of their story with additional more modern elements is an interesting read that adds new perspective and modernizes the original for new readers.
I received an eBook copy from the publisher for purpose of honest review for the Jeep Diva. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.